Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 06, 2006 Kislev 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:37 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Six comments on the situation
By Yoel Marcus

1. When the first Gulf War ended in 1991, Amnon Lipkin-Shahak, then chief of military intelligence, was asked why the Americans didn't finish off Saddam Hussein. His answer was prophetic: Better a live Saddam, slightly battered, than a dead one. Only he can prevent a battle of Gog and Magog between the Sunnis and the Shi'ites. Too bad Bush junior didn't consult Lipkin-Shahak before invading Iraq.

We are living in a region where outside military intervention triggers earthquakes. Operation Peace for Galilee roused the Shi'ites from their slumber and gave rise to the establishment of Hezbollah. Lebanon War II led Lebanon to the brink of civil war.

And yet the predictions of war this summer are stirring up needless panic around here. If anyone should be worried about Iran it should be Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Egypt and, of course, the United States. How many times do we have to get our teeth knocked in before we understand there are some things we need to keep our noses out of?

Advertisement

2. In another seven months, the occupation will be 40 years old. Israel today is the only democratic country in the world that continues to rule over the land of another people. Standing over David Ben-Gurion's grave, Ehud Olmert made a commitment from which there is no return. How right Ben-Gurion was when he declared, the moment the Six-Day War was over, that now was the time to give it all back. But we have been wandering in a desert of illusion for 40 years, and they have been marching nowhere in blood and fire for 40 years. Enough is enough. Let's make Olmert keep his word. He needs that Nobel Prize badly, to pay for his new digs.

3. Olmert did somersaults to prevent the establishment of a state commission to probe who was responsible for screwing up the war. Instead, he established an investigation committee headed by retired judge Eliyahu Winograd. The difference between the two is that a state commission is appointed by the president of the Supreme Court, while the Winograd Committee is government-appointed. Another difference is that a state commission would have binding authority over the political echelon, whereas the government can adopt the resolutions of the Winograd Committee or ignore them, as it sees fit. Last week, the Supreme Court rejected the petition submitted by opponents of the Winograd Committee in a majority vote of 4-3. Between the lines, one could see that the judges were not all that happy with their decision. But if anyone came out badly, it was Winograd himself. He was portrayed as a softy who will never confront the government or declare it responsible for the mess. On this point, the masterminds of the war and its muck ups may be in for a surprise.

4. As it does every year on November 29, the United Nations General Assembly convened and roundly condemned the State of Israel. 157 countries voted against us, and 10 voted in our favor, among them such superpowers as the Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Naura and Palau. What the delegates of the international community seem to have forgotten is that this same assembly voted to establish two states ? one Jewish and one Arab. We agreed to accept the little that was offered to us, whereas the Arabs gave up the chance for independence, remaining under Jordanian control, and then ours. Will we ever see the day when the UN assembles on November 29 to condemn the Arab countries for forcing their Palestinian brothers to give up a state of their own and go down in history as compulsive opportunity-losers?

5. The escape of Benny Sela the rapist reminds me of those slapstick scenes from the days of the silent movies where bumbling police officers run around chasing one another and falling out of their cars while the robbers are long gone, lazing around the campfire in another city. The intolerable ease with which Sela made his break is driving the police nuts. They're all over Tel Aviv, spinning like tops, prancing on their horses, flitting around in helicopters, parading in their fancy get-up with their guns at the ready. As if the rapist were waiting for them in Kikar Hamedina, all set to go back to jail. Sela will be caught in the end, of that I'm sure. Arcadi Gaydamak just needs to put a big enough price on his head.

6. What a terrible shame that Uri Geller, the spoon-bender doesn't live in Israel. With skills like his, we have the perfect job waiting for him in the President's Residence.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
State of illegality
The illegal aliens bill is tainted by considerable hypocrisy, self-righteousness.
News or ads?
At Israel's largest paper Yedioth Ahronoth, the line is becoming increasingly blurred.
  1.   Give us our state first before you make comments 10:45  |  Tamir Gaza 05/12/06
  2.   markus is gradually turning anti semite 11:18  |  fassoulius 05/12/06
  3.   Israeli soil 11:28  |  Josef 05/12/06
  4.   the little that was offered? 11:48  |  whodey 05/12/06
  5.   Total Nonsense-Marcus Did You Get Past The First Grade? 11:50  |  Ben Israel 05/12/06
  6.   If it quacks like a Zionist 11:53  |  Natallie Durson 05/12/06
  7.   What About US Control Of Iraq? 11:57  |  Victor Smolinsky 05/12/06
  8.   Point 4 is a total crock 12:05  |  Marilyn 05/12/06
  9.   Egypt refused Gaza`s return 12:06  |  Joe 05/12/06
  10.   Marcus` creation Olmert chastised by Marcus,pitiful toothless soo 12:13  |  Absolute Sweden 05/12/06
  11.   "The only democracy" lie 13:12  |  David Teich 05/12/06
  12.   6 misconceptions about the situation 13:13  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  13.   The ONLY Thing the Pals Have Going for Them is the " Occupation " 13:15  |  Klaudia 05/12/06
  14.   the swine`s snout 13:19  |  eliXelx 05/12/06
  15.   tamir gaza 13:31  |  saul a. readner 05/12/06
  16.   Some clarifications about the situation 13:34  |  Jonathan S 05/12/06
  17.   Marilyn 13:42  |  Sarah 05/12/06
  18.   On Point One 13:43  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/12/06
  19.   Yoel Marcus is a great antisemit joker ! :-0) 13:47  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  20.   Nattalie Durson 13:52  |  Sarah 05/12/06
  21.   i don`t understand... 14:06  |  saul a. readner 05/12/06
  22.   When did the green line become the border? 14:07  |  Sidney 05/12/06
  23.   no palestinian state until... 14:09  |  bounce 05/12/06
  24.   Reply to Marilyn: read a bit more! 14:11  |  Joe 05/12/06
  25.   unwittingly simple and shallow obsevations 14:15  |  Akiva Patysh, Tzioni 05/12/06
  26.   Hi Akiva how are you? 14:41  |  Ronnie Wolman 05/12/06
  27.   Now there`s an incentive to achieve comprehensive peace... 14:48  |  Smadar 05/12/06
  28.   Following the lead of Jonathan S in #6 15:03  |  Sidney 05/12/06
  29.   if it quaks like a zionist #6 15:06  |  zionist forever 05/12/06
  30.   ben gourion (to marilyn) 15:10  |  A.M. 05/12/06
  31.   mainstream Jewish journalism 15:10  |  Robert Jewish Voice 05/12/06
  32.   # 6 If it quacks like an anti-Semite 15:17  |  Paul Henzen 05/12/06
  33.   What about New Caledonia? 15:18  |  Gene 05/12/06
  34.   MARCUS, SIR 15:20  |  indrajaya 05/12/06
  35.   to tamir gaza 15:24  |  saul a. readner 05/12/06
  36.   Uri Geller can`t help Israel, only courage and wisdom will ! 15:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/12/06
  37.   To # 20 Sarah, be more inspired ! 15:39  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  38.   And Those Whor Refer to Wandering in hte Desert of Illusion 15:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/12/06
  39.   To # 24 Joe. Read history better 15:53  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  40.   Israel only country threatened with genocidal extinction 15:58  |  MG 05/12/06
  41.   #37 you do not make any sense 16:09  |  Bob 05/12/06
  42.   MG: "Genocidal War"????? #40 16:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 05/12/06
  43.   For Sarah and for #32 16:25  |  Natallie Durson 05/12/06
  44.   Israel as a democracy 16:43  |  Clickfool 05/12/06
  45.   #43 SO WHAT? 16:53  |  Bob 05/12/06
  46.   Yaakov Sullivan 16:54  |  ODP 05/12/06
  47.   To # 41 You are entirely irrelevant (Part 1) 16:56  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  48.   It only takes one Arab victory 16:59  |  Walter 05/12/06
  49.   To # 43 Nattalie : a minor detail... 17:03  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  50.   Occupation is Destroying Israel 17:11  |  Jane 05/12/06
  51.   to the saul a readner thats not true 17:14  |  Tamir Gaza 05/12/06
  52.   Mr Marcus needs an education 17:16  |  Gee 05/12/06
  53.   what kind of state is it?? 17:18  |  King 05/12/06
  54.   #52 17:36  |  King 05/12/06
  55.   Jewish rightwing (Zealots) 17:41  |  Robert Jewish Voice 05/12/06
  56.   Natallie Durson 17:53  |  Paul Henzen 05/12/06
  57.   Paul Henzen 18:04  |  Robert Jewish Voice 05/12/06
  58.   #47 stop reading crap and start learning history 18:08  |  bob 05/12/06
  59.   again to tamir gaza 18:11  |  saul a. readner 05/12/06
  60.   Re: Tamir Gaza 18:12  |  Morris 05/12/06
  61.   to king 18:13  |  saul a. readner 05/12/06
  62.   again to king 18:17  |  saul a. readner 05/12/06
  63.   King -- isn`t a starter state better than none? 18:28  |  bbl 05/12/06
  64.   Tamir #51 -- Are you serious? 18:36  |  bbl 05/12/06
  65.   US rules occupied territories too 18:44  |  Victor Chavez 05/12/06
  66.   To 50 Jane. Occupation 18:46  |  Altalena 05/12/06
  67.   #58 bob and Mark Twain 18:51  |  Boycott 05/12/06
  68.   To Gee 19:04  |  EV 05/12/06
  69.   Confusion down under (Marilyn #8; AM #30) 19:12  |  Tosefta 05/12/06
  70.   All the bad history quoted here 19:29  |  Sidney 05/12/06
  71.   re #4: be honest with yourself 19:39  |  Colin Wright 05/12/06
  72.   Genocide is a loaded term that should be used with exterm cautioe 19:51  |  Yaakoiv Sullivan 05/12/06
  73.   To Boycott. Mark Tawin, Lamartine, etc 19:56  |  Altalena 05/12/06
  74.   Iran 20:14  |  Shlomo 05/12/06
  75.   #67 apples and oranges 20:15  |  Bob 05/12/06
  76.   `Democracy` a la Israel 20:39  |  tbora 05/12/06
  77.   Yet another leftist Arab apologist?!! 20:42  |  Yaakov K. 05/12/06
  78.   #47: Please learn history 20:43  |  Morris 05/12/06
  79.   Dino #36 20:51  |  Gabe1 05/12/06
  80.   Ronnie Wolman 20:54  |  Walid 05/12/06
  81.   Democracy Isn`t a Recipe for Collective Suicide 21:05  |  massaraksh 05/12/06
  82.   #61 21:14  |  King 05/12/06
  83.   Sidney #28 Talk about bad geography 21:15  |  Debbie 05/12/06
  84.   Bush Junior Must`ve Listened to Shimon Peres 21:18  |  massaraksh 05/12/06
  85.   bob-history-allay my doubts 21:25  |  reimarus 05/12/06
  86.   #76 Hello, Al Qaeda 21:26  |  Bob 05/12/06
  87.   saul a readner you wronge again 21:32  |  Tamir Gaza 05/12/06
  88.   #24 Joe, Jews should also have Iraq 21:44  |  Janice 05/12/06
  89.   Excuse me? 21:47  |  Paul Freedman 05/12/06
  90.   King #54 21:58  |  Gee 05/12/06
  91.   Victor Chavez #65 22:01  |  Gee 05/12/06
  92.   EV #68 22:02  |  Gee 05/12/06
  93.   There is no such thing as "land of a people" 22:04  |  AA 05/12/06
  94.   Nattalie Durson 22:05  |  Sarah 05/12/06
  95.   #81 good for you 22:08  |  Bob 05/12/06
  96.   KICKOUT THE ARAB SQUATTERS BACK TO ARABIA 22:10  |  Sheffield Untd 05/12/06
  97.   Yankelowich 22:11  |  Sarah 05/12/06
  98.   #82 what about Native People? 22:12  |  Bob 05/12/06
  99.   the problem is ..... 22:14  |  george 05/12/06
  100.   Marcus - A Complete Dip---- 22:15  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/12/06
  101.   The only land? 22:23  |  Mr. D 05/12/06
  102.   I just wonder 22:24  |  Joe 05/12/06
  103.   South Israel 22:33  |  Ben 05/12/06
  104.   # 79 Gabe 1 22:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 05/12/06
  105.   occupation is relative 22:55  |  frank 05/12/06
  106.   It wasnt the UN to give. 23:05  |  Billy Jack 05/12/06
  107.   `No other democracy occupies.." Journalistic fraud. 23:09  |  Dr. L. Brnd 05/12/06
  108.   Generally on the mark. Therefore, condemned.. 23:14  |  Tony Price 05/12/06
  109.   To # 73 Rubbish : better entertain Roger Cukierman... :-0) 23:19  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  110.   Whodey & Marilyn: spot on. Shame on you, Yoel... 23:26  |  Kol ha-Nevi`im 05/12/06
  111.   To # 78 Was G.d wrong ? 23:29  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  112.   To # 86 "Bob" the Jew ! lol 23:36  |  Yankelowitz 05/12/06
  113.   Ben Israel 23:36  |  Stephen 05/12/06
  114.   #6, Natallie Durson 23:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/12/06
  115.   #107 Dr. L Brnd 23:59  |  Johnboy 05/12/06
  116.   Too Much Ado About Nothing 00:03  |  massaraksh 06/12/06
  117.   To # 88 Janice : Indeed, I agree with you 00:11  |  Yankelowitz 06/12/06
  118.   and again to tamir gaza 00:14  |  saul a. readner 06/12/06
  119.   and again to king 00:26  |  saul a. readner 06/12/06
  120.   state within a State 00:38  |  Jeff 06/12/06
  121.   Gaza remains occupied 00:42  |  Meena 06/12/06
  122.   Dino 01:51  |  Gabe1 06/12/06
  123.   Israel is NOT the only democracy occupying land(US occupies Iraq) 02:01  |  Moshe 06/12/06
  124.   Reply to Klaudia, No 13 02:13  |  Abe 06/12/06
  125.   What about Great Britain, France and Spain then? 02:32  |  Victor 06/12/06
  126.   Sahrah To whom did it belong? 03:02  |  John 06/12/06
  127.   Israel`s not a democracy, the majority does not want Olmert 03:21  |  Ignacio 06/12/06
  128.   40th year in the desert 03:33  |  mike g 06/12/06
  129.   #117 Moshe, his claim is more complicated than you think 03:38  |  Johnboy 06/12/06
  130.   reply to Victor re: U.S. occupying Iraq 03:47  |  Richie 06/12/06
  131.   Natillie 04:55  |  John 06/12/06
  132.   ToSaul a reader 05:05  |  John 06/12/06
  133.   #88 - Janice - There is a difference 05:29  |  * BEN JABO 06/12/06
  134.   Isreal the only democracy 05:59  |  ron 06/12/06
  135.   marcus `s history lesson 07:07  |  NATHAN FRIEDMAN 06/12/06
  136.   the better half 08:31  |  CommonSense 06/12/06
  137.   to john 08:44  |  saul a. readner 06/12/06
  138.   bob blum 08:49  |  i thought-enlighten 06/12/06
  139.   To no.2 08:51  |  raj 06/12/06
  140.   Statute of limitations on occupation? 08:58  |  FOX 06/12/06
  141.   Common sense - perpetuating the myth 09:15  |  whodey 06/12/06
  142.   Israel as a democracy 09:22  |  Gershon 06/12/06
  143.   127: Ignacio, you`d do better in Lebanon 09:23  |  David Teich 06/12/06
  144.   Common sense - ruling the hilltops 09:45  |  whodey 06/12/06
  145.   The land is everybody`s 09:49  |  Fredrik 06/12/06
  146.   #145 Frederik 10:14  |  whodey 06/12/06
  147.   Greenland, Inuits, Puerto Rico, Washington DC... 10:58  |  DJStahl 06/12/06
  148.   Gershon: High praise for Israel from a dhimmi-wit 11:35  |  Kol ha-Nevi`im 06/12/06
  149.   Gershon: BTW, I noticed that you don`t live here... 11:45  |  Kol ha-Nevi`im 06/12/06
  150.   Frederick #145 13:56  |  FOX 06/12/06
  151.   Yaakov, mixing intelligence with nonsense 14:20  |  FOX 06/12/06
  152.   Yaakov Sullivan 14:25  |  FOX 06/12/06
 Today Online
Egyptians offer to represent Beit Hanun victims at The Hague
Responses: 32
Amira Hass: Israel's cruelty toward Palestinian prisoners
Responses: 17
French Jewish groups pay the price for acting like AIPAC
Responses: 24
Under what circumstances would the U.S. attack Iran?
Responses: 25
Israeli Arabs seek autonomy and veto on government decisions
Responses: 67
Can homosexuals become Conservative rabbis and cantors?
Responses: 11


More Headlines
13:49 Peretz: Talks on prisoner exchanges must be kept out of public eye
11:47 Report accuses Hezbollah of war crimes, hiding among civilians
13:49 Peres: Proposed PA unity gov't would be no more than a 'facade'
14:27 Report: U.S. panel to call for Mideast peace plan to help stabilize Iraq
14:33 Defense panel chair proposes opening key debates to public
09:25 Israeli Arabs seek autonomy and veto on government decisions
11:12 France: Iran to face UN sanctions, but no agreement yet on scope
12:57 State demolishes 17 houses in unrecognized Bedouin village in Negev
07:14 Egyptians offer to represent Beit Hanun victims at The Hague
07:27 Livni: International pressure on Hamas beginning to bear fruit
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved