Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., December 29, 2006 Tevet 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:43 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Holocaust as alibi
By Dror Etkes

The curtain has dropped on the Theater of the Absurd directed by the Iranian regime last week - an event that convened figures from the margins of the Holocaust-denial scene and its "alternative" researchers. In Israel the conference was covered with an emphasis on the statements by the participants and the reactions of Israeli politicians. True, this was an international conference behind which was a country that declares its desire to bring about the fall of the "Zionist regime" - but beyond that hides a deeper factor, which is indicative of the connection between contemporary Israeli identity and the Holocaust.

"If the occurrence of the event (the Holocaust) is cast into doubt, the identity of the Zionist regime will also be cast into doubt." From these words, spoken at the opening session by Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki, it emerges that the Iranian regime has correctly identified the connections that exist in Israel between the Holocaust and local politics. One of the formative historical events of the West today, whose significance is relevant to all of humanity, the Holocaust is continuing more than 60 years later to provide Israel with an alibi for the deviancy of its political choices.

An Israel with no real distinction between the establishment political left and the right with all its offshoots, continues to make use of the Holocaust in a way that combines cynicism and boorishness. Even though there is indeed a considerable and complex connection between the Holocaust and Israeli political culture, there isn't - nor has there ever been - any justification for harnessing its memory for the sake of preserving the continuing occupation project that Israel has been conducting for 40 years now in the territories.

Advertisement

Israel's attitude toward the Holocaust is not really derived from the way in which the leadership is responding to the incendiary declarations of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his propagandists, which above all testify to the speakers themselves. It is possible to learn about this attitude from, among other things, the way in which it relates to the tens of thousands of survivors in whose flesh and minds the Nazis' crimes are etched, who live here in disgraceful conditions and below the poverty line.

However, the real treatment of the survivors is apparently a lot less glamorous than the cult of the worship surrounding those who were murdered, which provides a stage for every politician who is seeking his way to the center of the consensus. Thus, as was recently published again in Haaretz, the state is continuing to nationalize the reparations monies that are transferred to it for the benefit of those hundreds of thousands of survivors - while criminally neglecting many of them.

The primitive instrumentalist use that Iranian politics is making of the Holocaust is nothing but a mirror image of the way the memory of the Holocaust is exploited in political life in Israel. One of the aims of the Iranian campaign to "research the historical truth" surrounding the Holocaust is to unravel the system of justifications that Israeli politics has been accustomed to using in its all-too-frequent definition of the criticism of those politics, expressed both domestically and abroad as being tainted with anti-Semitism. Thus the role of the Holocaust as the sole justification for the existence of Israel has been sharpened, instead of focusing on the fact that today more than 7 million people of varied origins and nationalities are living in this country - a place which in most cases is their only possible home.

If indeed the Iranian foreign minister is correct and this is the sole source of legitimacy from which the Zionist project derives today, then apparently the time has indeed come for a radical revision of the concept of Zionism. And it would be a good thing if this is done before Ahmadinejad and his ultra-Orthodox partners from Brooklyn launch a new production.

The author coordinates the settlement follow-up in the Peace Now movement.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A friend indeed
Prodromos Papavasileiou, 1919-2006, a friend to Israel in time of need, died on Saturday.
Haifa's hidden gem
Haifa's recently opened Hanamal 24 is located in the shadow of Haifa's port.
  1.   why do we pay the price? 11:22  |  Rita 22/12/06
  2.   WHAT ABSOLUTE CRAP DOES THE DATE 1922 MEAN ANYTHING TO YOU 11:31  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  3.   Dror 11:34  |  Josef 22/12/06
  4.   This article harnesses its memory too 11:51  |  sh 22/12/06
  5.   Harris of TA 12:02  |  sh 22/12/06
  6.   Absolute rubbish 12:06  |  Zelkha 22/12/06
  7.   Playing alibis 12:07  |  TonyL 22/12/06
  8.   #5? eh? 12:23  |  Danny - Israeli one 22/12/06
  9.   Is there a difference between Neturi Karta and Peace Now? 12:35  |  Ilan 22/12/06
  10.   Zionism and the holocaust 12:40  |  Avi Yerushalmi 22/12/06
  11.   why wasn`t dror etkes at the iran confrence? 12:55  |  mike 22/12/06
  12.   Dror Etkes: Totally true although far not original (1) 13:03  |  zmogus 22/12/06
  13.   FOR THE UNKNOWING DEFINITON OF REFUGEE 13:05  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  14.   Holocaust = pretext to oppress Palestinians 13:05  |  KA 22/12/06
  15.   Dror Etkes: Totally true although far not original (2) 13:07  |  zmogus 22/12/06
  16.   Israeli Danny 13:23  |  sh 22/12/06
  17.   The unknowing 13:28  |  sh 22/12/06
  18.   There is only one connection between occupation and the Holocaust 13:31  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  19.   #14 do you understand THE MEANING of holcaust 13:33  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  20.   Paul Harris, who the hell are you? 13:39  |  Marilyn 22/12/06
  21.   go to hell you piece 13:40  |  harold 22/12/06
  22.   The occupation delegitimises Israel 13:48  |  Stephen Murray 22/12/06
  23.   Time to end the Arab occupation of Jewish homeland 13:53  |  Bennie 22/12/06
  24.   because 13:56  |  lu 22/12/06
  25.   Etkes uses `Holocaust` for stupid comparison 14:01  |  Shalom Freedman 22/12/06
  26.   #14, the holocaust "only" lasted for 6 years - not 2 14:01  |  Danny - Israeli one 22/12/06
  27.   Rita, Post No. 1, I am not sure to whom you refer as "we pay the 14:04  |  Nadav 22/12/06
  28.   The Holocaust as legitimate cause and case 14:08  |  Dror 22/12/06
  29.   to Rita #1 14:12  |  Michael 22/12/06
  30.   to rita 14:27  |  jean marie 22/12/06
  31.   #1 14:28  |  Danny - Israeli one 22/12/06
  32.   The Palestinians didn`t do it 14:39  |  Marilyn 22/12/06
  33.   Peace or Stupid Now 14:47  |  FOX 22/12/06
  34.   Dror-#28-You`re absolutely right 14:49  |  Daniel Leopold 22/12/06
  35.   No Holocaust Alibi 14:51  |  Psalm 22/12/06
  36.   Maladjusted child 14:51  |  JR 22/12/06
  37.   Peace now 14:52  |  charles 22/12/06
  38.   Marilyn and egg nog 14:53  |  FOX 22/12/06
  39.   Dror.God gave us the right to occupy and oppress? 14:54  |  Toronto`s Finest 22/12/06
  40.   [#28] Conquistadores après la lettre 15:04  |  JJ 22/12/06
  41.   deligitimised as a state. 15:05  |  scott 22/12/06
  42.   Holocaust as alibi 15:09  |  Michael Katz 22/12/06
  43.   Keep up your CAPITALS Paul Harris 15:10  |  albert amato 22/12/06
  44.   Norman Finkelstein`s work exposes this hypocracy 15:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/12/06
  45.   Self Infatuation Can Kill 15:12  |  Rowan Berkeley 22/12/06
  46.   ISRAEL: JEWISH HOMELAND SINCE RECORDED HISTORY! 15:27  |  Peter 22/12/06
  47.   Milking the Holocaust 15:38  |  Dudu 22/12/06
  48.   Speachless - Almost 15:43  |  Jane 22/12/06
  49.   The Jews have returned home!!!!! 15:51  |  Ben Uziel 22/12/06
  50.   Milking the memory of the Holocaust 15:56  |  Clickfool 22/12/06
  51.   Commander of the GPU 16:05  |  anon 22/12/06
  52.   Holocaust denial alibi 16:08  |  KUTW 22/12/06
  53.   THIS EXPLAINS PEACE NOW 16:09  |  B 22/12/06
  54.   Swiss(Dino) 16:09  |  ODP 22/12/06
  55.   Wrong 16:10  |  danite 22/12/06
  56.   Using the Holocaust as a weapon against its victims 16:13  |  KUTW 22/12/06
  57.   FOX 16:14  |  Danite 22/12/06
  58.   Nadav#27 16:16  |  Danite 22/12/06
  59.   Which ?occupation?? 16:17  |  KUTW 22/12/06
  60.   #50 Clickfool: You repeatedly point at Jews and Israel 16:17  |  Bennie 22/12/06
  61.   1. Rita: which price? 16:23  |  KUTW 22/12/06
  62.   HAARETZ IN CAPS STOP SCREAMING PLEASE 16:25  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  63.   Clickfool in Sussex - Shut Up 16:29  |  Jane 22/12/06
  64.   Paul Harris` crap. (# 2) 16:40  |  Wiktor 22/12/06
  65.   see finklestein on tv 16:41  |  shimon 22/12/06
  66.   marilyn"rabid zionists" 16:44  |  mattityahu 22/12/06
  67.   The founding lies of Israel 16:46  |  Amin Nusseibeh 22/12/06
  68.   Josef, let`s all run away from reality! #3 16:49  |  Wiktor 22/12/06
  69.   32 Marilyn: pals are trying to 16:52  |  KUTW 22/12/06
  70.   # 46. Peter, what absolute nonsense you spout! 16:59  |  Toronto`s Finest 22/12/06
  71.   Dudu # 47 Holocaust & Occupation 17:01  |  Jeff Northridge 22/12/06
  72.   # 52 Danite 17:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  73.   Zionism & Israel & Peace Now & Etkes 17:34  |  Ira Gelnik 22/12/06
  74.   If I want to read about Holocaust... 17:45  |  Veritas 22/12/06
  75.   Haaretz should hire Ahmadinejad! 17:46  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 22/12/06
  76.   Toronto, # 46 17:58  |  Peter 22/12/06
  77.   Joseph and Mary 18:08  |  Johnny Weintraub 22/12/06
  78.   Danite #51 18:17  |  Gabe1 22/12/06
  79.   Swiss(Dino) 18:19  |  ODP 22/12/06
  80.   to 60 - Jeff Northridge 18:34  |  Dudu 22/12/06
  81.   Holocaust happened and Israel is here to stay 18:47  |  albert amato 22/12/06
  82.   Palestinian holocaust, genocide etc. 18:54  |  Richard 22/12/06
  83.   to Paul Harris, THANK YOU :) Facts and Israel will win over all. 18:55  |  David 22/12/06
  84.   How many know that re-creation of Israel started in 1800s? 18:59  |  David 22/12/06
  85.   Palestine paying the price... 19:14  |  MIKE KATZ 22/12/06
  86.   #6 sorry, majority of population before the Holocaust was definat 19:24  |  Seymour 22/12/06
  87.   to KA 20:03  |  Sol 22/12/06
  88.   to Swiss (Dino) 20:12  |  Sol