Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 06, 2006 Kislev 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:55 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates fielding questions from members of the Senate Armed Services Committee during his confirmation hearing in Washington on Tuesday. (AP)
Last update - 02:46 06/12/2006
U.S. defense secretary: Can't assure Israel that Iran won't attack
By News Agencies

Robert Gates, nominated to replace Donald Rumsfeld as U.S. defense secretary, on Tuesday said Iran was trying to acquire nuclear weapons and its leaders were lying when they said the program is strictly civilian.

He said he was not sure Iran would attack Israel with such weapons because "the risks for them (Iran) are enormously high." But he also said the United States could not assure Israel that a nuclear attack by Iran would not happen.

"I don't think anybody can provide that assurance," he told the committee.

Advertisement

When asked at the U.S. Senate Armed Services Committee hearing on his nomination whether he believed Iran was seeking a nuclear weapons capability, he responded, "Yes, sir, I do."

Asked if he believed Iran's leaders were lying, Gates responded, "Yes, sir."

Iran says its nuclear work is aimed at generating electricity, but the West suspects Tehran is using the civilian program as cover to build an atomic bomb.

Gates also conceded that the United States is not winning the war in Iraq and warned that if that country is not stabilized in the next year or two
it could lead to a "regional conflagration."

"In my view, all options are on the table, in terms of how we address this problem in Iraq," he added.

Meanwhile, senior diplomats from six world powers who met in Paris on Tuesday failed to reach a full agreement on a draft resolution for a sanctions plan against Iran and its nuclear program, the French foreign ministry said.

"We made substantive progress on the scope of the sanctions, targeting proliferation-sensitive activities. There remain several outstanding issues, on which we will reflect over the coming days," the foreign ministry said in a statement.

"We all agree on the necessity of adopting an effective resolution. We are now close to a conclusion of this process. The next step will be in New York."

Earlier Tuesday, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said tough sanctions on Iran to punish it for pursuing uranium enrichment would be counter-productive.

"We believe it is irresponsible to impose these kind of sanctions," Lavrov told reporters on the margins of a meeting of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe in Brussels.

"We would achieve the opposite result if we do that," he said of Western efforts to get Russia and China to agree a UN Security Council resolution setting out penalties on Tehran for refusing to halt nuclear activities the West suspects are aimed at building an atom bomb - a goal Tehran denies.

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad on Tuesday warned Europeans his country will consider any decision against its nuclear rights an act of "hostility."

His statement came as political directors from United Nations Security Council permanent members Russia, China, France, Britain and the United States, as well as Germany were to attend the latest round of talks in Paris on the diplomatic impasse between the West and Iran over its nuclear program.

"I'm telling you in plain language that as of now on, if you try, whether in your propaganda or at international organizations, to take steps against the rights of the Iranian nation, the Iranian nation will consider it an act of hostility," Ahmadinejad said, addressing thousands of people in northern Iran.

"And if you insist on pursuing this path, it (Iran) will reconsider its relations with you," he warned European nations.

"Our path to reach the nuclear summit is in the final phase, and no more than one more step is needed," Ahmadinejad told the rally.

"Iran possesses the nuclear fuel cycle completely and by God's will it will undertake necessary measures to produce nuclear fuel for all of its nuclear power stations," he said.

Despite Russia's refusal to agree to tough sanctions on Iran, the French foreign minister said Moscow is likely to back a decision to pressure Tehran on is nuclear plan.

Russia has consistently refused to agree to measures that would be seen as a punishment of Tehran for its refusal to meet the August 31 UN deadline to abandon uranium enrichment, which can produce fuel for nuclear power plants or atom bombs.

French Foreign Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy said after talking with his Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov on Monday that progress had been made on the wording of a sanctions resolution.

"I think that we can now reach an agreement on the text," he told reporters after meeting Lavrov on the sidelines of the OSCE meeting.

"We are in agreement with Russia to adopt sanctions against the Iranian programme of proliferation."

EU diplomats say the sanctions called for in the text will be largely symbolic.

However, they say unanimous approval of even mild sanctions will send a strong signal to Tehran that the world is determined to stop Iran obtaining nuclear arms.

Also Tuesday the country's nuclear negotiator Ali Larijani said at a regional forum in Dubai that American "unilateralism" could cause more conflict in the Middle East.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Devil wears Prada
Patricia Field dresses models with the fashion philosophy reflected in 'Sex and the City.'
Wizards and music
The children's musical 'The Wiz' is back again this Hanukkah for the third time.
  1.   Israeli leaders submitted to US dictates on pals,getting no defen 21:26  |  Absolute Sweden 05/12/06
  2.   US should gradually hand over Iraq and focus on Iran 21:37  |  Kenny 05/12/06
  3.   It means: you are on your own 21:38  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  4.   A PHASED REDEPLOYMENT...TO IRAN 22:05  |  Ryan 05/12/06
  5.   Iran Deterrent 22:14  |  Steve 05/12/06
  6.   If i am not for myself , so whom 22:15  |  Joseph E . 05/12/06
  7.   What about Zionist Attack on Iran? 22:16  |  Dovy 05/12/06
  8.   To Sweden 22:29  |  I hate Clickfool 05/12/06
  9.   #1 response; what do you want the US to do, bomb em 22:36  |  ballistic 05/12/06
  10.   #2 response 22:38  |  ballistic 05/12/06
  11.   Absolute Sweden 22:52  |  eva 05/12/06
  12.   #2 Kenny 22:53  |  Boycott 05/12/06
  13.   NO WR GOING TO HAPPEN MATES 22:58  |  british observer 05/12/06
  14.   Salary 23:00  |  From the Moon 05/12/06
  15.   Hey ballistic....the same can apply to the US 23:04  |  British academic 05/12/06
  16.   America will not attack Iran unless Iran attacks America 23:04  |  Natallie Durson 05/12/06
  17.   Dont rely on foreign powers 23:15  |  Robert 05/12/06
  18.   Oh no. Not again 23:15  |  Iranian-American 05/12/06
  19.   # 1 Absolute Sweden 23:19  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/12/06
  20.   Jon-#9 absolutely right. But Israel historicaly never waited 23:34  |  Noah 05/12/06
  21.   reality 23:52  |  dick cohen 05/12/06
  22.   Baker Only Owes Israeli Jews An Apology 00:00  |  Tony Anthony 06/12/06
  23.   the US will not attack Iran 00:05  |  matt 06/12/06
  24.   To Noah about waiting #21 00:07  |  Jonathan S 06/12/06
  25.   Dovy - Wannabe King of Naturei Karta 00:25  |  Jane 06/12/06
  26.   Warm up engines , Warm up engines not tomorrow but now 00:27  |  Joseph E . 06/12/06
  27.   7 # dovy 00:32  |  Nolan 06/12/06
  28.   to #17 00:34  |  Mark Maliki 06/12/06
  29.   the good ones always win 00:41  |  g 06/12/06
  30.   #16 Response--You are not fighting for me!! 00:52  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  31.   #18 response is poppycock!!! 00:55  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  32.   #14 You must live in Israel 01:01  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  33.   #25 response 01:06  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  34.   natalie # 16 01:09  |  vs 06/12/06
  35.   #27 response 01:09  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  36.   # 22 Tony Anthony 01:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/12/06
  37.   American Scientist to British Academic 01:13  |  Scientist 06/12/06
  38.   US Democrats seem to reward radicals by betraying moderates 01:25  |  Joseph E . 06/12/06
  39.   the french and the russians are the key 01:33  |  Joey 06/12/06
  40.   Iraq exit strategy should be through Iran 01:41  |  RA 06/12/06
  41.   A JOB WORTH DOING IS WORTH DOING YOURSELF... 01:46  |  bat yam 06/12/06
  42.   #17, Very very very interesting. 01:47  |  Eckedin 06/12/06
  43.   the BULLY and the PUNK... 01:56  |  MIKE KATZ 06/12/06
  44.   #29 Couldn`t have said it better 01:56  |  Eckedin 06/12/06
  45.   Iran doesn`t have a lock on LIARS 02:08  |  Not a liar here! 06/12/06
  46.   "symbolic" sanctions to send strong signal??? 02:10  |  Mark Goodfriend 06/12/06
  47.   Israel is the Bastard son of the US 02:13  |  Rayn Q. 06/12/06
  48.   Bomb the hell out of Iran! 02:18  |  Michael M. 06/12/06
  49.   WHOLE AREA WILL BE DISTROYED 02:36  |  TOBIA 06/12/06
  50.   #28, who is the "me" you are refirring to ballistic? 02:37  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/12/06
  51.   THANK YOU FOR BALLISTIC 02:45  |  TOBIA 06/12/06
  52.   To Matt #23. 03:05  |  Michael M. 06/12/06
  53.   Gates, Asked If Iran is Lying??? 03:16  |  Astasheiks 06/12/06
  54.   Ballistic- Giuliani my next president will know how to deal 04:12  |  Noah 06/12/06
  55.   The Region is Going to Burn 04:16  |  John 06/12/06
  56.   And What If Ahmenjihad Was Assasinated? 05:35  |  Hmm 06/12/06
  57.   To # 42 LOL 05:43  |  Yankelowitz 06/12/06
  58.   to number 47 06:04  |  gg 06/12/06
  59.   Noah and his Guiliani 06:09  |  Iranian-American 06/12/06
  60.   Joey in Geneva, Alabama 06:15  |  Iranian-American 06/12/06
  61.   US will gradually hand over Iraq to Iran #2 06:22  |  Iranian-American 06/12/06
  62.   What`s The End Game In Store? 06:33  |  Yosemite Sam 06/12/06
  63.   The man is simply speaking commonsense 06:52  |  Johnboy 06/12/06
  64.   NUKES and glorification of martyrdom. 08:04  |  PETER SM 06/12/06
  65.   Gates` is a talk of "a shiker", and way ahead of the Holidays 08:34  |  Johnny Walker 06/12/06
  66.   new "arms race" is coming....US and IL defense stocks are a BUY ! 08:47  |  zayyin ba ayin 06/12/06
  67.   where is this article by Yossi Melman ?כך הפסדנו לאיראנים - חדשות 09:00  |  zayyin ba ayin 06/12/06
  68.   For Tobia # 49 09:36  |  Clickfool 06/12/06
  69.   #50 responsse 14:30  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  70.   #54 response 14:42  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  71.   #56 response 14:46  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  72.   #48 response--who is "we" 15:19  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  73.   #39 response 15:24  |  ballistic 06/12/06
  74.   world police tyrants 18:03  |  arab 06/12/06
  75.   Whatever Happens Two Things For Sure! 19:16  |  Yosemite Sam 06/12/06
  76.   Johnboy: u missed the point of "working too hard" on deterrence. 22:24  |  zayyin ba ayin 06/12/06
  77.   Ha`aretz: where is this article by Zvi Bar`el ? פרשנות: לאיראן וס 22:32  |  zayyin ba ayin 06/12/06
 Today Online
Israeli Arabs seek autonomy and veto on government decisions
Responses: 170
Report accuses Hezbollah of being guilty of war crimes
Responses: 86
Egyptians offer to represent Beit Hanun victims at The Hague
Responses: 58
French Jewish groups pay the price for acting like AIPAC
Responses: 98
Rosner: Under what circumstances would the U.S. attack Iran?
Responses: 65
Rosner's Domain
* Poll: New "Madrid Conference", a good idea?
* The abomination debate: Jewish conservatives and gays?
* Does inviting Lieberman to speak legitimize his views?
* Rosner's Guest: Jewish opposition to Zionism


More Headlines
22:50 Probe: IDF top echelons failed at all levels during war
22:51 Report: IDF soldiers captured by Hezbollah badly hurt at time
21:28 U.S. panel: Mideast peace drive may help stabilize Iraq
21:03 France's Chirac calls on Israel to stop IDF flights over Lebanon
20:15 Knesset okays preliminary reading to revoke gay marriage ruling
18:31 UN asks for record $450 million in aid for Palestinians next year
20:12 Man jailed for 9 months for throwing pig's head at mosque
22:43 Two Palestinians wounded by IDF in separate Gaza incidents
17:16 Hirchson overrides Accountant General over local gov't credit
14:33 Defense panel chair proposes opening key debates to public
21:19 Court gives man 10 years for raping woman he met on Internet
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved