Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 31, 2006 Tevet 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:32 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 14:01 03/12/2006
Israeli Arabs seek right to return to villages abandoned in 1948
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent

According to a position paper written by Mossawa - the Advocacy Center for Arab Citizens in Israel and presented in a conference in Nazareth on Friday, Israeli Arabs want the right to return to villages abandoned in 1948, educational autonomy and changes to the Israeli flag and national anthem.

The paper, written in close coordination with the Israel Higher Arab Monitoring Committee, was presented as part of the week-long Second Annual Days of Mossawa Festival and Nazareth Film Festival, which ended Saturday.

"Our goal is to achieve a historic compromise with the Jewish community in Israel," Mossawa Center director Jafar Farah told the conference. "The move by refugees of 1948 to their villages will not change the demographic balance or endanger the Jews. Unlike the refugees in Arab states, we are [already] here," Farah said. "The internal refugees [residents forced to leave their villages in 1948 who moved to other Arab communities within Israel] represent about one-fourth of the Arab population in Israel today."

Advertisement

Farah said the paper was spurred by a sense among many Israeli Arabs that they must have their say at a time when many Israeli organizations are working to frame a national constitution.

"We found ourselves in an absurd situation, in which Jews are deciding what is good for the Arabs because the Arab elites are not involved in the discussions. Now the decision makers will have to take our opinion into account," Farah said.

The 10-point position paper emphasizes the need to grant communal rights to the Arab public, including the increased use of the Arabic language; equality and fairness in immigration policy; the correct allotment of national resources; and fair representation. With regard to national symbols, the paper says: "The state's symbols, its flag and its national anthem are emotionally charged, public resources ... the state must give appropriate expression to the presence of Arab citizens in Israel and its historical relationship to the place."

Among the many jurists participating in the conference was Supreme Court Justice Salim Jubran, who said the existing Basic Right on Citizenship law must be amended to complete the constitutional protection of minority groups. He repeated his opposition to the Citizenship Law, which restricts the rights of Israeli Arabs to marry Palestinians.

Another participant, Dr. Raef Zreik, said the position paper does not refer to the Israeli Arabs' position regarding the Jewish majority in the country. He said the Israeli Arabs can officially recognize the right of the Jewish public to a state only as part of an overall peace agreement with the Palestinian people.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Fast forward
Time just goes by and refuses to synchronize itself with me. It will happen to you too.
Deli in the desert
The Reuben proved that it's possible to eat sauerkraut with corned beef in the morning.
  1.   Right of Return 03:44  |  Brod 03/12/06
  2.   Bloody cheek of these people 03:55  |  Steven 03/12/06
  3.   They have the right to return to their villages. 04:08  |  Colorado Blew 03/12/06
  4.   THE EXTREMISTS: Etc. - Part 2. 04:24  |  Proud Pal Defender 03/12/06
  5.   Appropriate expression? 04:25  |  GZLives 03/12/06
  6.   I am delighted 04:29  |  Blinky the Fish 03/12/06
  7.   Very cute.Their own state within a state,the salami technique 04:40  |  PETER SM 03/12/06
  8.   dont like the current status then leave 04:44  |  vik 03/12/06
  9.   Israel must... 04:47  |  schafe82 03/12/06
  10.   Jews will settle for no less in Diaspora 04:48  |  justiceseeker 03/12/06
  11.   The begining 04:51  |  Asher 03/12/06
  12.   we want a United Arab States of "Palestine": 05:08  |  bukra fil mishmish 03/12/06
  13.   answer bis no. unless israeli`s get to move back to all of histor 05:17  |  ralph 03/12/06
  14.   lets turn clock back why stop at 48, lets stop at king solomen 05:18  |  ralph 03/12/06
  15.   Israeli arabs seek right 05:27  |  Shmuelshachor 03/12/06
  16.   I`m curious -- serious responses, please 05:31  |  Mike 03/12/06
  17.   Bantustans? 06:06  |  Daniel Abrams 03/12/06
  18.   Israel open your eyes 06:10  |  Victor 03/12/06
  19.   right of return is ok for Jews then as well 06:13  |  Micha 03/12/06
  20.   Majority Rules 06:15  |  Johnny Weintraub 03/12/06
  21.   Lets say yes & commite suicide!! 06:19  |  thanks Israeli left! 03/12/06
  22.   !2 absolutely, and put Liberman in jail for being a Zionist 06:24  |  Noah 03/12/06
  23.   What about the minority obligations to the state? 06:34  |  Eli 03/12/06
  24.   At first glance 06:45  |  Danite 03/12/06
  25.   Return to historic 1948 villages 06:50  |  Michael Katz 03/12/06
  26.   compromise?? what do they have to offer in return? 07:39  |  matt 03/12/06
  27.   MKATZ.You say Israel is finished so why do anything 07:44  |  PETER SM 03/12/06
  28.   crap 07:45  |  Nechama 03/12/06
  29.   re: Peter SM #7 07:51  |  Paulo 03/12/06
  30.   re: Johnny Weintraub #20 07:53  |  Paulo 03/12/06
  31.   arabs want to change anthem and flag 07:58  |  chaim 03/12/06
  32.   Examples of reasonable Palestinians. Who says they don`t exit? 08:12  |  Timothy 03/12/06
  33.   Deport Non Loyal Israeli Arabs 08:17  |  J 03/12/06
  34.   Changing the flag and national anthem is appropriate. 08:18  |  Timothy 03/12/06
  35.   Proud Pal Defender 08:23  |  Aby 03/12/06
  36.   Obligations to the state 08:27  |  Lebanese admirer 03/12/06
  37.   Rights 08:40  |  Dov 03/12/06
  38.   Israeli Arabs seek right to return to villages 08:43  |  GZ 03/12/06
  39.   After reading #1,#2, #3..i can`t take it anymore... 08:45  |  Meir Gush Etzion 03/12/06
  40.   The question at hand could have been resolved with little 08:59  |  Nadav 03/12/06
  41.   PAULO .Read the article,Hamas charter and Palestinian covenant 09:10  |  PETER SM 03/12/06
  42.   RE: Michael Katz, coincidentally, re "1948", are you 48 yrs old ? 09:17  |  zayyin ba ayin 03/12/06
  43.   Will Jews get rights to return to their homes in Arab countries? 09:28  |  Sim 03/12/06
  44.   Right to return 09:52  |  tbora 03/12/06
  45.   Sim in new york 10:20  |  northern neighbor 03/12/06
  46.   SINCE ISRAEL APOLOGISES TO THEM ALL DAY 10:42  |  SALAH AL DIN 03/12/06
  47.   re: Peter SM #41 10:44  |  Paulo 03/12/06
  48.   Iqrit - A case study in Right to Return 10:51  |  EyeOnPal 03/12/06
  49.   Sim, and will the Ashkenazi Jews be able to return 10:55  |  Judith 03/12/06
  50.   Sim on chutzpah 10:55  |  sh 03/12/06
  51.   43: Jews have the right to reutrn home in Arab countries 10:58  |  zeev geneva 03/12/06
  52.   Refugees in their own land 11:02  |  Political 03/12/06
  53.   Re #43 11:04  |  tadzio 03/12/06
  54.   Just a thought... 11:04  |  Nicole 03/12/06
  55.   Incredible Racism 11:05  |  les 03/12/06
  56.   Israel Arabs 11:13  |  Baruch 03/12/06
  57.   Remembering - Related resource 11:16  |  EyeOnPal 03/12/06
  58.   Return, anthem and flag 11:21  |  sh 03/12/06
  59.   Let Them Move To Palestine 11:25  |  Terry 03/12/06
  60.   #55 les 11:27  |  Pavel 03/12/06
  61.   Sure, I`m all for it 11:36  |  exHalabi 03/12/06
  62.   Return as appropriate 11:51  |  Jean 03/12/06
  63.   FLAG : ok, if conversely 11:52  |  ziggurat 03/12/06
  64.   #45 All Lebanese Jews "fled" Lebanon 12:17  |  Laila 03/12/06
  65.   well writ danite 12:19  |  multicensored 03/12/06
  66.   Give them back their homes!! 12:20  |  Nick W 03/12/06
  67.   We Jews from Arabs Lands Don`t want to return 12:20  |  Fortunee 03/12/06
  68.   #51 zeev the peeve is back WITH MORE NONSENSE 12:21  |  paul harris 03/12/06
  69.   HOW CAN GODS "CHOSEN PEOPLE" BE SOO MEAN???? 12:27  |  Nick W 03/12/06
  70.   Double edged impossible position. 12:29  |  H.H.M 03/12/06
  71.   They haven`t even gotten us back to `48 yet 12:35  |  Ilan 03/12/06
  72.   FORTUNEE 12:36  |  GABBAI 03/12/06
  73.   Irael is a Jewish state 12:45  |  Nechama 03/12/06
  74.   What about changing the "Stars&Stripes" to accomodate Mexicans? 12:46  |  Absolute Sweden 03/12/06
  75.   Far from unreasonable demands 13:07  |  Gordon Shifman 03/12/06
  76.   Absolute Sweden (Post No. 74) 13:51  |  Johnny Weintraub 03/12/06
  77.   Paulo (Post No. 30) 13:55  |  Johnny Weintraub 03/12/06
  78.   if they want arab culture got to an arab state 13:56  |  zionist forever 03/12/06
  79.   To Nechama (#73) 13:58  |  Curious 03/12/06
  80.   re#41, a question for peter SM 14:01  |  viper 03/12/06
  81.   The right of return for all must be forced to ahieve peace 14:03  |  Human Rights 03/12/06
  82.   PAULO."Long term ceasefire" ?No recognition.No peace,Charter same 14:06  |  PETER SM 03/12/06
  83.   Curious #79 14:20  |  Nechama 03/12/06
  84.   National Anthem in Switzerland 14:21  |  Swiss Man 03/12/06
  85.   To Nechama (#83) 14:35  |  Curious 03/12/06
  86.   Restriction on marriages in 21st Century? That can`t be true! 14:39  |  BouSameer 03/12/06
  87.   Swiss man 14:52  |  JW 03/12/06
  88.