Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., January 07, 2007 Tevet 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:46 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
On the verge
By Ari Shavit

A man likely to enter the White House in January 2009 analyzed the new situation in the Middle East earlier this week in Washington. The promising candidate for the presidency exhibited knowledge, intelligence and conviction. He described in minute detail the various aspects of the American failure in Iraq and listed the mistakes of the Bush administration, along with its weaknesses. However, when he was asked about the urgent issue of Iran, he had very little of substance to say. It's too late, he said. Perhaps it's much too late.

This is the way the wind is blowing on the Potomac. The Democrats are rejoicing over the fall of their foes, and the Republicans are licking their wounds. The realists - the opponents of democratization - are invading the city with Baker-Hamilton in the lead, while the neo-conservatives are preparing to fend them off in a holding action. However, both are up to their necks in Iraq. Neither are able to pay any sort of attention to any issue that is not Iraq. The Americans are well aware that Iran is there. They know full well that its time has come. However, following 45 months of fiasco on the Tigris, they have no emotional, nor intellectual, strength left for dealing with Iran. The superpower of the 20th century is bleeding, battered and bruised. It is approaching the moment of truth on Iran without determination or willpower; without leadership or vision.

This is also the case in Israel. Since the summer of 2002, Israel has known what stands before it. For more than four years Israel has known that it is faced with the greatest existential challenge since May 1948. However, for a long time now, Israel has been unable to come to its senses. At first it knew about Iran, but did not comprehend. Then came comprehension, but it did not act. In the end it took action, but failed. And, instead of taking advantage of the disengagement as a way of rallying the world against Iran, it continued on its trip from disengagement to convergence.

Advertisement

Just like the Americans, who for the past four years have wasted their enormous national resources on a baseless belief in democratization in Iraq, Israel wasted its limited national resources on a baseless belief in the unilateral withdrawal from the Palestinian Authority. Like the great democracy on the Potomac, so the little democracy in Givat Ram faces the moment of truth with Iran, lacking determination and willpower; without leadership or vision.

It is not too late. It is late, very late, but not too late. By chance, or perhaps not, Iran is facing certain technical difficulties. Over and over, its efforts to enrich uranium are being delayed. This allows the failing decision makers in Jerusalem and Washington to correct their errors. They still have the rare privilege of a second chance.

However, this second chance is also the final one. If in the coming months Israel and the United States fail to rally the West in taking immediate dramatic diplomatic action - the only choice they will be left with is unacceptable: either attack or come to terms with it, a bad choice and a terrible one.

It is not yet too late. Iran has two souls - the mosque and the bazaar. The great failure of the West in recent years lies in the fact that it did not make the Persian bazaar pay for the craziness of the Shi'ite mosque. To date the Iranian public has not been presented with a dilemma. It has not had to pay the cost of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's uranium adventure.

This must be changed immediately. Instead of an Israeli-American dilemma (to attack or not to attack), the dilemma must become an Iranian one (to have nukes and become poor, or to give up on nukes and become wealthy). However, in order to impose such a dilemma on the Iranians, it is necessary to rally the West in an unprecedented way. This is the sort of effort that neither the battered President George W. Bush nor the vacuous Ehud Olmert can lead.

Olmert's slip of the tongue over Israel's nuclear arms is just the tip of the iceberg. The prime minister has been conducting a wanton policy since he came to power. However, at this critical moment, the time is not right for settling scores. If Olmert can overcome himself and set up an emergency cabinet that can lead the strategic campaign he himself is unable to lead, he will stay in his post. If he does not do this - he should step down immediately. When the United States is confused and at a loss for options, Israel must be at its best. Every additional minute the current government exists endangers its raison d'etre.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A wannabe grandma
What will I do if my kids persevere in their refusal to supply me with a grandchild?
The blog of Dan H.
Halutz remains locked on the target even without knowing what the target is.
  1.   BOMB THEM NOW, BOMB THEM HARD 09:44  |  Philly Jew 14/12/06
  2.   All this wretched paranoia 09:57  |  Marilyn 14/12/06
  3.   Start a war in order to avoid a war? What a joke 10:02  |  Natallie Durson 14/12/06
  4.   Israel is out of control 10:44  |  Matthew Whiting 14/12/06
  5.   #1 Philly Jew 11:00  |  Johnboy 14/12/06
  6.   N.DURSON The Arabs have been starting wars of annihilation 11:02  |  Peter S.M. 14/12/06
  7.   MARYLIN how many times do Hamas,Irans boys,have to say NEVER 11:05  |  PETER SM 14/12/06
  8.   What does this idiot suggest??? 11:06  |  Wise Syrian 14/12/06
  9.   I am just dying to see the outcome of this 11:12  |  Guy From NYC 14/12/06
  10.   Can`t take Marilyn or Natalie Seriously Anymore 11:14  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 14/12/06
  11.   Learn to live with the bomb 11:24  |  spyguy 14/12/06
  12.   #1 - are you prepared to die for Israel? 11:31  |  spyguy 14/12/06
  13.   My Dear Friends... Just count the bodies 11:38  |  Natallie Durson 14/12/06
  14.   The United States will not attack Iran 11:38  |  Chris Linthwaite 14/12/06
  15.   Olmert`s slip of the tongue 11:47  |  sh 14/12/06
  16.   The US NEEDS Iranian cooperation in Iraq 12:24  |  Isratinian 14/12/06
  17.   Is the west making Israel pay for the Settler Enterprise? 14:05  |  John 14/12/06
  18.   THe Bazaar or the Nuke 14:18  |  BenAbuzaglo 14/12/06
  19.   #JOHN AND MEMORIES OF SETTLERS IN 14:22  |  paul harris 14/12/06
  20.   HOW ABOUT MAKING ISRAEL PAY... FOR ONCE? 14:45  |  Jeremy 14/12/06
  21.   Who cares WHAT you think? 14:59  |  William 14/12/06
  22.   West has to make Iran pay............. 15:01  |  tbora 14/12/06
  23.   nazionist dr strangelove 15:02  |  john and the truth 14/12/06
  24.   Learn to love the bomb 15:52  |  Stephen Murray 14/12/06
  25.   #1 PARANOID LITTLE COUNTRY 15:59  |  ballistic 14/12/06
  26.   #6 NO WAR WITH IRAN 16:02  |  ballistic 14/12/06
  27.   Natalie Durson 16:18  |  ODP 14/12/06
  28.   Who is the West? 16:41  |  leopold 14/12/06
  29.   Drums of War and Existential Threats 17:13  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  30.   #16 17:16  |  matt 14/12/06
  31.   #24/25 BALLISTIC AFFECTED BY NUCLEAR TESTS IN NEVADA 17:34  |  paul harris 14/12/06
  32.   In defense of Natalie Durson 17:35  |  Wise Syrian 14/12/06
  33.   re: Marilyn #2 17:35  |  Desmond 14/12/06
  34.   #20 JEREMY HAS THE EAR AND CONFIDENC EOF THE AYATOLLAHS . 17:37  |  paul harris 14/12/06
  35.   weak, shortsighted commentators 17:41  |  David 14/12/06
  36.   #18,That will be a tall order for even Moshe 17:43  |  Wise Syrian 14/12/06
  37.   Little people can be the most dangerous... 17:50  |  Desmond 14/12/06
  38.   Natalie, for Israel there is no such thing as state terrorism 18:07  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  39.   Desmond, you mean Israel being bullied by Israel? #35 18:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  40.   To hell???/ 18:27  |  Joe 14/12/06
  41.   Is anyone in Israel, or any non-leftist Jew anywhere, ... 18:37  |  Yaakov K. 14/12/06
  42.   #14: Too RIGHT! The US wants ISRAEL to do ITS dirty wwork for it! 18:39  |  Yaakov K. 14/12/06
  43.   Linthwaite and the genocide fabrication #14 18:46  |  Jonathan S 14/12/06
  44.   NO they don`t 18:51  |  margaret 14/12/06
  45.   Not the West, only President Bush can 19:09  |  Jonathan S 14/12/06
  46.   Jonathan in franfkurt on sabra and shatila $43 19:20  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  47.   Is Israel part of the West? 19:25  |  Andreas 14/12/06
  48.   #43 Jonathan S 19:32  |  Chris Linthwaite 14/12/06
  49.   #13, Durson 19:34  |  Winner 14/12/06
  50.   Yaakov 19:35  |  ODP 14/12/06
  51.   re: Yaakov K. 19:36  |  Desmond 14/12/06
  52.   #1 Philly Jew don`t vouch for me and my friends! 19:47  |  T A Sheppard 14/12/06
  53.   The way for Israel to deal with Iran 19:59  |  Tosefta 14/12/06
  54.   "Mahmoud Ahmadinejad`s uranium adventure"? 20:01  |  Sakura-1 14/12/06
  55.   To Sullivan and Linthwaite #46,48 20:12  |  Jonathan S 14/12/06
  56.   " or to give up on nukes and become wealthy" 20:28  |  Iranian-American 14/12/06
  57.   Chris 20:37  |  ODP 14/12/06
  58.   Limits of the power of "the lobby" 20:40  |  Iranian-American 14/12/06
  59.   ODP on targeted assasinations or arrrests #50 21:28  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  60.   The West has to do WHAT? 21:37  |  Axel 14/12/06
  61.   natalie "for yaakov" there is no such thing as.. 21:39  |  Danite 14/12/06
  62.   Stop Double Standards 21:50  |  Al 14/12/06
  63.   Desmond on threats from Iran #51 21:59  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  64.   Johnathan S # 55 22:05  |  William 14/12/06
  65.   Jonathan in Germany on Sabra Chatila #55 22:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  66.   Not quite the case, Natalie. Danite distorts #61 22:12  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  67.   Unfortunately, Johnboy is right 22:26  |  Jake 14/12/06
  68.   NATALIE IS RIGHT 22:31  |  Nathan 14/12/06
  69.   for #5, JohnBoy in Sydney 22:33  |  Gullible Cynic 14/12/06
  70.   Yaakov Sullivan, no, not really 22:45  |  Jake 14/12/06
  71.   Axel , wrong on 2 scores 22:58  |  Jake 14/12/06
  72.   Israel has 200 nukes? 23:01  |  Jake 14/12/06
  73.   To Sullivan about the truth 23:13  |  Jonathan S 14/12/06
  74.   Israel out of control 23:17  |  larry 14/12/06
  75.   Glaring Omission? 23:20  |  Beatrix 14/12/06
  76.   Glaring Omission? 23:20  |  Beatrix 14/12/06
  77.   to Joe,re#40."To Hell" 23:20  |  jeff atkinson 14/12/06
  78.   No, Johnboy is wrong. 23:33  |  jeff atkinson 14/12/06
  79.   # 71 Jake 23:42  |  Axel 14/12/06
  80.   Jake, take it or leave it #70 23:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/12/06
  81.   # 72 Jake 23:46  |  Axel 14/12/06
  82.   Jake 00:05  |  Axel 15/12/06
  83.   Iran Problem 00:33  |  John Campo 15/12/06
  84.   Israel is a greater threat than Iran 00:54  |  Mr. Knowitall 15/12/06
  85.   JOHNBOY the ultimate weapon. 01:51  |  PETER SM 15/12/06
  86.   GUY from NY.Dying? Iran may see to it.They owe you for many years 01:59  |  PETER SM 15/12/06
  87.   Iran`s Nukes 02:03  |  Jim 15/12/06