Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 21, 2006 Kislev 30, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:05 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
O.K. from a declining America?
By Gideon Samet

Behind Ehud Olmert's fuzzy talk about hewing to the American opposition to negotiations with Syria hides a sorry pretext used by an agenda-free prime minister, but also one of the most important issues for the future of Israel.

Not only "bloated putzes in the media," as Olmert so rudely put it recently, are criticizing the prime minister for refusing to talk with Damascus and for waiting for the O.K. from Washington. Amos Oz, for example, joined them yesterday. And it is not true that Olmert has no agenda. He has a full agenda, stuffed to bursting with "no"s. No, to Syria, following his no to talking with the Palestinian leadership, no to removing outposts that laugh at the law, no to any measures that would reduce the suffering of the entire population in the Gaza Strip, no and no again to changing the prime minister's arrogant style.

Together with all these negatives is one big yes: Olmert, nodding in agreement with George Bush's no-no's. With Syria, Olmert grasps the pretext, because he will not admit the real reason: He does not want to come down from the Golan Heights. In one of his recent awkward declarations, Olmert stated that "as long as I'm prime minister, the Golan Heights will remain in our hands for eternity." We will find out soon enough just how eternal is Olmert's rule. In the meantime, he will avoid getting caught up in a political move that poses such danger to him, such as agreeing to evacuate tens of thousands of in the north and withdrawing to Lake Kinneret.

Advertisement

Yet, unlike Olmert, however, the U.S. is not what it once was, when President Dwight D. Eisenhower ordered Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion immediately to leave Sinai in 1957; when Secretary of State Henry Kissinger declared, in 1975, a "reassessment" of U.S. policy on Israel because of its refusal to agree to an interim arrangement in Sinai; when President Bill Clinton dragged Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization to Camp David. In the past decade, bookshelves and columns of top commentators have been filled with descriptions of the weakening of the American giant. It has become almost banal to talk about the decline of the Empire.

Discussing this historical process, illustrated pointedly by the abortive attempt to reeducate the Middle East, aimed at proving that the world's only superpower can no longer act unilaterally, because its power has waned too much. In his 2002 masterpiece, "The Paradox of American Power," Professor Joseph Nye, Dean of Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, foresaw serious consequences for the U.S. internationally and domestically if it insisted on an "unrealistic imposition" of schedules and of forceful intervention.

As in Israel, despite the differences, critics of declining American imperialism point to an overly narrow focus on the national interest. This is also the claim of the Baker-Hamilton Report. The U.S. is still motivated by some sense of being divinely chosen, which is rooted in the moralistic thinking of the country's early history. There is opposition even within the national consensus to this impulse toward hegemony and a unipolar world that is leading the U.S. to disasters. Among other things, this impulse deepens the hatred of American culture. Some here might compare this by-product with the rise in anti-Semitism in the West as a result of the Israeli occupation.

I once suggested, in these pages, that the power-drunk behavior of the Bush era be termed the "Israelization of America." Now Olmert believes he will be doing a favor to Israel by means of its Americanization. It won't work. The "illusion of control" and the "end of the American epoch" - key terms to the critical discussion of the past several years in the West - require sensitive Israeli attention. Equally to be noted is the almost obsessive talk in the U.S. of the imminent end (again, as happened six and a half years ago) of the bull market on Wall Street.

Such sensitivity invites, at the very least, a reshaping and updating of Israeli politics in accordance with what appears to be an obvious Israeli interest: a rational agenda instead of a slothful slouching after a wandering and habitually goring American bull.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Big money at stake
A heavy shadow of suspicion lingers over Israeli soccer over recent revelations of match fixing.
Death of a maverick
David Yanai's work was not part of the Israeli architectural mainstream.
  1.   American influence and control 09:58  |  Dror 20/12/06
  2.   Good Idea .... really 09:59  |  Natallie Durson 20/12/06
  3.   The paradoxum of the U.S. - Israel relations 10:15  |  Swiss (Dino) 20/12/06
  4.   #3 DINO THE BUILDER HAS FOUNDATIONS OF SAND 10:47  |  paul harris 20/12/06
  5.   Beggars can`t be choosers 10:49  |  Hannah 20/12/06
  6.   Israel`s future without America 10:53  |  alan 20/12/06
  7.   # 4 paul harris 11:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 20/12/06
  8.   Israel is not independant of the US 11:18  |  Isratinian 20/12/06
  9.   In For A Penny, In For A Pound 11:21  |  Victor Smolinsky 20/12/06
  10.   The obsequious shadow of the powerful 11:22  |  sh 20/12/06
  11.   Dino 11:26  |  sh 20/12/06
  12.   a modest proposal........... 11:43  |  Jim 20/12/06
  13.   # 11 sh 12:10  |  Swiss (Dino) 20/12/06
  14.   Jim # 12 12:48  |  Victor Smolinsky 20/12/06
  15.   The biggest "no" of all 12:54  |  Tzfonit 20/12/06
  16.   Interdependence Is Needed 13:19  |  Bruriah Sarah 20/12/06
  17.   A SERVICE TO THE MASTER 13:34  |  indrajaya 20/12/06
  18.   Gideon Samet,paid by EU to push their agenda 13:43  |  Absolute Sweden 20/12/06
  19.   SYRIA GOES SHOPPING IN RUSSIA 13:55  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 20/12/06
  20.   Status quo 14:03  |  ussishkin 20/12/06
  21.   Indrajaya # 17 14:16  |  Victor Smolinsky 20/12/06
  22.   Setting boundaries 14:20  |  Alicia 20/12/06
  23.   US Duplicty In Its Vision for the Rest of the World 14:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 20/12/06
  24.   Cipora Julianna Kohn # 19 15:01  |  Victor Smolinsky 20/12/06
  25.   Mr.SmolinskY: I think Miss Kohen would say yes to that #24 15:27  |  Yaakov Sullivan 20/12/06
  26.   Now Don`t Be Foolish 15:39  |  Yosemite Sam 20/12/06
  27.   Oh come on Natalie, you can afford ten bucks year 15:42  |  albert amato 20/12/06
  28.   #24, Victor 15:49  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 20/12/06
  29.   Hannulah #5 15:52  |  albert amato 20/12/06
  30.   If Israel were to the right of U.S. Samet`s tune would change 15:59  |  McQueen 20/12/06
  31.   America & Israel`s slavish aping of it. 16:18  |  SR 20/12/06
  32.   #17 Indrajaya 16:48  |  stright 2 the point 20/12/06
  33.   Swiss(Dino) 17:12  |  ODP 20/12/06
  34.   SALAMI TACTICS 17:20  |  Jim 20/12/06
  35.   Give our taxpayers` money back first. 18:02  |  Anoosh 20/12/06
  36.   Best talkback yet. 18:09  |  Lou Medel 20/12/06
  37.   # 33 ODP 18:17  |  Swiss (Dino) 20/12/06
  38.   Syria and self defense 18:20  |  John 20/12/06
  39.   As America is clueless when it comes to the Middle East... 18:20  |  Bimmer 20/12/06
  40.   indrajaya - strange thoughts 18:49  |  Sam 20/12/06
  41.   How stupid To alienate the U.S. over nowhere negotiations 19:17  |  Shalom Freedman 20/12/06
  42.   What Chutzpah from Appeasers and Post-Zionist Nincompoops 19:41  |  Tod Zuckerman 20/12/06
  43.   America`s influence is not declining 19:42  |  Jack 20/12/06
  44.   US and Israel 19:48  |  jack 20/12/06
  45.   This Talkback Is Starting To Resemble An Old Woody Allen Flik! 19:50  |  Yosemite Sam 20/12/06
  46.   42 Hey Tod 20:29  |  Baruch Nili 20/12/06
  47.   Apart From The $3B In Aid... 21:39  |  chet 20/12/06
  48.   what a load of BS 21:42  |  rich 20/12/06
  49.   51th State 21:53  |  Yuval Lerner 20/12/06
  50.   one flaw in this thinking 21:55  |  Raymond Deane 20/12/06
  51.   Jim in Phoenix 22:31  |  rich 20/12/06
  52.   (o_o) 22:39  |  JJ 20/12/06
  53.   Vell!.....I Tried! 22:48  |  Yosemite Sam 20/12/06
  54.   wagging the tail 22:58  |  david 20/12/06
  55.   The other way around as well 23:56  |  Michael N 20/12/06
  56.   The only way is peace! 23:59  |  Jews for peace 20/12/06
  57.   #19 Don`t be silly 00:00  |  alan 21/12/06
  58.   CHET when the Arabs comply with ALL UN resolutions complain 00:26  |  PETER SM 21/12/06
  59.   HANNAH Basic history.USA only allied itself to Israel in the 70`s 00:35  |  PETER SM 21/12/06
  60.   I touched a nerve with Rich, #51 01:01  |  Jim 21/12/06
  61.   Apologize 01:42  |  From the Moon 21/12/06
  62.   For #51 - Rich 01:55  |  chet 21/12/06
  63.   Advice from an Israeli American 02:08  |  AJ 21/12/06
  64.   jim in phoenix 02:28  |  rich 21/12/06
  65.   Cakecrumbs. 02:34  |  Maureen Ann 21/12/06
  66.   Jim in Phoenix read and eat humble pie 02:45  |  rich 21/12/06
  67.   #Cipora Julianna Kohn, SYRIA`S SELF DEFENSE. 02:46  |  Maureen Ann 21/12/06
  68.   Take reins in our own hands 02:46  |  Harry 21/12/06
  69.   Chet ..whats yr point? 03:00  |  rich 21/12/06
  70.   O.K. 03:23  |  Shmuelshachor 21/12/06
  71.   #60,touched a nerve with Rich 05:21  |  Shmuelshachor 21/12/06
  72.   Israel lobby a laugh 05:23  |  bri 21/12/06
  73.   to # 56,the only way is peace... 05:28  |  Shmuelshachor 21/12/06
  74.   Gideon needs a lifeboat.... 05:35  |  Blogowitz 21/12/06
  75.   #18(Gideon Samet) 07:05  |  George from Canada 21/12/06
  76.   #23(US duplicity) 07:11  |  George from Canada 21/12/06
  77.   O.K. from Declining America 08:45  |  Martin 21/12/06
  78.   Syria 09:11  |  R 21/12/06
  79.   Declining 09:47  |  David 21/12/06
  80.   # 40, SAM 11:16  |  indrajaya 21/12/06
  81.   # 40, SAM 11:16  |  indrajaya 21/12/06
  82.   #47.Chet-Correct.$3BiUS-.Israel+$9BiWeapons+New-+SpecialAid! 11:46  |  Moses 21/12/06
  83.   any other deluded ideas? 22:46  |  ralph 21/12/06
 Today Online
Shmuel Rosner: Is Jimmy Carter an anti-Semite?
Responses: 299
Source: Olmert to uphold restraint despite Qassams
Responses: 192
Peretz tells IDF to prevent rockets, but uphold truce
Responses: 192
Supreme Court won't release detained man to mourn his daughter
Responses: 212
U.S. ambassador appears to confirm Israeli-Saudi contacts
Responses: 37
Aluf Benn: Four reasons why PM keeps ranting on Iran
Responses: 34