Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., January 02, 2007 Tevet 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Hamas PM Ismail Haniyeh being shaved during the Haj pilgrimage near Mecca, Monday. (Reuters)
Last update - 17:44 01/01/2007
Israel rejects demand to release 1,000 prisoners for Shalit
By Avi Issacharoff, Amos Harel, Aluf Benn and Jack Khoury, Haaretz Correspondents and Haaretz Service

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert on Monday morning convened an advising meeting with his special envoy for the captive soldiers, Ofer Dekel, and other officials. Meeting participants said Israel has no intention of freeing 1,000 to 1,400 prisoners as reported in the Arab media.

The discussion also included statements that due to inflated demands by the Palestinians, no progress has been reached in negotiations to free kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit.

Nonetheless, the statements may be a final Israeli effort to present a firm stance ahead of signing a deal, as negotiators have done in previous incidents.

Advertisement

Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh on Sunday blamed Israel for noncompliance and foot-dragging in the negotiations, Israel Radio reported.

According to Israel Radio, Haniyeh told the Ramatan news agency that Israel is playing games and is not interested in putting an end to the prisoners' suffering.

In the Ramatan interview, Haniyeh also said that the meeting between Olmert and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas bore no fruit.

Senior Hamas officials on Sunday said a breakthrough has occurred in negotiations over the deal.

This was the first time since Shalit's abduction that Hamas leaders have publicly announced a breakthrough in the talks.

But Israeli political and military sources both said that they were unaware of any such progress. "We are not aware of any breakthrough or major progress in the deal to free Gilad Shalit," said one government source.

The Israeli sources also denied media reports that Shalit's family had received a video of the kidnapped soldier, as did the family itself.

Ahmed Yousef, Haniyeh's political advisor, told the Palestinian news agency Ma'an yesterday that he expects the first Palestinian prisoners to be released early this year, and that Thursday's planned meeting between Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak would significantly advance the emerging deal.

Other Palestinian sources told Haaretz that Hamas has agreed in principle to an Israeli proposal for an exchange that was transmitted via Egyptian intelligence chief Omar Suleiman.

Suleiman, who is currently in Saudi Arabia, met there with Haniyeh and apparently also met with Khaled Meshal, the head of Hamas' Damascus-based political bureau.

The sources said that under the Israeli proposal, Hamas would give Israel a video showing that Shalit is alive, and in exchange, Israel would release an as-yet undecided number of women and minor prisoners.

Next, Shalit would be transferred to Egypt, and then to Israel; at the same time, Israel would release some 450 Palestinian prisoners. Hamas would give Egypt a list of the prisoners it wants released, and Israel would be asked to approve this list.

Finally, about two months later, Israel would release additional prisoners. Israel would be authorized to decide both how many and which prisoners to free at this stage, but has promised to be "generous," the sources said.

A spokesman for Hamas' military wing, Abu Obeida, confirmed to Haaretz that there had been a breakthrough in the talks. However, he said, there is as yet no timetable, and "we can't say whether we're talking about days or weeks."

A spokesman for the Popular Resistance Committees (PRC), which carried out the kidnapping jointly with Hamas, also confirmed the reported breakthrough. The spokesman, Abu Mujhad, declined to give details, but said that Israel had moved significantly closer to the Palestinians' demands.

Ismail Radwan, Hamas' spokesman in Gaza, similarly said that "there has been very positive progress" in the negotiations.

Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit on Sunday told the London-based newspaper Al-Hayat that "the deal is ready." But Aboul Gheit, who noted that Olmert and Mubarak would discuss the deal at their meeting this week, said that the other parties are still awaiting a final decision from Hamas.

Israeli sources, in contrast, said that they were unaware of any breakthrough. Nevertheless, defense sources said, public declarations of an impending deal by both Hamas and the PRC indicate that both organizations have apparently softened their positions.

It seems that the main outstanding issue is which prisoners will be on the list of 450 to be freed along with Shalit. Negotiations on this issue could yet delay the deal.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
State of the art
Amitai Mendelson, the man in charge of local art at the Israel Museum, has a vision.
Real estate bubble?
Prices in the center of the country rose steadily in 2006 and are expected to grow.
  1.   The fragile ego of Olmert is the problem 10:20  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  2.   to klick kluc klan 10:56  |  Tina 01/01/07
  3.   What are the legal rights of jailed Palestinians in Israel? 11:00  |  Natallie Durson 01/01/07
  4.   Rip The Charter! No Release of Murderers! 11:37  |  Yosemite Sam 01/01/07
  5.   Release Pals to come back and kill Israeli Jews? NOT. 11:41  |  Yacov 01/01/07
  6.   Foot dragging... 11:47  |  Giles Martin 01/01/07
  7.   nice hair cut! 11:59  |  Karam 01/01/07
  8.   HAJJI at the barber, looking well fed and relaxed 12:01  |  PETERSM 01/01/07
  9.   NATALIE DURSON *3 12:01  |  Michael 01/01/07
  10.   4# Hamas can not accept your propoals 12:04  |  Nora 01/01/07
  11.   kidnapping, #3 12:19  |  YOEL 01/01/07
  12.   Trade mark of Zionism 12:20  |  Sam (UK) 01/01/07
  13.   #12 Sam: You described history of British colonialism 12:32  |  Yacov 01/01/07
  14.   no publicity lies from the pals 12:56  |  Adrian de Klerk 01/01/07
  15.   Israelis value Palestinians more than they do 13:02  |  David Teich 01/01/07
  16.   Koran says.. 13:06  |  islam exposed 01/01/07
  17.   I`m sorry to say that there should be no deal at all. 13:07  |  Sarit 01/01/07
  18.   # 1 Clickfool 13:09  |  ChanahS 01/01/07
  19.   Going back to what he does best 13:23  |  sh 01/01/07
  20.   312 SAM THE ALHAJI TELLS THE USUAL FALSEHOODS 13:42  |  paul harris 01/01/07
  21.   #1 NO DEAL WITH KIDNAPPERS CLIKKY 13:44  |  paul harris 01/01/07
  22.   To ChanahS No. 10 13:46  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  23.   relerse HUNDREDS FOR ONE?? PLEASE! 14:03  |  JON FEIGENBAUM 01/01/07
  24.   To 16 your answer from london 14:07  |  Samir 01/01/07
  25.   What`s the (moral) difference between 450 and 1000 ?? 14:07  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/01/07
  26.   Its become a farce!!!! Release them! 14:13  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/01/07
  27.   LOL # Clickfool 14:16  |  Zuriel 01/01/07
  28.   what are the legal right of the palestinians in sraeli jails 14:23  |  DANNY 01/01/07
  29.   Simple math Dino "Swiss" 14:25  |  Zuriel 01/01/07
  30.   TO NO 9 14:29  |  DANNY 01/01/07
  31.   paul harris on "no deal" 14:29  |  sh 01/01/07
  32.   Release 1000, capture 2000!!! 14:32  |  Raafi 01/01/07
  33.   TO NO 13 14:34  |  DANNY 01/01/07
  34.   TO HANNAH NO 10 14:39  |  DANNY 01/01/07
  35.   TO SAMIR NO 24 14:47  |  DANNY. 01/01/07
  36.   #3. Natalie Durson 14:55  |  Steven 01/01/07
  37.   to 24 Samir - 15:04  |  dorothy 01/01/07
  38.   To DANNY 15:29  |  SAMIR 01/01/07
  39.   # 29 Zuriel The "logic" of numbers 15:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/01/07
  40.   DANNY YOU GIVED ...... 15:37  |  SAMIR 01/01/07
  41.   To Dorothy ..there is a solution 15:42  |  Samir 01/01/07
  42.   No deal 15:44  |  Haim 01/01/07
  43.   41: Yes, Sami, the solution`s for you to learn about time 16:01  |  David Teich 01/01/07
  44.   release 10000 16:03  |  flashman 01/01/07
  45.   #13 Yacov, well said 16:09  |  hmpierson 01/01/07
  46.   Hamas have one thing only 16:10  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/01/07
  47.   Reply to No 36 16:13  |  Abe 01/01/07
  48.   To Swiss (Dino): It makes a very big difference. 16:19  |  Natan 01/01/07
  49.   they are as easy to catch as salmon 16:31  |  flashman 01/01/07
  50.   A bad deal at any time 16:46  |  David 01/01/07
  51.   To Clickfool 17:04  |  Motale 01/01/07
  52.   perhaps we should trade haniyeh`s life for shalit 17:07  |  ralph 01/01/07
  53.   Israel rejects release of 1,000 prisoners 17:10  |  Shmuelshachor 01/01/07
  54.   Taking of Hostages Against Geneva Conventions 17:13  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/01/07
  55.   Samir # 41 Have You Ever Heard of Birth Control? 17:14  |  Jeff Northridge 01/01/07
  56.   It appears that 17:20  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  57.   #3 Michael 17:26  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  58.   What Israel proposal should be 17:32  |  KUTW 01/01/07
  59.   # 48 Natan 17:33  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/01/07
  60.   #36 Danny 17:34  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  61.   gimmee a break release them all 17:36  |  flashman 01/01/07
  62.   #49 - salmon vs. Palestinians 17:40  |  Boris 01/01/07
  63.   the value of 1 palestinian life?... 17:42  |  Richard S 01/01/07
  64.   A simple solution for now and a way to move forward in the future 17:42  |  Boris 01/01/07
  65.   HAMAS tries to blackmail ISRAEL. The deal should exclude......... 17:45  |  Vittorio 01/01/07
  66.   Ronnie Wolman # 46 The Palestinian Dream 17:52  |  Jeff Northridge 01/01/07
  67.   To #16 "islam exposed" 17:53  |  Ahmed 01/01/07
  68.   1,000 prisoners for Shalit 17:54  |  Ralph 01/01/07
  69.   Israel should free IDF to obliterate Gaza 17:55  |  Sal 01/01/07
  70.   To clickfool #10 17:57  |  Levy 01/01/07
  71.   # 60 17:58  |  ChanahS 01/01/07
  72.   1 israeli life is worth all of the Palistinians 17:59  |  Levi 01/01/07
  73.   To Jeff Northridge Look what Muslim Do 18:20  |  Samir 01/01/07
  74.   clickfool# 22 you dont need a fake clickfool to make you look 18:25  |  your friend in usa 01/01/07
  75.   Chris Linthwaite 18:34  |  Da Nang 01/01/07
  76.   to boris,the simple solution is stop terrorism,period 18:34  |  terrornaotr 01/01/07
  77.   Clickfool # 1 -Palestinian victory ??? 18:40  |  Avrum 01/01/07
  78.   Jeff Northridge: Hamas are holding on for dear life 18:43  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/01/07
  79.   Give them all the prisoners they want 18:44  |  Yonatan 01/01/07
  80.   Abe # 47 The "Illegal and Brutal" Occupation 18:52  |  Jeff Northridge 01/01/07
  81.   HOW DARE OLMERT REJECT HANIYEH`S REQUEST 18:55  |  Dutch 01/01/07
  82.   #71 ChanahS 19:04  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  83.   For Motale # 51 19:12  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  84.   #79 Yonathan 19:14  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  85.   For Levy # 70 19:17  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  86.   Yonatan:Prisoners and Prisms 19:17  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/01/07
  87.   #14 Advice from Adrian de Klerk 19:23  |  maoriboy 01/01/07
  88.   Jeff Northridge How Do You Define Torture 19:24  |  Samir 01/01/07
  89.   Natallie If They Were All Like You There Wouldn`t Be A Problem! 19:25  |  Yosemite Sam 01/01/07
  90.   Olmert is SO easy to call 19:26  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  91.   Land 19:28  |  Jerry D 01/01/07
  92.   So if one israeli life = 1000 arab lives 19:35  |  James 01/01/07
  93.   clickfool "are all zionists so pathetic" 19:49  |  yirmi 01/01/07
  94.   81. Dutch: Exchange Shalit for me 19:49  |  Ducth Conscience 01/01/07
  95.   responsibility 19:51  |  randolf 01/01/07
  96.   clickfool you could differentiate 19:52  |  yirmi 01/01/07
  97.   Trademark of Muslims 19:56  |  #12 01/01/07
  98.   #22, you do not only look one, you are one! 20:00  |  PPM 01/01/07
  99.   #1 and 90: both FAKE Clickfools 20:02  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  100.   natallie and clickfool 20:03  |  Kipperraes 01/01/07
  101.   #13 what`s your point??? 20:03  |  ballistic 01/01/07
  102.   For Yirmi # 93 20:12  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  103.   # 82 20:18  |  ChanahS 01/01/07
  104.   For Kipperraes # 100 20:22  |  Clickfool 01/01/07
  105.   # 90 20:23  |  ChanahS 01/01/07
  106.   The Koran and its taching 20:23  |  Mansoor 01/01/07
  107.   Samir # 73 What Are You Talking About? 20:23  |  Jeff Northridge 01/01/07
  108.   99 Fake Clickfool 20:25  |  Dave 01/01/07
  109.   IT CANT BE DONE 20:29  |  TOBIA 01/01/07
  110.   to # 67 20:30  |  Abushanab 01/01/07
  111.   so... 20:36  |  randolf 01/01/07
  112.   #103 ChanahS 20:40  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  113.   #101 ballistic: You are the point. 20:45  |  Yacov 01/01/07
  114.   Shalit release 20:51  |  Paul 01/01/07
  115.   Reply to No 80 Jeff 20:52  |  Abe 01/01/07
  116.   109: it CAN be done. 20:52  |  naftaly k 01/01/07
  117.   lost generation 20:59  |  randolf 01/01/07
  118.   81 - Hamas wants to destroy Israel 20:59  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/01/07
  119.   we are all 21:01  |  Jerry D 01/01/07
  120.   # 122 21:01  |  ChanahS 01/01/07
  121.   release 21:03  |  isiaiah 01/01/07
  122.   they must rot in israeli jails 21:09  |  alan 01/01/07
  123.   Samir # 88 Torture 21:10  |  Jeff Northridge 01/01/07
  124.   #112, 3 falacies in one post 21:11  |  PPM 01/01/07
  125.   The moral difference (Swiss #25) 21:15  |  Tosefta 01/01/07
  126.   Huh? 21:19  |  xyz 01/01/07
  127.   To: Doris-Dutch: You ask us, fair minded people - We answer 21:20  |  fair minded people 01/01/07
  128.   # 72 livi 21:23  |  double standards 01/01/07
  129.   TO 46 RONNIE WOLMAN 21:32  |  DANNY 01/01/07
  130.   to Achmed # 67 21:33  |  BO 01/01/07
  131.   to # 47 and everyone else 21:34  |  the only door 01/01/07
  132.   Dutch-Doris. Your anger shouldn`t blind you. Don`t forget to eat, 21:36  |  PEOPLE OF THE WORLD 01/01/07
  133.   to 101 (ballistic) 21:36  |  Marco 01/01/07
  134.   SAM in the UK #13 21:47  |  BB 01/01/07
  135.   Only Gaza`s detruction will release Shalit 21:48  |  Bernard Ross 01/01/07
  136.   #86 Ronnie, I agree, but 22:00  |  Yonatan 01/01/07
  137.   Abe # 115 In a Nutshell, Yes 22:05  |  Jeff Northridge 01/01/07
  138.   release them all in one fell swoop 22:06  |  peter 01/01/07
  139.   to ABE # 115 22:12  |  BO 01/01/07
  140.   to 128 22:20  |  BO 01/01/07
  141.   Trade All Women and Children and Those Held For A Year Or More... 22:23  |  chet 01/01/07
  142.   56. Chris Linthwaite: It appears that 22:24  |  KUTW 01/01/07
  143.   Belief in Authority Figures in the Arab World 22:28  |  Phinias Whoppy 01/01/07
  144.   to 127 22:32  |  Shelley N 01/01/07
  145.   ref # 110 22:41  |  Abu Gaafar 01/01/07
  146.   to SAMIR 40 22:45  |  ISRAELLISTICALLY 01/01/07
  147.   #142 KUTW 22:47  |  Chris Linthwaite 01/01/07
  148.   To # 99 Re Both Fake Clickfools 23:00  |  Phinias Whoppy 01/01/07
  149.   # 72 Double Standards 23:12  |  ChanahS 01/01/07
  150.   # 125 Tosefta 23:16  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/01/07
  151.   147 Chris Linthwaite 23:27  |  KUTW 01/01/07
  152.   HOW DARE HANIYEH REFUSE TO EXCHAGE SHALIT FOR ME 23:43  |  Dutch 01/01/07
  153.   Shalit`s safety (Swiss #150) 23:52  |  Tosefta 01/01/07
  154.   Let him rot 00:07  |  Moe 02/01/07
  155.   #151 KUTW 00:08  |  Chris Linthwaite 02/01/07
  156.   # 128 Double Standards - see 149 00:13  |  ChanahS 02/01/07
  157.   To ISRAELLISTICALLY 00:23  |  Samir 02/01/07
  158.   Shrewd negotiator 00:29  |  Pablo B 02/01/07
  159.   # 135 00:35  |  Moe 02/01/07
  160.   TO ISRAELLISTICALLY SICK 00:37  |  Samir 02/01/07
  161.   Imagine, just a few months ago 00:40  |  Mark Lincoln 02/01/07
  162.   @101, ballistic 00:58  |  vladimir 02/01/07
  163.   HAMAS, YOUR DAYS ARE NUMBERED 01:01  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 02/01/07
  164.   Ready, set, change 01:16  |  TonyL 02/01/07
  165.   @125, bravo tosefte, at least you know about rabby meir of regens 01:26  |  vladimir 02/01/07
  166.   Isreali bashers & short term memory 01:27  |  Adrian de Klerk 02/01/07
  167.   #129 Danny Thank you kindly 01:31  |  Ronnie Wolman 02/01/07
  168.   Yonatan: I lost U babe ! (Qassams got it) 01:35  |  Ronnie Wolman 02/01/07
  169.   Every soldier safe and sound or not one inch! 01:48  |  Neil Golan 02/01/07
  170.   Prisoner exchange 02:19  |  Otto Rand 02/01/07
  171.   Rothenburg vs. Regensburg (Vladimir #163) 02:53  |  Tosefta 02/01/07
  172.   chanahS #149 03:00  |  #128 02/01/07
  173.   Islam Exposed to #16 and #67 03:19  |  Otto Rand 02/01/07
  174.   #170, Otto Rand 03:23  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 02/01/07
  175.   173# OTTO FOR YOU 03:57  |  NEIL GOLAN 02/01/07
  176.   CHILDREN VILLAGE 04:01  |  TOBIA 02/01/07
  177.   HATE TO SAY I TOLD YOU SO 04:04  |  Dr David I. Gross 02/01/07
  178.   176 04:21  |  visa versa 02/01/07
  179.   The issue 04:26  |  Omar 02/01/07
  180.   Natallie Durson 04:28  |  Omar 02/01/07
  181.   Read between the lines 04:38  |  Baz Mann 02/01/07
  182.   SEND THIS #175`S QURAN TO ALL YOU KNOW! 04:45  |  NAJI 02/01/07
  183.   Fence Re #177 04:48  |  Baz Mann 02/01/07
  184.   #178 05:09  |  TOBIA 02/01/07
  185.   184 05:31  |  visa versa 02/01/07
  186.   Hi Cipora 05:48  |  Otto Rand 02/01/07
  187.   To #175 05:53  |  Otto Rand 02/01/07
  188.   #113 Yacov-I don`t deny anything you say in your post, but 06:03  |  ballistic 02/01/07
  189.   #133 to Marco--first of all, you don`t need to use "small words"; 06:11  |  ballistic 02/01/07
  190.   #135 Mr. Ross 06:14  |  ballistic 02/01/07
  191.   #162 What does that have to do with the price of tea 06:20  |  ballistic 02/01/07
  192.   BALLISTIC YOU ARE ANGRY ???? 06:24  |  TOBIA 02/01/07
  193.   VISA VERSA IT MAKES A LOT OF SENSE 06:31  |  TOBIA 02/01/07
  194.   #192 Tobia response 07:22  |  ballistic 02/01/07
  195.   prisoners of war 07:37  |  mike 02/01/07
  196.   Olmert`s crazy logic 08:12  |  BradL 02/01/07
  197.   #172 Children in danger 08:12  |  ChanahS 02/01/07
  198.   194: Ballistic, as confused as usual 08:14  |  David Teich 02/01/07
  199.   195: Yes Mike, and you should try it some time 08:23  |  David Teich 02/01/07
  200.   155. Chris Linthwaite 09:52  |  KUTW 02/01/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: If Ariel Sharon were with us now
Responses: 4
Amir Oren: The Shin Bet has failed in Gaza
Responses: 1
Moshe Arens: Don't talk with Syria if there's a gun at your head
Responses: 1
Israel may replace Arrow with U.S.-made missile
Responses: 31
Gilad Shalit's father: One call from Assad can free my son
Responses: 19
Rosner's Domain
* Will Israel choose to replace the Arrow with THAAD?
* Zev Chafets: Why the Orhodox love the Evangelicals
* Poll: What can the U.S. do in 2007?
* Look at Somalia, think about Lebanon


More Headlines
09:47 Israel may opt for U.S.-made missile over Arrow
09:45 IDF general: Many top officers doubt Halutz still able to lead
08:56 Mortar shells hit Gaza entry point, wounding truck driver
08:38 Olmert: minimum wage may increase to $1,000 this year
08:35 Winograd panel's to present report by end of February
08:23 Gilad Shalit's father: One phone call from Assad can free my son
06:31 Engineer again warns that Moghrabi Gate walkway may collapse
05:07 New evidence casts doubt on identity of Katzrin murderer
04:34 New German film by Jewish director offers comic portrayal of Hitler
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved