Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 31, 2006 Tevet 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The year of the zigzag
By Yoel Marcus

Apart from the dramatic news that the singing duo Datz and Datza are finally getting divorced, two nights from now, we will be bidding farewell to a year in which nothing that happened was predicted or certain.

Take peace with Syria, for example. Is Bashar Assad really willing to negotiate, or interested in negotiating, with Israel? It depends whom you ask. The chief of the Mossad claims we have no information to that effect. But the head of Military Intelligence's research division says yes, Assad is prepared to be politically flexible. Two agencies that constitute the basis of our defense system are busy contradicting one another, and not for the first time.

Then we have Ehud Olmert putting in his two cents: Talking to Syria goes against the interests of George Bush, so it is not going to happen. The next day, he changes his mind: Dialogue with Syria is possible. Tzipi Livni hears this and says Syria is ready for an agreement. Barely an hour goes by and Olmert backtracks: There has been no change in the Syrian position. Then comes the Foreign Ministry's response: The signals from Damascus are genuine and Assad will agree to a "cold peace." So who's got it right? Zig or zag?

Advertisement

The rivalry between our two intelligence agencies is enough to make you dizzy. The Mossad is now predicting an attack on Israel this coming summer, but Military Intelligence says nothing doing. Come to think of it, what do they know? Did they predict last year that this year there would be another war in Lebanon?

Yitzhak Rabin and Shimon Peres used to say that in the matter of peace agreements, intelligence has always fallen down on the job. Can we trust the Mossad's assessment that Iran will have nuclear weapons three years from now? And how will we know that Israel is ready to take preemptive action? When the chief of staff gives orders to his bank to sell his shares?

Last week, Olmert paid a surprise visit to King Abdullah of Jordan. A new political initiative? A report on his invitation to Mahmoud Abbas? The mystery question is what Olmert said to the king to make him run off and tell a Japanese newspaper that "Israel is not as strong as we thought." Is that what Olmert told him? And is that any way to show gratitude for our rescuing Jordan from a Syrian invasion back in September 1970? When Syrian troops massed along the Jordanian border, Israel presented an ultimatum that made the Syrians pull back. The naughty joke going around in those days was that Golda Meir had warned the Syrian army: Over my (dead) body.

But Jordan's ungrateful king is not the only one spoiling our reputation. The U.S. senators who came to visit also expressed doubt that Israel was still the superman of the Middle East and a deterrent, stabilizing force. The three musketeers of the Lebanon War - Olmert, Amir Peretz and Dan Halutz - seriously damaged Israel's image as a mythical powerhouse with reckless decisions comparable to none.

The most pathetic of the three is Peretz, who bragged that he "gave the orders," he "led" the campaign, etcetera, etcetera. Now he is crying that Olmert has neutralized him and he is no longer part of the decision-making process. But after the zig - whining about his misfortunes - comes the zag: "I'm made of tough stuff. I don't break so fast. I know how to fight, and I know how to win."

Stupid he's not, but Peretz would have been a hell of a defense minister if he had vetoed the war and sided with Rafi Eitan's proposal that "Israel will respond when and where it sees fit." Without Peretz, Olmert would not have gone to war. As Ehud Barak likes to say, unlike sports, where the main thing is participating, in war, the main thing is winning.

The eight-month-old Olmert administration is weak and battered. None of its ministers or Knesset supporters are very anxious for early elections, so the chances of this happening are slim. But in these zigzag times of ours, anything is possible. The bomb could fall when Olmert, Peretz and Halutz are called in for questioning by the Winograd Commission, if, as a result, the commission issues an interim report so devastating that it sets off a public tsunami, like the one after the Yom Kippur War, and sends Olmert flying.

With a prime minister who declares his country a nuclear power, but cannot do anything about the Qassam rockets or Hamas, which is preparing for an offensive, Israel is zigzagging its way toward 2007 as a place that is not exactly fun to live in.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Fast forward
Time just goes by and refuses to synchronize itself with me. It will happen to you too.
Deli in the desert
The Reuben proved that it's possible to eat sauerkraut with corned beef in the morning.
  1.   TIM E FOR THE DISSOLUTION OF KADIMA NEW ELECTIONS 10:25  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  2.   but Marcus, Olmert/Kadima is Sharon`s Doing and YOURS 10:31  |  Pablo 29/12/06
  3.   2006 was a poor year for Israel, 2007 will be worse 10:40  |  Clickfool 29/12/06
  4.   At least Clickfool has a reason to celebrate... 10:49  |  Somebody from Europe 29/12/06
  5.   Isreal has been badly led for a long time 10:50  |  RW 29/12/06
  6.   CLICKFOOL WHER DO YOU GET THIS HOIRSE MANURE FROM 11:13  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  7.   Yes, indeed, so-called Israel seems like a horrible place 11:17  |  Hannah 29/12/06
  8.   Yoel Marcus Paints a Grim ,Accurate, Picture.. 11:40  |  Klaudia 29/12/06
  9.   Israel Not Fun? 11:43  |  Dror 29/12/06
  10.   Not Fun? cont. 11:46  |  Dror 29/12/06
  11.   Always happy to hear from Hannah 11:58  |  Ismail 29/12/06
  12.   Yes, Hannah, just like Italy... 11:59  |  Somebody from Europe 29/12/06
  13.   I had fun in 2006, can`t wait for 2007! 12:01  |  Sam 29/12/06
  14.   So nice to hear!!!!! 12:11  |  tony 29/12/06
  15.   #7 AND WHERE YOU LIVE HANNAH IT DOESNT HAPPEN 12:24  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  16.   Shattered dreams 12:25  |  Lena 29/12/06
  17.   I am sure Israel 2006 is a fun place to live..... 12:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/12/06
  18.   Clickfool is right 12:35  |  mollio uk 29/12/06
  19.   Major hotels and airlines for Passover almost fully booked now. 12:36  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  20.   to Sam - Amen! 12:39  |  Me 29/12/06
  21.   # 9- Dror....You Said It ! 12:39  |  Klaudia 29/12/06
  22.   HANNAH I have never bumped into "fully formed turd" 12:41  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  23.   Tony in SA 12:42  |  Somebody from Europe 29/12/06
  24.   to Lena 12:59  |  Me 29/12/06
  25.   Clickfool and mollio uk 13:00  |  Somebody from Europe 29/12/06
  26.   TONY "S.A. a proper country" with an epidemic of violence 13:03  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  27.   The reputation of the IDF was ruined in Lebanon 13:08  |  GPWS.1 29/12/06
  28.   wishes from the heart... 13:12  |  saul a. readner 29/12/06
  29.   Klaudia in Canada 13:15  |  Dror 29/12/06
  30.   SWISS RE "fun".The smiling Swiss are joy to be with. 13:20  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  31.   LENA" I knew, that I will be here about four years" 13:40  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  32.   What a Bore??? 13:44  |  asa 29/12/06
  33.   # 30 PETER SM 13:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/12/06
  34.   asa in far Australia 14:34  |  Me 29/12/06
  35.   Time to leave Israel,Yoel, take Gideon and Amira w/ you! 14:37  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 29/12/06
  36.   To 31/ PETERSM,T0 24 Me 14:43  |  Lena 29/12/06
  37.   Thanks Lena #16 14:53  |  Alicia 29/12/06
  38.   #14 Tony...........Where do you live???? 15:14  |  Joe Moer 29/12/06
  39.   For Peter SM, who never bumped into a fully formed turd 15:26  |  Clickfool 29/12/06
  40.   Hannah, why are you so obsessed focusing on a place, 15:30  |  Nadav 29/12/06
  41.   Lena 15:38  |  Me 29/12/06
  42.   it never was, it will never be except for bandits 15:38  |  arab 29/12/06
  43.   # 72 marcus is not the problem, others are 15:44  |  arab 29/12/06
  44.   german-jews 15:50  |  wh 29/12/06
  45.   The decline of the zionist entity 16:46  |  Amin Nusseibeh 29/12/06
  46.   Hannah describes her own home squatting among the garbage 17:12  |  Jasmine Murphy 29/12/06
  47.   #38 SEWAGE INTO THE SEA STILL EXISTS EVERYWHER E 17:45  |  paul harris 29/12/06
  48.   Zigzag to the point of dizziness 17:52  |  S 29/12/06
  49.   Yoel Marcus 18:16  |  Gabi Z 29/12/06
  50.   Twisted logic, didn`t mention tsunami and Janes Brown... 19:12  |  Ron 29/12/06
  51.   SWISS Happy New Year 19:17  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  52.   SO MOVE! 19:20  |  Brant 29/12/06
  53.   Paul Harris : Wishful thinking... 19:41  |  christa 29/12/06
  54.   Lena.A very recent health survey in Israel 19:47  |  PETERSM 29/12/06
  55.   Lena 20:44  |  Me 29/12/06
  56.   Brant 20:45  |  Me 29/12/06
  57.   NOT SO Paul Harris #41 21:21  |  Alicia 29/12/06
  58.   Amin Nusseibeh 21:46  |  Somebody from Europe 29/12/06
  59.   re # 48 Yoel Marcus 21:52  |  Izy L 29/12/06
  60.   Marcus`s wrong:Orange camp predicted that Itnatkut will bring War 22:09  |  The AntiMarcus 29/12/06
  61.   # 51 PETER SM 22:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/12/06
  62.   Appreciate what you have 22:52  |  David Hoffman 29/12/06
  63.   NUSSEBEH.When any of your Islamic Paradises catch up 23:03  |  PETER SM 29/12/06
  64.   Syrians and peace 23:11  |  Tosefta 29/12/06
  65.   Zig-zagging Marcus still doesn`t get it 00:41  |  Absolute Sweden 30/12/06
  66.   # 7 take off your burka 01:34  |  larzbeach 30/12/06
  67.   Israel should thank Palestinians... 02:30  |  Maureen Ann 30/12/06
  68.   Somebody from Europe 03:48  |  justice 30/12/06
  69.   tosefta 04:26  |  justice 30/12/06
  70.   all the haters out in force 05:50  |  sweis Melbourne 30/12/06
  71.   #70, Sweis Melbourne 07:32  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  72.   All talk 09:01  |  Downunder 30/12/06
  73.   yes, proud 09:59  |  sweis Melbourne 30/12/06
  74.   to justice 10:40  |  Somebody from Europe 30/12/06
  75.   Question to Hannah 10:46  |  Somebody from Europe 30/12/06
  76.   #75, Somebody 12:04  |  Hannah 30/12/06
  77.   Yes, Hannah 12:05  |  zelkha 30/12/06
  78.   # 35 - Cities Yoel, Gideon and Amira could move to.... 12:28  |  A.I.G. 30/12/06
  79.   #53 THIRD ATTEMPT WHAT ARE YOU WISHFUL ABOUT CRISTA 12:32  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  80.   Investers know that Iran nuke threat is bombast 13:26  |  Alphonse 30/12/06
  81.   monologues,shouting and namecalling!! 13:31  |  ben 30/12/06
  82.   #76 HANDS UP ON WHICH OF US WILL PAY THEIR FARE 14:09  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  83.   Yoel Marcus 14:41  |  Marco Strovsky 30/12/06
  84.   Again to Hannah 15:29  |  Somebody from Europe 30/12/06
  85.   why aren`t the principles of mr. burston`s talkback... 15:48  |  saul a. readner 30/12/06
  86.   #81 BEN THE KNESSET IS TRYING TO OUTLAW 16:02  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  87.   #85 AND LEAVE US WITH NO FUN AT ALL SAUL 16:03  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  88.   Impotent men, impotent government 16:31  |  Mark Lincoln 30/12/06
  89.   #88 mark the fashion for incompetence IS WORLD WIDE 17:13  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  90.   paul harris. You are a perfect example 17:41  |  ben 30/12/06
  91.   #THANK YOU BEN I KNOW IM PERFECT EVEN IF MY WIFE DOESNT AGREE 17:50  |  paul harris 30/12/06
  92.   Somebody from Europe 18:17  |  michael3k 30/12/06
  93.   # 3 On the other hand 21:00  |  ChanahS 30/12/06
  94.   # 14 Tony 21:07  |  ChanahS 30/12/06
  95.   paul harris re hannah 21:08  |  bev 30/12/06
  96.   #86 Trace Talkback Posters---what 21:36  |  ballistic 30/12/06
  97.   Mr Yoel Marcus 22:10  |  Gabi R 30/12/06
  98.   How interesting and encouraging, Paul Harris # 86 22:26  |  Clickfool 30/12/06
  99.   For Ballistic # 96 22:29  |  Clickfool 30/12/06
  100.   ben I don`t know if youn are joking 22:34  |  bev 30/12/06
  101.   zigzag 23:15  |  Peter Lauterman 30/12/06
  102.   zig zag 23:46  |  rob 30/12/06
  103.   europe not much funnier in my opinion 00:08  |  Albert Fischer 31/12/06
  104.   NO Fun Place to Live.... 00:32  |  Ali 31/12/06
  105.   That old joke 00:51  |  Dennis Gordon 31/12/06
  106.   CITIBANK announced a major expansion in ISRAEL next year.!! 02:28  |  PETERSM 31/12/06
  107.   berlin, budapest 02:40  |  sweis Melbourne 31/12/06
  108.   ALI (Villanova).Israel is a MAJOR player in world technology 02:42  |  PETERSM 31/12/06
  109.   CITIBANK announced a major expansion in ISRAEL next year.!! 03:03  |  wibism 31/12/06
  110.   wibism bye 06:12  |  bev 31/12/06
  111.   To Yoel Marcus 06:17  |  Bimmer 31/12/06
  112.   #95 HAARETZ PRINT THEM TO KEEP THE POSTING ALIVE BEV 08:57  |  paul harris 31/12/06
  113.   Israel best place under the sun 09:09  |  Esther 31/12/06
  114.   Constructive criticism, please! 09:29  |  Ros 31/12/06
  115.   Hannah 09:32  |  Ros 31/12/06
  116.   #Paul Harris I have been called... 09:37  |  Maureen Ann 31/12/06
  117.   Esther I agree with you 10:01  |  Israeli 31/12/06
  118.   Hannah everywhere 10:03  |  Esther 31/12/06
  119.   Esther 10:06  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 31/12/06
  120.   Clickfool hohum 10:08  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 31/12/06
  121.   NO suprise Citibank is zionist 10:11  |  John 31/12/06
  122.   Tony 10:13  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 31/12/06
  123.   emollient mollio 10:15  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 31/12/06
  124.   Poor Lena 10:19  |  Jasmine Murphy 31/12/06
  125.   Hizbollah`s loss 5 months later is even more obvious 16:23  |  Mathew 31/12/06
  126.   Hizbollah loss 5 months later continued 16:33  |  Mathew 31/12/06
 Today Online
Palestinians: Hamas, Israel agree on deal to free Gilad Shalit
Responses: 90
Saddam death spurs joy in Iran, Kuwait, ire among Saudis
Responses: 79
Editorial: End the construction spree in W. Bank settlements
Responses: 92
Zvi Bar'el: Help! Syria's peace attack is underway!
Responses: 42
Canada probes abuse claims of asylum seekers from Israel
Responses: 121


More Headlines
17:39 Erekat: PA not notified of developments in talks
15:58 Palestinians publicly mourn Saddam, set up condolence tents
17:01 NIS 50.6 bn 2007 defense budget okayed in preliminary vote
18:32 Doctors petition against privatizing early childhood clinics
17:59 MTS group wins tender to build Tel Aviv light-rail train
16:33 Two killed, 20 injured as six mysterious blasts rock Bangkok
13:30 Eight people lightly injured when train plows into bulldozer
09:10 Canada probing abuse claims of asylum seekers from Israel
10:59 IDF to ease restrictions on West Bank population from Monday
09:28 Saddam hanging spurs joy in Iran, Kuwait, ire among Saudis
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved