Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., January 01, 2007 Tevet 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:11 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Painting a rosier future
By Haaretz Editorial

The views that Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni has expressed recently are a welcome continuation of the prime minister's Sde Boker speech, and even go beyond it. The foreign minister proposes directing efforts toward energetic diplomatic activity with the Palestinians, in an orderly and sustained fashion, and not only as an occasional gesture. She thinks that progress must be made constantly, without being conditioned on progress in the cease-fire. Livni also says that Palestinian good behavior should not be a precondition for goodwill gestures, but only for the agreement that will be signed in the end. And she also calls for bolstering the moderate camp among the Palestinians.

When the Palestinians hold elections, which appears likely to happen in the coming months, they must know what is at stake if they elect Hamas. This is not a threat, just a promise, and it should be made clear at the most practical level. At the end of the day, it is the Palestinians' decision. Currently, the Palestinian voter can see no obvious advantage in voting for Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian Authority chairman. But if they are shown a brighter future, with a detailed program for gains; if it is made clear to them what symbols of Palestinian sovereignty they will be given and how their lives might improve, then perhaps there is still a chance for the moderates to win. Israel is the occupier, so it is the one that must present the future that will follow the occupation. Instead of handing out carrots in measured quantities, it must make it clear to the Palestinians that the final target is for them to grow their own carrots and not be dependent on Israel. It is necessary to talk ceaselessly about the stage after the occupation - the stage of separation, independence - and about borders and cooperation.

The foreign minister's moderation; her support for Ehud Olmert's policy of restraint against Amir Peretz; her openness to the world and her willingness to accept their help; her desire for a cease-fire as early as the second day of the war in Lebanon, out of a clear understanding that diplomacy would achieve more than a thousands bombs; her emphasis on the conflict with the Palestinians as the root of the problem; her attempts to deal with Iran in a low-key, discreet way, instead of being drawn into Benjamin Netanyahu's rhetoric; and above all, the optimism that Livni broadcasts and the hope that the Olmert-Livni team, if they cooperate instead of being dragged into prestige battles, could further a genuine agenda - these are the important aspects of the interviews she has granted to the press.

Advertisement

The foreign minister emphasizes that the ball is in the Palestinians' court. The Palestinians are the ones who need to decide whether their aim is to bring about an end to the occupation and the conflict, by deciding between Hamas and Fatah. However, Israel cannot remain an uninvolved observer. It must promote a better future, instead of just talking about it. If the Palestinian voter thinks that nothing will come of supporting Abbas, he will vote accordingly. If instead of continuing to say that Abbas is weak and that, in the end, Hamas will inevitably win, we say that everything depends on the Palestinian voter, and that only he can bring about an end to the Israeli occupation, then perhaps Abbas and his supporters, with the active support of the Arab world, will succeed in tipping the balance.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A father's plea
The father of captured IDF soldier Gilad Shalit publishes an open letter to his son.
Privatizing drought
The Milgam company will lead the Water Commission's conservation campaign.
  1.   this fuzzy belief that israel can micro manage 09:55  |  nowecant 29/12/06
  2.   this fuzzy belief that israel can micro manage 09:55  |  nowecant 29/12/06
  3.   the barbarians know their own minds 09:57  |  youcrazy 29/12/06
  4.   More than Press Releases? 10:15  |  Mark of Lewiston 29/12/06
  5.   WHY BOTHER ? ARABS DONT CHANGE 10:27  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  6.   Israel`s Vichy Government 10:29  |  Yacov 29/12/06
  7.   A game of spin the Arab 10:40  |  Natallie Durson 29/12/06
  8.   A losing strategy 10:41  |  Hannah 29/12/06
  9.   Israels wishful thinking and the reality on the ground 10:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/12/06
  10.   to youcrazy 10:53  |  Y 29/12/06
  11.   Israel must show Palestine that Abbas is better? 11:15  |  Stephen Murray 29/12/06
  12.   For the moment we`re stuck with our government, 11:19  |  sh 29/12/06
  13.   Fatah And Hamas Are Both Terrorist Groups 11:20  |  Yishai Kohen 29/12/06
  14.   Paul Harris #5 not that i should expect better of you but... 12:08  |  mollio uk 29/12/06
  15.   #11 STEPHEN AND THE INABILITY TO REASON 12:14  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  16.   #13 12:14  |  mollio uk 29/12/06
  17.   ISRAELI LEFT IS IN DENIAL 13:01  |  SAM 29/12/06
  18.   Spinning The Arab 13:01  |  Yosemite Sam 29/12/06
  19.   mollio: Why Don`t You Share London With The IRA? 13:18  |  Yishai Kohen 29/12/06
  20.   Eliminate Hamas & Fatah 13:59  |  Terry 29/12/06
  21.   Abbas better than Hamas for Zionism, not for Palestinians 14:01  |  Fatah 29/12/06
  22.   Yosemite...the land is occupied not disputed 14:04  |  expert in int law 29/12/06
  23.   Mahmoud Abbas 14:07  |  Johnny Weintraub 29/12/06
  24.   Still trying to help Abbas? 14:08  |  Briton 29/12/06
  25.   Yishai Kohen: Israel is also a terrorist state 14:08  |  honest Jew 29/12/06
  26.   mollio! the new kid on the block 14:09  |  Watcher 29/12/06
  27.   #16 14:26  |  Jacob 29/12/06
  28.   `Uninvolved observer` 14:28  |  JJ 29/12/06
  29.   #19 14:29  |  mollio uk 29/12/06
  30.   Olmest and Livni are leftist defeatists in fantasy land 14:43  |  DANIEL ROSEHTHAL 29/12/06
  31.   I dont believe for a minute that this is an independent decision 14:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/12/06
  32.   At last, some logical, calculated enlightened thinking! 14:45  |  Tzfonit 29/12/06
  33.   #29: Bull- Give The IRA London 14:46  |  Yishai Kohen 29/12/06
  34.   Lost opportunities 14:55  |  Joe 29/12/06
  35.   #19 the IRA 14:58  |  Tony 29/12/06
  36.   Just more Israeli narcissism 14:59  |  Tim 29/12/06
  37.   mollio uk #29 15:05  |  Gee 29/12/06
  38.   Fatah-#21-You want war not peace 15:05  |  Daniel Delmonte 29/12/06
  39.   expert in int law #22 15:08  |  Gee 29/12/06
  40.   Fatah: What have you built?????? 15:09  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/12/06
  41.   Delusions of Ha`aretz 15:09  |  Shlomo 29/12/06
  42.   Bracha not Tsfonit- Teller of Fairy Tales 15:12  |  Gabe1 29/12/06
  43.   Hannah-#8-A loosing strategy? 15:21  |  Daniel Leopold 29/12/06
  44.   # 31 Ronnie Wolman 15:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/12/06
  45.   #14 SORRY MOLIO I SHOULD HAVE SAID 97.5%OF ARABS 15:28  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  46.   #31...writing the Protocols of Mecca 15:32  |  Tim 29/12/06
  47.   #29 MOLLIO AND THE ERROR OF HER WAYS 15:35  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  48.   #21 THE FUTURE IS INDEED CLEAR DOES OLMERT GET IT ? 15:37  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  49.   spiritually diseased zionist thinking 15:55  |  naftaly k 29/12/06
  50.   # 19-mollio uk 15:55  |  Klaudia 29/12/06
  51.   Israel must show terrorism does not pay 16:05  |  B 29/12/06
  52.   STRENGTHEN THE QUIZLING? FAT cHANCE 16:32  |  GOODDOCTOR 29/12/06
  53.   Release Marwan 17:25  |  Baz Mann 29/12/06
  54.   Not a threat, but a promise? 17:25  |  H50 29/12/06
  55.   for someone who is expert in law you have a 17:30  |  amused 29/12/06
  56.   Article is based on a lie 17:32  |  H50 29/12/06
  57.   Very Patronizing Editorial 17:44  |  Jane 29/12/06
  58.   # 8 17:45  |  ChanahS 29/12/06
  59.   Reply to Ronnie Wolman 18:01  |  Johnny Weintraub 29/12/06
  60.   Livni?s peace plan 18:08  |  Tosefta 29/12/06
  61.   Haaretz`s dream for the new year 18:09  |  Tosefta 29/12/06
  62.   Nothing is ever enough 18:36  |  John 29/12/06
  63.   For god`s sake Israel stay the hell out of it 18:45  |  Marilyn 29/12/06
  64.   to Stephen Murray from Amsterdam 18:46  |  Jack 29/12/06
  65.   If it was the final possibility? 18:47  |  jean-marie 29/12/06
  66.   Yosemite, it is the Israeli`s who are the butchers 18:48  |  Marilyn 29/12/06
  67.   Abbas editorial 19:30  |  Laura Mohammad 29/12/06
  68.   Marilyn 19:50  |  Michael 29/12/06
  69.   Surreal 20:01  |  Colin Wright 29/12/06
  70.   Bracha NOT Tzfonit /Ben Ami NOT Nahariya 20:03  |  Gabe1- 29/12/06
  71.   therefore 20:33  |  H 29/12/06
  72.   A THREAT BY ISRAEL... 20:44  |  MIKE KATZ 29/12/06
  73.   you`re killing me 20:44  |  Pssd Off American 29/12/06
  74.   Indefinite truce 20:51  |  Not in my name 29/12/06
  75.   Haaretz supports palestinian refusal to take responsibility 21:12  |  Bimmer 29/12/06
  76.   Sorry, I`m Not Into Cultural Relatavism 21:29  |  Yosemite Sam 29/12/06
  77.   #13 all three entities like 3 peas in a pod!! 21:36  |  ballistic 29/12/06
  78.   #31 Ronnie; like I said on many posts 21:50  |  ballistic 29/12/06
  79.   #39 the premise of collective punishment 21:56  |  ballistic 29/12/06
  80.   hand picked STOOGES... 22:19  |  MIKE KATZ 29/12/06
  81.   #57 IDF "most human soldiers in the world"!! 22:19  |  ballistic 29/12/06
  82.   #38 Paul Harris 22:28  |  mollio uk 29/12/06
  83.   Show the Palestinian a brighter future? 23:28  |  Abe 29/12/06
  84.   #61 Tosefta is correct, since all indications show that Abba`s 00:07  |  Smadar 30/12/06
  85.   Thanks Gabe 1 00:40  |  Tzfonit (Bracha) 30/12/06
  86.   Abbas vs. Hamas is not the issue, the outcome is 00:44  |  Dr. L. Brnd 30/12/06
  87.   Good advice - a year ago 01:04  |  Mark Lincoln 30/12/06
  88.   Ballistic: When Bush comes to Shove 01:14  |  Ronnie Wolman 30/12/06
  89.   Painting a rosier picture 01:19  |  Yellowbirdwoman 30/12/06
  90.   #86 Dr. response--I wouldn`t be pushing that war 01:46  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  91.   Helping Abbas 01:47  |  Reality Check 30/12/06
  92.   #88 Ronnie--I don`t know what is going on either 01:56  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  93.   Shouldn`t Israel show they are better then both first? 02:15  |  Guy From NYC 30/12/06
  94.   Ballistic: Anxieties were always Us 02:48  |  Ronnie Wolman 30/12/06
  95.   `Unless`..The new gun Boat Diplomacy. 04:01  |  Akram Zekaria 30/12/06
  96.   "Ballistic", Israel doesn`t need Hague OK to try war criminals 04:32  |  Dr. L. Brnd 30/12/06
  97.   Victory for Hamas is defeat for Israel? Or not! 05:47  |  Voice of Reason 30/12/06
  98.   honest Jew 06:22  |  honest Arab 30/12/06
  99.   Israeli political support for Abbas 06:34  |  gladiarornyc 30/12/06
  100.   borders - HAHAHA 10:13  |  keith 30/12/06
  101.   #98 honest arab 10:20  |  keith 30/12/06
  102.   If Fatah is found to better then Hamas 11:19  |  Guy From NYC 30/12/06
  103.   Why Israel treats Abbas with contempt 11:41  |  Clickfool 30/12/06
  104.   Clickfool 12:37  |  LL 30/12/06
  105.   Abbas is good for Israel 13:17  |  Alphonse 30/12/06
  106.   #100 KEITH AND THE JOKES ON HIM 13:30  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  107.   For LL # 105 15:51  |  Clickfool 30/12/06
  108.   Tsfonit/Bracha Or Ben Ami/Nahariya 16:18  |  Gabe1 30/12/06
  109.   # 107 Clickfool 16:34  |  Joseph E . 30/12/06
  110.   honest Jew to Honest Arab 17:43  |  Honest Jew 30/12/06
  111.   Plan in stages (Smadar #84) 17:44  |  Tosefta 30/12/06
  112.   Israsel must show Palestinians that Abbas is better than hamas 18:02  |  bob poris 30/12/06
  113.   To Be Or Not To Be Dependent Upon Israel 18:10  |  Eman 30/12/06
  114.   #109, Joseph E--er, pardon me for intruding on the post, but 18:55  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  115.   Honestly Guys 18:58  |  Mark Lincoln 30/12/06
  116.   #100 Keith response 19:00  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  117.   #96 silly and unenforceable law 19:13  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  118.   Clickfool 19:17  |  LL 30/12/06
  119.   For Joseph E, marching up and down with his little tin drum # 109 19:23  |  Clickfool 30/12/06
  120.   Why can`t they figure it out on there own... 19:23  |  deal 30/12/06
  121.   #94 Ronnie response 19:24  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  122.   Israel must? 20:38  |  Jon Purizhansky 30/12/06
  123.   Ballistic: Blocks and Ad Hocs 20:41  |  Ronnie Wolman 30/12/06
  124.   How can we show a better future? 20:59  |  Simcha 30/12/06
  125.   For LL on discussion board etiquette # 118 21:11  |  Clickfool 30/12/06
  126.   The Editorial 22:14  |  Mordechai 30/12/06
  127.   abbas/hamas 00:09  |  tom 31/12/06
  128.   Clickfool 00:10  |  LL 31/12/06
  129.   Missed Opportunities 00:23  |  Ramez 31/12/06
  130.   More Nonsense from the Oracles of Appeasement 00:49  |  Tod Zuckerman 31/12/06
  131.   Meddling in their business - kiss of death 00:58  |  david 31/12/06
  132.   #107 Clickfool 01:08  |  Jim 31/12/06
  133.   Clickfool re #125 01:46  |  Oh please 31/12/06
  134.   #119 Clickfool 01:51  |  Jim 31/12/06
  135.   #125 Clickfool 02:08  |  Jim 31/12/06
  136.   #126 Mordechai 02:12  |  Jim 31/12/06
  137.   ClickFOOL, etiquite, blah blah. Not important folks. 02:43  |  Dave from Chicago 31/12/06
  138.   ..What really matters... 02:53  |  Dave from Chicago 31/12/06
  139.   ..what really matters II..... 03:01  |  Dave from Chicago 31/12/06
  140.   ...what really matters III... 03:09  |  Dave from Chicago 31/12/06
  141.   "... that Abbas is better than Hamas" 04:28  |  Moises 31/12/06
  142.   palistians 08:25  |  sara avin 31/12/06
  143.   is not if Abbas is better... 13:31  |  jean marie 31/12/06
  144.   Fatah(Abbas )that murders US citizens R not good terrorists 19:44  |  sam 31/12/06
  145.   #86: Yes, people and countries can change 23:50  |  Harry 31/12/06
  146.   103: Wow, CF, an Uncle Tom who denies the Holocaust 08:42  |  David Teich 01/01/07
  147.   131: Yet David from Tucson has no problems meddling 13:06  |  David Teich 01/01/07
 Today Online
Rosner's guest: 'Seeing evangelicals as dumb rednecks'
Responses: 108
Peace Now photos show new caravans at Amona outpost
Responses: 85
Israel rejects demand it release 1,000 prisoners
Responses: 17
Avigdor Lieberman: Israel should press to join NATO, EU
Responses: 85
New IDF Gadna youth program criticized as overly militaristic
Responses: 9
Shlomo Shamir: Was Israelis' hostility to Annan justified?
Responses: 24


More Headlines
11:14 Israel rejects demand it release 1,000 prisoners
11:42 'Halutz will quit if probe blames him personally for war failures'
07:57 Peace Now aerial photos show new caravans at Amona outpost
09:36 Avigdor Lieberman: Israel should press to join NATO, EU
12:54 Plan: Half of MKs would be elected to represent regions
13:01 New IDF Gadna youth program criticized as overly militaristic
07:41 Proposed law would fine prisoners for vandalizing jails
07:59 Gov't to expand list of reserve soldiers entitled to war benefits
06:11 Court orders media to give police all material on Katzrin murder
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved