Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., December 19, 2006 Kislev 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:04 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A truce without a partner is preferable
By Zvi Bar'el

On Friday quite a few Israelis were eating their hearts out: How, they wondered. did they manage not to assassinate [Palestinian Prime Minister] Ismail Haniyeh? Had the Palestinians only aimed a little bit more accurately, it would have been possible to put an end to Israel's real problem. For this is the new panic: Hamas is bringing money from Iran. Now Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad will have a base in the territories and his "deputy," the Hamas people, will act according to his commands.

Why should the Palestinians act according to the commands of Iran, and not on the instructions of Saudi Arabia, which this year sent along tens of millions of dollars, or according to the commands of Qatar, which has committed to paying the salaries of officials of the Palestinian Authority, of which the Hamas is now in charge? Why forget the previous aid from Iran, which only now has come to the fore? Because that's how you build a threat: If you have touched Ahmadinejad, you are Ahmadinejad. Never mind that Turkey does business with Iran, or India, the Israeli aviation industry's client, which is about to purchase billions of dollars worth of gas from Ahmadinejad. But Haniyeh?

Haniyeh would not have had to accept money from Iran if Israel had understood that an economic boycott does not ensure desirable political results and mainly harms an innocent population; if Israel had not pretended that only recognition of the Jewish state was lacking for it to agree to conduct diplomatic talks; and if it had recognized that Hamas won the elections not because the Palestinian people had chosen Allah. But now the tree that Israel climbed is shooting even higher. Keeping money out of the hands of Hamas has become a strategic aim, and blocking the dinars will become a measure of victory, and not a means for changing its policy.

Advertisement

Israel can make this rule, because at the same time, there is a paradox. It turns out that even when the Palestinians are killing one another, the hudna is still in effect. Qassams are still landing on Sderot, but Hamas' commitment is still in force. They are also getting money from Iran, and it is still true that the hudna has not been canceled. And the Israeli is tearing his hair out and wondering: What's going on here?

What is going on is that there is a violent struggle raging for political control. A struggle in which a movement that won elections according to rules of the game set by the Palestinian constitution, America's aspirations and Israel's willingness is being asked to concede to the movement that lost. What is happening is that this movement, Hamas, is even prepared to concede in the domestic political arena, on condition that the concession is reasonable and honorable. If the demand is for Hamas to give up the position of prime minister, at least key portfolios should remain in its hands. Temporarily, it is shelving its radical religious ideology. Perhaps Hamas will pull this out when new elections are held, and it wins again in a big way, and on condition that it is then left to run the Palestinian state.

Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) is not certain that in fact his faction will be elected this time. This is, after all, the same Abbas who once threatened to hold a referendum on the prisoners' document and changed his mind; threatened to fire Haniyeh and changed his mind; and now is threatening early elections, because perhaps this threat will have an effect. It is indeed having an effect, but mostly on Israel.

Herein lies a second paradox. Israel, of course, is "making an extraordinary effort," as the prime minister explained to the German chancellor, to advance the peace process. So extraordinary that it is really paralyzing it. Because what will happen if early elections are indeed held in the PA and Hamas loses? What will be the fate of the hudna? After all, in the absence of a peace process, or confidence-building measures, or at least just the release of prisoners, Abu Mazen will have nothing to talk about with Israel. He will once again be left with agreements that are of no use to him. Worse than that, Hamas will once again be free to use its military veto and cancel the hudna.

It would not be going too far to suspect that in the absence of a desire to conduct real negotiations for peace, Israel's secret aspiration is for Hamas to win again, so again it will not have a partner and again the hudna will be maintained.

According to Israeli-style common sense, the real effort needs to be directed at crushing the recommendations of the Baker-Hamilton report, which has linked the private Israeli-Palestinian peace to a general, American-Iraqi peace. Then life will indeed be wonderful.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Never too late
Many Israeli adults who never learned to ride are discovering the delights of bicycling.
Avirama on the sea
A seaborne voyage becomes unfortunate when seasickness settles in.
  1.   HAMAS = HOLOCAUST = ANTI-SEMITIC 10:13  |  indrajaya 17/12/06
  2.   Why not talk with Hamas? 10:25  |  dana 17/12/06
  3.   LIBERATE GAZA, PUT AN END TO FIGHTING,RESETTLE GAZANS 10:33  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 17/12/06
  4.   Israel is playing with fire 10:39  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/12/06
  5.   Know thine enemy 10:39  |  Elimelech 17/12/06
  6.   The "good guys" are far worse than the "bad guys" 11:16  |  Natallie Durson 17/12/06
  7.   Bara`el`s passionate defense of Hamas Sickening 12:05  |  Shalom Freedman 17/12/06
  8.   Moshiach and ethnic cleansing 12:08  |  Mark 17/12/06
  9.   Some sense being spoken 12:21  |  Keith from UK 17/12/06
  10.   Blodking the pipeline won`t help prevent terror 12:29  |  Tzfonit 17/12/06
  11.   talk with hamas.Of what? 13:02  |  jean marie 17/12/06
  12.   zvi barel on hamas and gideon levy on the supreme court 13:30  |  chalom 17/12/06
  13.   Peace Is Just Not Possible 13:39  |  Terry 17/12/06
  14.   Mark in London 14:08  |  rich 17/12/06
  15.   Without War What is Israel? 14:36  |  Mark Lincoln 17/12/06
  16.   To Dana #2 15:00  |  Stinker 17/12/06
  17.   you finally said it! 15:34  |  John and the truth 17/12/06
  18.   THE ONLY DIFFERENCE BETWEEN FATAH AND HAMAS TERRORISTS 15:39  |  Yishai Kohen 17/12/06
  19.   MARK-UK, ETHNIC CLEANSING COMMITED BY SHARON AGAINST JEWS IN GAZA 15:52  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH 17/12/06
  20.   13 & 15 16:08  |  Dan 17/12/06
  21.   #13, Terry 16:45  |  naja 17/12/06
  22.   #9 KEITH AND A TOTAL LACK OF HISTORY AND KNOWLEDGE 17:03  |  paul harris 17/12/06
  23.   Actually the arabs were there first 17:23  |  Marilyn 17/12/06
  24.   Answer to Marilyn. 18:43  |  David Nigel Braham 17/12/06
  25.   To Dana #2 19:06  |  Rudolph 17/12/06
  26.   #6 Mrs Durson 19:15  |  Rudolph 17/12/06
  27.   Israel Wants Hamas in Power 19:21  |  Wiseone 17/12/06
  28.   Without War What is Israel? 19:24  |  Bruce 17/12/06
  29.   Mariyln 23 19:27  |  Rudolph 17/12/06
  30.   #23 MARYLIN GOES EVER THE EDGE 19:34  |  paul harris 17/12/06
  31.   Missing an important fact 20:07  |  Nathaniel 17/12/06
  32.   win again???? 20:28  |  Joe 17/12/06
  33.   To #2 - Relative Machiavellianism 21:06  |  Amitai Blickstein 17/12/06
  34.   #24, check your history 21:08  |  jenna 17/12/06
  35.   right 21:19  |  wh 17/12/06
  36.   the only solution is to liquidate reactionary zionism 21:39  |  Sam (UK) 17/12/06
  37.   #36 THE REAL SOLUTION TELL SAM TO STOP WRITING 22:14  |  paul harris 17/12/06
  38.   Truce without partner 22:19  |  Keith from UK 17/12/06
  39.   sure just a secretly do not want my garbage picked up so i can ye 22:49  |  ralph 17/12/06
  40.   BRACHA/TSFONIT#10 23:53  |  GABE1 17/12/06
  41.   To # 24 David Nigel Braham : Judaism been around for 5.766 years? 00:24  |  Yankelowitz 18/12/06
  42.   #2 dreamon 01:11  |  samuel 18/12/06
  43.   #38 Keith Reality check? 01:29  |  shmuel 18/12/06
  44.   Israel`s preference has nothing to do with it. 01:55  |  Voice of Reason 18/12/06
  45.   #41 HEY YANKELE YOUR E GOOD TELL ME 02:03  |  paul harris 18/12/06
  46.   # 26 You Are Wasting Your Time 04:08  |  Tony Anthony 18/12/06
  47.   Marilyn ur knowledge of history n that area 07:54  |  Anubhav 18/12/06
  48.   Barel - Such Intellectual Dishonesty ! 08:13  |  Tod Zuckerman 18/12/06
  49.   Zvi`s recommendations... 08:14  |  sandra chitayat 18/12/06
  50.   Response #13 from Eilat 08:22  |  sandra chitayat 18/12/06
  51.   rudolph - Check your history. 08:24  |  Canadian 18/12/06
  52.   rudolph - Check your history. 08:25  |  Canadian 18/12/06
  53.   Fatah will deafeat Hamas militarily. 09:37  |  Devin 18/12/06
  54.   Chat with Hamas 10:45  |  Tom Spender 18/12/06
  55.   Some idiot says 10:59  |  Jasmine Murphy 18/12/06
  56.   Natalie 11:07  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 18/12/06
  57.   naja 11:10  |  freda 18/12/06
  58.   Total gibberish - Israel wants Hamas - the proof please! 17:46  |  sheri 18/12/06
  59.   $53 - Devin - most Palest back Fatah? 17:54  |  sheri 18/12/06
  60.   To # 45 Paul Harris : NO Bible story 06:00  |  Yankelowitz 19/12/06
  61.   #34 Jenna - what do you think jews are if not semitic 06:33  |  sheri 19/12/06
 Today Online
PM: Will set up joint panel to discuss issue of prisoners
Responses: 169
Hamas frees abducted former minister Abu Zaida
Responses: 134
Editorial: Jerusalem must enter talks with Damascus
Responses: 106
Danny Rubinstein: Hamas readier for civil war than Fatah
Responses: 55


More Headlines
06:31 Israeli official: We have time to block Iran nuclear program
23:38 Fatah and Hamas trade fire in Gaza, despite truce
06:54 Interior Min. plans to develop area along Syrian border
01:42 IDF probe of Gaza pullout: Few refused orders, disciplined lightly
02:03 Rights groups reject travel ban on West Bank hitchhikers
00:50 U.S. Senators to PM: Don't be tempted by Syrian talks offers
03:01 Coalition begins to crack, Labor calls for Lieberman ousting
00:38 Halutz okays most Almog panel proposals, rejects Hirsch appeal
04:30 Study: Blair failed because of inability to influence Washington
22:19 Panel slams inclusion of pre-1967 borders in school maps
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Yad Ezra VeShulamit
This Chanukah gift the gift of a hot meal to a Jewish child
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved