Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 28, 2006 Tevet 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:33 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Four reasons for ranting
By Aluf Benn

We should not take the Iranian threat to Israel lightly. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad seriously intends to erase the Jewish state from the map, and his engineers are working on the development of nuclear weapons that will change the regional balance of power. But what is the purpose of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's intensified rhetoric against Iran? Why has he abandoned the "low profile" that he preached at the beginning of his term? Four explanations come to mind:

1. To spur on Bush. The ideal scenario, from Israel's point of view, would be an American military attack that would destroy Iran's nuclear facilities and remove the threat. "We have to get the United States to carry out what it promised to do, and to create the proper international climate," explains a senior official. It is not clear what President Bush told Olmert in private talks that had him leaving Bush's office feeling so satisfied. We can only presume that Olmert is depending on Bush's religious faith and obstinacy, which will lead him to attack Iran, even in light of American public opposition to military adventures in the Middle East.

When will that happen? The head of the Mossad spoke this week about an Iranian nuclear bomb in another three years. This leaves a year for diplomacy and sanctions, and moves H-hour for a military attack to 2008, if Iran continues its nuclear development. The timing is right politically. It will be Bush's last year in the White House, and he will be busy bequeathing his "legacy." It is a known fact that U.S. election years have always been years of dramatic moves in relations with Israel, from Harry S. Truman's recognition of the Jewish state to Bill Clinton's Camp David summit, to the "Bush letter" that recognized the settlements and the separation fence.

Advertisement

2. To prepare for an Israeli attack. Former prime minister Ariel Sharon used to deny that Israel was planning to attack Iran on its own. Olmert prefers to hint at a military option. That's good for spurring the "world" into action, but it is also good for preparing Israeli public opinion for a complex conflict that is liable to continue for years. The experts disagree as to whether Israel has the ability to paralyze the Iranian project if it strikes it at critical points. It is clear that Israel would have to receive American approval for such an operation, and would prefer receiving it from Bush, who is friendly to Israel, rather than gambling on his successor. That is why even for this alternative 2008 will be the critical year.

3. To solve political problems. There is nothing like an external threat to calm the internal arena, and there is nobody like Olmert, an experienced politician, to use it. Expanding the coalition? Appoint hawk Avigdor Lieberman as minister of strategic threats. Paralyzing the opposition? Allow Benjamin Netanyahu to curse Ahmadinejad and call for his trial in The Hague - then he won't attack the government. Commissions of inquiry? Who has time to discuss the failures of Lebanon when the Iranian mushroom cloud threatens?

4. To remain in the territories. Olmert wants to remain in the Golan, refuses to talk to Syrian President Bashar Assad and uses Bush's opposition as an excuse: Israel needs Bush to fight Iran, and we must not annoy him by babbling nonsense about peace with Syria. This is an update to the old debate about the link between the territories and Iran.

The right has warned that the Iranian bomb would provide an umbrella for a ground attack on Israel, and therefore we must not come down from the mountains.

The left believes that withdrawal to the Green Line would take away Iran's excuse for attacking Israel. This does not interest Ahmadinejad: He wants to destroy the "Zionist regime," with or without the territories. The Green Line does not appear on his map. But his threats provide a convenient justification for Olmert, who talks like Yitzhak Rabin and behaves like Yitzhak Shamir.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Terms of employment
P.M., 52, was fired from her supermarket job immediately after disclosing her cancer.
A gilded glass of bubbly
No wines are more closely associated with the New Year than assorted champagnes.
  1.   The unreliable American catspaw 11:14  |  Clickfool 21/12/06
  2.   #5 reason: to keep Aluf busy thinking 11:26  |  Iranian-American 21/12/06
  3.   THE OLD POLITICAL GAME CALLED HUNT THE PATSY 12:10  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  4.   Pipe (as in Daniel) Dreams 12:47  |  Hannah 21/12/06
  5.   The US can`t even secure Baghdad 13:07  |  spyguy 21/12/06
  6.   The Blind Leading the Blind 15:02  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/12/06
  7.   HANNAH EXPOUNDS MILITARY PHONEY PHILOSOPHY 15:33  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  8.   #1 AND WHAT CLICKFOOL IS IRAN WERE AGAIN AN ALLY TO ISRAEL 15:36  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  9.   Er... Just a detail 16:07  |  Ulfsteinn 21/12/06
  10.   clickfool"without it costing a single shekel" 16:19  |  gabbai 21/12/06
  11.   clickfool"without it costing a single shekel" 16:19  |  gabbai 21/12/06
  12.   Mr. Harris suggests the courage to go nuclear #7 16:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/12/06
  13.   Olmert in search of an agenda 17:00  |  Tosefta 21/12/06
  14.   Israel trafficked weapons during the Iran-Contra 17:18  |  Marilyn 21/12/06
  15.   Four reasons Olmert is unfit 17:30  |  Mark Lincoln 21/12/06
  16.   Aluf Benn has lost the plot entirely 17:45  |  Jake 21/12/06
  17.   Yaakov Sullivan, spittting in the wind 17:47  |  Jake 21/12/06
  18.   Marilyn, the Ayatollah say no nukes? 17:48  |  Jake 21/12/06
  19.   "Whinging" Marilyn, an answer to your question 17:50  |  Jake 21/12/06
  20.   312 YAAKOV THE NEUTRON BOMB ALREADY EXISTS 17:54  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  21.   Olmert downplayed possibliities of war with Iran and Syria 17:55  |  Jake 21/12/06
  22.   Jake, on spitting in the wind #17 18:04  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/12/06
  23.   Spyguy on the mark 18:10  |  Ah 21/12/06
  24.   Fifth reason 18:20  |  Ah 21/12/06
  25.   Paul Harris, first truman and now putin #20 18:28  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/12/06
  26.   "The Green Line does not appear on his map" ????????????????????? 19:02  |  THE JACKAL 21/12/06
  27.   Author is right about one thing 19:35  |  H50 21/12/06
  28.   It Only Takes One.... 20:14  |  Nick 21/12/06
  29.   Yaakov 20:57  |  Michael 21/12/06
  30.   #8 TIDE IN IRAQ TURNING FOR THE WORSE 21:19  |  ballistic 21/12/06
  31.   Olmert the Slow (Jake #21) 21:27  |  Tosefta 21/12/06
  32.   For Paul Harris # 8 22:01  |  Clickfool 21/12/06
  33.   Four reasons for ranting 22:06  |  n_erber 21/12/06
  34.   Benn`s and Haaretz`s Nonsense About Syria 22:07  |  Tod Zuckerman 21/12/06
  35.   Unlike Iraq, Iran is perfect for regime change 22:16  |  Jewish-American 21/12/06
  36.   Michale on the threat from Ahmadinejad 22:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/12/06
  37.   #25 YAAKOV APPROVES THE SOLUTION A LEIBERMAN 23:15  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  38.   #26 THE JACKAL FORGETS OSLO A TOTAL FAILURE 23:18  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  39.   #30 ATYPING ERROR FOR IRAN NOT IRAQ 23:21  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  40.   #32 THAT IS TO BE EXPECTED C YOU DONT UNDERSTAND MUCH ATALL 23:23  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  41.   The American people know they are on terrorist Iran`s hit list 23:33  |  Aaron 21/12/06
  42.   Sullivan 23:35  |  LL 21/12/06
  43.   Yaakov, did you miss the Gaza pullout? 23:46  |  Aaron 21/12/06
  44.   Olmert the Slow (Jake #21) - correction 23:57  |  Tosefta 21/12/06
  45.   #41 Aaron thinks that the USA is on Iran`s "hit list" 00:41  |  Johnboy 22/12/06
  46.   #41 WE SURE DO AGREE 00:43  |  ballistic 22/12/06
  47.   #43 GIVE BACK ALL STOLEN LAND 00:55  |  ballistic 22/12/06
  48.   Sullivan and his Lieberman obsession 01:31  |  Where`s waldo 22/12/06
  49.   Michael #29 01:43  |  Guess who 22/12/06
  50.   paul harris #40 01:50  |  Guess who 22/12/06
  51.   Tosefta, veiled threats? 03:24  |  Jake 22/12/06
  52.   Tosefta, well reputed analyst? 03:51  |  Jake 22/12/06
  53.   I made a mistake (Jake #48) 04:12  |  Tosefta 22/12/06
  54.   I made a mistake (Jake #48) 04:30  |  Tosefta 22/12/06
  55.   Aaron, Israel are the aggressors mate 05:18  |  Marilyn 22/12/06
  56.   Marilyn, what are your citations? 05:48  |  Aaron 22/12/06
  57.   Bush doesn`t even have the power to launch a war on Iran 06:30  |  Pablo B 22/12/06
  58.   #43 Aaron thinks highly of the Gaza pullout 06:44  |  Johnboy 22/12/06
  59.   Hint, hint, hint 07:26  |  Jim 22/12/06
  60.   #9 Ulfsteinn 07:35  |  Jim 22/12/06
  61.   Balance of Power = Equal Rights 08:11  |  Natallie Durson 22/12/06
  62.   Let`s not be overly worry about Ahmadenijad.. 08:57  |  Willy 22/12/06
  63.   Aarons world views . . . . 09:19  |  revoltop 22/12/06
  64.   Jim you forgot something . . . . 10:18  |  revoltop 22/12/06
  65.   For Aaron on the Gaza withdrawal # 43 10:43  |  Clickfool 22/12/06
  66.   Natalie Durson, commander in chief 11:19  |  Aaron 22/12/06
  67.   #64 - Bush may try to attack Iran, but he will 11:27  |  spyguy 22/12/06
  68.   Revoltop and Johnboy: why can`t the Jews have a state? 11:43  |  Aaron 22/12/06
  69.   Pablo B, thanks for undermining our credibility on the nuke thing 11:50  |  Aaron 22/12/06
  70.   Thanks Aaron 13:01  |  revoltop 22/12/06
  71.   Spyguy knows America. . . 13:13  |  revoltop 22/12/06
  72.   #68 WHY MUST THERE BE A SOLELY JEWISH STATE 23:39  |  ballistic 22/12/06
  73.   #6 TELL EM AGAIN, MR HARRIS 23:42  |  ballistic 22/12/06
  74.   #66 Natalie better commander/chief than Bush or Olmert 23:46  |  ballistic 22/12/06
  75.   four reasons for ranting 00:20  |  moti 24/12/06
  76.   Interesting Racism against those purporting to support 22:02  |  Observer 24/12/06
  77.   #36 Yaakov Sullivan Stop pretending 00:43  |  Ron 26/12/06
  78.   isreal amd the u.s.a. 00:49  |  kevin 27/12/06
  79.   What Israel can do now to put an end to an ending 04:18  |  Tommi Harkins 27/12/06
  80.   the Us can`t even secure Baghdad 05:05  |  tommi harkins 27/12/06
  81.   no one will impeach bush SPY GUY #5 21:59  |  Jacob 27/12/06
 Today Online
IDF to resume pinpoint operations against Qassam cells
Responses: 355
Tzipi Livni supports talks with PA, even under fire
Responses: 105
Amira Hass: IDF expelling West Bank Palestinians
Responses: 89
Ultra-Orthodox, El Al hammer out draft agreement
Responses: 53
Shmuel Rosner: In-married Jewry and intermarried Jewry
Responses: 80


More Headlines
03:33 Egypt transfers arms, ammunition to Fatah
04:37 Israel to impose limits on bank accounts of security prisoners
22:24 PM: Opposition to Syria talks not the result of U.S. pressure
02:20 Katzrin police confiscate murder suspect's washing machine
06:09 Treasury calls on state lottery to fund classroom construction
00:46 Three Iranians unable to find way to convert to Judaism
02:55 Shock treatment center in Sderot faces closure due to lack of funds
02:08 U.S.: Plans for new West Bank settlement violate road map
05:15 'Elderly ward' doubles as nursing home to aging prisoners
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved