Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 20, 2006 Kislev 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:08 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
First, say yes
By Yoel Marcus

At no point should Israel find itself in a situation in which an Arab country offers to negotiate and Israel refuses. In the 1970s, president Anwar Sadat, in an interview with Newsweek, offered to negotiate with Israel for peace in return for occupied territories. Golda Meir, "Madam No," said under no circumstances. Our arrogant leaders maintained at the time that it was just a public relations ploy. Until the Yom Kippur War hit us. We took him up on his offer late, and paid with 3,000 lives.

A great deal of time has passed since. We have signed peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan, two out of the three neighboring countries that attacked Israel in 1948. Syria has remained the most intransigent and hostile of them all, unremittingly assisting terror organizations, by, for instance, giving refuge and weapons to Hezbollah in Lebanon.

But since 1973, Syria has taken care not to activate terror from within its borders. Assad senior had something of the yekke in him, and believed agreements should be honored. And when Yitzhak Rabin became prime minister for the second time, there was even a kind of secret understanding between them, that Israel was holding "a deposit that belongs to him" - the Golan Heights - against a future arrangement.

Advertisement

But every attempt at negotiations over the years was nipped in the bud for ostensibly foolish reasons. Mainly because Syria demanded everything, including the right of its soldiers to dip their feet in the Kinneret. In the second Iraq war, Assad found himself trapped and loathed as a collaborator with the axis of evil. And it is precisely from that dark corner that Syria emerges with a peace campaign "with no prior conditions."

In an interview with the Washington Post, the Syrian foreign minister called on Olmert to negotiate without prior conditions, and not from the point where previous negotiations stopped or failed. Bashar Assad reinforced his foreign minister's statements in an interview to an Italian newspaper: Our intentions are real, and if Olmert is unable to decide, then let Washington decide for him. There is a sense of a turning-point in the air, not only toward Israel but perhaps even toward the United States.

Syria is uncomfortable with its central position in the axis of evil. This is the only way to explain the recent outpouring of dovishness from Damascus. If his day of reckoning with Iran is coming, Assad prefers to send America a message in the spirit of Gaddafi: "How do we get out of here?" He has no desire to be worn down by the madman from Tehran.

In a position paper for the Council for Peace and Security, Dr. Nimrod Novick, advisor to Shimon Peres during his premiership, wrote that Assad was impressed with the fact that Israel was prepared to embark on a military campaign and expose its citizens to rocket barrages. And when its civilian population was shot at, Israel did not end the war nor shrink from attacking populated areas in Beirut.

Israel proved its intelligence and operational capabilities in destroying the long-range rocket array and its launchers and still enjoyed the diplomatic cover of the Americans, who blocked the Security Council from forcing a cease-fire. From a strategic perspective, Syria has for the near future lost Hezbollah as a proxy for attacking Israel from Lebanese territory.

Calls for negotiations have not come from pure intentions. Assad's regime is concerned about his involvement in Iraq, concerned about the renewed momentum in the investigation into the murder of Rafiq Hariri, about Syria's isolation from of the bloc of moderate Arab countries, and most of all, he does not want to be around should Bush decide to respond or to strike.

Still, it is clear that the central condition to negotiations without prior conditions was - and is - the Golan Heights. The Golan is not inscribed in the Bible and is not the heart's desire of the messianic settlers. From our perspective, it is a matter of quality of life for 33 years, a beautiful view, and of course, strategic location - "the eyes of the nation" which, if given up, will require arrangements to ensure first and foremost our security in the North.

Ehud Olmert's harsh opposition to Syria's initiative is not wise. Bush will go home, but we will still be here. If a government needs an agenda, the Syrian challenge is one of those national agenda items Olmert so disparages, and which require courage and intelligence. That a rose garden will bloom from this bud is perhaps unlikely so long as Iran is around threatening humanity. But Israel must always be ready to move, never passive in its aspirations for peace. Even if one of our greatest enemies extends a hand to us, we must first of all say yes.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Unhealthy arithmetic
Numbers of calorie counters live in constant guilt and are easy prey for diet marketing.
Musical genes
IPO contrabassist Nimrod Kling, 30, comes from a very established musical family.
  1.   a very wise opinion article 09:07  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  2.   Maybe a rose garden will not bloom from this bud - 09:22  |  Daniela 19/12/06
  3.   Predictably, Wrong 09:25  |  Tod Zuckerman 19/12/06
  4.   Good article, but... 09:40  |  An Arab Neighbor 19/12/06
  5.   Peace with Syrians 09:46  |  Sam 19/12/06
  6.   WRONNG YES IT NEEDS TO COME FROM DAMASCUS 09:47  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  7.   Israel or when having a nice view seems to be more important..... 09:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  8.   to tod zuckerman 09:58  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  9.   to daniela in f. 10:12  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  10.   3 Tom - You negotiate peace with enemies 10:23  |  Davids 19/12/06
  11.   Swiss (Dino) #7 Israel`s Security 11:01  |  Tim 19/12/06
  12.   M. Dagan:(Israel`s YES)"a stab in the back to mod. Arab rulers" 11:08  |  Pablo 19/12/06
  13.   Yes is fine, but not `blind` yes 11:08  |  TonyL 19/12/06
  14.   Yes, of course. What can be more obvious? 11:52  |  Natallie Durson 19/12/06
  15.   # 11 Tim 11:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  16.   Let Syria Cook its own goose! 12:02  |  Asa 19/12/06
  17.   Bla, bla, bla from peace parrots 12:06  |  Ilan 19/12/06
  18.   DONT GIVE UP THE GOLAN! WE NEED IT FOR SECURITY 12:44  |  SLAVO 19/12/06
  19.   Slavo 13:06  |  mollio uk 19/12/06
  20.   saul a. readner #8 (`Catching Assad the snake` dream) 13:07  |  TonyL 19/12/06
  21.   IIan 13:18  |  mollio uk 19/12/06
  22.   # 18 SLAVO 13:25  |  Axel 19/12/06
  23.   Say no to Syria 13:50  |  Jonathan S 19/12/06
  24.   What Is Assad`s Motivation 14:14  |  Terry 19/12/06
  25.   Ehud Olmert`s harsh opposition to Syria`s initiative is not wise. 14:41  |  sh 19/12/06
  26.   golan heights 14:50  |  isiaiah 19/12/06
  27.   Swiss(Dino) 15:55  |  ODP 19/12/06
  28.   # 23 Jonathan S: too obvious, again 16:03  |  Axel 19/12/06
  29.   Feel sorry for you mollio 16:07  |  Ilan 19/12/06
  30.   A realistic approach 16:10  |  Jack 19/12/06
  31.   Syria is the key to peace here 16:33  |  Tosefta 19/12/06
  32.   Reply to Jack in London (Post 30) 16:40  |  Johnny Weintraub 19/12/06
  33.   # 27 ODP 16:48  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  34.   to axel in germany 16:58  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  35.   to tony l 17:02  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  36.   Tosefta 17:04  |  ODP 19/12/06
  37.   #30 JACK POSES THE QUESTION AND THE ANSWER IS ALL BAD 17:04  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  38.   A REPEAT, BUT IN THE AGE OF MULTITASKING, WHY NOT BEGIN DIALOGUE 17:09  |  Smadar 19/12/06
  39.   To Johnny Weintraub 17:15  |  Jack 19/12/06
  40.   Syria is a viper. Don`t agree to viper`s suggestions. 17:15  |  Vittorio 19/12/06
  41.   #36 ODP; The Deal 17:21  |  Tosefta 19/12/06
  42.   To Tosefta in Tveria 17:28  |  Jack 19/12/06
  43.   Golan Was Palestine Till 1922 / However Talk 17:29  |  semsem 19/12/06
  44.   # 34 saul a. readner 17:39  |  Axel 19/12/06
  45.   To Paul Harris 17:42  |  Jack 19/12/06
  46.   The Right of Return (Jack #42) 17:54  |  Tosefta 19/12/06
  47.   mollio, the british colonialist. 18:04  |  Joe 19/12/06
  48.   #45 JACK YOU HAVE THE WRONG REASON 18:18  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  49.   #47 JOE YOU FORGOT GIBRALTAR. 18:20  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  50.   Israeli intransigence 18:30  |  david 19/12/06
  51.   To Axel in Germany about a misconception #28 18:55  |  Jonathan S 19/12/06
  52.   Intense US Pressure 18:57  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/06
  53.   again to axel 19:06  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  54.   saul a. readner #35 19:21  |  TonyL 19/12/06
  55.   Say No 19:45  |  Domingo 19/12/06
  56.   Ilan - thank you so much for your concern - how kind.. 20:05  |  mollio uk 19/12/06
  57.   re Joanathan S. 20:06  |  Axel 19/12/06
  58.   3 days ago Y.Marcus attacked Olmert for waging the war. Now he 20:06  |  Absolute Sweden 19/12/06
  59.   SYRIA AND PEACE 20:17  |  CHARLES 19/12/06
  60.   pity not sympathy 20:24  |  Ilan 19/12/06
  61.   How convenient and self-serving of Mollio 20:25  |  Joe 19/12/06
  62.   the solution 20:31  |  David 19/12/06
  63.   and again to axel 20:35  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  64.   Mark Lincoln #52 20:36  |  TonyL 19/12/06
  65.   joe - Britain had a colonial attitude 21:04  |  mollio uk 19/12/06
  66.   IIlan - Are your opinions the only ones that matter 21:10  |  mollio uk 19/12/06
  67.   # 63 saul 21:22  |  Axel 19/12/06
  68.   Syrian overture 21:25  |  JW 19/12/06
  69.   Syria 21:31  |  Ah 19/12/06
  70.   another time to axel 22:03  |  saul a. readner 19/12/06
  71.   #65 MISCONCEPTIONS GO ON AND ON DONT THEY MOLLIO 22:26  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  72.   Mollio, UK 22:30  |  Joe 19/12/06
  73.   WHY? Syria extends no hand for peace, merely empty words! 22:33  |  Yaakov K. 19/12/06
  74.   Swiss (Dino) #15 22:41  |  Tim 19/12/06
  75.   To Axel, a lousy historian #57 22:51  |  Jonathan S 19/12/06
  76.   WHY?!!!!! Syria only "talks the talk." It does NOT "walk the walk 22:56  |  Yaakov K. 19/12/06
  77.   We need to see a PEACEFUL SOLUTION now. 23:10  |  Amnon 19/12/06
  78.   `# 75 Jonathan S. 23:43  |  Axel 19/12/06
  79.   What is really going on here 23:47  |  Danite 19/12/06
  80.   mark Lincoln 23:49  |  Danite 19/12/06
  81.   Tony ignorant as always 23:50  |  Mark Lincoln 19/12/06
  82.   ODP 23:52  |  Danite 19/12/06
  83.   History without dates (Axel #75, Jonathan S #75) 23:59  |  Tosefta 19/12/06
  84.   Paul - are you also called Joe? 00:05  |  mollio uk 20/12/06
  85.   #70 saul 00:08  |  Axel 20/12/06
  86.   Syria Talks 00:15  |  Joseph 20/12/06
  87.   No Danite 00:29  |  Mark Lincoln 20/12/06
  88.