Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 06, 2006 Kislev 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:12 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 09:59 05/12/2006
PM remarks infuriate families of IDF men captive in Lebanon
By Jack Khoury and Gideon Alon, Haaretz Correspondents

Families of the two IDF soldiers captive in Lebanon have strongly criticized Prime Minister Ehud Olmert for remarks in which he said that he would rather they remained in captivity, than for more soldiers to have been killed in a prolonged conflict in Lebanon.

Olmert, speaking to 11th-graders in Nahariya on Monday, also said that Israel lacked solid evidence that Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser, the two reserve soldiers captured by Hezbollah in July, were still alive.

"W

Advertisement

"What should we have done?" Olmert asked. "Keep fighting and maybe create dozens more bereaved families to accelerate the return of two people, and I hope they are still alive, for whom it's a question of spending a little more or a little less time in captivity in the face of the possibility or certainty that many dozens more would be killed in the continued fighting?"

His remarks drew fire from the committee for the soldiers' return.

"We ask that the prime minister say less and do much more to bring about the release of the captives from Lebanon," the committee for the captured soldiers said in a statement.

"The prime minister should be very careful with his words, so that they are not, heaven forbid, misinterpreted."

Olmert made the remarks during a meeting with 11th-graders from the Amal Nahariya high school, in response to a question about the cabinet's decision to end the war despite the fact that the kidnapped soldiers had not been released.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
State of illegality
The illegal aliens bill is tainted by considerable hypocrisy, self-righteousness.
News or ads?
At Israel's largest paper Yedioth Ahronoth, the line is becoming increasingly blurred.
  1.   Unbelievable! 05:21  |  Westwell 05/12/06
  2.   If soldiers are not released, HIZB should know THE STONE AGE 05:30  |  Vittorio 05/12/06
  3.   Lebanon 05:41  |  Rabbi Lazaros 05/12/06
  4.   Olmert needs to be replaced 07:05  |  kipperaes 05/12/06
  5.   Does Olmert Think ALL the Jews are Stupid? 07:10  |  Ben Israel 05/12/06
  6.   What a Jobnik 07:10  |  Amnon 05/12/06
  7.   Olmert the Hypocrite 07:10  |  FNU LNU 05/12/06
  8.   # 1 you took the words 07:26  |  wow 05/12/06
  9.   seniora and olmert 07:32  |  lebanese 05/12/06
  10.   imagine all the people 07:41  |  beiruti 05/12/06
  11.   imagine all the people 07:47  |  beiruti 05/12/06
  12.   imagine 07:48  |  beiruti 05/12/06
  13.   Vittorio 07:50  |  maoriboy 05/12/06
  14.   What an A****le! 07:51  |  David 05/12/06
  15.   What `s Next, Out of This Leftist Lawyer`s Mouth ?... 07:53  |  Klaudia 05/12/06
  16.   Olmert is right 07:55  |  pali 05/12/06
  17.   You are all wrong 08:06  |  A.M. 05/12/06
  18.   #5, Olmert thinks everyone is stupid 08:08  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/06
  19.   Olmert Has the Midas Touch..IN REVERSE 08:15  |  Klaudia 05/12/06
  20.   Olmert: Two captive soldiers better than more dead ones 08:27  |  Simon 05/12/06
  21.   Two Soldiers 08:31  |  Ali 05/12/06
  22.   Resounding proof of Olmert`s unfitness as PM 08:36  |  Dr. L. Brnd 05/12/06
  23.   To #17, A.M. 08:37  |  FNU LNU 05/12/06
  24.   ANOTHER STUPID REMARK BY AN IMPOTENT LEADER. 08:41  |  Robert 05/12/06
  25.   Olmerts sons 08:59  |  g.e. 05/12/06
  26.   Soldiers´sacrifice? 10:02  |  Anne 05/12/06
  27.   He is a total disgrace to the nation... 10:24  |  Zalmi 05/12/06
  28.   Olmert is not like the others were 10:38  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/06
  29.   Olmert ,etc. = dog and pony show 10:43  |  Julie 05/12/06
  30.   Olmert is right, yet is so wrong 10:44  |  Chuck 05/12/06
  31.   What he should have done 10:57  |  sh 05/12/06
  32.   In that case why start the war at all? 10:58  |  Danny -Israeli one 05/12/06
  33.   Saniora vs. Nasrallah 11:20  |  Sami - Lebanese 05/12/06
  34.   klaudia 11:28  |  A.M. 05/12/06
  35.   SHOW SOME UNITY!! 11:39  |  lay 05/12/06
  36.   Captive Soldiers 11:42  |  Robert Firth 05/12/06
  37.   Israel elected Olmert 11:53  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  38.   Olmert is Right 12:14  |  koos koos 05/12/06
  39.   Say no to War! 12:19  |  koos koos 05/12/06
  40.   Olmert & the captived soldiers 12:27  |  northern neighbor 05/12/06
  41.   2 other Ron Arads ? 12:35  |  Lebanese maronite 05/12/06
  42.   Difficulties Olmert had and Stupidities he has 12:52  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/12/06
  43.   Olmert sacrificing Jewish life 12:55  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  44.   # 27- AM 13:05  |  Klaudia 05/12/06
  45.   who would not be infuriated, Olmert is destroying Israel`s morale 13:09  |  Pablo 05/12/06
  46.   None concern for soldiers/ citizens. 13:20  |  H.H.M 05/12/06
  47.   Nasrallah 13:34  |  Zobaida 05/12/06
  48.   11th Graders 13:36  |  Victor Smolinsky 05/12/06
  49.   To Cipora about Olmert #28 13:46  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  50.   First rule of the military 14:04  |  Chris Linthwaite 05/12/06
  51.   Olmert 14:19  |  Rod 05/12/06
  52.   Anguish of the captive`s families 14:30  |  Hem 05/12/06
  53.   Democratic terrorists 14:33  |  Lebanese maronite 05/12/06
  54.   Lebanese maronite 14:54  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/12/06
  55.   #9:lebanese - A much better idea... 15:27  |  bat yam 05/12/06
  56.   28 Cipora. Perfect comparison and description of Olmert... 15:36  |  bat yam 05/12/06
  57.   New government please - the sooner the better 15:38  |  Karen R 05/12/06
  58.   To Lebanese moronite (#53) 15:40  |  imad 05/12/06
  59.   To Jonathan S/43 15:44  |  Lena 05/12/06
  60.   The first rule of military 15:54  |  Anne 05/12/06
  61.   Our naked and unempathetic emperor 15:58  |  Tosefta 05/12/06
  62.   To Lena about a big misconception 16:04  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  63.   What about the families of those who died??? 16:06  |  r 05/12/06
  64.   Olmert is technically correct... 16:19  |  Guess who 05/12/06
  65.   Ronnie Wolman 16:22  |  Walid 05/12/06
  66.   To Jonathan S 16:28  |  Lena 05/12/06
  67.   To Lebanese Maronite #53 - I hope you like Dubai 16:33  |  Amnon 05/12/06
  68.   #64 -Int. Law 16:46  |  Julie 05/12/06
  69.   Perplexed Israelis 16:48  |  Walid 05/12/06
  70.   Some clarifications to Lena 17:06  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  71.   Israeli Terrorist 17:17  |  Point Blank 05/12/06
  72.   To Amnon 17:32  |  Lebanese maronite 05/12/06
  73.   Walid:Recognition 17:43  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/12/06
  74.   #63 r 18:01  |  Chris Linthwaite 05/12/06
  75.   Julie #68 18:10  |  Guess who 05/12/06
  76.   Ronnie Wolman 18:28  |  sh 05/12/06
  77.   Walid, there are things you don`t understand 18:38  |  sh 05/12/06
  78.   OF COURSE, OLMERT IS RIGHT! 18:38  |  Dutch 05/12/06
  79.   Sh 19:52  |  Walid 05/12/06
  80.   Ronnie Wolman 20:11  |  Walid 05/12/06
  81.   Walid 20:59  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/12/06
  82.   #49, Jonathan S 21:12  |  Cipora Julianna Koh 05/12/06
  83.   Walid 21:30  |  ODP 05/12/06
  84.   Jasmine Murphy 21:58  |  Walid 05/12/06
  85.   Ronnie Wolman and WALID and NADAV 22:11  |  GABE1 05/12/06
  86.   sh #77 22:20  |  Gabe1 05/12/06
  87.   A.M. 22:27  |  Gabe1 05/12/06
  88.   ODP 22:35  |  Walid 05/12/06
  89.   Walid-PLEASE 22:36  |  Gabe1 05/12/06
  90.   ODP 22:39  |  Gabe1 05/12/06
  91.   ODP 22:59  |  Walid 05/12/06
  92.   80. Walid re Ronnie Wolman 23:17  |  KUTW 05/12/06
  93.   78. Dutch: Right or wrong 23:20  |  KUTW 05/12/06
  94.   Walid: Selective Choices 23:38  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/12/06
  95.   Walid 23:55  |  ODP 05/12/06
  96.   Gabe1 00:08  |  ODP 06/12/06
  97.   Gabe1 #87 00:14  |  Guess who 06/12/06
  98.   Walid #88 00:26  |  Guess who 06/12/06
  99.   I WILL SAY IT AGAIN 00:35  |  Dr David I. Gross 06/12/06
  100.   Sh: Shhhhhhhhh!!!! 00:48  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/12/06
  101.   Gabe1 00:53  |  sh 06/12/06
  102.   PM`s remarks 01:12  |  Isaac 06/12/06
  103.   vittorio 01:28  |  Omar 06/12/06
  104.   SH 95 02:31  |  Gabe1 06/12/06
  105.   Gabe 1, I never called Walid a "moderate". What I said, if I 05:20  |  Nadav 06/12/06
  106.   Walid, you still have to do your homework about who we, Israelis, 05:31  |  Nadav 06/12/06
  107.   To Nadav 06:50  |  Pierre 06/12/06
  108.   Guess Who 08:01  |  Walid 06/12/06
  109.   Pierr, I assume you express pain, and if so, I share much of it 08:34  |  Nadav 06/12/06
  110.   Walid, in order to expell us from a 40 sq kms one does not need 08:42  |  Nadav 06/12/06
  111.   Walid 09:07  |  Jasmine Murphy 06/12/06
  112.   Kim, I blame Israel`s aggressive policies... 09:11  |  Dutch 06/12/06
  113.   Sanioura`s Resistance of tyranny 10:45  |  Lebanese Shiite 06/12/06
  114.   Nadav #110 18:07  |  Guess who 06/12/06
 Today Online
Egyptians offer to represent Beit Hanun victims at The Hague
Responses: 46
Amira Hass: Israel's cruelty toward Palestinian prisoners
Responses: 37
Report accuses Hezbollah of being guilty of war crimes
Responses: 73
French Jewish groups pay the price for acting like AIPAC
Responses: 60
Rosner: Under what circumstances would the U.S. attack Iran?
Responses: 42
Israeli Arabs seek autonomy and veto on government decisions
Responses: 113
Rosner's Domain
* The abomination debate: Will Jewish conservatives accept gays?
* Baker-Hamilton, the false debate
* Does inviting Lieberman to speak legitimize his views?
* Rosner's Guest: Jewish opposition to Zionism


More Headlines
18:07 U.S. panel: Mideast peace drive may help stabilize Iraq
17:49 Knesset okays preliminary reading to revoke gay marriage ruling
17:51 UN asks for record $450 million in aid for Palestinians next year
16:35 Two Palestinians wounded by IDF in separate Gaza incidents
17:39 France and Israel fail to resolve dispute on Lebanon overflights
17:16 Hirchson overrides Accountant General over local gov't credit
16:52 Peretz: Talks on prisoner exchanges must be kept out of public eye
14:33 Defense panel chair proposes opening key debates to public
18:03 Report accuses Hezbollah of war crimes, hiding among civilians
14:39 State demolishes 17 houses in unrecognized Bedouin village in Negev
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved