Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., January 02, 2007 Tevet 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Making the law a laughingstock
By Haaretz Editorial

Virtually not a week goes by without a new revelation, each more sensational and revolting than the previous one, about the building spree in West Bank settlements, in blatant violation of the law and in complete contradiction to official government policy. All this is happening with the knowledge of the defense officials responsible for enforcing the law in the territories, and with cooperation - by commission or omission - from the political echelon. The latest discovery does not rely on external sources such as Peace Now, which specializes in monitoring and documenting activity in the Land of the Settlers. Amos Harel's report in Friday's Haaretz about the 200 mobile homes that have been placed in the West Bank during the past six months quotes documents prepared by the Civil Administration - the body responsible for enforcing planning and construction laws in the area.

In the middle of last week, it was reported that Defense Minister Amir Peretz had authorized the repopulation of Maskiot, an abandoned Nahal Brigade outpost. Thirty new homes will be set up there for evacuees from Gush Katif, in the Gaza Strip. Maskiot is one of a long list of communities established beyond the Green Line that have been completely untouched by the government's commitment under the road map: to freeze all settlement activities, including "natural growth." Two weeks ago, Attorney General Menachem Mazuz notified Peretz that according to data he received from the Civil Administration, construction in the illegal outposts is continuing, including the construction of permanent structures. Mazuz listed 168 illegal structures that had been identified in the settlements and outposts over the past year.

It will soon be two years since the government decided, in response to a report on the outposts drafted by attorney Talia Sasson, "to keep its commitment to dismantle unauthorized outposts set up since March 2001." As a result of this delay, the demolition orders issued against some of the outposts are close to expiry, a fact that will make the evacuations more difficult, if such a day ever comes. According to last Friday's report, the Israel Defense Forces have not presented a detailed plan or a timetable for evacuating the outposts. Instead, for some months now, the defense minister has been involved in negotiations with the leaders of the Yesha Council of settlements in an effort to reach an agreement on the voluntary evacuation of some outposts and the relocation of the rest to within the boundaries of the "mother" settlements.

Advertisement

The agreement being formulated with the settlers is reminiscent of the outposts agreement of October 1999, in which then prime and defense minister Ehud Barak reached a deal with the Yesha Council to evacuate a mere 11 outposts (four of which were empty), out of a total of 42 illegal outposts. At the time, Barak was praised for this "precedent," in which the Yesha Council and even some of the right's political leaders expressed their willingness to cooperate with the government in carrying out a decision to evacuate communities in the territories. He argued that the agreement with the "mainstream" settlers would "contribute to bolstering the rule of law." But according to the Sasson report, now collecting dust in government ministries, since that "precedent" was established, at least 60 more outposts have been set up - most with government assistance, and all while the army turned a blind eye. It seems that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert adheres to that same longstanding tradition of "bolstering the rule of law."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
State of the art
Amitai Mendelson, the man in charge of local art at the Israel Museum, has a vision.
Real estate bubble?
Prices in the center of the country rose steadily in 2006 and are expected to grow.
  1.   Keep on building on the LIBERATED TERRITORY!!!!!!!!! 09:52  |  Ben Uziel 31/12/06
  2.   Misdirected efforts, lost in a sea of misdirected efforts 09:55  |  Natallie Durson 31/12/06
  3.   As long as we violate our commitments 09:57  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 31/12/06
  4.   The silent consent of Israels population 10:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 31/12/06
  5.   The only thing revolting is Haaretz 10:16  |  Beni 31/12/06
  6.   Not a laughing stock 10:20  |  Walid 31/12/06
  7.   "Making the law a laughingstock" 10:22  |  Zev 31/12/06
  8.   it seems as though 10:26  |  rose 31/12/06
  9.   The New Year of old Ideas . . . 10:28  |  revoltop 31/12/06
  10.   it seems as though 10:28  |  rose 31/12/06
  11.   Who pays the price? 10:36  |  JW 31/12/06
  12.   WE WILL KEEP BUILDING IN OUR LAND 11:11  |  Yishai Kohen 31/12/06
  13.   Ben Uziel, get a bloody grip on reality man 11:23  |  Marilyn 31/12/06
  14.   True target: Settlement expansion / West Bank annexation 11:24  |  www.kibush.co.il 31/12/06
  15.   Marilyn: The Arabs Gave Up ALL Sovereign Claims Here 11:29  |  Yishai Kohen 31/12/06
  16.   SHALL I HOLD UP ONE FINGER OR TWO? 11:37  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  17.   Haaretz is the "laughing stock" 12:09  |  Nat Weinstein 31/12/06
  18.   Supply and demand- Jews want to live in Judea and Samaria 12:11  |  Dani 31/12/06
  19.   Zionist greed 12:18  |  Hannah 31/12/06
  20.   The ignorance is amazing in Israel 12:27  |  Marilyn 31/12/06
  21.   Arab greed 12:29  |  David 31/12/06
  22.   #19 HANNAH IN CANADA CITES GREED IN WANTING TO BEIN YOUR OWN LAN 12:30  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  23.   Prof Jacob Talmon 12:35  |  Stephen Connor 31/12/06
  24.   It won`t be a laughing matter when settlements come under attack 12:42  |  Joe 31/12/06
  25.   wrong concepts of sovereignty, Marilyn 12:53  |  Frank 31/12/06
  26.   #23 Thanks for the link. Talmon`s prophetic nightmare scenerio 13:01  |  Joe 31/12/06
  27.   marilyn would it be a good idea 13:05  |  and if not 31/12/06
  28.   marilyn "israel has bred a few generations 13:07  |  and if not 31/12/06
  29.   #22 only because of the u.s., paul harris 13:08  |  eric 31/12/06
  30.   #21, David 13:11  |  Hannah 31/12/06
  31.   Settlements 13:27  |  Mitch Cohen 31/12/06
  32.   Govt. wake up settlement is legalized by Human Rts.signed by Govt 13:27  |  sam 31/12/06
  33.   re Frank: and YOU would call Islam bachward? 13:35  |  Axel 31/12/06
  34.   #20 Marilyn´s amazing ignorance 13:37  |  Alicia 31/12/06
  35.   #25 Frank, with your logic, qassam attacks are legitimate 13:42  |  Joe 31/12/06
  36.   Article 1 of the 49th Geneva Convention 13:43  |  Marilyn 31/12/06
  37.   2nd Try: Alternative peace plan: 3 states living side by side 13:45  |  Yacov 31/12/06
  38.   #29 ERIC PREPARES FOR NEW YEAR WITH BIG JOKE TO HAARETZ 13:55  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  39.   editor australia is a friend 13:56  |  and if not 31/12/06
  40.   #36 MARYLIN IS CORRECT THAT IS WHY THE 1948 INVASION OF ISRAEL WA 14:04  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  41.   #37, yakov squatting in al-Majdal 14:07  |  Hannah 31/12/06
  42.   Hannah: Anyone not devoted to the destruction of Israel 14:19  |  Yacov 31/12/06
  43.   #33 GOOD ON YER AXEL SO ARE ALL THE OTHER MEMBERS OF THE UN 14:21  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  44.   paul harris 14:37  |  Axel 31/12/06
  45.   Land versus people 14:43  |  Sam 31/12/06
  46.   Why the debate? Israel will keep all of the West Bank. 14:45  |  Toronto`s Finest 31/12/06
  47.   You made my day Marilyn! 14:47  |  Alicia 31/12/06
  48.   PAUL HARRIS. Capital letters...... 14:48  |  Toronto`s Finest 31/12/06
  49.   Keep writing in the CAPITALS Paul! 15:02  |  Alicia 31/12/06
  50.   Alicia 15:05  |  Axel 31/12/06
  51.   Mr. Editor 15:07  |  Choni Davidowitz 31/12/06
  52.   Toronto`s Finest:: As you write from land stolen from Indians 15:16  |  Yacov 31/12/06
  53.   CAPS are awesome . . . . 15:19  |  revoltop 31/12/06
  54.   Laws, landgrabs, war, peace 15:22  |  Vito 31/12/06
  55.   Real obscenity 15:23  |  Nicholas 31/12/06
  56.   marilyn has got her claws into a project 15:24  |  and if not 31/12/06
  57.   For Nat Weinstein in the safety of Baltimore # 17 15:25  |  Clickfool 31/12/06
  58.   marilyn is an innocent waif 15:28  |  and if not 31/12/06
  59.   Israelis not telling the truth 15:29  |  Walid 31/12/06
  60.   Question for Paul Harris # 48 15:29  |  Clickfool 31/12/06
  61.   build build build 15:30  |  yonatan 31/12/06
  62.   Marilyn`s ignorance!!!!! 15:31  |  Ben Uziel 31/12/06
  63.   TO AXEL #51 15:36  |  Alicia 31/12/06
  64.   For Yacov # 52 on ancient crimes 15:37  |  Clickfool 31/12/06
  65.   #51 Choni... and soon from the river in Egypt to the Euphrates 15:42  |  Toronto`s Finest 31/12/06
  66.   revoltop you are raving 15:42  |  levy and levy 31/12/06
  67.   marilyn "the ignorance is amazing" 15:45  |  and if not 31/12/06
  68.   #44 GOOD AXEL IS LISTENING TO THE SCREAMING CORECTIONS 15:54  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  69.   #53 ANOTHER CANDIDATE FOR EDUCATION 15:57  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  70.   The west Bank 16:09  |  Mordechai 31/12/06
  71.   Not telling truth Part 2 16:10  |  Walid 31/12/06
  72.   clickfool did the fact that you hate jews 16:12  |  yirmi 31/12/06
  73.   #61 Yonatan: Because we`re Jews. 16:14  |  Yacov 31/12/06
  74.   walid i am touched 16:16  |  yonatan 31/12/06
  75.   WAS THIS A ONE WAY ROAD MAP DEAL? 16:22  |  ben Avraham 31/12/06
  76.   walid: the jews have come home!!!!!!! 16:24  |  Job 31/12/06
  77.   #60 NO CLICKFOOLITS BECAUSE ITS AUTOMATIC SETTINGS 16:27  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  78.   Funny... 16:44  |  John 31/12/06
  79.   #69 PAUL HARRIS (Hairy Paul) . . . . . 16:50  |  revoltop 31/12/06
  80.   Read the damn history you peasants 16:50  |  Marilyn 31/12/06
  81.   General U Thant of the UN said 16:53  |  Marilyn 31/12/06
  82.   biblical schizophrenia 16:56  |  Axel 31/12/06
  83.   Joe#35 16:57  |  John 31/12/06
  84.   Levy and Levy the dictator. . . . 16:58  |  revoltop 31/12/06
  85.   yonatan 17:05  |  John 31/12/06
  86.   Walid #59 Part1 17:21  |  Gabe1 31/12/06
  87.   Israel is GOD`s land 17:22  |  albert paul ortiz 31/12/06
  88.   Walid #59 Part 2 17:33  |  Gabe1