Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., December 23, 2006 Tevet 2, 5767 | | Israel Time: 01:54 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
End the policy of isolation
By Mousa Qous

With Palestinians on the brink of civil war, it has become impossible to separate this crisis from the overall situation in a region polarized by the United States into "moderate" Arab regimes versus the "axis of evil," which includes Iran and Syria.

The conflict between these two poles, which has manifested itself in the crises in Lebanon, Iraq and Palestine, is a result of the erroneous foreign policies of President George W. Bush's administration. After categorizing Iran and Syria as part of the "axis of evil" (along with North Korea), the United States proceeded to boycott and diplomatically isolate these countries in the hope that by doing so, they could somehow force them to moderate their positions.

But the result was just the opposite. Both Syria and Iran hardened their stances toward America and their influence in the region only increased. In the most recent Israeli war on Lebanon, both Israel and the United States predicted the wrong outcome. Largely because of Iranian and Syrian support, Hezbollah proved to be strong both on the battlefield and among the people, and the group ultimately foiled Israel's objectives in going into Lebanon in the first place.

Advertisement

But the U.S. policy of isolation had already spilled over into the Palestinian arena. As just one more way of imposing his foreign policy in the Middle East, Bush called for a boycott of Hamas once the movement won democratic parliamentary elections last January. Thus, when Hamas formed a government at the end of March, the United States and Israel led the international community in isolating, rather than dealing with, the newly elected Palestinian leaders.

The United States had been an active advocate of democratic elections during the rule of the late president Yasser Arafat, but when the time came the results proved not to be to America's liking. As a result, neither the United States nor Israel allowed Hamas the opportunity to prove itself competent or otherwise in governing the Palestinians.

Instead, Hamas was squeezed diplomatically and financially, and by a tight economic siege on the Palestinian leadership. The movement was forced to turn elsewhere for support. Since the so-called "moderate" Arab governments followed America's lead and turned their backs on the newly formed government, the only support Hamas could find in the region came from Iran and Syria.

In addition, Hamas' election victory also led the Americans, Europeans and certain Arab countries to more actively support Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas in assuming greater authority over the security forces and the media - Palestine Radio and Television is under the direct supervision of the presidency - thus stripping a number of key authorities from the government.

With whatever international funding still coming to Palestinians being funneled through the presidency, the Western powers and their regional allies only helped to exacerbate an already escalating crisis between the presidency and the government.

Contrary to its purpose, however, this support did not always serve Abbas well: American and Western support for the president in the form of training and financing his security forces in fact helped weaken Abbas' popularity on the street.

All of these factors led to a situation in which foreign actors had an undue influence on Palestinian politics. Whenever Palestinians came close to resolving significant issues, especially regarding the formation of a unity government or the formulation of a prisoner-exchange deal - either Hamas or Abbas would pull the plug due to pressure from Iran or the United States.

As long as the United States does not change its policies toward Iran and Syria - that is, open the lines of communication and break their diplomatic isolation as well as the isolation of Hamas - there can never be a solution to the Palestinian problem.

This also forms part of the recommendations issued in the Baker-Hamilton report, recommendations that Bush still seems very hesitant to adopt. Unlike Syria. In an interview with the Italian paper La Repubblica, Syrian President Bashar Assad said he was ready and willing to reinitiate peace talks with Israel. He has yet to receive an answer, because Israel is waiting for its cue from the United States. Washington continues to cling to its hard line toward Damascus. Syrian Foreign Minister Walid Mualem has even gone so far as to offer to jumpstart peace talks with Israel without the precondition of returning the Israeli- occupied Golan Heights to Syria.

Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Shimon Peres responded by saying that it would be a grave mistake for Israel to start negotiations with Syria as long as such a move would be in contradiction with Washington's policies.

If the United States truly wants to right the situation for itself and for the Middle East as it claims, it must abandon categorizing countries in the region as those belonging to an "axis of evil" and those that do not. It must also abandon its policy of isolation - of Iran, Syria and Hamas - and allow for the lines of communication to be opened.

America has tried a policy of boycott and isolation, and it has failed repeatedly. Now is the time to try something new. The ideal solution would be to hold an international conference and for the United States to allow the international community, particularly the European Union and Arab countries, to play a larger role in resolving the Palestine question (and the Iraq debacle).

The 2002 Saudi initiative, in which the Arab world offered full normalization with Israel in exchange for an Israeli withdrawal from all land occupied in 1967, provides a sound and solid foundation for a just and lasting peace in Palestine in particular, and in the Middle East in general.

Mousa Qous is the Arabic media coordinator of Miftah, the Palestinian Initiative for the Promotion of Global Dialogue and Democracy.

By arrangement with www.bitterlemons.org

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Doom on an epic scale
The Holocaust didn't destroy Judaism or its languages, but it caused them to be rethought.
Scenario
A muted explosion is followed by a series of powerful blasts from different directions.
  1.   Largely true but. And what a but 12:32  |  S 22/12/06
  2.   Isolation only furthers extremism 12:35  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  3.   #2 CLICKFOOL VENTURES INTO HISTORY VERY BADLY 13:18  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  4.   America is not free...the Jewish lobby controls everything 13:29  |  American 22/12/06
  5.   # 3 paul harris 13:34  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  6.   The price of ending the isolation 14:42  |  Jordan 22/12/06
  7.   What planet are you from? 15:18  |  Bill 22/12/06
  8.   The next time Christ comes he will have a furious face. 15:28  |  simon 22/12/06
  9.   From one American to Another 15:29  |  Bill 22/12/06
  10.   Tired of this garbage 15:30  |  hate schiff 22/12/06
  11.   #5 HAARETZ DDNT PUBLISH THE CORRECTION 15:43  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  12.   A Jew controls "American`s" Brain 15:51  |  Sid 22/12/06
  13.   The United States has isolated the USA 15:55  |  Mark Lincoln 22/12/06
  14.   Paul Harris 17:23  |  Alex 22/12/06
  15.   Why in Haaretz? 17:31  |  Ari 22/12/06
  16.   # 11 paul harris 17:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/12/06
  17.   Arrogant 18:11  |  emad matahin 22/12/06
  18.   What a stupid editorial 18:16  |  Gee 22/12/06
  19.   Lincoln 18:36  |  Michael 22/12/06
  20.   Arabs must stop isolating Israel! Hamas must end charter to kill 19:03  |  David 22/12/06
  21.   #2 Paul Harris 20:06  |  Malleck 22/12/06
  22.   Isolating Syria, Iran & Hamas 20:46  |  gregdn 22/12/06
  23.   Listing of Past Errors 20:51  |  BP DIP 22/12/06
  24.   Michael 22:44  |  Mark Lincoln 22/12/06
  25.   Great Analysis 23:06  |  George Palestine 22/12/06
  26.   !4 IS THIS AN OZJOKE ? BALSAMIC IS MORE LIKE IT !1 ALEX 23:06  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  27.   #16 DINO S AMNESIA IS INTERESTING READ YOUR OWN POSTING 23:08  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  28.   no talks with Assad lest Golan booty be lost 23:08  |  raymond deane 22/12/06
  29.   #21 CHALK AND CHEESE FROM MULLOCH 23:11  |  paul harris 22/12/06
  30.   To Ari # 15 23:19  |  George Lamb 22/12/06
  31.   On axis of evil and more nonsense 23:26  |  dana 22/12/06
  32.   Part 2- Isolating "axis of evil" is evil too 23:36  |  dana 22/12/06
  33.   #26 RAYMNDE THINKS CAPTAIN BOYCOTT IS THE GOLAN LANDOWNER 00:00  |  paul harris 23/12/06
  34.   #29/30 DANA HISTORY IS AGAINST YOU READ UP WW2 00:19  |  paul harris 23/12/06
  35.   Hitler also should not have been Isolated? 00:57  |  Semsem 23/12/06
  36.   #28 02:56  |  Moshe 23/12/06
  37.   Denying that AIPAC Controls ME US Policies 05:17  |  Roger 23/12/06
  38.   Jewish "democracy" 07:47  |  keith 23/12/06
  39.   #37 19:33  |  Moshe 23/12/06
 Today Online
Security Council okays sanctions on Iran over its nuclear program
Responses: 331
Dror Etkes: Holocaust as alibi for occupation
Responses: 262
Ze'ev Schiff: Give Syria a chance
Responses: 84
Hamas, Fatah fighting resumes in Gaza after two-day truce
Responses: 182
Yoel Marcus: It's too bad no Sharon clone has emerged
Responses: 77


More Headlines
01:34 PM agrees to transfer $100 million in frozen PA taxes to Abbas
00:20 UN Security Council unanimously approves sanctions on Iran over nuclear program
00:16 Israel welcomes UN resolution; Iran calls sanctions 'illegal'
00:17 ANALYSIS / UN resolution on sanctions will not stop Iran
21:06 Exiled Hamas political leader vows PA elections won't take place
22:15 David Irving: Jews should ask themselves why they are hated
16:25 Senior Fatah security official critically hurt in Gaza shooting
17:24 200 Israelis, Palestinians protest new Israeli-only W. Bank road
21:28 Amr Moussa: Efforts to end Lebanese crisis not success nor failure
14:55 U.S. judge: Iran owes $254m to victims of 1996 Khobar Towers bombing
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved