Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 13, 2006 Kislev 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:52 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 17:13 05/12/2006
Israel offers to free 1,000 in exchange for release of Shalit
By Avi Issacharoff and Akiva Eldar, Haaretz Correspondents

A senior Israeli source said Monday that the total number of prisoners that Israel would be willing to exchange for captive IDF soldier Gilad Shalit is some 1,000.

Israel is expecting that progress will be achieved on the negotiations for Shalit's release as a result of the meeting between Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh and exiled Hamas political bureau chief Khaled Meshal, in Damascus on Monday.

The two Hamas leaders were expected to have reached an agreement on the deal that is being negotiated for the release of Shalit in exchange for the freeing of many Palestinian prisoners.

Advertisement

On Tuesday cabinet minister and former senior Shin Bet official Gideon Ezra of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's Kadima party, has proposed releasing imprisoned Fatah-Tanzim leader Marwan Barghouti in exchange for Shalit and a pledge to continue the cease-fire.

Ezra said Barghouti's release could reduce terror and strengthen Fatah as a moderate factor

Israel informed Egypt's intelligence chief, Omar Suleiman, of its willingness to release prisoners, during meetings the Egyptian mediator held in Israel last week, a senior source in Jerusalem said Monday.

"We agreed to release several hundred women and children, mostly the young among them," the Israeli source said. "We have also agreed to release several hundred [adult male] Palestinian prisoners, among them prisoners sentenced to many years in prison," he added.

The senior Israeli source said that the total number of prisoners that Israel would be willing to release "revolves around one thousand. We have made the figure clear to Egypt and they know our stance. The prisoners will be released in a number of stages, women and children during the first stage.

Three days ago, Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak confirmed that Israel will have to release women and children as part of a deal for the release of Shalit, even before he is handed back to Israel.

According to Egypt's plan, the first stage of the exchange will include the transfer of Shalit to Egypt, in return for the women and children. At the second stage, Shalit will be returned to Israel, in return for another group of prisoners. At the third stage, another group of Palestinian prisoners will be released.

However, any such deal is still being delayed by Hamas, the Israeli source says.

"The reason for the delay is not clear to us, but it is possible that the difficulties in establishing a government of national unity is undermining the completion of the deal," he said.

"It is hard to envision a scenario in which Israel agrees to release Marwan Barghouti [a leading Fatah figure sentenced for his role in the deaths of Israelis] but in any case, it should be understood that names have not been discussed at this point. We have only talked about numbers," the Israeli source added.

Other sources added that so far Hamas has not presented the mediators with a list of names of prisoners they would like released.

However, the same source said that the name of Barghouti will be on such a list.

Mediators also confirm that in their indirect negotiations, Israel and Hamas have not discussed names of prisoners that would be freed, only numbers. However, they said that there is a huge gap between the claims each side is making on the number of prisoners that are to be released in exchange for Shalit.

"Israel has agreed to release about 300 prisoners," the mediators say. "Hamas is demanding about 1400, including women and children. Suleiman has asked Israel to raise the figure, but to date we have not received a clear answer on this request."

The mediators also said that "there is no problem over the way the stages are divided or the timing of the prisoner release, all of which has already been agreed upon."

The same sources also said that in their view, Hamas would be willing to accept a figure lower than 1,400 prisoners.

According to other sources, the difference between the Hamas demands and Israel's position does not exceed several hundred prisoners.

The Palestinian prime minister met on Monday with Syrian President Bashar Assad, and reports from Damascus said that the meeting focused on the efforts of Palestinians to establish a government of national unity.

During his visit to Damascus, the first since he became prime minister earlier this year, Haniye said that the dialogue for a unity government must go on.

"If there are any sides among the Palestinians who wish to put an end to the talks, they will be the ones responsible for the failure of the talks," he warned.

Meanwhile, sources who follow the talks between Haniye and Meshal said that Hamas is willing to lower the number of prisoners whose release the group is demanding in return for Shalit.

However, Hamas is demanding that the deal also include prisoners who have been sentenced to long terms in prison and who are senior members of the organization.

A senior source in Jerusalem told Haaretz Monday that there are no guarantees that Meshal will authorize the deal, since he is under pressure from Iran and Syria, neither of which is interested in any development that will allow the creation of a unity government in the Palestinian Authority along guidelines put forth by Chairman Mahmoud Abbas.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Comedy of errors
At Egypt's film festival, so much went wrong that no one bothered to critique the films.
Navigating at sea
An old nautical legend tells of a man who sailed from Haifa to Cyprus without a map.
  1.   Beautiful Lies.. 04:01  |  Ahmed 05/12/06
  2.   Beautiful Lies.. 2 04:08  |  Ahmed 05/12/06
  3.   Why not Marwan Barghouti? 04:20  |  Palestinian 05/12/06
  4.   Why so many children in prisons? 04:22  |  Mike 05/12/06
  5.   for Shalit 04:28  |  Akiva Patysh, Tzioni 05/12/06
  6.   ahmed 04:32  |  bev 05/12/06
  7.   THOSE CHILDREN FUTURE HAVE BEEN RUINED BY ISRAEL 04:35  |  indrajaya 05/12/06
  8.   FREE ALL JAILED PALESTINIANS 04:40  |  MOE 05/12/06
  9.   More Olmert Appeasement 04:43  |  Sam Weinstein 05/12/06
  10.   Beautiful Lies 04:45  |  Joy 05/12/06
  11.   Mucho bonito lies 05:08  |  Ahmed the Fat 05/12/06
  12.   Ahmed. Women and children have been used by your Palestinian Arab 05:11  |  Nadav 05/12/06
  13.   Thats a days arrest. 05:15  |  billy jack 05/12/06
  14.   Ahmed has so much anger at Jews 05:18  |  Yosef 05/12/06
  15.   their crime is 05:20  |  God 05/12/06
  16.   The truth will wait for all of us, Ahmed 05:21  |  Itamar 05/12/06
  17.   #1+2 Ahmed, There are so many flaws in your arguments part 1 05:24  |  Daniel Friedman 05/12/06
  18.   ahmed argument flaws part2 05:34  |  Daniel Friedman 05/12/06
  19.   #4 - Mike`s monstrous question 05:34  |  SG 05/12/06
  20.   ahmed 05:36  |  duncan 05/12/06
  21.   #1 - Ahmed`s ugly lies and true 05:38  |  SG 05/12/06
  22.   To Mike - Children prisoners 05:39  |  Alex 05/12/06
  23.   mike 05:40  |  duncan 05/12/06
  24.   Why Does America Support this Banana state? 05:40  |  Natallie Durson 05/12/06
  25.   a DEAL, or not a DEAL, give STONE AGE AS RESPONSE TO ANY VIOLENCE 05:42  |  Vittorio 05/12/06
  26.   ahmed argument flaws part 3 05:42  |  Daniel Friedman 05/12/06
  27.   To #3 05:43  |  Alex 05/12/06
  28.   A final point 05:45  |  Daniel Friedman 05/12/06
  29.   Foolish deal 05:47  |  Rabbi Lazaros 05/12/06
  30.   THIS IS NOT RIGHT 05:56  |  indrajaya 05/12/06
  31.   THIS IS NOT RIGHT 05:56  |  indrajaya 05/12/06
  32.   kidnapped civil palestinians 05:57  |  arab 05/12/06
  33.   Prisoners swap is more like Potato Tomato Exchange 06:01  |  Abu Samra 05/12/06
  34.   Just and Lasting Peace with clean Jails 06:04  |  Abu Samra 05/12/06
  35.   both sides should 06:08  |  matt 05/12/06
  36.   indrajaya: Read Quran,, don`t bother Israelis 06:23  |  vittorio 05/12/06
  37.   Prisoners 06:24  |  Clausewitz 05/12/06
  38.   Ahmed #1 and 2 06:35  |  Maureen Ann 05/12/06
  39.   #9Joy and the soldiers from your country and mine... 06:45  |  Maureen Ann 05/12/06
  40.   Ahmed. You are a good man pure of heart. God bless you. 06:57  |  Timothy 05/12/06
  41.   #16 Denial Friedman presumes murder without evidence 07:16  |  Pablo B 05/12/06
  42.   Just and lasting peace with clean Jails (part1) 07:22  |  Abu Samra 05/12/06
  43.   Mr. Friedman #16 07:27  |  Philistine 05/12/06
  44.   22 Alex Israeli double standard defining children 07:34  |  Pablo B 05/12/06
  45.   SG 07:36  |  Mike 05/12/06
  46.   Denial Friedman missed the lessons of WWII, Holocaust 07:49  |  Pablo B 05/12/06
  47.   #41+43 who responded to me 07:50  |  Daniel Friedman 05/12/06
  48.   # 36, VITTORIO, GRACIAS SENOR 07:52  |  indrajaya 05/12/06
  49.   Don`t release murderess Mona either 07:57  |  Ilan 05/12/06
  50.   Alex`s Comment 08:00  |  Mike 05/12/06
  51.   Natalie Durson 08:02  |  Connie 05/12/06
  52.   Human Right Watch & co 08:08  |  Suzanne 05/12/06
  53.   @ Pablo ref age differences 08:10  |  Suzanne 05/12/06
  54.   Daniel Friedman doesn`t know the count 08:28  |  Pablo B 05/12/06
  55.   1000 new suicide bombers on the way 08:33  |  BradL 05/12/06
  56.   Word to Mr. Friedman #47 08:34  |  Philistine 05/12/06
  57.   Release children to become homicide bombers? 09:29  |  Bennie 05/12/06
  58.   No problem for Israel at all 09:35  |  Clickfool 05/12/06
  59.   To Maureen Ann, Natallie, Pablo. Crimes & Punishment 09:48  |  Altalena 05/12/06
  60.   Children. 10:02  |  David Nigel BRaham 05/12/06
  61.   As they say on exam papers: "DISCUSS...." 10:05  |  Clickfool 05/12/06
  62.   For Bennie in Jerusalem # 57 10:09  |  Clickfool 05/12/06
  63.   Response to Clickfool No. 58 10:18  |  Natan 05/12/06
  64.   #46, Pablo B 10:27  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/06
  65.   All 10500 10:37  |  dav 05/12/06
  66.   Everyday we hear same news about releasing PA prisoners 11:04  |  Tamir Gaza 05/12/06
  67.   madness I: 1000 and one 11:26  |  luriah 05/12/06
  68.   To Clickfool 11:40  |  Daniel King 05/12/06
  69.   BURP 11:55  |  anon ymus 05/12/06
  70.   Collaboration between Haaretz and Olmert? 12:01  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  71.   several hundred women and children ? 12:05  |  viper 05/12/06
  72.   re: Nadav #12 12:07  |  Paulo 05/12/06
  73.   re: BradL #55 12:11  |  Paulo 05/12/06
  74.   Ahmed/ women in prison 12:42  |  Maya Roth 05/12/06
  75.   Nataliie Durson, I realize you have nothing positive to say about 12:45  |  Nadav 05/12/06
  76.   #24 Why Does America Support this Banana state? 13:02  |  Hubal 05/12/06
  77.   For Daniel King # 62 13:06  |  Clickfool