Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 10, 2006 Kislev 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:51 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
South African Nobel laureate Desmond Tutu addressing the European Development Days conference in Brussels on November 17. (Reuters)
Last update - 22:42 09/12/2006
UN delays probe into Beit Hanun shelling
By The Associated Press and Reuters

A UN mission to investigate the deaths of 19 civilians in the Gaza Strip town of Beit Hanun, led by South Africa's Desmond Tutu, has been delayed because Israel has yet to authorize the trip, a spokeswoman said Saturday.

The Nobel Peace laureate had been due to leave for the Middle East at the weekend, but he would not now leave before Monday, mission spokeswoman Sonia Bakar said.

"We are still waiting for a sign from Israel. It (the departure) will not be before Monday," she said.

Advertisement

Tutu was to begin leading a six-member team this weekend in the town to investigate the killings of 19 civilians in an errant Israel Defense Forces shelling November 8.

But Israel has yet to grant the South African anti-apartheid campaigner and former Anglican archbishop of Cape Town the necessary travel clearance, said three different officials close to the talks between the global body and Israel.

The officials, speaking on condition of anonymity because discussions were continuing, said they had yet to receive any indication from Israel that the mission will take place at all.

Israeli officials in Geneva said they were unable to comment immediately.

Tutu's team was supposed to report its findings to the UN Human Rights Council by mid-December.

The 47-nation council authorized the mission last month, asking Tutu to assess the situation of victims, address the needs of survivors and make recommendations on ways to prevent further casualties.

The shelling, which Israel said was unintended, came after its troops wound up a weeklong incursion meant to curb Palestinian rocket attacks on Israel from the Gaza Strip town.

The IDF said Beit Hanun was a rocket-launching stronghold.

Tutu chaired South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission after the end of white rule. Tutu, who was in Geneva, could not be reached for comment.

Earlier Friday the UN Human Rights Council passed a seventh resolution criticizing Israel on Friday, this time for its failure to act on earlier recommendations that it end military operations in the Palestinian territories and allow a fact-finding mission to the region.

The rights body, which has only condemned the Israeli government in its seven-month existence, noted with regret its July resolution urging the release of all arrested Palestinian ministers has yet to be carried out.

"Violations of the fundamental rights of the Palestinians continue unabated," said Pakistani diplomat Tehmina Janjua on behalf of the 57-nation Organization of the Islamic Conference, which proposed the resolution. "The Palestinian ministers, officials and civilians have not been set free."

Janjua demanded that UN human rights expert John Dugard be allowed to conduct an "urgent" fact-finding in the region, which the council ordered at an emergency session only one month after it was called into existence to replace the discredited Human Rights Commission.

Criticism by the council brings no penalties beyond international attention. Countries, however, lobby hard to avoid having their rights records scrutinized.

Dugard, a former anti-apartheid civil rights lawyer from South Africa, has frequently clashed with Israel, who note that he has been mandated only with investigating violations by the Israeli side. The United States - which along with Israel is only an observer at the 47-nation council - also has dismissed Dugard's reports as one-sided.

Only Canada voted against Friday's resolution. Cameroon and Japan joined the 10 European members of the council in abstaining. The rest of Africa and Asia, along with all of Latin America, voted in favor.

Israel's ambassador to the global body in Geneva criticized the council for ignoring a Nov. 26 cease-fire agreement that ended five months of fierce fighting in Gaza.

"Why does this resolution fail to make any mention of the cease-fire between Israelis and Palestinians, that persists despite the continuation of Qassam rockets fired on Israel?" Itzhak Levanon asked the council.

UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan urged the watchdog last month to deal with the Mideast conflict in an impartial manner, and said it was time to focus attention on "graver" crises such as Darfur.

Despite his plea, the council has passed only a watered-down resolution on the western Sudanese region proposed by African countries, which urged all parties to the conflict to end human rights violations.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
The Hirschfelds, Eyal and Avigail, run a B&B and raise five kids at their Izuz home.
Why a duck?
Dudu Geva was far more than a prolific comics artist working primarily in journalism.
  1.   Professional Israel-abuser Dugard lives La Dolce Vita on World ex 15:26  |  Absolute Sweden 08/12/06
  2.   THE INHUMAN RIGHTS COMMITTEE 15:52  |  Brant 08/12/06
  3.   Another UN Joke 15:55  |  ATLAS 08/12/06
  4.   Sham UN council an insult not only to Israel 16:06  |  Dave 08/12/06
  5.   UN Rights council. 16:06  |  David Nigel Braham 08/12/06
  6.   Even Kofi Anan condemns this sham council 16:13  |  Dave 08/12/06
  7.   Gutless wonders 16:14  |  Sol 08/12/06
  8.   UN Joke 16:25  |  Jozef 08/12/06
  9.   Again, the words of the Human Rights leader raises a question 16:42  |  Jacob Blues 08/12/06
  10.   UN - Safe Haven For Hypocrites and Bigots 17:03  |  Nephtaly 08/12/06
  11.   Reference data for the quote 17:21  |  Jacob Blues 08/12/06
  12.   UN HRC - what a joke. The world suffers but the UN doesn`t care. 17:26  |  Marwan مروان خوري 08/12/06
  13.   Human Rights Kangaroo court 17:33  |  Yariv 08/12/06
  14.   No to external interference 17:36  |  Brod 08/12/06
  15.   We could have needed this during WWII 17:44  |  Ingrid 08/12/06
  16.   Its the whole world 17:54  |  Baz Mann 08/12/06
  17.   Monomaniac contempt of all suffering people 18:32  |  Montefiore 08/12/06
  18.   What is wrong with these people!?!?!? 18:36  |  Ahmad 08/12/06
  19.   What does the UNHRC know about... 18:38  |  Polybios 08/12/06
  20.   dave in toronto 18:48  |  dubious 08/12/06
  21.   To 16 18:53  |  Jozef 08/12/06
  22.   Baz Mann#16 18:55  |  Yariv 08/12/06
  23.   #19 Good point Dubious 19:20  |  Dave 08/12/06
  24.   Israel should nominate Borat as its ambassador to this circus, 19:28  |  Mufasa 08/12/06
  25.   What happened to the 8th Resolution? 19:37  |  Gina 08/12/06
  26.   Again, Ashamed of Canada 19:44  |  chet 08/12/06
  27.   THERE ARE MANY OTHER hUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES BUT... 20:04  |  MASKIR 08/12/06
  28.   Civil(human) Rights......where in any Islamic country?? 20:40  |  r 08/12/06
  29.   Could it be the UN "human rights" council is a farse? 21:00  |  AV 08/12/06
  30.   DUMP THE UN 21:03  |  Rick 08/12/06
  31.   #26..Chet 21:06  |  Barry 08/12/06
  32.   Human Rights 21:25  |  Booby 08/12/06
  33.   Tutu doesn?t need to investigate 21:30  |  KUTW 08/12/06
  34.   Sent him to Tehran 21:34  |  Jonathan S 08/12/06
  35.   Tutu unbiased? 21:37  |  Sherman 08/12/06
  36.   Lovely Example with perfect Timing 21:42  |  Natallie Durson 08/12/06
  37.   Why doesn?t Tutu look into terrorism against Israel? 21:44  |  KUTW 08/12/06
  38.   Get US OUT of the UN 21:48  |  Isaac 08/12/06
  39.   A visa ? 21:51  |  christa 08/12/06
  40.   dave in toronto 21:53  |  dubious 08/12/06
  41.   # 32 : the problem 21:57  |  christa 08/12/06
  42.   # 33 Jonathan S 21:58  |  christa 08/12/06
  43.   Send him home 21:59  |  SystemF 08/12/06
  44.   LET HIM IN ... 22:03  |  MIKE KATZ 08/12/06
  45.   Things Tutu should read while waiting 22:07  |  Bimmer 08/12/06
  46.   picking on Desmond Tutu 22:08  |  whoopwhoop 08/12/06
  47.   Tutu better stay home and read your Holy Bible 22:15  |  Brod 08/12/06
  48.   Tutu still awaiting Israeli entry visa to probe Beit Hanun deaths 22:22  |  Southern Cross 08/12/06
  49.   Give him a tourist visa 22:57  |  Shlomo from Tel Aviv 08/12/06
  50.   The Bishop`s Report 22:58  |  J of Hollywood 08/12/06
  51.   United Nations Investigations 23:04  |  Marc 08/12/06
  52.   36christa: the problem 23:18  |  KUTW 08/12/06
  53.   #35 Natalie Durson 23:18  |  Nemesis 08/12/06
  54.   Israels CRIMES... 23:24  |  MIKE KATZ 08/12/06
  55.   The results are known #41 23:24  |  Jonathan S 08/12/06
  56.   #35 JUDICIAL APPROACH BY NATALLIE FALLS SHORT 23:26  |  paul harris 08/12/06
  57.   #50 Marc..WPB 23:28  |  Barry 08/12/06
  58.   Tutu a hypomanic giggling nothing 23:44  |  Alan 08/12/06
  59.   46. whoopwhoop: picking on Desmond Tutu 23:50  |  KUTW 08/12/06
  60.   Zionist fear 00:14  |  Boycott 09/12/06
  61.   Typical 00:21  |  W 09/12/06
  62.   Jacob Blues #9 00:33  |  Guess who 09/12/06
  63.   why they need Israel --let Arabs and Africans give them 00:36  |  Sal 09/12/06
  64.   Christa 00:39  |  MR 09/12/06
  65.   he has already written his report...why legitamize him. 00:47  |  r 09/12/06
  66.   What next? 00:56  |  james 09/12/06
  67.   TUTU DANGER FOR ISRAEL 01:00  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 09/12/06
  68.   Tutu still awaiting 01:06  |  Shmuelshachor 09/12/06
  69.   I am not surprized 01:21  |  Jozef 09/12/06
  70.   Entry Visa for Tutu? 01:24  |  Sylvia 09/12/06
  71.   Big Investments 01:44  |  ron 09/12/06
  72.   Natalie#36 01:46  |  Yariv 09/12/06
  73.   Tutu, Go to Darfur, deal with Genocide close to home 01:55  |  Michigan 09/12/06
  74.   Natalie Durson 02:01  |  Barry 09/12/06
  75.   Get US out of UN and get UN out of US. 02:01  |  Alex 09/12/06
  76.   re: Tutu, Go to Darfur, deal with Genocide close to home 02:17  |  Sol 09/12/06
  77.   Send him to.... 02:18  |  Blogowitz 09/12/06
  78.   What kin of joke is this!! 02:20  |  Tamir Gaza 09/12/06
  79.   Crims 02:49  |  Mike 09/12/06
  80.   Israeli war crims 02:56  |  Mike 09/12/06
  81.   Israel Afraid of Truth 03:18  |  Larry Saltzman 09/12/06
  82.   Dugard and Elmer J Fudd 03:19  |  Lawyer II 09/12/06
  83.   If a few IDF soldiers have to spend 10 to 20 in prison, so be it. 04:02  |  Timothy 09/12/06
  84.   Mike from NY NY 04:07  |  MR 09/12/06
  85.   TUTU 04:21  |  MR 09/12/06
  86.   TUTU FACT FINDING MISSION 04:24  |  colin elkon