Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., December 25, 2006 Tevet 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:42 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Three states for two peoples
By Zvi Bar'el

Without taking too much of a risk, and with the appropriate caution, it's possible to state that a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians won't be signed this year. It isn't too hard to draw such a conclusion, considering that there is only a week left before year's end. So now let's move on to next year. What miracle needs to happen so that such a peace treaty can be added to the ranks of those with Egypt and Jordan?

On the assumption that the primary players will remain on the same stage, then no significant meeting will take place between Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. By significant, I mean political and not humanitarian. The eight months in which Olmert managed to serve as premier without significant contact with the Palestinian chairman have been habit-forming. The concept of "soon" is the one that will really continue to make its appearance.

On the Palestinian side, too, there is no great brightness on the horizon. Abbas has made three threats: to conduct a national referendum on the prisoners' document, to fire Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh or the Haniyeh government and now to hold early elections. Two threats have not materialized, and the third is on its way to collapse. Abbas, like his supporters in Arab states, realizes this is a haphazard idea when the ground isn't stable, and the Palestinian public does not guarantee victory for a Fatah state. Abbas will therefore continue this year, as well, to run the Fatah forces, whatever their names will be, while Haniyeh continues to run his country, the same Gaza with the abundance of scattered forces and variety of gangs operating within it.

Advertisement

All these point to an original political diagram: three states for two peoples - Israel, Gaza and the West Bank. It's kind of a flawed Sudoku, with components that can't be connected. There is only one other example of such a division; it is located some 1,000 kilometers to the east, in Iraq.

For this reason, Sderot residents will also need to strengthen themselves with a little more patience, because the policy of restraint - even if there are exceptions here and there - will continue to be the permanent remedy. Now that most of the "reasonable" military solutions have been tried - and failed, and now that assassinating wanted Palestinians has not brought quiet, and now that Israel has rejected all Palestinians with whom it might have had a dialogue, there is only one reason to count the Qassam rockets: When the post-cease-fire average becomes higher than the pre-cease-fire average, there will certainly be someone who will want to send forces into Gaza. As long as the average is low, the restraint will continue.

This is the most optimistic scenario imaginable right now, with the current players. It is possible that in other countries, the citizens would hold protests against such dangerous behavior. Not here, though, because each of the leaders in this web is certain that he will soon win. The Hamas government will soon collapse due to lack of resources, Abbas will soon lose his forces because he can't pay their salaries and, in Israel, it doesn't matter if it's Hamas or Fatah, for there is no capitulation to terror.

Along with this optimism, it's not superfluous to present the fantasy as well. It has three components: negotiations with Syria; public adoption of the Arab initiative, as accepted at an Arab League summit in Beirut in 2002; and normalization with the Palestinian Authority, whoever its leaders might be. A peace treaty with Syria is no alternative to peace with the Palestinians or to an agreement with Lebanon, but it would reduce the relevance of Israel's opponents in the region, and is likely to diminish the range of Hamas' activity toward the outside.

Adopting the Arab initiative would destroy the key formal argument that Hamas uses to avoid recognizing Israel, even before the initiative is implemented, and would simultaneously be liable to advance formal peace agreements with additional Arab countries. And perhaps normalization with the PA, even without a peace deal, would be liable to strengthen long-term quiet between Israel and the Palestinians.

It should be immediately emphasized this is not, heaven forbid, about peace treaties, or about withdrawals, but only about public declarations and humanitarian steps. In other words, the construction of a new platform for regional relationships. They used to call it "starting the process" or "creating momentum." But this is only a fantasy. After all, it's still possible to live with 30 to 40 Qassams.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sanctions fall short
Despite UN sanctions, Iran's President has all the support for his nuke plan at home.
Time for change
Time magazine has declared the end of the age of great people and hero-geniuses.
  1.   TWO states for two peoples 13:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/12/06
  2.   One State, One Nation: Israel 13:07  |  Yishai Kohen 24/12/06
  3.   Ironic 13:21  |  Choni Davidowitz 24/12/06
  4.   The Arab peace plan 13:21  |  KUTW 24/12/06
  5.   #3 Ironic-You Can`t Wish them Away 14:40  |  Tzfonit 24/12/06
  6.   Swiss, to use some of your words I would that before Palestinian 15:26  |  Petra 24/12/06
  7.   Palestinian state 15:29  |  Shulamit 24/12/06
  8.   Tzfonit your right you cannot wish them away 15:43  |  David G 24/12/06
  9.   No arab peace plan...the grand illusion 15:45  |  bounce 24/12/06
  10.   The zionist dream has become a NIGHTMARE!!!! 15:54  |  Ben Uziel 24/12/06
  11.   # 2, 3, 7 XXBXNXRAUM? 16:28  |  KUMA 24/12/06
  12.   To Yishai Kohen 16:34  |  John 24/12/06
  13.   # 6 Petra 16:58  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/12/06
  14.   To #11 and #12: How Wrong You Are 17:05  |  Yishai Kohen 24/12/06
  15.   What If Rockets Were Falling on Bar`el? 17:08  |  Ben Israel 24/12/06
  16.   Inexerable Logic 17:14  |  Robert 24/12/06
  17.   The three state solution is unstable 17:24  |  Tosefta 24/12/06
  18.   KAHANE OR ARABFART,THE CHOICE IS YOURS! 18:11  |  Dori Gold 24/12/06
  19.   No longer "land for peace" but PEACE FOR LAND 18:36  |  albert amato 24/12/06
  20.   FOUR states for 2 peoples-count Jordan,part of historic Palestine 19:04  |  Mark 24/12/06
  21.   Haaretz send Barel to Sderot 19:10  |  Jonathan S 24/12/06
  22.   Now I Get It - Unfortunately 20:12  |  Tod Zuckerman 24/12/06
  23.   go to hell you piece of **** 20:42  |  harold 24/12/06
  24.   Is it a stupidity compatiton ? 23:15  |  Akram Zekaria 24/12/06
  25.   a peace agreement between Israel and the Pals won`t be signed...? 23:40  |  Yankelowitz 24/12/06
  26.   To Swiss (Dino) 23:42  |  Yankelowitz 24/12/06
  27.   re Shulamit 00:35  |  Axel 25/12/06
  28.   TWENTY FIVE states for two people 00:55  |  Bruce 25/12/06
  29.   #23 Harold, The bottom line 01:04  |  Dutch 25/12/06
  30.   Peace 01:23  |  Dwido 25/12/06
  31.   Just more proof of the SICKNESS OF LIBERAL SELF LOATHING JEWS 02:28  |  amir 25/12/06
  32.   No solution but zionist emigration 02:48  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  33.   Only two states 03:13  |  Dr.Ari Nir 25/12/06
  34.   ALL THE WORLD TO THE AFRICANS 03:18  |  KUMA 25/12/06
  35.   Jonathan you are in Germany, what do you know? 03:38  |  Marilyn 25/12/06
  36.   Restraint: What a croc of shit 04:30  |  Michael Korn 25/12/06
  37.   Yishai Cohen, enough is enough 04:31  |  Otto Rand 25/12/06
  38.   2 states: Maybe hudna for 99 years 04:32  |  Judy Abeles Eliasov 25/12/06
  39.   To Choni Davidovich 04:39  |  Otto Rand 25/12/06
  40.   To Amir 04:53  |  Otto Rand 25/12/06
  41.   Three states 05:01  |  Shmuelshachor 25/12/06
  42.   To Mr. Ben Uziel 05:12  |  Otto Rand 25/12/06
  43.   To Mr. Tod Zuckerman 05:18  |  Otto Rand 25/12/06
  44.   otto 06:38  |  Bounce 25/12/06
  45.   To Swiss 07:21  |  DAVID KAPLAN 25/12/06
  46.   Four states not three 07:25  |  howiej 25/12/06
  47.   Otto Rand (Post No. 40) 07:32  |  Johnny Weintraub 25/12/06
  48.   To Kuma 07:33  |  DAVID KAPLAN 25/12/06
  49.   To Bounce #44 07:40  |  Otto Rand 25/12/06
  50.   Pushing a car towards a cliff is also "creating momentum" 08:14  |  Robert 25/12/06
  51.   #36, Michael Corn in Princeton 08:19  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  52.   #41, SS in Brazil 08:27  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  53.   "possible to live with 30 to 40 Qassams. " 08:28  |  Zev 25/12/06
  54.   #44, Bounce 08:35  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  55.   EXTREMISTS HAVE NO ROOM 09:13  |  Jay 25/12/06
  56.   To "Hannah" 09:39  |  David 25/12/06
  57.   more pinto beans please 09:45  |  sho 25/12/06
  58.   FORGOTTEN PEOPLE 09:47  |  Nicole 25/12/06
  59.   WHY DOESNT ANYONE EVER MENTION JORDAN 09:49  |  Nicole 25/12/06
  60.   Hannah`s Insults 09:59  |  Ian Williams 25/12/06
  61.   #55 Jay: All 3 choices are conflict! That`s the rub! 10:10  |  Robert 25/12/06
  62.   #55, Jay 10:11  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  63.   To David, Ian, and all the others who are intellectually bankrupt 11:02  |  Hannah 25/12/06
  64.   THE USUAL HAARETZ ABSURDITY FOR RANTING POSTERS 11:11  |  paul harris 25/12/06
  65.   Hannah again 11:49  |  Ian Williams 25/12/06
  66.   to no. 21 18:10  |  free speech 25/12/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Jews aren't supposed to love Christmas
Responses: 165
Military Intelligence: Syria serious about talks with Israel
Responses: 58
Akiva Eldar: Time to fight terror, pursue peace
Responses: 24
Editorial: Olmert-Abbas meeting was too little, too late
Responses: 51
Few foreigners mark Christmas in Bethlehem
Responses: 164


More Headlines
18:42 PM approves removal of 27 West Bank roadblocks
14:49 Military Intelligence officer: Syria serious about negotiations with Israel
17:43 Court okays Ramon request for another hearing before verdict
17:09 U.S., European officials visit Fatah training base in Jordan
18:32 Court reviews Klagsbald appeal in negligent manslaughter case
17:47 Ex-Shas MK Ofer Hugi convicted of embezzling state funds
17:00 Labor MK calls on gov't to hasten Falash Mura immigration
11:58 Court hears appeal of Hamas MPs banned from living in J`lem
14:26 In Christmas message, Pope expresses wish to visit Holy Land
14:29 Jerusalem girds for possible snow storm on Wednesday
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved