Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., December 08, 2006 Kislev 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:22 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 20:35 06/12/2006
Report accuses Hezbollah of war crimes, hiding among civilians
By Haaretz Service and The Associated Press

Hezbollah operated during the second Lebanon war from within civilian structures and its operatives disguised themselves as civilians, and is therefore guilty of war crimes, according to a report authored by Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center.

The report also says that 650 out of the 1,084 people the Lebanese government has said were civilians killed in the conflict were in fact Hezbollah militants.

According to international law on warfare, the use of civilian structures during combat is forbidden, and turns the structures into legitimate military targets. International human rights organizations and the United Nations have accused Israel of attacking civilian targets during the war.

Advertisement

The Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center works in close cooperation with the Israel Defense Forces Intelligence Corps. The center's director, Colonel (res.) Reuven Erlich, said the report is intended to help make Israel's case to the world regarding IDF activities during the war.

"I think it could offer a response to allegations of human rights organizations on why the Israel Defense Forces operated in civilian areas," Ehrlich said.

The report said Hezbollah operated from civilian areas to deter the Israeli military and gain a propaganda advantage if an Israeli counterattack caused civilian casualties. Militants stashed weapons in hundreds of private homes and mosques, had missile transports closely follow ambulances and fired rockets near UN monitoring posts, the report said

The report's authors say it proves that Hezbollah made serious efforts to blend in with the civilian population in Beirut and southern Lebanon. The report includes aerial photographs of buildings and facilities in civilian neighborhoods being used by Hezbollah, as well as pictures of Hezbollah militants firing rockets next to residential buildings. In at least one instance, say the authors, Hezbollah weapons were found in a mosque.

The report also includes testimony given by captured Hezbollah militants, in which they admit they were instructed to hide in civilian buildings. One militant said, according to the report, that he transported a Katyusha rocket under the cover of a white flag. Another militant is quoted as saying that he and his comrades wore civilian clothes and traveled in civilian vehicles, to avoid being identified as militants.

One video included in the report showed a captured Hezbollah guerrilla telling his interrogators how the militia rented houses in residential areas to secretly store missiles.

"Even the owner of the house, he knows he's giving (the building) to Hezbollah, they rent it for instance, but its not possible for him to know what's in it," said the militant, identified as 30-year-old Maher Hassan Mahmoud Kourani.

The report presents Hezbollah Katyusha rocket "firing cards", which include instructions on how to aim in order to hit civilian population centers in northern Israel.

The report concludes by offering a legal determination accusing Hezbollah of war crimes. Three chapters in the report addressing the war crimes issue were prepared by the IDF legal department, in conjunction with Foreign Ministry lawyers, the report said.

A Hezbollah official dismissed the Israeli report as "totally untrue," saying it was part of "a campaign to vilify Hezbollah and justify the unjustified Israeli massacres in Lebanon."

"These allegations are part of Israeli propaganda aimed at protecting Israel's generals and officials who face accusations of committing massacres against Lebanese civilians during the summer war," Hussein Rahhal, Hezbollah's media chief, told The Associated Press in Lebanon.

Amnesty International said the report did not contain many new allegations. "In terms of the fact that Hezbollah had weapons, tunnels, militia facilities in villages, no one disputes it. Hezbollah does not dispute it," said Claudio Cordone, a senior director of research at Amnesty.

Cordone called for "a proper international investigation ... to look into these allegations and other ones," including Hezbollah's rocket attacks on northern Israel.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Error and trials
Beilinson Hospital Gynecologists published an article with data from nonexistent trials.
Mom and pop Italian
The recently opened 'Mel and Michelle' gives the appearance of a true Italian trattoria.
  1.   lying self-serving report 11:57  |  raymond deane 06/12/06
  2.   Now we are going to start hearing additional blames against 12:00  |  Yair 06/12/06
  3.   What can you expect of Hezbollah? 12:12  |  Cristina 06/12/06
  4.   The truth as first victim, Mr Deane? 12:15  |  Josef Manasterski 06/12/06
  5.   This is utterly laughable 12:17  |  Stephen Murray 06/12/06
  6.   #2: Reply 12:20  |  Stephen Murray 06/12/06
  7.   WAR CRIMES 12:20  |  SEAN 06/12/06
  8.   Report accuses... 12:20  |  JJ 06/12/06
  9.   Neglecticide 12:24  |  M Porter 06/12/06
  10.   Stephen Murray, the report quotes Hizbollah people captured 12:31  |  Ken Jurist 06/12/06
  11.   Umm, not exactly an *independent* investigation 12:33  |  Johnboy 06/12/06
  12.   is nasrallah concerned with his captives in israel 12:39  |  salah al din 06/12/06
  13.   Jewish report= no crediblity 12:43  |  KMS 06/12/06
  14.   Blinded by hate 12:49  |  Jonathan S 06/12/06
  15.   WAR CRIMES 13:02  |  HASSAN 06/12/06
  16.   Life is cheap to Hisb.they committed war crimes 13:05  |  steve 06/12/06
  17.   Are Israel`s military installations on the country side - no 13:07  |  Petteri 06/12/06
  18.   Zero Credibility 13:13  |  Victor Smolinsky 06/12/06
  19.   Lebanon Report 13:50  |  Wolfram 06/12/06
  20.   #17 Petteri,can you give me an example 13:51  |  Hastaroth 06/12/06
  21.   They didn`t need to go to all that trouble 13:53  |  Natallie Durson 06/12/06
  22.   Furthermore... 13:55  |  Hastaroth 06/12/06
  23.   #10 Israel is known to mistreat prisoners 13:56  |  Jens 06/12/06
  24.   #14 Jonathan S 13:59  |  Hastaroth 06/12/06
  25.   To Hassan from Nigeria, 15 14:00  |  Jozef 06/12/06
  26.   Excellent report 14:01  |  Nechama 06/12/06
  27.   #16 14:01  |  JJ 06/12/06
  28.   Hezbollah`s war crimes 14:07  |  Ssam 06/12/06
  29.   # 1- raymond deane 14:09  |  Klaudia 06/12/06
  30.   Who lie? 14:14  |  Michele 06/12/06
  31.   NOTHING can convince the Israel haters,NOTHING! simple as that! 14:16  |  Ben 06/12/06
  32.   Who is the war criminal?? 14:20  |  I.d. 06/12/06
  33.   Who is the war criminal?? 14:22  |  I.d. 06/12/06
  34.   As always the truth will be somewhere in the middle 14:24  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/12/06
  35.   to Hassan 14:27  |  Harry 06/12/06
  36.   WHERE IS THE REPORT ABOUT MUSLIM OCCUPATION OF LEBANON? 14:28  |  Law and Order 06/12/06
  37.   I want to leave lebanon and never come back 14:35  |  Rita 06/12/06
  38.   No-one believes the United Nazis any more 14:45  |  Allon 06/12/06
  39.   This report is good for only fools and horses 14:46  |  Sam (UK) 06/12/06
  40.   KMS # 13, Khalid I assume... 14:53  |  Yair 06/12/06
  41.   Already a good number of poster have illustrated my point that I 14:58  |  Yair 06/12/06
  42.   To Rita 15:07  |  Georges 06/12/06
  43.   Hizbollah and human shields 15:15  |  Ian 06/12/06
  44.   Natallie Durson 15:22  |  rich 06/12/06
  45.   Raymond Deane 15:35  |  Yonatan 06/12/06
  46.   to Ben, Yair, and other nice people. Why you bother anyway? 15:54  |  leila perez 06/12/06
  47.   LET THE SERBS DO THEIR OWN STUDY 2 15:57  |  Bozo 06/12/06
  48.   Who is the war criminal?? 15:59  |  I.d. 06/12/06
  49.   Since when Pinocchio works for Shin Beit? 16:00  |  Ralph is back 06/12/06
  50.   Israeli Intelligence Lacked in this war 16:00  |  Guy From NYC 06/12/06
  51.   # 15 Hassan 16:02  |  Josef 06/12/06
  52.   Report accuses Hezbollah of war crimes, hiding among civilians 16:03  |  steve 06/12/06
  53.   Stephen Murray 16:04  |  Sol 06/12/06
  54.   reply to raymond deane 16:06  |  Mike 06/12/06
  55.   RE: Jewish report= no crediblity 16:08  |  Mike 06/12/06
  56.   Greetings to the Ordinary Hizbollah Ranks 16:08  |  BP DIP 06/12/06
  57.   Stephen Murray: Ignorant Yak 16:12  |  Jake 06/12/06
  58.   Hassan 16:14  |  Sol 06/12/06
  59.   Greetings to the Decent Lebanese... 16:20  |  BP DIP 06/12/06
  60.   to Michele 16:24  |  Sol 06/12/06
  61.   If Hiz wears uniforms, can you describe them to me? 16:28  |  Ben 06/12/06
  62.   Official Israeli apology 16:29  |  Official 06/12/06
  63.   to I.d. - Who is the war criminal?? 16:33  |  Sol 06/12/06
  64.   Who is the real winner and loser of this war? 16:33  |  Dave 06/12/06
  65.   jozef,sol&harry 17:05  |  hassan 06/12/06
  66.   To Bozo#47 17:07  |  Ilya 06/12/06
  67.   To # 1 17:09  |  even 06/12/06
  68.   to Rita#37 17:10  |  Ilya 06/12/06
  69.   sol&id 17:15  |  hassan 06/12/06
  70.   Not mentioned the one dressed like women to run away 17:22  |  Hate blinds 06/12/06
  71.   hate blinds 17:36  |  hassan 06/12/06
  72.   Stephen Murray deffending undeffendable 18:02  |  TOMY 06/12/06
  73.   Rita who wants to leave lebanon 18:06  |  Jamal 06/12/06
  74.   I wana hear some good news from Lebanon 18:12  |  Tamir Gaza 06/12/06
  75.   # 66 Ilya 18:16  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/12/06
  76.   Hassan from Nigeria 18:30  |  Motale 06/12/06
  77.   Missing the point 18:43  |  A Historian 06/12/06
  78.   # 65 hassan 18:43  |  Josef 06/12/06
  79.   WHAT DO U EXPECT FROM HASSAN 19:12  |  SAMUEL 06/12/06
  80.   to Swiss#75 19:50  |  Ilya 06/12/06
  81.   Ilya - NATO not rapist or ethnic cleansing 19:57  |  Bozo 06/12/06
  82.   Ilya - HISTORY OF DECEPTION 20:03  |  Bozo 06/12/06
  83.   You have apoint BEN 20:57  |  TOMY 06/12/06
  84.   To Bozo#81, 82 21:01  |  Ilya 06/12/06
  85.   To Bozo#81, 82 21:02  |  Ilya 06/12/06
  86.   Bozo - #82 21:44  |  Bman 06/12/06
  87.   Take them to Int`l court 21:47