Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 27, 2006 Tevet 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:32 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The test is yet to come
By Haaretz Editorial

The meeting between Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas was too little, too late. It was too late because Olmert waited for a year before inviting the Palestinian leader to a work meeting. And it was too little because in the year that has passed, the political standing of both figures has been seriously weakened.

The Palestinian Authority is being torn apart in an internal struggle and is on the verge of civil war, while Olmert has lost public support and is worried about potentially destabilizing his coalition. Under such conditions, despite the importance of the meeting, the two leaders will have a hard time turning it into a real political process.

Olmert depicted the meeting with Abbas as a first step in implementing the political initiative he raised four weeks ago in his Sde Boker speech. The prime minister made an offer to Abbas at the time to begin a political process that would include "the evacuation of many territories and communities established therein," the establishment of a Palestinian state with territorial contiguity in the West Bank, and the release of many prisoners. Since that speech, serious international pressure has been exerted on Olmert and Abbas to forgo their preconditions and agree to talk. Israel must show it is standing with Abbas and Fatah in their confrontation with Hamas.

Advertisement

Ahead of the meeting, Abbas conceded his demand that prisoners be released, and Olmert conceded his demands for a new Palestinian government and the release of abducted soldier Gilad Shalit. The prime minister also took a political risk in his decision to show restraint in the face of continuing Qassam fire from Gaza, despite pressure from Defense Minister Amir Peretz and other ministers to resume Israel Defense Forces activities there. Olmert's policy of restraint enabled the meeting to take place, an eventuality that was in doubt until the last moment.

The gestures that Olmert promised his guest at the Prime Minister's Residence - primarily unfreezing PA funds and removing roadblocks in the West Bank - are important and appropriate, but we must address them cautiously. Experience shows that Israel has promised repeatedly to provide relief for the Palestinian population that is not involved in terror, but it has never upheld such steps over time. This time it was clarified from the beginning that the gestures would be miserly: Olmert said that no prisoners would be freed before Shalit's release, and only some of the PA funds would be unfrozen, subject to the establishment of a supervisory mechanism. But even if the gestures are made, they will not be enough to strengthen Abbas' unstable position and shift the Palestinian public's support from Hamas to Fatah.

Olmert's test will therefore lie in his ability to continue the political process beyond a single meeting and initial gestures. Only if he perseveres with the process, sticks to his words and isn't deterred by difficulties will the Sde Boker initiative make progress and even be implemented. Olmert's remark at the cabinet meeting yesterday that he would consider freeing prisoners in honor of the Muslim holiday of Id al-Adha, even before Shalit is returned, was the first step in the right direction.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Animals for sale
International animal exports improve the bottom line of the Ramat Gan Safari.
Sewage stench
A tourist in Israel will quickly encounter an embarrassing fact: The country simply stinks.
  1.   u must read this 09:26  |  sho 25/12/06
  2.   At least feed the children 10:09  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  3.   Never before has been Abbas more hated in the West Bank 10:38  |  Palestinian 25/12/06
  4.   #2 MARYLIN AT THE EGGNOG AND WHER IS THEIS DISASTER TAKING PLACE 11:01  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  5.   Meeting with Abbas is pointless, meaningless 12:10  |  Natallie Durson 25/12/06
  6.   #3 Palestinian 12:14  |  Jim 25/12/06
  7.   #2 Marilyn 12:25  |  Jim 25/12/06
  8.   # 2 Marilyn, A slap instead of a kiss 12:43  |  Dutch 25/12/06
  9.   To 6, Jim 12:46  |  Jackline 25/12/06
  10.   Humbug Paul Harris 12:48  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  11.   Harris, The Man in the Moon 12:56  |  Dutch 25/12/06
  12.   Marilyn-#2-Whose money? 13:16  |  Daniel Leopold 25/12/06
  13.   no test between a master and his agent abbas 13:18  |  jm 25/12/06
  14.   Marilyn No. 2 on feeding children 13:20  |  Charles 25/12/06
  15.   Meeting with Abbas even more pointless, meaningless 13:22  |  Natallie Durson 25/12/06
  16.   Jim #6: If Hamas is murderer, Israel is a far greater murderer 13:23  |  Palestinian 25/12/06
  17.   Marilyn-#2-Whose money? 13:33  |  Daniel Leopold 25/12/06
  18.   Natalie Durson-#5-Nothing will satisfy you 13:34  |  Daniel Leopold 25/12/06
  19.   Palestinian-#3-Look at your Arab and Muslim brothers 13:43  |  Daniel Leopold 25/12/06
  20.   Olmert`s concessions too early, too much, too foolish 13:48  |  Yakov 25/12/06
  21.   Daniel Leopold and Charles and Jim 14:03  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  22.   #10 MARYLIN BETTER TO BE SENILE THAN UTTERLY STUPID 14:04  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  23.   5,000 Israeli`s affected? 14:07  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  24.   Daniel Leopold...Oh, I didn` t know that 14:12  |  Palestinian 25/12/06
  25.   #11 THE REASON IS DDRIS ITS JEWS WHO ARE INDIGENOUS 14:20  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  26.   What about :Moratorium on all news so we can live in Peace. 14:44  |  Akram Zekaria 25/12/06
  27.   To#17:Daniel Leopold, It is the Pals money 14:58  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  28.   To#17,18,19, We get sick of your worthless repetitive claims 15:23  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  29.   16 - End Terrorism 16:02  |  Bruriah Sarah 25/12/06
  30.   To#14 Charles, Marilyn is just saying a little about the truth 16:05  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  31.   27 & 28 - Hamas will use the money to destroy Israel 16:06  |  Bruriah Sarah 25/12/06
  32.   28 Human Rights? 16:08  |  Bruriah Sarah 25/12/06
  33.   So what? 16:18  |  Mark Lincoln 25/12/06
  34.   You hate-mongers will never have peace 16:24  |  Albert Lewis 25/12/06
  35.   PEACE DOESN`T HAPPEN OVERNIGHT 16:39  |  Smadar 25/12/06
  36.   To#25 Paul Harris, You know nothing about apartheid 16:40  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  37.   Abbas and Olmert 16:41  |  Jules Kadish 25/12/06
  38.   #28 ITS EASY HR DONT READ DONT COMMENT ON IT 16:42  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  39.   #30 REALITY AND TRUTH HAVE TWO SIDES 16:44  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  40.   To # 16 Bruriah Sarah, End your occupation 16:48  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  41.   ISRAEL DOES NOT WANT PEACE 16:53  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  42.   40 - Disputed, not Occupied 17:07  |  Bruriah Sarah 25/12/06
  43.   #32 Bruriah Sarah, I am the evidence 17:11  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  44.   Marylyn in "stupid Australia" 17:15  |  Avrum 25/12/06
  45.   Dear Editors, WHY? 17:20  |  Sidney 25/12/06
  46.   Albert Lewis, hate-mongers of both sides will never have peace 17:34  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  47.   #42 18:01  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  48.   Avrum in Canada 18:06  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  49.   Palestinian Faces Reality 18:22  |  Reality Check 25/12/06
  50.   Avrum in "stupid Montreal" 18:30  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  51.   007 ;-) 18:40  |  JJ 25/12/06
  52.   TO BRURIAH SARAH #42 18:47  |  Oetis 25/12/06
  53.   POCOHONTAS SMOKE PIPE OF PEACE AFTER 58 YEARS ASHES COLD 18:58  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  54.   Mr HUMAN RIGHTS is inhuman..loves suffering on both sides 19:15  |  albert lewis 25/12/06
  55.   A Xmas Gift From Paul Harris To All Talback Posters 19:32  |  chet 25/12/06
  56.   What Olmert should want 19:39  |  Tosefta 25/12/06
  57.   Releasing prisoners 19:50  |  Tosefta 25/12/06
  58.   "Human Rights" - don`t play the moderate 19:50  |  Yonatan 25/12/06
  59.   Marilyn 19:53  |  Shalom2U 25/12/06
  60.   #50 (In)Human Rights 19:55  |  Yonatan 25/12/06
  61.   #54 albert lewis 19:57  |  Yonatan 25/12/06
  62.   Paul Harris, Covering up, is not the answer 20:11  |  Shalom2U 25/12/06
  63.   albert lewis:I wish you suffer as well to know the value of Insan 20:23  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  64.   Haaret`z Continual War Against Reality 20:39  |  Tod Zuckerman 25/12/06
  65.   Avrum -- "Clueless Monterial" 20:41  |  Shalom2U 25/12/06
  66.   Yonatan, the peaceful man with a machine gun 21:23  |  Human Rights 25/12/06
  67.   Was meeting too short, too late? - Abbas should keep cease-fire.. 21:51  |  Vittorio 25/12/06
  68.   Olmert the Dum Dum 21:51  |  Danite 25/12/06
  69.   Haaretz Editorial 22:04  |  John Fletcher 25/12/06
  70.   Human Rights-not desrving 22:13  |  Avrum 25/12/06
  71.   #6, Jim 22:37  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  72.   Barking up the wrong tree 22:48  |  sh 25/12/06
  73.   #20, Yakov squatting upon Palestinian land 22:50  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  74.   #44, Avrum 22:57  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  75.   55 HARD CHEESE MAPLE ,LEAF , TRY HARDER 23:20  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  76.   Human Rights-#28-Truth hurts 00:02  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  77.   THE TEST 00:12  |  Shmuelshachor 26/12/06
  78.   For PAUL!!! HARRIS!!! From Maple Leaf 00:27  |  chet 26/12/06
  79.   Marilyn-#41-What gives you the right to pontificate on Israel 00:50  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  80.   Too little too late only if 00:51  |  Baz Mann 26/12/06
  81.   Marilyn-#21-Stomach sickness 01:04  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  82.   to Marylin 01:13  |  eva 26/12/06
  83.   gaza 01:24  |  eva 26/12/06
  84.   Marilyn has the right idea 01:40  |  Abe 26/12/06
  85.   Spoton Hannah 02:14  |  sweis Melbourne 26/12/06
  86.   #68-Danite on Olmert and his policies 02:21  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  87.   Illmert and Abobo 02:43  |  Chaim Gorenstein 26/12/06
  88.   Daniel Leopard and money 02:46  |  Angela 26/12/06
  89.   The wrong tree named Abbas (Sh #72) 03:44  |  Tosefta 26/12/06
  90.   Daniel Leopold....Iranian money 04:12  |  maoriboy 26/12/06
  91.   Eva #82 04:33  |  JJ 26/12/06
  92.   Eva, the marks don`t make it right 05:09  |  Marilyn 26/12/06
  93.   Abe-#84-You don`t need to pretend you`re Jewish 05:53  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  94.   Angela-#-88 Please give us a break 06:03  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  95.   maoriboy-#90-Iranian money? 07:58  |  Daniel Leopold 26/12/06
  96.   #marilyn - how right!!! 08:26  |  mary 26/12/06
  97.   Or you fight back arab terror or you give up to arab terror 08:54  |  Joseph E . 26/12/06
  98.   #71 SO CALLED hannah re #6 JIM 10:09  |  Ari ben Yisrael 26/12/06
  99.   #95 Daniel... Israel owes money to the Palestinians 10:15  |  maoriboy 26/12/06
  100.   #2 Malicious marilyn 10:22  |  Ari ben Yisrael 26/12/06
  101.   Sde Boker Initiative. 11:17  |  sandra chitayat 26/12/06
  102.   response #35, Smadar from Toronto. 11:21  |  sandra chitayat. 26/12/06
  103.   #100 16:31  |  JJ 26/12/06
  104.   #2 Marylin Your post is a furphy,You understand Aussie English 00:49  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 27/12/06
  105.   Re Eva #82 03:10  |  JJ 27/12/06
 Today Online
FM: Before agreeing to talks, we must ask if Syria wants peace
Responses: 77
Yoel Marcus: Olmert and Abbas - A Qassam for every kiss
Responses: 87
New settlement planned for former Gaza settlers
Responses: 119
Amira Hass: Rule change could re-unite thousands in W. Bank
Responses: 53
PM: Palestinians will soon feel major improvement in lives
Responses: 71
IDF says Hamas exploiting truce to beef up its arsenal, forces
Responses: 133


More Headlines
04:17 Tzipi Livni supports talks with PA, even under fire
04:09 Two teens injured in Sderot Qassam strike, one hurt critically
03:37 Ultra-Orthodox community, El Al hammer out draft agreement
02:30 Investigators: Announcement Katzrin murder had been solved was premature
01:33 Residents of West Bank go without water for 48 hours
02:07 Egyptian Foreign Minister to arrive in Israel for talks with leadership
22:28 Finance panel approves budget and Economic Arrangements Bill
23:03 Army judge criticizes detention of Palestinians without trial
21:14 IDF offered to 'transfer' 2 W. Bank villages, court told
22:48 Three killed and 270 hurt on roads as Israel lashed by storms
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved