Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 14, 2006 Kislev 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:33 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 01:42 12/12/2006
Israeli official 'not sorry' Tutu's probe into Beit Hanun strike canceled
By Haaretz Staff and Agencies

Israeli diplomatic sources said Monday night they were not sorry that the United Nations' fact-finding mission to investigate Israeli-Palestinian violence in Beit Hanun was canceled.

The mission, headed by Nobel laureate and former Cape Town archbishop Desmond Tutu, came to investigate the killing of 19 Palestinian civilians in Beit Hanun at the beginning of November.

The sources said that the six-member delegation was "one-sided and cynical."

Advertisement

Earlier, Tutu said Israel refused to let him enter the Gaza Strip and was also preventing his entrance to Israel. "We find the lack of cooperation by the Israeli government very distressing," Tutu told reporters.

The sources said Israel wanted the mission members to enter as tourists, probably because a tourist status would not oblige Israel to recognize the mission's work. The UN, however, insisted they come as diplomats, that is, as representatives of the UN. The sources said negotiations were still in progress.

The mission was due to set out for the Middle East at the end of last week and report its findings by mid-month to the UN Human Rights Council.

Tutu said Monday that he has been trying to obtain an entrance permit both to Israel and the Gaza Strip for 10 days and that the delay may make the investigation impossible.

"We canceled important commitments to make ourselves available for this task," Tutu said, adding that he had left the bedside of his wife, who was in a hospital.

Christine Chinkin, a law professor at the London School of Economics, said she and other members of the team had hoped to meet with Israeli authorities and therefore decided against entering Gaza through Egypt.

"That would be one-sided. It would not give us the full picture. It would also look as though we were going in the back door," she said. "It was in no way at all a one-sided mission."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The art and war
Suzanne Landau is the second woman to be chosen to curate Israel's pavilion in Venice.
Seniority on the job
Despite living longer, healthier lives, new laws are forcing Israelis to leave the workforce.
  1.   Tutu`s got nothing better to do 01:48  |  rich 12/12/06
  2.   tutu 01:49  |  av 12/12/06
  3.   One-sided mission. 02:23  |  Gary 12/12/06
  4.   Investigating the Deaths of Baha Baaloushe`s Sons? 02:29  |  Dr. Barry 12/12/06
  5.   TUTU had already announced his opinion before he left S.A 02:29  |  PETER. S.M 12/12/06
  6.   Desmond Tutu 02:33  |  Rabbi Y Lazaros 12/12/06
  7.   archbishop tutu 02:41  |  bob 12/12/06
  8.   APARTEID ISRAEL # 1 & 2 02:44  |  wally 12/12/06
  9.   TuTu 02:54  |  jean jaures 12/12/06
  10.   Tutu should attend Iran Holocaust conference.... 02:56  |  Bernard Ross 12/12/06
  11.   Wallyworld 03:29  |  Yariv 12/12/06
  12.   Tutu - Hot Balloon 03:36  |  Ami 12/12/06
  13.   Tutu:An Anti-Semite? 04:01  |  Fred Bainhauer 12/12/06
  14.   What would be enough evidence for Israel? 04:11  |  John from Canada 12/12/06
  15.   Tutu too 04:15  |  david 12/12/06
  16.   Bishop Tutu 04:20  |  tzvi 12/12/06
  17.   Tutu Had Already Reached His Decision 04:52  |  observer 12/12/06
  18.   Answer to #11-How much evidence---None!!! 05:15  |  ballistic 12/12/06
  19.   #11 05:20  |  Alex 12/12/06
  20.   #8 THEY WOULD MALIGN GOD IF HE WENT TO INVESTIGATE 05:22  |  ballistic 12/12/06
  21.   Your logic 05:33  |  Anguillilo 12/12/06
  22.   UN mission to Beit Hanun 05:46  |  NE 12/12/06
  23.   Tutu 05:51  |  Joseph 12/12/06
  24.   To John #11 05:53  |  NE 12/12/06
  25.   Why is anyone surprised... 06:12  |  Peter 12/12/06
  26.   It would have been better 07:02  |  Rose 12/12/06
  27.   to Peter #20 07:19  |  Ben 12/12/06
  28.   Why is Peter Surprised? 07:28  |  Dan 12/12/06
  29.   #1 Thinks that Israel has just started blocking people coming in 07:38  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  30.   To NE #19 - FINALLY a sensible response 07:41  |  John from Canada 12/12/06
  31.   Israel puts Palestinians in big birds cage 07:41  |  Abu Samra 12/12/06
  32.   #Ben asks peter a question 07:48  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  33.   To NE #19 - Continued 07:53  |  John from Canada 12/12/06
  34.   #18 what does that have to do with the price of tea in China 08:00  |  ballistic 12/12/06
  35.   to Ben #25 08:04  |  david 12/12/06
  36.   # 9 Yaariv 08:16  |  wally 12/12/06
  37.   Finally, Israel did something right. 08:30  |  BradL 12/12/06
  38.   Bishop Tutu`s Probe 08:46  |  J of Hollywood 12/12/06
  39.   Tutu 09:08  |  David 12/12/06
  40.   #20 WHICH GOD IS THAT BALLS# ALLAH WAS WITH TUTU 09:30  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  41.   #31 PEACE AT LAST ABU , AND YOU TOLD US WHY 09:35  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  42.   Villains never want their crimes to be investigated 10:20  |  Clickfool 12/12/06
  43.   Israel - Human Rights council/Tutu 1 - 2 10:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/12/06
  44.   THANKS HAARETZ FOR PUBLISH THIS 10:39  |  indrajaya 12/12/06
  45.   What are we afraid of? 10:56  |  JW 12/12/06
  46.   A pronouncemen of guilt before an investigation is a star chamber 11:13  |  PETER SM 12/12/06
  47.   HARIRI VS BEIT HANUN (2nd ATTEMP) 11:13  |  indrajaya 12/12/06
  48.   tutu objectivity 11:24  |  tzvi 12/12/06
  49.   THANK GOD 11:59  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 12/12/06
  50.   No one should be sorry about it 12:16  |  Jonathan S 12/12/06
  51.   Israel is nowadays a pure joke 12:23  |  Petteri 12/12/06
  52.   To20, 44 Indrijaya. Compare what must be compared 12:42  |  Altalena 12/12/06
  53.   standard way of undermining criticism 13:04  |  tuairimiocht 12/12/06
  54.   "When Hariri been killed" Indrajaya 13:18  |  Hussein Abdul 12/12/06
  55.   Tutu / UNO don`t need a fact finding mission to blame Israel 13:21  |  Paul Henzen 12/12/06
  56.   #46 PETER SM and a refusal to allow an outside investigation... 13:28  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  57.   #50 Jonathan S - you zionists so love to cling to Darfur 13:36  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  58.   # 54, HUSSEIN ABDUL 13:53  |  indrajaya 12/12/06
  59.   To 56 Johnboy. Investigation & propaganda 13:54  |  Altalena 12/12/06
  60.   # 57 Johnboy, so why did UNO bother about Apartheid ? 13:59  |  Paul Henzen 12/12/06
  61.   Waste of time anyway 14:15  |  Jy praat twak 12/12/06
  62.   Wally 14:30  |  Yariv 12/12/06
  63.   Bishop Tutu Can Stay Home For My Part 14:45  |  Johnny Weintraub 12/12/06
  64.   #56 JOHNBOY I PROPOSE DERSHOWITZ &FOXMAN TO LEAD THE INVESTIGATIO 15:10  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  65.   Wally in Oz 15:14  |  rich 12/12/06
  66.   Yellow streak running down Israel`s back 15:27  |  Tim 12/12/06
  67.   to new readers of Ha`aretz 15:41  |  flimflam 12/12/06
  68.   Indrajaya bad bad 15:42  |  Abubakr 12/12/06
  69.   TUTU THE CLOWN 15:46  |  JOHN FROM INDONESIA 12/12/06
  70.   Wally, #8 16:04  |  JES 12/12/06
  71.   Desmond Tutu. 16:09  |  David Nigel Braham 12/12/06
  72.   #59 Altalena - Invetiagation/Propoganda 16:10  |  tbora 12/12/06
  73.   One leads to 2, Dino 16:13  |  Jacob Blues 12/12/06
  74.   We`re tired of Tutu`s bigotry 16:15  |  David Teich 12/12/06
  75.   Tim#66 16:15  |  Yariv 12/12/06
  76.   60: No Paul, Sudan didn`t. Nobody did. However... 16:24  |  David Teich 12/12/06
  77.   57: Poor JB, ethics & facts don`t matter to him. p1 16:39  |  David Teich 12/12/06
  78.   Lesson to the World 16:40  |  Tosefta 12/12/06
  79.   57: Poor JB, ethics & facts don`t matter to him. p2 16:42  |  David Teich 12/12/06
  80.   Don`t lose much words. Simply introduce visa regime for Israelis. 17:12  |  Andreas 12/12/06
  81.   REMEMBER JENIN !! 17:15  |  David James Vickery 12/12/06
  82.   # 67, 68 Tutu a clown,, Tutu a bigot 17:17  |  tbora 12/12/06
  83.   Parents of Thomas Hurndell knew how to bring the IDF to account 17:18  |  Nick Ferriman 12/12/06
  84.   TuTu is so disappointed 17:26  |  Bimmer 12/12/06
  85.   #6 Rabbi Y Lazaros 17:45  |  Boycott 12/12/06
  86.   To 71. Tosefta, You are a man of c onscience 17:58  |  Altalena 12/12/06
  87.   Tutu and His Big Paddle 18:15  |  Tony Anthony 12/12/06
  88.   #77 AND TELL IT TO THE RELATIVES OF THE DEAD DOCTORS 18:20  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  89.   # 70 Jacob Blues 18:23  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/12/06
  90.   Jacob Blues On Compassion 18:25  |  Gabe1/Hanem5 12/12/06
  91.   # 60 Paul Henzen. If the UN can`t get them may be the ICC can 18:27  |  Nick Ferriman 12/12/06
  92.   # 79 Andreas, I agree ! 18:27  |  Paul Henzen 12/12/06
  93.   Daoud Youssef Vickery 18:30  |  Gabe 1 12/12/06
  94.   Sorry? Excuse me? 18:32  |  Haaretz fan 12/12/06
  95.   #81 Remember Jenin 18:45  |  Yariv 12/12/06
  96.   TUTU ? IT IS NOT REALITY 18:52  |  myron 12/12/06
  97.   #88 this is intende for david james VICKERY AT 81 18:55  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  98.   #83 NICK AND THE LAW A LONDON COURT 19:02  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  99.   Tosefta 19:03  |  Gina 12/12/06
  100.   Jacob Blue Wannabee 19:08  |  Gbae1/Hanem5 12/12/06
  101.   Tuto has exposed the lies 19:10  |  Yossi Mahran 12/12/06
  102.   Tutu doesnt need to look into the matter to know 19:17  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  103.   The UN is as illegitimate organization 19:22  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  104.   Tutu should better have stayed with his wife 19:26  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  105.   To 72. Tbora in Karachi. Good answers 19:36  |  Altalena 12/12/06
  106.   What can be expected from a man who justifies jihad on the West? 19:36  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  107.   Gina #99 19:44  |  Tosefta 12/12/06
  108.   Tu tu much! 19:55  |  Gerard 12/12/06
  109.   # 99 Gina 20:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 12/12/06
  110.   Tim 20:06  |  Jasmine Murphy 12/12/06
  111.   flimflam 20:08  |  Jy praat twak 12/12/06
  112.   Not wise for Israel to give tacit proof 20:14  |  Mark Lincoln 12/12/06
  113.   Tutu criticises roadblocks and ignores suicide bombings 20:19  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  114.   #103: The creation of Israel was not legetimate then... 20:22  |  cc 12/12/06
  115.   Gabe, have the grapes to say it in public 20:41  |  Jacob Blues 12/12/06
  116.   tutu 20:43  |  les 12/12/06
  117.   now lets see him go to darfur. but he won`t because he knows his 21:02  |  ralph 12/12/06
  118.   What Else Could Possibly Be Expected?? 21:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 12/12/06
  119.   To Andreas from Basel 21:20  |  christa 12/12/06
  120.   Tutu`s complaint 21:24  |  Briton 12/12/06
  121.   Jacob Blue#115 21:31  |  Gabe1 12/12/06
  122.   72. tbora: Invetiagation/Propaganda 21:31  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  123.   Jacob Blu 21:35  |  Gabe1 12/12/06
  124.   Tutu, consoling the Cartoon Mob 21:43  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  125.   112. Mark Lincoln. Not wise for whom? 21:48  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  126.   Tutu, what a hateful person 22:00  |  KUTW 12/12/06
  127.   #114 HEY PAL ISRASEL WAS CREATED IN 1922 22:11  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  128.   There is nothing for you to teach Gabe 22:11  |  Jacob Blues 12/12/06
  129.   The Mayflower reference Gabe, was related to your claim 22:16  |  Jacob Blues 12/12/06
  130.   Yaakov 22:20  |  ODP 12/12/06
  131.   As for the bullying Gabe 22:23  |  Jacob Blues 12/12/06
  132.   #20 Response; more spin, more BS 22:28  |  ballistic 12/12/06
  133.   I was surprised to read Israel was a safe haven... 22:42  |  Maureen Ann 12/12/06
  134.   #59 Altalena - the IDF has given its version, so no need for Tutu 23:14  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  135.   Motivations of A True Humanitarian 23:16  |  Brian Freund 12/12/06
  136.   #60 Paul Henzen makes a statement 23:20  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  137.   #64 Paul Harris proposes Dershowitz for the investigation 23:26  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  138.   #77 David Teach does so love to dissemble 23:35  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  139.   #79 David Teich makes this statement 23:39  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  140.   #132 BSALLISTIC FAILS TO NOTICE THE US OCCUPATION 23:52  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  141.   #133 wher WER THES WAR CRIMINAL TRIED AND CONVICTED MAUREEN 23:56  |  paul harris 12/12/06
  142.   NOTHING TO HIDE? 00:25  |  H50 13/12/06
  143.   Maureen Ann/ Jacob Blue 00:42  |  Gabe1 13/12/06
  144.   133. Maureen Ann : a safe haven... 00:54  |  KUTW 13/12/06
  145.   # 133 Maureen Ann, why don`t you... 01:11  |  Paul Henzen 13/12/06
  146.   The power of one good man 01:14  |  Tim 13/12/06
  147.   Selective Investigation is wrong. 01:43  |  Felix 13/12/06
  148.   reply to # Jes 02:09  |  wally 13/12/06
  149.   #9 Jean le con Jaures 02:39  |  Henryk 13/12/06
  150.   To Rich 02:59  |  wally 13/12/06
  151.   To Alex 03:05  |  Nabeel 13/12/06
  152.   rabbi y lazaros 03:38  |  dubious 13/12/06
  153.   What`s the matter Gabe, they don`t teach mathamatics 101 05:03  |  Jacob Blues 13/12/06
  154.   #68, ABUBAKR 05:16  |  indrajaya 13/12/06
  155.   Inaccurate Sullivan 05:23  |  SG 13/12/06
  156.   NE 05:30  |  John 13/12/06
  157.   #Gabe1 Fortunately I happen to know... 05:38  |  Maureen Ann 13/12/06
  158.   lies, yes it is one sided. but perfect opportunity for these perf 05:54  |  ralph 13/12/06
  159.   Jacob Blues #131 05:55  |  Gabe1 13/12/06
  160.   KUTW 06:04  |  Maureen Ann 13/12/06
  161.   TUTU. has spare time now to protest Mengitsu shelterd in Zimbabwe 06:39  |  PETER SM 13/12/06
  162.   ballistic investigation 06:45  |  SG 13/12/06
  163.   Another nail in Israel`s conffin..They are cheating themselves 07:10  |  American Taxpayer 13/12/06
  164.   Tutu goes after mackeral and ignores the whale 07:11  |  Seymour 13/12/06
  165.   # 98 Reply to Paul Harris 07:20  |  Nick Ferriman 13/12/06
  166.   DUBIOUS.What exactly do you mean "perhaps some Jews" 07:21  |  PETER SM 13/12/06
  167.   If TUTU had a shred of honesty he would have disqualified himself 07:31  |  PETER SM 13/12/06
  168.   155. Maureen Ann 08:19  |  KUTW 13/12/06
  169.   134: Johnboy`s still in denial 08:41  |  David Teich 13/12/06
  170.   #135 Mr. Harris Response 08:43  |  ballistic 13/12/06
  171.   #157 Response 08:46  |  ballistic 13/12/06
  172.   #134 the facts are the facts--why jewish investigators 08:56  |  ballistic 13/12/06
  173.   #136 Occupation 08:59  |  ballistic 13/12/06
  174.   #94 Who are racist occupiers, Israel? 09:02  |  ballistic 13/12/06
  175.   Credibility 10:20  |  stan 13/12/06
  176.   175: Stan, only if you define "credibility" as "bias" 10:50  |  David Teich 13/12/06
  177.   Ballistic show he is 10:54  |  David Teich 13/12/06
  178.   david teich 166 01:00  |  bubious 14/12/06
  179.   david teich 167 01:03  |  dubious 14/12/06
  180.   179: Dubious lives up to his name 15:26  |  David Teich 14/12/06
 Today Online
Netanyahu wants Ahmadinejad tried for genocide
Responses: 124
Israel worried Hamas and Iran developing strategic relations
Responses: 59
High Court: Int'l law does not forbid targeted killings
Responses: 82
Rosner: Christmas trees, Menorahs and the shortcut to hell
Responses: 70
Israeli Arabs must realize subverting the state offers no future
Responses: 20
The West has to make Iran pay for its uranium adventure
Responses: 23
Rosner's Domain
* Christmas trees, Menorahs and the shortcut to hell
* Poll: Did Olmert kill Israel's nuclear ambiguity?
* Q&A with Rabbi Epstein on Conservatives and gays
* On Conservative homosexuals and liberal values


More Headlines
14:44 High Court: International law does not forbid targeted killings
14:01 Arab MKs: Ruling on targeted killings authorizes 'war crimes'
15:00 Israeli forces kill 2 Palestinians in separate W. Bank incidents
14:46 PA intelligence agent linked to Fatah abducted in Gaza City
14:00 Court orders criminal probe into IDF killing of Rafah girl in 2004
14:42 Source: Arab League mediation in Beirut garners no success
08:14 Israel worried Hamas and Iran developing strategic relations
12:06 Peretz orders IDF to crack down on illegal West Bank building
14:06 Olmert: European visit achieved more than 90 percent of its goals
08:33 Israel Medical Association demands NIS 250M more for health basket
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Yad Ezra VeShulamit
This Chanukah gift the gift of a hot meal to a Jewish child
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Menorahs by Judaica Mall
Great selection of Hanukkah gifts
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved