The Migron disgrace - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., January 11, 2008 Shvat 4, 5768

Israel Time: 18:41 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Last update - 09:39 20/12/2006

The Migron disgrace

By Haaretz Editorial

In response to a petition filed by the Palestinian owners of the property on which the illegal settlement outpost of Migron was established, the State Prosecutor's Office asked the court to delay its deliberations on the case for four to five months, in order to give the state time to submit an "update." The justification offered for this request was that Defense Minister Amir Peretz had ordered the Israel Defense Forces to hold talks with the settler leadership in an effort to reach an agreement on the voluntary evacuation of the illegal outposts "in the near future." If the talks fail to bear fruit, Peretz plans to order the evacuation of Migron within six months.

The outpost of Migron was set up on the sly in May 2001. First, an antenna was set up; then a container, in which a guard lived; and since then, 60 caravans and two permanent homes, housing 43 families, have been erected. In view of the fact that their property was stolen, the owners of the land repeatedly applied to the Civil Administration, seeking its help in getting their property back. The authorities turned a blind eye and the construction and population of Migron went on. Two months ago, the owners of the land filed a petition demanding that the army raze the structures, against which final demolition orders had already been issued.

On May 16, 2006, the defense minister announced that he would allow two weeks for negotiations with the settlers in the illegal outposts on evacuating of their own accord, and if no results were achieved, the IDF would begin evacuating them by force in early November. The defense minister did not keep his word, and the illegal outposts, including Migron, are still standing. Now, Migron - and probably the other illegal outposts as well - has been given a further extension that will last at least "four or five months." In practice, the procrastination could continue endlessly, because the State Prosecutor's Office said in its statement that the timing of the evacuation depends on coordination with the prime minister, the circumstances and various other constraints.

	Advertisement

The failure to evacuate the illegal outposts, despite the Talia Sasson report, is an unacceptable scandal. But the case of Migron is especially shameful for the state authorities and the rule of law. The demand to evacuate Migron requires no political justification; the fact that it was built on clearly private land - not lands that were appropriated for various uses by the state, but lands for which documentary proof of private ownership exists - is enough to justify evacuating the trespassers without hesitation or delay. In a law-abiding state, the owners of the land ought to be able to expect the authorities to aid them and restore their property to them. But the government of Israel repeatedly relies on excuses and makes promises that no one believes it intends to keep.

Migron is not the sole illegal outpost built on private land (see the article by Uzi Benziman on this page, which cites Peace Now's findings that 130 settlements were fully or partially set up on private land). But it sticks out due to the cunning and fraud that led to its establishment and the authorities' embarrassing and continued failure to remove it. And it also raises serious doubts about who really rules the territories - the law or the settlers.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	'Body of 2008'
	A U.K. men's magazine pays homage to Israeli supermodel Bar Refaeli.


	Echoes of Thessaloniki
	A book on Sarkozy's Greek-Jewish roots goes on sale in Greece.




1.	The Dynamic Duo of Immorality	09:54	\|	Natallie Durson	20/12/06

2.	The outposts as a symbol for Israels "readiness" for peace	10:00	\|	Swiss (Dino)	20/12/06

3.	Tzedek, tzedek tirdof	19:17	\|	David	20/12/06

4.	Legal:1st in time 1st in right by Israel,arabs illegally entered!	22:52	\|	sam	20/12/06

5.	Free4All	02:38	\|	JJ	21/12/06

6.	That last sentence just doesn`t go far enough	09:39	\|	Johnboy	21/12/06

7.	In support of the righteous posters #1, 2, 6, others	10:35	\|	dana	21/12/06

8.	To Nattalie...	11:32	\|	JDM	11/01/08

9.	MIGRON WILL STAY!!! ARABS DO NOT OWN THE LAND	14:30	\|	Mordi Man	11/01/08

Today Online


	Bradley Burston: Sharon, settler savior, killer of Palestine
	Responses: 68


	Israeli official: Bush call for 2008 peace deal 'positive step'
	Responses: 71


	CIA reveals that in 1974 it said Israel had nuclear weapons
	Responses: 64


	Officials: Progress made in Shalit deal, but no breakthrough
	Responses: 22


	Bush overheard at Yad Vashem saying 'we should've bombed Auschwitz'
	Responses: 7

More Headlines
14:52 Bush leaves Israel with hopes for 'chances of peace'


18:06 At Yad Vashem, Bush says U.S. erred in not bombing Auschwitz


12:19 UN Security Council condemns Katyusha fire on northern town


12:39 Hamas: Shalit talks halted due to row over prisoner swap criteria


17:22 'Jew - a common curse word among the youth of Germany'


18:33 Renault Nissan to invest in Israeli electric car project


17:26 Hamas: Bush promises 'unacceptable' for next generations of Palestinians


10:47 MK proposes bill to strip draft-dodgers of right to vote


10:34 CIA: We said back in 1974 that Israel had nuclear weapons