Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., December 23, 2006 Tevet 2, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:14 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Olmert's Hanukkah miracle
By Israel Harel

Since the Lebanon fiasco, the ground has been shaking beneath Ehud Olmert's chair. He did manage to thwart the demand to establish a state commission of inquiry, but even the Winograd Committee may mark him as the bearer of supreme responsibility for the failures that caused Israel to lose a war for the first time in its history. To survive the political and military failure and the entanglements of the investigations, Olmert knows - and the precedent set by Ariel Sharon proves - that the path of making territorial concessions is his only hope for saving himself from ousting and perhaps a trial. Only by making additional sacrifices in this area will he reach the protected status of "etrog," as the media called Sharon.

This means that every failure will be forgiven, every shady deal laundered, every file closed. If Sharon was absolved retroactively for the sin of Lebanon and the sin of creating the settlements merely by proposing to uproot Jewish communities, all the more will Olmert, who does not bear the burden of even one-hundredth of the reasons for which Sharon was hated and persecuted in Israeli politics, gain the approval of the country's media and legal system.

There is even a Hanukkah miracle, which could win him the validation of all the political and legal elements who are after him: Bashar Assad is calling, publicly, for direct talks with Israel. In contrast to the past, the Syrian leader says, without preconditions.

Advertisement

But in an incomprehensible and even surprising way, the beneficiary of the miracle, who should immediately have grasped that he has been given a one-time opportunity to extricate himself from his troubles, does not discern the miracle and rejects the proffered hand.

Never mind that the head of the Mossad, whose job it is to be suspicious - and who obviously also has information to support his suspicions, told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee that "Assad is not really offering negotiations," or "the Syrians have preconditions." But for Olmert to reject, contrary to his survival instinct, dialogue with Assad because "first Syria's actions must be examined, not only its words"?

The declaration is surprising. If he responds positively to the Syrians, he will become the darling of the decision-makers, he will receive the status of etrog and will gain much political and legal time. What is he being asked to sacrifice, after all - the Golan Heights? If, as a graduate of the Betar movement, he is willing to give up most of Judea and Samaria to the Arabs, he will all the more not spare the Golan Heights.

This is unlikely to be the reason. Even his statement after his meeting with Tony Blair, and despite Blair's support of this line, is not persuasive: "Our demands are clear: (even before negotiations) Syria must stop undermining the Siniora government in Lebanon and stop supporting terror."

The prime minister received a hint as to the thoughts of those who have the power to decide his political or legal future, in a series of articles the line of which most of the media and the legal system usually toes: The main thrust is that Olmert should respond positively to the Syrian even if the U.S. is opposed, unless it turns out that this is a Syrian trick. Certainly from the perspective of these circles, there is no reason, if the maneuver turns out to be real, not to give the Syrians the Golan Heights and destroy the settlements. It is therefore entirely incomprehensible that this seasoned man does not take advantage of the most serious opportunity that has ever crossed his path to save his standing and his position and also, as with the Sharon precedent, to get rid of his legal troubles. Moreover, if the talks with the Syrians do get started, it is reasonable to assume that the Winograd Committee, like Menachem Mazuz with disengagement, will take the revolutionary political circumstances into consideration and not dare take responsibility for dismissing a prime minister at the height of peace talks with Syria.

The media, among whom Olmert has more personal friends than Sharon had, will certainly act this way. They will happily once again come to his aid after he has won the appropriate approval.

The accepted explanation, that American interests are the reason Olmert has not responded to the Syrians, is not convincing. In the past the Americans never came out against a move that led to Israeli withdrawal, even if they were surprised and taken aback by Israel's moves, as was the case at the beginning of the Oslo process - and subsequently, when the process was bogged down, they ardently demanded its implementation.

It is a clear American interest that Syria depart the axis of evil following receipt of the Golan. It is therefore reasonable to assume that in absolute contradiction to the public rejection of Assad's initiative, something significant is happening beneath the surface in the Israel-Syria arena. And to surprise us all, and thus increase the effect of the achievement, Olmert's and Livni's unconvincing declarations are being aired ("We must know when the opportunity is real and when it is only an image of one").

Then will the exaltation of the etrog, if the breakthrough is significant, be carried from the ends of the country to the ends of the earth.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The girl and the hood
Some say 'Little Red Riding Hood' is based on a 19th-century incident in Germany.
Oil and trouble
In Jaffa, nearly all the stores have boiling oil pots smelling of frying dough.
  1.   Israel needs a " bad guy" 10:35  |  Lebanese 21/12/06
  2.   No Don`t Do It! Forget Syria! 10:38  |  Yosemite Sam 21/12/06
  3.   What miracle? It`s a diabolical trick ! 11:19  |  Paul Henzen 21/12/06
  4.   The Miracle Is That Harel Still Believes This. 11:35  |  Terry 21/12/06
  5.   Henzen, thanks for the heads up, BUT 11:38  |  Maral 21/12/06
  6.   Miracles and donkey-work 12:03  |  sh 21/12/06
  7.   Harel 12:19  |  Mordechai 21/12/06
  8.   #1, your are so right 12:33  |  viper 21/12/06
  9.   # 5 Maral - release Ehud Goldwasser / Eldad Regev 12:40  |  Paul Henzen 21/12/06
  10.   Does this say what I think it says? 13:44  |  Shlomo 21/12/06
  11.   To #7 14:01  |  Emanuel 21/12/06
  12.   the zionists choices 15:25  |  John and the truth 21/12/06
  13.   antisemitism a la Peretz 15:34  |  candide 21/12/06
  14.   Israel Seems to Have Mader that Choice #12 15:43  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/12/06
  15.   Same as EU , Harel goes for Arabs appeasement policy 16:35  |  Joseph E . Post 1 21/12/06
  16.   Same as EU , Harel goes for Arabs appeasement policy 16:37  |  Joseph E . Post 2 21/12/06
  17.   Hanukkah Miracle 17:11  |  Bimmer 21/12/06
  18.   Olmert Has Bush As His Role Model 17:45  |  Nate 21/12/06
  19.   AYRIA DOES NEED TALK IT CAN ACT UNILATERALLY 18:12  |  paul harris 21/12/06
  20.   Harel also believes in Peter Pan 18:17  |  rich 21/12/06
  21.   John and the truth 18:18  |  rich 21/12/06
  22.   The only miracle is... 18:38  |  Paul 21/12/06
  23.   Want Peace? 19:30  |  Nick 21/12/06
  24.   Is it not obvious 20:59  |  Aryeah 21/12/06
  25.   and you are crazy, no miracle for you this year 22:15  |  ralph 21/12/06
  26.   Perceptive Column - No Faith in Olmert`s Integrity and Probity 22:35  |  Tod Zuckerman 21/12/06
  27.   joseph E post 1 22:39  |  mollio uk 21/12/06
  28.   What a miracle! 22:56  |  Jonathan S 21/12/06
  29.   Yah, Some Miracle 23:01  |  Justinian 21/12/06
  30.   aryeah 23:03  |  Wiseplato 21/12/06
  31.   It is an act he will try 2 give Israel away 23:25  |  sam 21/12/06
  32.   #19, PAUL HARRIS, YOUR REPLY ? 04:48  |  viper 23/12/06
 Today Online
Dror Etkes: Holocaust as alibi for occupation
Responses: 150
Ze'ev Schiff: Give Syria a chance
Responses: 60
Hamas, Fatah fighting resumes in Gaza after two-day truce
Responses: 116
Sneh: Time to decide on Iran military option is nearing
Responses: 149
Yoel Marcus: It's too bad no Sharon clone has emerged
Responses: 57


More Headlines
00:25 Palestinians fire three Qassam rockets at western Negev
07:29 Europeans circulate Iran sanctions draft in bid to win Russian support
21:14 At least nine hurt in clashes between Hamas, Fatah in Nablus
06:08 Quartet to channel funds to Palestinians skirting Hamas
06:57 Man killed, six wounded in weekend violence across Israel
03:51 Holocaust denial forum participant slams Canadian college
07:01 Three Israeli backpackers reported missing in remote Chilean park
01:23 Father of 14-year-old girl killed by IDF released on bail to mourn
00:55 Settler jailed for murdering four Palestinians commits suicide
15:44 Pedestrian and driver killed in two traffic accidents in north
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved