Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., December 25, 2006 Tevet 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:40 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:25 19/12/2006
Test Yourself: The Mideast in 10 self-deceptions or less
By Bradley Burston

There's no deception like self-deception.

There's no self-deception like the personal truths we tell ourselves about ourselves, in order to feel better about ourselves.

There's nothing quite like the personal truths - truths we hold to be self-evident - which we tell ourselves about those we sincerely revile. In order to feel better about ourselves.

There's no struggle quite like the one we will put up to preserve our personal truths, our bedrock self-deceptions. As far as we can tell, they keep us safe, keep us happy, keep us focused, keep us ourselves.

If our self-identity is threatened, we will fight as if our very lives depended on it.

This may be applicable whether the identity in question is that of a respected surgeon, a revered cleric, or a devoted football fan.

Which brings us to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Can there be another conflict on God's green earth which in the space of a few generations has generated two entire new cultures, two entire new identities, each at war with the other, each dismissing the validity of the other, the rights of the other, the very authenticity of the identity the other is trying so vigorously to hang onto?

There are those on both sides, propagandists, fanatics, columnists, who insist that their own side is the sole heir to antiquity, the sole claimant to the property and the history of the Holy Land, the sole injured party, the sole heroic player.

They believe it with everything they have.

The best part, of course, is that they tend to believe that anyone who sees things differently is deluded. A victim of self-deception.

In view of this complex reality, how can you know truth from self-deception - Here's a simple self-test that may help:

1. True or False: One side is regularly condemned internationally for war crimes it is alleged to have committed. The other is shielded, left to commit them at will.

2. True or False: One side desecrates holy places. The other respects religious shrines, and the right of all to worship as they choose.

3. True or False: One side can be trusted to observe negotiated peace accords and agreed cease-fires. The other side violates them at will.

4. True or False: One side takes care to abide by the terms of peace agreements and cease-fires, until such time as the other side blatantly violates them.

5. True or False: One side has learned the lessons of the Holocaust. The actions of the other side are reminiscent of those who perpetrated it.

6. True or False: One side has a legitimate historical claim to territory of the Holy Land, being direct descendants of its ancient inhabitants. The claims of the other do not stand up to factual inspection.

7. True or False: One side repeatedly launches attacks which kill innocent civilians. The actions of the other are acts of legitimate self-defense.

8. True or False: One side genuinely seeks peace. The other side truly wants the land on its own terms, and is prepared to continue to kill people on the other side as long as its actual desires are unattained.

9. True or False: News media are over-sympathetic to one side only.

10. True or False: The people who support and speak for the other side are either lying or self-deceived.

HOW TO SCORE: Count 10 points for every "True" answer, none for every "False."

If you scored 0 - 20: Chances are that you still harbor a secret belief in the eventual possibility of peace.

Chances are that you are reluctant, at this point, to reveal this to anyone.

People on both sides are sure to tell you that you are deceiving yourself.

If you scored 30 - 50: Chances are you once harbored a belief in the eventual possibility of peace.

Chances are that you have stopped discussing this with people on the other side.

People on your side will now tell you that you have finally come to your senses.

You are on your way to self-deception.

If you scored 60 - 100: The Israeli-Palestinian conflict makes perfect sense to you.

You are a victim of serious self-deception. Unbeknownst to you.


___________________



Note: After serious consideration of a number of reader comments with respect to the guidelines for talkbacks on "A Special Place in Hell," the guidelines have been modified.

Although some rules have been relaxed, special emphasis will be placed on deleting letters which contain personal attacks on other respondents.

___________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Previous blogs:

  • Jews who make Satan look good
  • Christmas 2006: Is Jesus still a Palestinian?
  • No Palestinians, No Palestine, No Problem
  • Wishing the Palestinians out of existence

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Sanctions fall short
    Despite UN sanctions, Iran's President has all the support for his nuke plan at home.
    Time for change
    Time magazine has declared the end of the age of great people and hero-geniuses.
    <
      1.   deception 18:28  |  Israel Zwick 18/12/06
      2.   I Tested Myself! 18:30  |  Allan 18/12/06
      3.   I scored 0, but there are some conditional answers 18:56  |  Bandar Michaels 18/12/06
      4.   Both sides use similar arguments, but... 19:34  |  Joe 18/12/06
      5.   True or False 19:56  |  Yoel 18/12/06
      6.   Welcome to the Jungle 20:39  |  Matthew Sawtell 18/12/06
      7.   true 21:18  |  emad matahin 18/12/06
      8.   Deception 21:28  |  Ted 18/12/06
      9.   true 21:41  |  zichron 18/12/06
      10.   job 23:46  |  rich 18/12/06
      11.   The questions are proof of success of anti-Israel propaganda 23:48  |  Boris 18/12/06
      12.   irrelevant 23:50  |  Pssd Off American 18/12/06
      13.   I scored a whopping 973 points... 23:55  |  bat yam 18/12/06
      14.   Problems with the scoring 00:42  |  Davids 19/12/06
      15.   Welcome to the jungle 01:07  |  Jack 19/12/06
      16.   I got a negative score !! 01:15  |  heinz 19/12/06
      17.   I scored a 100 01:33  |  Mike Steffen 19/12/06
      18.   Not the first to discuss self identity 02:28  |  Efox 19/12/06
      19.   The Deceived 02:31  |  Efox 19/12/06
      20.   Self-deception or deceiving others? 03:48  |  Brad R 19/12/06
      21.   Burston, you are the most self-deceived of all! 03:57  |  McQueen 19/12/06
      22.   bat yam 04:03  |  dubious 19/12/06
      23.   Bradley forgot a tiny thing 04:22  |  Marilyn 19/12/06
      24.   Straw Men 04:59  |  D B 19/12/06
      25.   I scored 0; no correlaltion to peace beliefs 07:26  |  David Howard 19/12/06
      26.   Bradley:Sing in our chorus or sing solo. 09:11  |  Akram Zekaria 19/12/06
      27.   BETWEEN THE TWO IMPOSSIBLE PEACE 09:18  |  indrajaya 19/12/06
      28.   # 25 David Howard If you can show me one Israeli ...... 09:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
      29.   Missing link discovered in Israel . . . 09:47  |  revoltop 19/12/06
      30.   Fighting continues despite ceasefire 09:51  |  FOX 19/12/06
      31.   Indajayra 27 09:59  |  FOX 19/12/06
      32.   bradley who will decide is the posts come from SANEpeople 10:01  |  paul harris 19/12/06
      33.   #28 THE QUESTIONS ARE LOADED IN FAVOUR OF BRADLEY 10:03  |  paul harris 19/12/06
      34.   Sullivan, Gabe1, Ben Jabo, Clickfool 10:05  |  A pox on both 19/12/06
      35.   Test Yourself 10:08  |  Choni Davidowitz 19/12/06
      36.   exercise in futility 10:15  |  Dror 19/12/06
      37.   BRADLEY I FORGOT WILL YOU EXCLUDE ALL THOS EWHO 10:17  |  paul harris 19/12/06
      38.   POP CULTURE...neon thoughts 10:17  |  FOX 19/12/06
      39.   Why should I believe your scoring system,are you GOD? 10:25  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      40.   Spot on 10:27  |  Helen Jones 19/12/06
      41.   Test Yourself (cont) 10:27  |  Choni Davidowitz 19/12/06
      42.   Thank you 10:38  |  Cord Kaldrack 19/12/06
      43.   I scored really high and still harbor hope-I`m stupid 10:46  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      44.   Indrajaya 10:51  |  Yosemite Sam 19/12/06
      45.   314Davids,you prove Burstons` scoring is lunacy 10:55  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      46.   #15,Jack proves burston`s scoring is lunacy 10:57  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      47.   #25,Ojai,those who score zero are very biased 11:07  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      48.   Bradley Burston 11:15  |  Alasdair Anderson 19/12/06
      49.   Neon Thoughts, Fox #38 11:20  |  Dror 19/12/06
      50.   # 44, YOSEMITE SAM 11:22  |  indrajaya 19/12/06
      51.   # 27 Indrajaya 11:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
      52.   #35Choni,do you think the holocaust was the wrath of God or Goyim 11:33  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      53.   Indrajaya-#44-You`re completely wrong 11:37  |  Daniel Leopold 19/12/06
      54.   #41Choni,Do you know that the Rabbis of the past put God on trial 11:43  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      55.   Indrajaya 11:54  |  Yosemite Sam 19/12/06
      56.   FOX 11:57  |  sh 19/12/06
      57.   #50Indrajaya,liars score zero-you show your true colors-"the only 11:59  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 19/12/06
      58.   # 57 Susanna/Shoshanah 12:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/12/06
      59.   on Choni Davidowitz #35 12:39  |  zeev 19/12/06
      60.   Susanna said so . . . 12:44  |  revoltop 19/12/06
      61.   # 57, SUSANNA/SHOSHANAH 12:52  |  indrajaya 19/12/06
      62.   Einstein and Israel . . . 12:58  |  revoltop 19/12/06
      63.   # 62, REVOLTOP 13:22  |  indrajaya 19/12/06
      64.   Thank you indrajaya 13:31  |  revoltop 19/12/06
      65.   my condolences 13:49  |  a friend 19/12/06
      66.   indraja - get it right 13:49  |  alef 19/12/06
      67.   Stupid Article 14:02  |  Psalm 19/12/06
      68.   #27 Jakarta 14:09  |  SLAVO 19/12/06
      69.   Martin Luther King`s words regarding Zionism 14:09  |  Psalm 19/12/06
      70.   Think about it 11 against 1 we are born to win. 14:47  |  Simon 19/12/06
      71.   both peoples` characters are prone to sophistry 14:47  |  Mohamed Mansour 19/12/06
      72.   Is that you Jacob Blue #34 14:58  |  Gabe1 19/12/06
      73.   and another thing... 15:03  |  Mohamed Mansour 19/12/06
      74.   I Got a D- (60) 15:10  |  Jeff Northridge 19/12/06
      75.   #69 and martin luther king 15:16  |  Mohamed Mansour 19/12/06
      76.   Susanna/Shoshanah # 43 Stupidity 15:34  |  Jeff Northridge 19/12/06
      77.   #2 15:44  |  ODP 19/12/06
      78.   peace 15:50  |  mothandrust 19/12/06
      79.   Author`s self-deception 16:03  |  Gene 19/12/06
      80.   #68, SLAVO 16:11  |  indrajaya 19/12/06
      81.   # 66, ALEF 16:14  |  indrajaya 19/12/06
      82.   indrajaya what is your beef against the white man 16:34  |  australopithicus 19/12/06
      83.   indrajaya does it bother you unduly that 16:37  |  australopithicus 19/12/06
      84.   indrajaya and alef 16:42  |  ODP 19/12/06
      85.   Einstein quote 16:44  |  mothandrust 19/12/06