Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 31, 2006 Tevet 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:14 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
IDF Chief of Staff San Halutz (Kobi Gideon / BauBau)
Last update - 10:29 30/12/2006
Probe results on Lebanon war do not call for Halutz resignation
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent

The Israel Defense Forces' inquiries into the second Lebanon war will conclude soon, following the submission of the last probe's findings on Friday.

Former chief of staff Dan Shomron conducted the inquiry that focused on the General Staff's performance during the war.

Shomron's conclusions are considered "soft," and he did not recommend personal sanctions against anyone. Chief of Staff Dan Halutz is therefore not required to resign from his position. Halutz will convene the IDF's most senior officers on Monday for a two-day conference at which all the inquiries' findings will be presented. General Staff officers expect that Halutz, encouraged by the Shomron report, will announce his plan to lead rehabilitation efforts based on the probes' conclusions.

Advertisement

Shomron, who served as chief of staff during the first intifada, told Army Radio upon being appointed to head the inquiry that he did not believe his role included personal recommendations.

Although Shomron's report relies heavily on the findings of other inquiries, it is not written as sharply as those penned by Major General Udi Shani or Major General (res.) Amiram Levin.

Shomron highlights the delay in calling up reservists and Halutz's failure to pressure politicians into authorizing such a call-up - which Halutz admits in retrospect; the belated declaration of a state of war, five days after Hezbollah kidnapped two IDF soldiers on the northern border; the fact no war room was opened in the IDF headquarters' underground bunker; and belated identification of the short-range Katyusha rocket problem.

Shomron has told associates recently that despite his reservations about Halutz's performance and that of the General Staff, he believes the current team should stay in uniform and continue to lead the IDF. Shomron believes that their experience in this unsuccessful war will serve them well in the rehabilitation process.

At an Air Force cadet graduation ceremony at the Hatzerim base Thursday, Halutz praised the four-month inquiry process, which he called the "way to improve and progress," adding: "No inquiry of this kind has ever been carried out in the IDF, with the intention of becoming a better army."

Military sources believe the forward-looking commencement speech is further evidence that Halutz does not plan to resign.


Bookmark to del.icio.us
Fast forward
Time just goes by and refuses to synchronize itself with me. It will happen to you too.
Deli in the desert
The Reuben proved that it's possible to eat sauerkraut with corned beef in the morning.
  1.   Probe finds no one else more competent 06:31  |  Hannah 29/12/06
  2.   hannah we do not need competent people 08:54  |  amnon reshef 29/12/06
  3.   What a shame on us all 09:55  |  Robin 29/12/06
  4.   Dangerous incompetency 10:42  |  S 29/12/06
  5.   robin baresbreast 10:50  |  yirmi 29/12/06
  6.   s quit the histrionics and amateur moralising 10:52  |  israelisok 29/12/06
  7.   hannah 11:01  |  mb 29/12/06
  8.   hannah 11:11  |  mb 29/12/06
  9.   to hannah idf iaf 11:14  |  mb 29/12/06
  10.   to s 11:25  |  mb 29/12/06
  11.   #5, Yirmi 11:53  |  Hannah 29/12/06
  12.   #6,7,8, mb 12:02  |  Hannah 29/12/06
  13.   mb #10 12:39  |  S 29/12/06
  14.   We lost the Lebanon2 war. 12:44  |  Nora 29/12/06
  15.   We lost the Lebanon2 war. 12:44  |  Nora 29/12/06
  16.   #14/15, Nora 13:09  |  Hannah 29/12/06
  17.   to hannah - The same answer even against facts! 13:14  |  mb 29/12/06
  18.   Choose soft get soft. 13:20  |  Nora 29/12/06
  19.   to all soldiers fallen families and friends 13:50  |  mb 29/12/06
  20.   Yes halutz made a good job- for #9 #5 13:56  |  Robin 29/12/06
  21.   To Mr Robin 1 14:23  |  mb 29/12/06
  22.   To mr. robin 2 14:30  |  mb 29/12/06
  23.   Mr robin 3 14:39  |  mb 29/12/06
  24.   mb`s pride 17:16  |  S 29/12/06
  25.   So What Exactly Is the Penalty For the Wasted Lives in ... 17:30  |  Klaudia 29/12/06
  26.   to mb 21,22,23 17:36  |  Robin 29/12/06
  27.   Contrite Dan Halutz 17:46  |  Esther 29/12/06
  28.   Hannah: Whether Israel Lets Down Its Guard Periodically Or Not 20:45  |  Lavi 29/12/06
  29.   to Ester #27 Let this valuable man prove himself. 20:53  |  Robin 29/12/06
  30.   to 26 21:05  |  mb 29/12/06
  31.   Halutz said one thing that condemned him .. 23:03  |  redmike 29/12/06
  32.   #27 - he protected soldiers and not citizens - a grave error ! 23:11  |  redmike 29/12/06
  33.   to mb #30 23:14  |  Robin 29/12/06
  34.   Halutz and his cronies 23:45  |  Observer 29/12/06
  35.   Whitewash 01:28  |  Mark Lincoln 30/12/06
  36.   HALUTZ FAILED THIS TIME.HE SHOULD RESIGN 01:42  |  REUVEN 30/12/06
  37.   #28, Lavi 01:58  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  38.   Dear Hannah, whoever you are 04:45  |  Otto Rand 30/12/06
  39.   Hannah #37: Israeli Bodies Are Made Up Of Flesh & Blood ... 08:36  |  Lavi 30/12/06
  40.   #38, Otto Rand 09:00  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  41.   #39, Lavi, Part 1 10:21  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  42.   Hannah: The Palestinian Team Needs A Good Defender ... 10:29  |  Lavi 30/12/06
  43.   #39, Lavi, Part 2 10:29  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  44.   Klaudia to Otto Rand 10:57  |  S 30/12/06
  45.   To Lavi 11:57  |  imad 30/12/06
  46.   Hannah vs. Otto Rand 12:07  |  Nadav 30/12/06
  47.   #39 IDF No Differeent the Terrorists 12:25  |  Tupac 30/12/06
  48.   Haaretz stops me again 13:14  |  S 30/12/06
  49.   #42 - the result of cowards hiding behind women and children 14:11  |  redmike 30/12/06
  50.   In Lebanon the IDF lost from sheer cleverness 14:29  |  Natallie Durson 30/12/06
  51.   Imad, knowing languages is a very good thing, and Arabic is one.. 14:38  |  Nadav 30/12/06
  52.   # 44- S... Huh? 15:45  |  Klaudia 30/12/06
  53.   they are laughing 17:20  |  fred 30/12/06
  54.   #52 klaudia 17:33  |  S 30/12/06
  55.   S, some of my responses to Hannah have not gone through. I hope.. 18:21  |  Nadav 30/12/06
  56.   To: Nadav 19:48  |  imad 30/12/06
  57.   to S, Klaudia 20:07  |  imad 30/12/06
  58.   Hannah: The Palestinian People Deserve More ... 20:10  |  Lavi 30/12/06
  59.   Imad, is it not the case that the brave "resistance fighters", be 20:51  |  Nadav 30/12/06
  60.   To Nadav 21:22  |  imad 30/12/06
  61.   To Nadav - 2nd response 21:41  |  imad 30/12/06
  62.   to: rEDmIKE 21:45  |  imad 30/12/06
  63.   Imad: Hezbollah Media Is Custom Scripted, Videotaped, ... 22:14  |  Lavi 30/12/06
  64.   Imad: Did Hezbollah Media Report On Israel`s Interrogation of .. 22:34  |  Lavi 30/12/06
  65.   #46, Nadav 22:56  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  66.   To Hannah #40 23:13  |  Otto Rand 30/12/06
  67.   Hannah #43: Is It Normal For Any Brave Fighter To ... 23:51  |  Lavi 30/12/06
 Today Online
Saddam Hussein executed by hanging in Baghdad
Responses: 404
200 trailers placed in West Bank outposts since June
Responses: 370
Bradley Burston: The Archbishop's guide to Muslim intolerance
Responses: 307
Israel must show Palestinians Abbas is better than Hamas
Responses: 131
Shmuel Rosner: Are intermarried couples hopeless?
Responses: 100
Yoel Marcus: Heading into 2007, Israel is not exactly fun to live in
Responses: 105
Rosner's Domain
* Every Qassam pushes back the clock
* Was Ford a good President for Israel?
* The in-married Jewish people, the intermarried Jewish people
* Poll: what to do about the rockets from Gaza?


More Headlines
21:22 Deputy Defense Minister: Israel worried about post-Saddam Iraq
01:24 Family: Saddam Hussein to be buried in Sunni stronghold of Ramadi
23:45 ANALYSIS - Saddam's execution: Settling accounts with Bush
01:50 Deputy Al-Qaida leader calls Abbas, Fatah 'secular traitors'
00:03 Nazareth man stabbed to death; biker injured in Jaffa shooting
19:29 Abbas to visit Gaza for first time since breakout of PA violence
10:15 200 new trailers placed in West Bank settlements since June
10:54 Financial spat will not torpedo antimissile systems for El Al jets
19:51 Four-year-old boy dies from injuries sustained in 4 story fall
18:59 Two killed, two others injured in fatal car crash near Arad
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved