Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 24, 2006 Tevet 3, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:03 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
We miss you, Sharon
By Yoel Marcus

In a few days, it will be a year since Ariel Sharon went into a coma, and many Israelis are feeling the urge to cry out from the depths of their hearts: "Sharon, we miss you."

Sharon was at the height of his popularity and power as prime minister, but above all, he was at the height of his maturity as a leader. It was a stage in his action-packed life when he was not shooting bluff and bluster from the hip. It was a stage when he donned his reading glasses and delivered his rare speeches from a written text, carefully choosing and weighing the words jotted down in his little book.

Gone was the unbridled warrior heading into battle. Gone was the political punk who snatched microphones at political assemblies. Most of all, gone was the fearless settler and right-wing mascot of the Greater Israel movement.

Advertisement

The disengagement was carried out under the slogan "with sensitivity and determination," but from my breakfasts with Sharon, with or without halvah, I can tell you it was really carried out "with determination and determination." The sensitivity stuff was bull.

The settlers knew the truth and were careful not to stretch the rope too far. They knew Sharon would uproot them from their homes and settlements with whatever force was necessary. Because that's what a leader does.

Unfortunately, no Sharon clone has emerged yet, built from the same stuff.

Does this mean that if Sharon hadn't slipped into a coma, he would have continued with unilateral disengagement? The answer is no. He explicitly said that after the Gaza withdrawal, the next stage would only be by agreement, i.e., the product of negotiations. Sharon said what he meant, and his guideline was the Bush plan. According to this plan, negotiations must be preceded by a cessation of terror. Sharon didn't "sell off the Land of Israel," as his opponents claimed. What he did was roll the ball into the Palestinian court and set a precedent in this neck of the woods.

Sharon the leader and statesman was more calculating and cautious than Sharon the soldier and politician. He spoke little and very rarely put his foot in his mouth. He wouldn't have come out with a slip of the tongue about Israel's nuclear capacity like Olmert, which brought the whole world down on us. He wouldn't talk about our kidnapped soldiers as if they were dead, sabotaging our justification for the Lebanon War.

Sharon had natural instincts that kept him from doing stupid things. If he were around, Amir Peretz wouldn't have been appointed defense minister in a million years. He would never have entrusted Avigdor Lieberman with one of the most sensitive defense jobs for coalitionary reasons. For that sort of thing, he would have made do with Agudat Yisrael.

If Ariel Sharon were with us today, standing at the helm, maybe there wouldn't have been a second Lebanon war. It certainly would not have been timed the way it was, or carried out so sloppily. Sharon would have pored over every detail of the military maneuvers. He might have chosen to stick with aerial combat, or postponed retaliatory action until Israel was fully prepared to go in and settle accounts once and for all, by finishing off Nasrallah.

A senior officer who worked at Sharon's headquarters for many years says he had a land campaign at his fingertips. An egg-on-the-face operation like this one would never have seen the light of day if he were around. If Sharon were to wake up for a minute and see what is left of our power of deterrence, he would ask to be put back to sleep.

Sharon spent a lot of time thinking and planning, and less time talking. His heir, Ehud Olmert, talks more than he thinks. That's the difference between a statesman and a politician. There is no way in the world that Sharon would tell Assad he is not a partner for peace because President Bush objects. That kind of statement is an embarrassment to both sides. Bush and Sharon would sit together and come up with a plan to call Assad's bluff. Because they were real friends, whereas Olmert and Bush are only photo-op and back-slapping buddies.

If we ever find ourselves pondering what leads to what - is it history that creates the leader, or the leader who creates history? - the Sharon phenomenon provides an answer.

The metamorphosis of Sharon's personality and thinking is what changed history. No other Israeli leader would have dared to evacuate the Gaza settlements and settlers. He was the man who roused this country from its dreams and delusions, and paved the way for a Palestinian state. Now the rest depends on them.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Doom on an epic scale
The Holocaust didn't destroy Judaism or its languages, but it caused them to be rethought.
Scenario
A muted explosion is followed by a series of powerful blasts from different directions.
  1.   Whom do you suggest? 11:32  |  Joe 22/12/06
  2.   As soldier a HERO, as politician a ZERO 12:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  3.   a touching piece... 12:13  |  saul a. readner 22/12/06
  4.   Article is quite OK but there is hope: 12:17  |  S 22/12/06
  5.   Retribution 12:21  |  Choni Davidowitz 22/12/06
  6.   Olmert, Zero, Peres...are the same 13:17  |  KA 22/12/06
  7.   A very good article but... 13:26  |  Hastaroth 22/12/06
  8.   A very good article (part 2) 13:32  |  Hastaroth 22/12/06
  9.   Olmert - Zero achievements 13:39  |  HonestIsraeli 22/12/06
  10.   Yoel Marcus, tell this to Olmert directly 14:08  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 22/12/06
  11.   Hastoroth you are right 14:10  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 22/12/06
  12.   Clone the Lebanon massacre Sharon? Or the disengagement Sharon? 14:12  |  Natallie Durson 22/12/06
  13.   # 8 Hastaroth 14:16  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  14.   Olmert is a disaster for Israel 14:41  |  Psalm 22/12/06
  15.   well, well it seems the Israel`s aren`t happy at all 14:50  |  Tamir Gaza 22/12/06
  16.   you forget he was israels worst lviing war criminal 14:51  |  John 22/12/06
  17.   Sharon 15:09  |  Brod 22/12/06
  18.   if,if,if,if 15:15  |  david 22/12/06
  19.   My. my such a paen on the first anniversary 15:22  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/12/06
  20.   Why do you need a Sharon clone? 15:45  |  Clickfool 22/12/06
  21.   Sharon paved the way for a Palestinian state - 15:54  |  Somebody from Europe 22/12/06
  22.   Clickfool - Unindicted war criminals - 15:56  |  Somebody from Europe 22/12/06
  23.   Natalie - road to chaos 16:05  |  Somebody from Europe 22/12/06
  24.   Marcus misses the corrupt fat one who stole $3Million! 16:18  |  me 22/12/06
  25.   Swiss Dino you forgot the 1982 invasion to Lebanon 16:35  |  Saladino 22/12/06
  26.   Amen! 16:51  |  A. 22/12/06
  27.   Peans from appeasenick Marcus to corrupt appeasenick Sharon 17:50  |  Absolute Sweden 22/12/06
  28.   Choni Davidowitz 18:19  |  Johnny Weintraub 22/12/06
  29.   Re: # 22 question to Clickfool 18:39  |  Kipperraes 22/12/06
  30.   Choni Davidowitz, at least Sharon kept it an internal affair 18:52  |  Jake 22/12/06
  31.   Sullivan, even the Palestinians admit Intifada was pre-planned 18:55  |  Jake 22/12/06
  32.   david, mind you words 19:04  |  Jake 22/12/06
  33.   #26 - Absolute Sweden 20:00  |  Dudu 22/12/06
  34.   "UNBRIDLED WORRIOR""LEADER"... 20:31  |  MIKE KATZ 22/12/06
  35.   Dudu,fools like you are`a joy of arabs.What was Israel to negotia 20:33  |  Absolute Sweden 22/12/06
  36.   Aboslute Sweden, not so 20:43  |  Jake 22/12/06
  37.   why should you? 21:00  |  H 22/12/06
  38.   Ariel Sharone`s replacement... 21:28  |  David James 22/12/06
  39.   Shaaron 21:38  |  larry 22/12/06
  40.   just a comment 22:23  |  justice 22/12/06
  41.   sharon was shamefull for all jews 22:44  |  a brazilian jew 22/12/06
  42.   Ariel Sharon - the sandwich maker... 23:04  |  Maureen Ann 22/12/06
  43.   #8 ASTOROTH FRED ASTAIRE ONCED DANCED WITH A HAT AND COAT STAND 23:16  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  44.   Sharon`s Illness - Choni 23:21  |  Asher 22/12/06
  45.   Olmert is a clone of Sharon 23:29  |  Eli 22/12/06
  46.   Not missing Sharon 23:32  |  Tosefta 22/12/06
  47.   Sharon Cloned? 23:49  |  Guy From NYC 22/12/06
  48.   # 25 Saladino 23:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  49.   #38 ANOTHER WHO ANSWERS WHO OWN QUESTIONS ?/ MO ANN 00:05  |  paul harris 23/12/06
  50.   Justice - there`s no justice in your words 00:31  |  Somebody from Europe 23/12/06
  51.   Tosefta, ben Gurion? 00:46  |  Jake 23/12/06
  52.   OLMERT SEEMS DETERMINED, WITH OR WITHOUT HALVAH FOR BREAKFAST 00:58  |  Smadar 23/12/06
  53.   Jake,sop defence of Israel to rely on past reputation alone? 01:22  |  Absolute Sweden 23/12/06
  54.   speak fo yo`self dude 02:16  |  sho 23/12/06
  55.   "V`od ache" 02:17  |  Rabbi David Hoffman 23/12/06
  56.   Response to hastaworth 03:26  |  Dennis Cast 23/12/06
  57.   #55, Rabbi 04:06  |  Hannah 23/12/06
  58.   Are you kidding me? 04:52  |  Robert Rivers 23/12/06
  59.   hannah 09:37  |  saul a. readner 23/12/06
  60.   Re: Rabbi David Hoffman 10:24  |  Guy From NYC 23/12/06
  61.   I can`t believe it 11:02  |  Petra 23/12/06
  62.   to hannah 12:27  |  saul a. readner 23/12/06
  63.   The Clones we really need 12:46  |  Tzfonit 23/12/06
  64.   Payback 13:05  |  Rachel 23/12/06
  65.   Title of article gives room to imagination 13:19  |  Hannah 23/12/06
  66.   Sharon, Agree with Natalie Durson 13:35  |  Abe 23/12/06
  67.   SHARON WILL BE IN HELL (REAL HELL) 14:48  |  indrajaya 23/12/06
  68.   Gen. Eisenhower to President Eisenhower 15:38  |  albert amato 23/12/06
  69.   #61, Saul A. Readner 15:52  |  Hannah 23/12/06
  70.   Nobody misses Sharon - Olmert is his clone and 16:40  |  Sal 23/12/06
  71.   Sharon the diplomat? (Smadar #52) 17:23  |  Tosefta 23/12/06
  72.   again to hannah 17:32  |  saul a. readner 23/12/06
  73.   Great Points Natalie 18:46  |  Abe 23/12/06
  74.   Yaakov Sullivan 19:08  |  David 23/12/06
  75.   The Sweet Teddybear of Israel 19:09  |  Alicia 23/12/06
  76.   RE # 67 IT`S DONE... 21:29  |  MIKE KATZ 23/12/06
  77.   Indrajaya 22:43  |  God 23/12/06
  78.   Indrajaya #67 Don`t spew your crap! 00:26  |  Brod 24/12/06
  79.   #76 KATZ GIVES BOWL OF MILK TO ISRAELS OWN DER STURMER 05:29  |  paul harris 24/12/06
  80.   Sharon for President 08:40  |  Asa 24/12/06
  81.   SHARON`s STUPIDITY brought us the HITNATKUT DISASTER 08:40  |  amir 24/12/06
  82.   We DON`T MISS TRAITOR SHARON 08:51  |  amir 24/12/06
  83.   Indrajaya, It`s wrong for you to condemn Sharon to hell 09:52  |  Dutch 24/12/06
  84.   Indrajaya, Re: Sins of omission 11:12  |  Dutch 24/12/06
<
 Today Online
Ahmadinejad: Backers of UN sanctions will soon regret it
Responses: 61
Olmert tells cabinet: Further meetings with Abbas to come
Responses: 122
Zvi Bar'el: It's still possible to live with 30 to 40 Qassams.
Send response
Avi Issacharoff: Hamas' nightmare - Israel frees prisoners
Responses: 197
WHO survey finds better health among Jews than Arab Israelis