Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 21, 2006 Kislev 30, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:20 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Denying the denial is not enough
By Nazir Mgally

Even if the whole world were to rally around Israel's condemnation of the Holocaust denial conference in Iran, it ought not satisfy the Israeli government or anyone engaged with the Holocaust. Denying the denial is not enough; and anyone who considers it important for the world to identify with the Jewish people and all other Nazi victims needs to adopt a serious, in-depth line of action to define Holocaust denial as a crime.

This conference - to give it its true dimensions - is the Arab and Muslim equivalent of a conference of the extreme anti-Zionist, ultra-Orthodox Neturei Karta. The limited coverage it received in the Arab media proves that there is a rational understanding of the event. They are not ignoring it, but neither are they dancing in the streets to its drumbeats.

No devout Muslim can identify with the objectives of the conference. A Muslim raised on the values of supporting the victim and opposing the hangman, the tyrant and the aggressor, will be disgusted by the idea, even if the conference ends with the establishment of a professional committee to examine the Holocaust. The reason is that anyone who reads history knows that the Nazis planned to exterminate the Jews and other peoples; Hitler simply ran out of time. The matter does not require research; it is testified to by Nazi writers. The Germans themselves confessed their Holocaust crimes, and still do today. No serious entity in Germany doubts the historical verity of the events.

Advertisement

The Arabs need to dissociate themselves completely from the Iranian conference. After all, it is clear that the Khomeinist junta that rules Iran did not convene the conference for the sake of scientific historical research. The idea was raised by a group of Arab intellectuals that decided to call a conference in Beirut in 2001. Hundreds of other Arab intellectuals, among them the Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish, opposed it. The idea was buried, and with it the conference.

Iran seized the opportunity, and within five years convened a conference on the same subject. The purpose was to demolish the foundations on which the State of Israel was built - not because there is an Israeli-Iranian conflict, but for entirely different reasons. Iran wants to regain its Persian imperial glory, to avenge the Arab "theft," as it sees it, of its homeland, its culture and its splendor. There is evidence of that in its violent intervention in Iraq, its unlimited support for Hezbollah in Lebanon, its unreserved aid to Syria and its recent backing of Hamas and Islamic Jihad.

Iran uses Arab means to hurt the Arabs. By its reckoning, the Arab world has reached a low-point in its global and regional influence, and now is the time for Iran to regain control. The quickest way to do so is to exploit the hatred of the Arab world for Israel. The destruction wrought by the Israel Defense Forces in Lebanon in the last war merely added fuel to the flames, and IDF actions in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank spread the conflagration throughout the Arab world.

The group of Holocaust deniers is not large, however, and the Arab world will not rush to identify with it. Until now, it appears that the Arab world has not been overly engaged with the subject of Holocaust denial, despite the rage and the hatred. Nevertheless, one should not play down even that power, especially in light of Iranian encouragement.

This conference must open everyone's eyes - especially those of Israel, the Arab world and the Palestinian Authority - to the fact that there is no vacuum in politics. Every day without a genuine peace process will only strengthen the extremists everywhere, and Holocaust denial will seem trivial in comparison with future plans.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Di's lawyers visit Israel
Representatives of British law firm Mishcon de Reya visited prominent Tel Aviv law firms.
Death of a maverick
David Yanai's work was not part of the Israeli architectural mainstream.
  1.   Bullying does not further reason 09:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  2.   Missing Link 09:28  |  Political 19/12/06
  3.   crap revisited NO PEACE FOR 58 YEARS what s the point ?/ 09:31  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  4.   Denial of reality 09:40  |  Brigitte Meier 19/12/06
  5.   Hear hear! 09:47  |  Tzvi 19/12/06
  6.   B.MEIER Zionism long preceeded the Nazis as did Balfour 09:57  |  PETER SM 19/12/06
  7.   denial or reality revisited 10:06  |  realistic 19/12/06
  8.   The Time Has Come For Israel And Arabia To Close Ranks! 10:19  |  Yosemite Sam 19/12/06
  9.   SWISS Apologists do not help.Apologising for lies does not help 10:31  |  PETER SM 19/12/06
  10.   Brigitte Meyer 10:41  |  Sarah 19/12/06
  11.   Keep the dialogue going! 10:43  |  Ben Azai 19/12/06
  12.   # 9 PETER SM Still searching your way...?? 11:02  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  13.   People believe whatever they want (regardless of history police) 11:16  |  Natallie Durson 19/12/06
  14.   SWISS. Re USA/Israel.Arabs hated Israel long before any alliance. 11:30  |  PETER SM 19/12/06
  15.   Dear Dino 11:32  |  Silvia 19/12/06
  16.   natallie durson and "true facts" (sic) 11:42  |  salah al din 19/12/06
  17.   Ahmadinejad`s seminar... 12:00  |  Maureen Ann 19/12/06
  18.   # 14 PETER SM Clarification needed ?? 12:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  19.   # 15 Silvia 12:16  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
  20.   KEEP THE DIALOGEUE GOING 13:04  |  DANNY. 19/12/06
  21.   TO NO 13 NATALIE DURSON 13:10  |  DANNY. 19/12/06
  22.   denying the hypocrisy 13:35  |  afzal 19/12/06
  23.   Conference was a PR disaster 13:41  |  Freddy 19/12/06
  24.   sarah 13:47  |  afzal 19/12/06
  25.   zionist history 14:04  |  afzal 19/12/06
  26.   Brigitte Meier`s wishful reality 14:36  |  sh 19/12/06
  27.   Free Speech is More Imp. Than Your Feelings 14:49  |  Gideon 19/12/06
  28.   This Fiasco Has Imploded On Itself 14:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/06
  29.   afzal 14:52  |  Sarah 19/12/06
  30.   MAUREEN AN Thanks for the insight into how your mind works 15:03  |  PETER SM 19/12/06
  31.   Arab racist violence and Nazi Facism are cousins 15:56  |  Michael Korn 19/12/06
  32.   Brigitte Meyer - not an enemy! 16:06  |  BP 19/12/06
  33.   nazir mgally IS ALWAYS A NON-SENSE, A LOSER AND BACKSTABER 16:12  |  Martin Hashim 19/12/06
  34.   But WHY did the Hollocaust occur? 16:21  |  Guess who 19/12/06
  35.   So what they had a Conference 16:27  |  emad matahin 19/12/06
  36.   Guess why is guess not #34 16:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/06
  37.   Don`t Hold Your Breathe 17:00  |  Bimmer 19/12/06
  38.   afzal, your analysis is true indeed #25 17:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/06
  39.   This post is for Guess who 17:19  |  Michael Korn 19/12/06
  40.   #27 IM PUZZLED GIDEON FREE SPEECH IS REPRESSED IN LAW 17:34  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  41.   #34 if you dont know the answer stop writing to HAARETZ 17:39  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  42.   I AM IN TOTAL SHOCK I AGREE 100% WITH YAAKOV 36 17:41  |  paul harris 19/12/06
  43.   Idiotic 17:51  |  Graham 19/12/06
  44.   # 34 Guess who - Zionism / Shoah / lessons 18:08  |  Paul Henzen 19/12/06
  45.   #PeterSM Have you heard... 18:16  |  Maureen 19/12/06
  46.   The immigration started in 1878! 18:19  |  Alicia 19/12/06
  47.   so you all admit that there is a Palestine,,, its about time 19:04  |  emad matahin 19/12/06
  48.   Yes Yaakov, the 6% Jews 19:33  |  Marilyn 19/12/06
  49.   Marilyn #48, thats the way i see it too 19:49  |  emad matahin 19/12/06
  50.   MARILYN - THE LADY KNIGHT 20:26  |  THE JACKAL 19/12/06
  51.   Marilyn, words have meaning #48 Part I 20:47  |  yaakov sullivan 19/12/06
  52.   Marilyn, words have meaning Part II#48 20:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/06
  53.   Facts Are Not Enforced By Law 20:59  |  Daniel Marcus 19/12/06
  54.   Yaakov Sullivan #28 21:07  |  Guess who 19/12/06
  55.   Michael Korn #31 21:08  |  Guess who 19/12/06
  56.   Paul Henzen #44 21:10  |  Guess who 19/12/06
  57.   Guess who and the why of Hitler #54 21:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/12/06
  58.   Guess Who: Open your eyes 21:52  |  Michael Korn 19/12/06
  59.   Holocaust, Holosphage, and Holoexaleipsis (I) 22:09  |  Joachim Martillo 19/12/06
  60.   Holocaust, Holosphage and Holoexaleipsis (II) 22:11  |  Joachim Martillo 19/12/06
  61.   Holocaust, Holosphage and Holoexaleipsis (VI) 22:17  |  Joachim Martillo 19/12/06
  62.   Afzal 22:18  |  Johnny 19/12/06
  63.   Bullying 22:30  |  Michael 19/12/06
  64.   Holocaust 22:33  |  Michael 19/12/06
  65.   to Frau Meier 23:01  |  Nachman Pilpel 19/12/06
  66.   Addendum to Yaakov 23:04  |  david 19/12/06
  67.   responce 23:22  |  black god 19/12/06
  68.   Yaakov Sullivan #57 (Part 2) 00:16  |  Guess who 20/12/06
  69.   Funny that "bullying" is the term 00:21  |  Moises 20/12/06
  70.   Rescuing Nazis 00:41  |  Mark Lincoln 20/12/06
  71.   Recognize all guilty parties 02:07  |  J.Olsen 20/12/06
  72.   thanks johnny 02:36  |  afzal 20/12/06
  73.   Answering Sarah 02:59  |  hollingsworth 20/12/06
  74.   Did anyone pick up on this? 03:03  |  hollingsworth 20/12/06
  75.   CIA M15 M16 FBI money and Imperialism 05:56  |  will 20/12/06
  76.   Irrelevant issues 06:13  |  Wise man 20/12/06
  77.   Hollingsworthless 06:18  |  Seymour 20/12/06
  78.   #Guess Who, Who, What, Why, When. 06:37  |  Maureen Ann 20/12/06
  79.   anti-Zionist? 07:35  |  Robbie 20/12/06
  80.   Re: #9. You fail to mention Prescott Bush`s role in the holocaust 08:45  |  kooskoos 20/12/06
  81.   Brigitte Meier, How true... 08:54  |  Dutch 20/12/06
  82.   Holocaust 08:54  |  kooskoos 20/12/06
  83.   Maureen Ann #78 10:14  |  Guess who 20/12/06
  84.   Israel`s existence has nothing to do with the Holocaust 16:23  |  Serge 20/12/06
  85.   hollingsworth 21:01  |  Alex 20/12/06
  86.   Dutch a correction 23:23  |  krystal 20/12/06
  87.   anti-zionism 00:51  |  afzal 21/12/06
 Today Online