Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 17, 2006 Kislev 26, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:19 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Too big for them
By Yoel Marcus

The more our leaders err, the more we suffer. Upon reading the headlines about the failures and blunders in the Lebanon war, the unaviodable conclusion is that the tasks were too big for our leaders. There is the prime minister, whose slips of tongue precede him, whether regarding nuclear ambiguity or the abductees, and whether they are alive or dead. And there are the disgraceful reports about the Israel Defense Forces - about a chief of staff who erred in his relations with senior officers, generals who did not act properly and flaws in the command positions. About medications that had expired, tanks that were below standard and maps that were not current. As the investigators put it: "We couldn't turn over a single stone without finding serious rot under it."

And this is before we receive the Winograd report, which is liable to lob the bomb of comprehensive responsibility at the government and the army. There is already talk of the next war, of the danger of a Shi'ite Tehran-Beirut-Damascus axis and Hamas in Gaza, which may try to implement Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's vision for the annihilation of Israel.

Instead of a short burst of punishment, bee-style - going in, stinging and getting out - the government started an all-out war, which exposed our weakness on the home front in the face of the staunchness of Hezbollah. During the next war, its rockets will be much heavier and more accurate. A leader who can bring millions of demonstrators into Beirut's streets with one phone call is proving anew that the magical power of Israel's leaders has not expired: Every time we strike at Lebanon, Hezbollah gets stronger.

Advertisement

Now some intelligence sources are predicting a large attack next summer. In this confusion, the concerned citizen should adopt the more pessimistic forecast, and should rightly ask himself whom to believe. Will the bleak predictions prove true? In light of the laxness and carelessness we have now experienced, can we rely on the IDF and the government?

Winston Churchill conducted the Battle of Britain with a small cabinet of five ministers - a wise, collective civilian mind that dictated the moves of the army. Churchill predicted the war years in advance, and at no stage did he accept the dictates of the generals and their plans as Moses' Torah from Sinai. Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who came into power by chance, had no clue about military matters. He was captivated by the charms of Chief of Staff Dan Halutz, who day by day proves he is charmed mainly by himself. Olmert did not ask the right questions. A local politico for most of his life, he did not ask whether it was possible to carry out a campaign like this with a snap of the finger, and only from the air. Did he know in advance that for 33 days, Hezbollah would fire about 200 rockets daily as far south as Hadera?

Olmert is in love with himself as a speechmaker, especially abroad. He hurt our friend the United States twice - first by attacking the Baker-Hamilton report, which calls for an end to the Israeli occupation as part of a solution in Iraq, and then by embarrassing both Israel and America in revealing that nuclear ambiguity was only a maneuver. He also erred in appointing Amir Peretz defense minister so that his pal Abraham Hirchson would become finance minister. This appointment, as Talleyrand said, was worse than a crime; it was stupid. Peretz, a buffoon of a local politico, is now fighting like a lion to maintain the leadership of the Labor Party. With self-esteem that knows no bounds, he still believes he will be elected prime minister. In the meantime, Olmert does not dare dismiss him for his failure as defense minister, lest the Labor Party leave with him.

Halutz will no doubt be compelled to resign, as in the saying, "When three people tell you you're drunk, lie down." Olmert is the only one whose party cannot depose him. This is because Kadima is not really a party with orderly arrangements for deposing. And thus, the country is stuck with a leadership that has bottomed out in the polls. Only an external threat, like renewed terror or a third intifada, will impel it toward elections or a political reshuffle. The public will not agree to suffer for long.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
He cast a giant shadow
Modern Hebrew writing is deeply rooted in earlier literature, especially Agnon's.
Work space to my place
If one spends hours a day at work, one way to feel at home is to jazz up the work cubicle.
  1.   HIS MOUTH IS TOO BIG (SORRY TO SAY) 11:19  |  indrajaya 15/12/06
  2.   Dont understand why all the world says... 11:32  |  German 15/12/06
  3.   # 2, GERMAN 11:55  |  indrajaya 15/12/06
  4.   Rather, our "leaders" are not fit to BE leaders! 11:58  |  Yaakov K. 15/12/06
  5.   Yoel Marcus, please excuse me 12:21  |  Winner 15/12/06
  6.   #2, German 12:24  |  Winner 15/12/06
  7.   INDRAJAYA IN A PICKLE AND SHOULD STAY PICKLED 12:32  |  paul harris 15/12/06
  8.   WHAT LEADERS ??? CAREER POLITICIANS CERTAINLY 12:37  |  paul harris 15/12/06
  9.   Guess what 16:08  |  Asher 15/12/06
  10.   Olmert 16:46  |  Californian 15/12/06
  11.   The Price of Serial Incompetence 16:49  |  Mark Lincoln 15/12/06
  12.   Churchill 16:53  |  michael cohen 15/12/06
  13.   IF THE ARAB WORLD CAN`T DEMONSTRATE UNITY, IS IT OLMERT`S FAULT? 16:59  |  Smadar 15/12/06
  14.   indrajaya 17:11  |  ODP 15/12/06
  15.   Israeli leaders 17:38  |  Avner 15/12/06
  16.   the leopard and his spots 18:16  |  saul a. readner 15/12/06
  17.   Never at a Worse Time 18:32  |  Tzfonit 15/12/06
  18.   IF THE ARAB WORLD CAN`T DEMONSTRATE UNITY, IS IT OLMERT`S FAULT? 19:09  |  Smadar 15/12/06
  19.   the leopard and his spots 19:13  |  saul a. readner 15/12/06
  20.   to TZFONIT 19:36  |  Jacob 15/12/06
  21.   "Haaretz" the last and only asylum for confused olding Y.Marcus 21:19  |  Absolute Sweden 15/12/06
  22.   To Indrajaya 22:05  |  Otto Rand 15/12/06
  23.   to absolute sweden 22:28  |  saul a. readner 15/12/06
  24.   # 18, Yes, To be Pro-Baker is Suicidal 22:47  |  Tod Zuckerman 15/12/06
  25.   Jews must be portrayed as victims 23:48  |  BradL 15/12/06
  26.   16 Smadar - Comprehensive Peace? 01:31  |  Davids 16/12/06
  27.   Yoel Marcus, Why cry over spilled milk? 01:35  |  Dutch 16/12/06
  28.   Mistakes! Bulls..t!! 02:15  |  Fritz 16/12/06
  29.   # 28 Wrapped up In Our Own Myths 05:32  |  Tony Anthony 16/12/06
  30.   # 14, ODP 06:17  |  indrajaya 16/12/06
  31.   #26 Davids, No one took Unilateral Disengagement Seriously 08:20  |  Smadar 16/12/06
  32.   ODP, Indrajaya, & Jacob 09:29  |  Tzfonit 16/12/06
  33.   #12 CHURCHILLS BLINDERS EXTEND BACK TO WW1 10:46  |  paul harris 16/12/06
  34.   # 17 Tzfibut...your wake up call, appreciated 11:22  |  kameel 16/12/06
  35.   #2German No, No, No. 15:52  |  Maureen Ann 16/12/06
  36.   #27 at last dutch DORIS makes acase for muslim women 16:59  |  paul harris 16/12/06
  37.   To Indrajaya 19:01  |  Zak Lamont 16/12/06
  38.   #12 Michael, Let`s have another book on Chamberlain 19:15  |  Dutch 16/12/06
  39.   What was well done... 19:17  |  Zak Lamont 16/12/06
  40.   #2 FORGET THE SPIN; BAKER SAYS ISRAEL HAS NUKES 19:26  |  ballistic 16/12/06
  41.   # 32, TZFONIT 08:46  |  indrajaya 17/12/06
 Today Online
Hamas: Elections bid is 'defeat, submission to the Zionist enemy'
Responses: 215
Bradley Burston: Jews who make Satan look good
Responses: 296
Ze'ev Sternhell: The Green Line is the border
Responses: 205
Iran: Olmert's nuclear comments are sign of Israel's weakness
Responses: 235
Ultra-Orthodox Shabbat boycott hits El Al in the pocket
Responses: 124


More Headlines
08:39 Gunmen storm base of Abbas' guard, kill officer
09:08 PM aides to cabinet ministers: Maintain silence on PA feuding
07:22 PM Olmert rejects Syrian overtures for peace talks
06:17 Military officers: War probes will force Halutz to resign
04:35 40 institutes boycott Iran think tank over Holocaust conference
04:43 ANALYSIS: Abbas prepares for battle - one of these days
05:03 Early results show Ahmadinejad's opponents leading vote
01:48 Soccer match canceled after three players admit taking bribes
02:34 Islamic Movement sheikhs slam theories of Holocaust denial
06:21 'First Lady of piano' Pnina Salzman dies at 84
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Yad Ezra VeShulamit
This Chanukah gift the gift of a hot meal to a Jewish child
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Menorahs by Judaica Mall
Great selection of Hanukkah gifts
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved