Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 10, 2006 Kislev 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:54 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Not just a report, a friend as well
By Yossi Sarid

About 12 years ago James Baker was in Israel on one of his visits.

He was already a former secretary of state at the time, but still wielded considerable influence. Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin held a dinner for him at his residence, to which I, a minister in his cabinet, was invited too. The evening was pleasant, but mainly, it was interesting. In a collective attack of feeble-minded candor, the participants opened their hearts.

I remember Baker's words on that night clearly. "I know," he said, "that in Israel I am always suspect. I am not regarded as a friend here. Some of you believe that I am too tough, that my hidden agenda is to impose an agreement. This is a complete misunderstanding of my position. A day will come and you will realize that I, of all people, was a true friend of Israel."

Advertisement

And that day has come - with the release of the Baker-Hamilton report. Only one who lives from hand to mouth, from one news bulletin to the next, from an off-the-cuff speech in Herzliya to an off-the-wall speech in Sde Boker, could continue to describe Baker as harboring "anti-Israeli prejudices." Only someone obstinately plotting, manipulating, surviving at any price and waging a rearguard battle, could turn Baker at this time into another link in the axis of evil.

Of course, one could pick on some seemingly weak point or other in the report. But the document's great advantage is not in points but in lines; and all the lines lead to the correct, inevitable blueprint for settling the Israeli-Arab conflict. There is no alternative, only false substitutes and short-term spins.

If President George Bush rejects the report or ignores it, if he yet again spares us the rod of reality in the Middle East - it would not be from love of Israel, but from hatred. Someone who allows a blind man to walk along the edge of a cliff is only setting him up for a fall.

Ehud Olmert and his ministers are the blind man, and so far a lame administration has been carrying them on its shoulders toward the marsh triangle - Iraq, Lebanon, Palestine, while Iran led the lost American-Israeli convoy astray.

The cripple and his rider sank into the mud. Perhaps now they will switch roles - the blind will carry the lame and with draining but combined strength they will manage to move forward, not only to wallow.

The first responses to the report are not at all encouraging, especially the comments made in "Olmert's vicinity." "There is no cause for concern," responded the autistic vicinity, which remains unmoved. "The sky hasn't fallen down on us," reports the prime minister's bureau, noting that "Israel is mentioned in only three of the 79 recommendations, and in any case the president won't adopt the recommendations."

Did the officials from the prime minister's bureau not read the report? Did they read it but fail to understand? Is the Israeli government completely out of touch with the altered political situation in America? Will a faltering president who managed to get rid of his good friend Donald (Rumsfeld) and his eager servant John (Bolton) have any trouble shaking off the blind man on his back, if his sole desire is to save himself from the Iraqi curse? If all he wants now is to save his name from the wrath of history, lurking in wait for him in a dark corner?

An earthquake is taking place in Washington, and Jerusalem doesn't understand what all the fuss is about. One gets the impression that it is not Nasrallah who has been hiding in a bunker since the war, but Olmert, who has not been exposed to what is clear as the light of day.

After the designated secretary of defense, Robert Gates, warned this week against military action against Iran, confirmed the possibility of a nuclear attack on Israel and linked the Iranian nuclear program to Israel's, let us call out to Israel's prime minister: Olmert, Olmert, come out, call George on the telephone urgently and tell him: "Dear President, I haven't had time to have a first thought yet, but on second thought, this report isn't so terrible after all and Baker himself is not selling Israel down the river.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
The Hirschfelds, Eyal and Avigail, run a B&B and raise five kids at their Izuz home.
Why a duck?
Dudu Geva was far more than a prolific comics artist working primarily in journalism.
  1.   Baker is a friend and Yossi is a friend 10:45  |  Ilan 08/12/06
  2.   James Baker, or when your worst enemy is in fact your best friend 10:49  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/12/06
  3.   No peace in Palestine, no peace in the world 11:07  |  KA 08/12/06
  4.   JAMES BAKER 11:11  |  Indrajaya 08/12/06
  5.   Hidden Agenda 11:15  |  Johnny Weintraub 08/12/06
  6.   good friends and bad friends 11:18  |  Akiva Patysh 08/12/06
  7.   Hilarious utter nonsense. What ya been smoking there Yossi? 11:24  |  Pablo 08/12/06
  8.   No purple prose needed 11:25  |  sh 08/12/06
  9.   At least, Baker secured Golan for Israel 11:26  |  Paul Henzen 08/12/06
  10.   KA: If You Want War, Then You Will Face The Mother Of All Naqbas 11:43  |  Yishai Kohen 08/12/06
  11.   Baker once again tries to sell the Kurds to the Wolves 11:47  |  Eric Ritter 08/12/06
  12.   The Biggest Lie 11:54  |  Terry 08/12/06
  13.   Baker the friend 12:06  |  Jonathan S 08/12/06
  14.   i never disagree with sarid,but... 12:11  |  concluder 08/12/06
  15.   First Fallout from the Baker Surrender Group 13:01  |  Jonathan S 08/12/06
  16.   Privatize Iraqi oil james? 13:05  |  revoltop 08/12/06
  17.   johnathan s - don`t kill the messenger 13:12  |  freddy 08/12/06
  18.   Tishai Kohen...keep dreaming 13:14  |  KA 08/12/06
  19.   Jonathan S 13:54  |  Klaudia 08/12/06
  20.   Another friend of Israel, Syria, likes the report as well 13:59  |  Asylum Aleikum 08/12/06
  21.   With Friends like Baker who needs enemies! 14:20  |  Max Zinger,P.Chimist 08/12/06
  22.   Sarid- Hanieh Jusr answered your question-Destruction of Israel 14:49  |  Noah 08/12/06
  23.   WHO NEEDS ENEMIES WITH FRIENDS LIKE BAKER 15:19  |  paul harris 08/12/06
  24.   Baker report 15:24  |  norman ravitch 08/12/06
  25.   The Blind Leading the Blind on the Precipice 15:26  |  yaakov sullivan 08/12/06
  26.   Such a poor article 15:27  |  Igor 08/12/06
  27.   Sarid gave us Oslo and his friendship with Arafat 15:45  |  Shalom Freedman 08/12/06
  28.   Israel is loosing, loosing, loosing ... 15:46  |  Mafalda 08/12/06
  29.   American ex President, Secy of State do not have to prove anythin 15:47  |  omolll 08/12/06
  30.   YAAKOV DEVOID OF REALITY AGAIN #22 15:52  |  paul harris 08/12/06
  31.   Terry 12- The Jews were responsible for the Black Plague-realy 16:00  |  Noah 08/12/06
  32.   The Me Needs a Way Forward Not Back to the Bad Old Days 16:02  |  Jane 08/12/06
  33.   Belin and Sarid should run arab countries that their priority 16:19  |  zionist forever 08/12/06
  34.   Baker Bad for US 16:23  |  Bob 08/12/06
  35.   Olmert learns, but very slowly 16:24  |  Tosefta 08/12/06
  36.   Mr. Sarid`s ignorance 16:37  |  Gene 08/12/06
  37.   Baker shows Israel cannot rely on even the US 16:38  |  zionist forever 08/12/06
  38.   Our friend Jim Baker 16:45  |  Tosefta 08/12/06
  39.   # Mafalda, have I got news for you ! 16:49  |  Paul Henzen 08/12/06
  40.   The Baker report... 16:50  |  Ali 08/12/06
  41.   To nr. 2 KA from Palestine 17:11  |  Tulip 08/12/06
  42.   baker & Sarid 17:14  |  j.b. 08/12/06
  43.   Olmert learns, but very slowly 17:15  |  Tosefta 08/12/06
  44.   Bob & Bad 17:27  |  Freddy 08/12/06
  45.   The panels report 17:31  |  Bimmer 08/12/06
  46.   He never, ever, not once gave me the impression of impartiality, 17:37  |  nehemia dB 08/12/06
  47.   this too shall pass... 17:55  |  Joe 08/12/06
  48.   Torn 18:34  |  David S 08/12/06
  49.   Canard about Baker - setting it straight 18:38  |  David 08/12/06
  50.   Baker is Pro-Saudi, NOT Pro U.S.A, Not Pro-Israel 18:46  |  Robert B. 08/12/06
  51.   Is this a joke? 18:50  |  Brod 08/12/06
  52.   Sarid`s Alternative Reality 18:59  |  Tod Zuckerman 08/12/06
  53.   To Klaudia about Yossi Sarid #19 18:59  |  Jonathan S 08/12/06
  54.   # 52- Jonathan S 19:30  |  Klaudia 08/12/06
  55.   Baker - Hamilton support a nuclearized Iran 19:31  |  Bimmer 08/12/06
  56.   #43 Tosefta, Better a slow learner producing a masterpiece 19:44  |  Smadar 08/12/06
  57.   "Facts on the ground" 19:50  |  Stanley 08/12/06
  58.   #3 No peace in Israel,no Palestian state 20:11  |  Don Saliman 08/12/06
  59.   IElementary Dr. Watson, eh, Mr. Baker 20:19  |  Bimmer 08/12/06
  60.   To Yishai Cohen 20:20  |  Joshua 08/12/06
  61.   Between positive creativity and slow learning (Smadar #56) 20:31  |  Tosefta 08/12/06
  62.   #6 Akiva Patysh 20:55  |  Boycott 08/12/06
  63.   # 3 My Hat Goes Off To You 20:56  |  Alexander 08/12/06
  64.   Hamas answers Baker-Hamilton report 21:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/12/06
  65.   To Klaudia about right or left 21:09  |  Jonathan S 08/12/06
  66.   Sarid and Baker..sharing the cuckoo`s nest 21:28  |  Connie 08/12/06
  67.   a friend of ilan 21:30  |  michel 08/12/06
  68.   Mafaldo 21:31  |  Connie 08/12/06
  69.   YOSSI WHAT ARE YOU ON 21:56  |  Dr David I. Gross 08/12/06
  70.   Sarid 22:29  |  L. Gomberoff 08/12/06
  71.   Greetings to the Good Muslim People 22:59  |  BP DIP 08/12/06
  72.   Everything is a Smokescreen. 23:02  |  Ah 08/12/06
  73.   Klaudia is right, again... 23:22  |  Paul Henzen 08/12/06
  74.   #61 Tosefta, misinterpreting sequence of events 23:52  |  Smadar 08/12/06
  75.   Baker and Sarid 00:15  |  Charles 09/12/06
  76.   The Baker Hamilton report. 00:59  |  sandra chitayat 09/12/06
  77.   "God, protect me from my friends, I`ll take care of my enemies.." 01:42  |  Michigan 09/12/06
  78.   Sarid is a left wing appeaser 02:10  |  BradL 09/12/06
  79.   Israeli rejectionist culture relies on the conflict 02:14  |  Ibrahim 09/12/06
  80.   Gird on wisdom and seek the face of ADONAI 02:50  |  THIL 09/12/06
  81.   Dr. Gross #69`s slow learning curve 03:17  |  Stanley 09/12/06
  82.   wake and smell the coffee, israel 03:28  |  shegay 09/12/06
  83.   revolting, what dead soldiers? 04:11  |  Jake 09/12/06
  84.   Right on Yossi 04:14  |  Holden 09/12/06
  85.   BAKER IS A FRIEND TO MONEY 04:38  |  TOBIA 09/12/06
  86.   Boycott @ # 62 05:05  |  Akiva Patysh, Tzioni 09/12/06
  87.   Zionists cringe at the thought of peace 05:14  |  Michael H. 09/12/06
  88.   Ibrahim The Hamas are the rejectionist culture 05:21  |  Michigan 09/12/06
  89.   How does giving the Pals a state fix Iraq? 05:22  |  J. Crohn 09/12/06
  90.   Stanley No recognition of Israel, no just solution possible. 05:53  |  Michigan 09/12/06
  91.   Baker -Saudi Connection 06:13  |  Micha 09/12/06
  92.   Micha - Baker Saudi connection and your point? 07:17  |  justiceseeker 09/12/06
  93.   baker= yosi sarid=ahmadinejad=arafat=nasralah 09:56  |  DR MANUCH 09/12/06
  94.   Baker`s proposals are half baked 10:12  |  David 09/12/06
  95.   MichaelH 10:14  |  Connie 09/12/06
  96.   #86 Akiva 13:16  |  Boycott 09/12/06
  97.   If Rudy Giuliani and Joe Lieberman would head this commission.... 13:19  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/12/06
  98.   reports and actions 17:39  |  Joe 09/12/06
  99.   Smadar #74; understanding Olmert 17:52  |  Tosefta 09/12/06
  100.   To Mafalda from Argentina 18:32  |  Jozef 09/12/06
  101.   To Swiss Dino#2 18:32  |  Otto Rand 09/12/06
  102.   Klaudia, 19 18:39  |  Jozef 09/12/06
  103.   To Akiva Patish 18:42  |  Otto Rand 09/12/06
  104.   Rhythm - Tosefta, Smadar 18:47  |  sh 09/12/06
  105.   To Bradl #78 19:04  |  Otto Rand 09/12/06
  106.   Hi Tosefta 19:14  |  Otto Rand 09/12/06
  107.   To Mr. Crohn #89 19:30  |  Otto Rand 09/12/06
  108.   To THIL 19:32  |  Otto Rand 09/12/06
  109.   #98 Tosefta, okay maybe "renouncing all violence" by Hamas 20:48  |  Smadar 09/12/06
  110.   # 101 Otto Rand 20:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/12/06
  111.   friend as well 20:58  |  Ralph 09/12/06
  112.   Americans for Americans 21:03  |  John 09/12/06
  113.   Sard 21:20  |  daat y 09/12/06
  114.   To #105 Otto Rand 22:20  |  BradL 09/12/06
  115.   Funny how all Israel`s enemies really want the best for it 22:20  |  McQueen 09/12/06
  116.   Baker is Sarid`s friend, not Israel`s 22:30  |  Yaakov K. 09/12/06
  117.   AGAIN AGAIN AGAIN JOHN #112 22:31  |  Tobia 09/12/06
  118.   PRESIDENT CARTER CALLED LIER SWiss Dino 22:37  |  TOBIA 09/12/06
  119.   #105, Otto Rand 01:04  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/12/06
  120.   As usual: the truth is hurting isn`t 02:29  |  cc 10/12/06
  121.   Isreal`s disconenct 02:56  |  margaret 10/12/06
  122.   #107 - Otto`s hollistic approach 03:31  |  SG 10/12/06
  123.   HAARETZ- WHAT ARE YOU AFRAID OF? 04:30  |  David I. Gross A.uD 10/12/06
  124.   STANLEY PART TWO 04:48  |  Dr David I. Gross 10/12/06
  125.   Margaret: Hamas PM in Teheran today: No Peace, No recognition, 05:23  |  Michigan 10/12/06
  126.   The new left 05:48  |  Otto Rand 10/12/06
  127.   Not just a report.. 07:22  |  Shmuelshachor 10/12/06
  128.   Otto Rand The Naive Old Left 07:49  |  Michigan 10/12/06
  129.   122SG re #107 - Otto`s holistic approach 08:01  |  Michigan 10/12/06
  130.   from THIL to Otto R. re: his response #108 08:30  |  THIL 10/12/06
  131.   To SG #126 and Michigan #128 08:50  |  Otto Rand 10/12/06
  132.   to# 92 09:54  |  Micha 10/12/06
  133.   Otto Rand, I am for peace as much as you are. 10:50  |  Michigan 10/12/06
  134.   Y.Sarid is good4Baker&Baker is good 4Sarid! 19:51  |  sam 10/12/06
 Today Online
Ze'ev Schiff: Why did Gates blow Israel's nuclear cover?
Responses: 73
Haniyeh, in Iran, vows jihad 'until Jerusalem liberated'
Responses: 166
MI officer: Syria preparing its army for war with Israel
Responses: 43
IDF: Iran to have nuclear capability 'in near future'
Responses: 52


More Headlines
19:27 MI officer: Syria preparing its army for war with Israel
19:33 PM to ministers: Keep mum on Baker report, it is internal U.S. matter
19:07 Hawking says Mideast situation has deteriorated since last visit
18:14 Hundreds of thousands of Hezbollah supporters attend anti-gov't protest in Beirut
17:34 Hamas minister target of attempted assassination in Gaza
17:52 Merkel meets Mubarak, vows new Mideast diplomatic effort
18:23 Israel, Jordan, Palestinians, launch study on topping up Dead Sea
17:04 Lawyers slam police conduct in capture of rapist Benny Sela
16:11 Hamas promises $50,000 to dress up Bethlehem for Christmas
19:00 Two killed in multi-vehicle crash as truck crushes car in Negev
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved