Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 14, 2006 Kislev 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:45 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
MK Azmi Bishara. (Itzik Ben-Malki)
Last update - 22:28 05/12/2006
MK Azmi Bishara removed from hearing for profane remark
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent

MK Azmi Bishara (Balad) was removed from a Knesset Legislative Committee session on Tuesday for his use of profane language during an official meeting.

A heated argument broke out between Bishara and MK Gilad Erdan (Likud) at the hearing of a proposed law submitted by MK Zevulun Orlev (National Religious Party) that would allow the Knesset to expel elected members from its ranks.

According to Orlev's proposal, MKs deemed as inciting racial hatred, denouncing Israel's right to exist as a Jewish and democratic country or expressing support of violence against the state or in a terror organization could be voted out of the parliamentary assembly.

Advertisement

Erdan, who was in favor of the proposed law, remarked that "Hitler's government was also democratically elected," and called on the Israeli Arab Bishara to "go preside in a Palestinian or Syrian parliament."

Bishara, who apparently misheard Erdan's remark and confused the Hebrew verb for to preside with the similar sounding Hebrew verb for to procreate, replied by using the f-word and called the Likud member a "dog."

In response, a commotion erupted and the chairman of the committee, MK Menahem Ben-Sasson (Kadima), removed Bishara from the hearing.

Outside the boardroom, Bishara said he misunderstood Ardan's remark and lamented his choice of words in the midst of a heated debate.

Meanwhile, Ben-Sasson rejected Orlev's attempts to postpone the committee vote in order to introduce changes to it that would boost its chances of being approved.

Orlev's proposal was rejected by a majority of 11 to 5.

After the hearing was over, MK Ardan told press he thought MK Bishara's response was uncalled for no matter what he thought he had heard.

Bishara to propose bill to return expropriated land

Bishara submitted a Knesset bill Wednesday that would force the government to return expropriated land to its original owners in specified cases.

According to the proposed law, the property would revert to its owners if after seven years it has not been used for the original purposes intended by the government, or if the original purpose has been changed.

Countless acres of land have been expropriated from Arab and Jewish citizens over the years, and given the status of state land, to be used at the discretion of the government.

In the case of revised uses for the land, the original agreement between the landowner and the government would be examined. If the landowner received compensation, he would be required to return the payment in full.

Bishara said the new law aims to correct a "distortion" in the current land directive established by British Mandatory rule in 1943, and followed to this day by the Supreme Court and the government's legal advisors.

The present directive cuts ties between previous owners and their land, giving the government the power to do whatever it sees fit with the land once the deed is signed.

"We are talking about a matter of public interest of the utmost importance, something the High Court has addressed, and not a new 'Land Day,'" said Bishara, in a reference to an annual day of protests by Israeli Arabs, in part over past land confiscations.

Attorney Suhad Bishara, representing the Adalah Center, a rights advocacy group which deals with land rulings, said the proposal is meant to complement a verdict reached by the High Court, "which clearly states that the bond between the expropriated land and its owners remains even after the land is taken."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The art and war
Suzanne Landau is the second woman to be chosen to curate Israel's pavilion in Venice.
Seniority on the job
Despite living longer, healthier lives, new laws are forcing Israelis to leave the workforce.
  1.   Expropriated Land 14:16  |  EhadHaAm 05/12/06
  2.   Bisharah & Co. 14:41  |  Natan Katzenelson 05/12/06
  3.   What ever happened to... 15:20  |  Asher S 05/12/06
  4.   Justice for all 15:29  |  Rami 05/12/06
  5.   Re: What ever happened to... 15:43  |  SayItAintSo 05/12/06
  6.   #2: Collapse of Israel 15:45  |  Brad 05/12/06
  7.   sure and lets get back all historic jewish lands 15:59  |  ralph 05/12/06
  8.   Uh, expropriated and historic are differed 16:50  |  MC 05/12/06
  9.   #7, I couldn`t have said better 17:31  |  Moshe 05/12/06
  10.   Democracy in Israel 17:35  |  Realist 05/12/06
  11.   Responce to %5 17:37  |  Michael 05/12/06
  12.   #7 17:39  |  friend of ralph 05/12/06
  13.   this is about palestian right of return 17:52  |  zionist forever 05/12/06
  14.   2 Natan, YOU SHOULD BE PRAISING MK BISHARA .... 18:59  |  Dutch 05/12/06
  15.   Arabs: Now return Jewish owned lands 19:00  |  Semsem 05/12/06
  16.   Israeli Democracy 19:55  |  Spike 05/12/06
  17.   Bishara & the 5th column 20:30  |  Trudy 05/12/06
  18.   Remove Arabs from land expropriated by Arab invaders 21:15  |  Bennie 05/12/06
  19.   # 16 / 1/ Spike / Trudy 21:32  |  yuval 05/12/06
  20.   I Cannot BELIEVE What I Just Read !! 23:14  |  Klaudia 05/12/06
  21.   Justice,Justice shall ye seek 23:39  |  krystal 05/12/06
  22.   Well said, Klaudia #20 23:44  |  Realist 05/12/06
  23.   What? It appears that MK Bishara has been receiving etiquitte... 00:16  |  Jacob Blues 06/12/06
  24.   Bishara could be the passive motivator for Palestinians` rights 00:18  |  Bill 06/12/06
  25.   WHAT STOLEN LAND 01:59  |  TOBIA 06/12/06
  26.   Klaudia cannot believe what she just heard? 02:41  |  Marlene 06/12/06
  27.   the crux of the problem 03:51  |  Ishka Bibble 06/12/06
  28.   Let him learn hebrew better instead of causing problems 23:53  |  Steven 06/12/06
  29.   Bishara etc 13:37  |  Hilda 14/12/06
 Today Online
Netanyahu wants Ahmadinejad tried for genocide
Responses: 94
Israel worried Hamas and Iran developing strategic relations
Responses: 52
High Court: Int'l law does not forbid targeted killings
Responses: 37
Rosner: Christmas trees, Menorahs and the shortcut to hell
Responses: 60
Israeli Arabs must realize subverting the state offers no future
Responses: 13
The West has to make Iran pay for its uranium adventure
Responses: 16
Rosner's Domain
* Christmas trees, Menorahs and the shortcut to hell
* Poll: Did Olmert kill Israel's nuclear ambiguity?
* Q&A with Rabbi Epstein on Conservatives and gays
* On Conservative homosexuals and liberal values


More Headlines
13:24 High Court: International law does not forbid targeted killings
13:32 Arab MKs: Ruling on targeted killings authorizes 'war crimes'
13:37 Court orders criminal probe into IDF killing of Rafah girl in 2004
13:16 Sources: IDF kills Palestinian throwing stones in West Bank
13:20 PA intelligence agent linked to Fatah abducted in Gaza City
10:40 Netanyahu wants Iran president tried for genocide at The Hague
08:14 Israel worried Hamas and Iran developing strategic relations
12:06 Peretz orders IDF to crack down on illegal West Bank building
13:34 Olmert: European visit achieved more than 90 percent of its goals
08:33 Israel Medical Association demands NIS 250M more for health basket
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Yad Ezra VeShulamit
This Chanukah gift the gift of a hot meal to a Jewish child
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Menorahs by Judaica Mall
Great selection of Hanukkah gifts
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved