Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., December 04, 2006 Kislev 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:47 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Did anyone see the superpower?
By Zvi Bar'el

One can imagine Nuri al-Maliki, the prime minister of Iraq, nervously scratching his head on his way back from Amman to hemorrhaging Baghdad, with an expression of great amazement on his face: What, in fact, did he say to me? Are they withdrawing or staying? Am I a good prime minister or a Shi'ite weakling? Are they talking with Iran, or do they want us to stop the dialogue? And, in general, what was so urgent to trouble me to come from Baghdad?

Al-Maliki is not alone. The world's greatest superpower is stuck in the murderous alleys of Baghdad, shooting in all directions and not hitting anything. The U.S. administration's long-term strategy in the region is going to be defined by two pensioners, James Baker and Lee Hamilton, who have become the Urim and Thummim of the administration, which operates the largest intelligence service in the world. The relationship between George W. Bush and the prime minister of Iraq is formulated in a leaked document composed by National Security Adviser Stephen Hadley. It relies primarily on the assessment of the U.S. ambassador in Baghdad, Zalmay Khalilzad, who detests al-Maliki.

The meeting with al-Maliki in Amman is only a symptom. Who still remembers the previous meeting with Bush in Jordan, with Abu Mazen and Ariel Sharon, in June 2003? What has Washington contributed since then to advancing the decisions made there, to promoting its own policies, which support a solution of two states for two peoples? Where was the superpower in all of the violent dialogue between Israel and the Palestinian Authority, and what was its contribution to the cease-fire or to bolstering Abu Mazen? What is it doing to strengthen the government of Lebanon? And what is it doing to strengthen the government in Iraq? Or was the slap in the face that al-Maliki received from Washington meant to show affection?

Advertisement

This is not a diagnosis of the great superpower's methods of action, but rather a search for its hiding place. Because despite the enormous power it is deploying in Iraq, and despite the deep crises in Lebanon and the Palestinian Authority, and despite Iran's nuclear threat, the superpower is absent. Apparently there is not a single policy or joint strategy indicating that Washington is capable of not only getting into a deep crisis, but also capable of knowing how to rescue and extricate itself from it.

Washington under Bush is a superpower searching for its tail. It initiates two wars based on an illusion of building a better world, and has not learned to contribute where it really could create a better reality. It regards Syria as a state that supports terrorism, and Iran as an existential threat, but does not enable turning these two states into part of the family of nations. It is satisfied with the long boycott imposed on the Palestinian Authority of Hamas, but is not lifting a finger to advance a diplomatic horizon.

But this complaint is about as valuable as howling at the moon. It seems that the focus needs to return to the internal front and to realize that Washington will fall in line with anything the sides themselves agree upon in Iraq, Lebanon or Palestine. Just as it fell in line with reality and stated it is no longer realistic to return to the 1967 borders, it would also adopt any agreement Israel reaches with Syria or Hamas, and any agreement that al-Maliki reaches in Iraq or Fouad Siniora attains in Lebanon. As James Baker once said: The United States cannot want peace more than the sides themselves. This is the same Baker who left us his phone number in the event that we seek American assistance in advancing negotiations, the same Baker who is now proposing a gradual withdrawal from Iraq and dialogue with Iran and Syria.

Bush is no more to blame than the sides themselves. Ehud Olmert, Siniora, al-Maliki and Hosni Mubarak are more familiar with their problems than he is. When Bush is seeking only to get out of the situations he has landed himself in, any logical solution would be welcomed. America can no longer serve as an excuse. It is absent.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A test of strength
The int'l community cannot be a mere bystander as Nasrallah tries to topple Siniora.
To help the mentally ill
The call to suspend mental health insurance reform doesn't reflect genuine compassion.
  1.   Wrong - Bush IS to blame 10:24  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  2.   No 10:59  |  shaun 03/12/06
  3.   The U.S. is a superpower in (fast) decline 11:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 03/12/06
  4.   Declare surrender and accept defeat 11:36  |  Jean 03/12/06
  5.   America needs to sit on its hands for a few years. 11:42  |  Natallie Durson 03/12/06
  6.   #5, who is slaughtering Arab civilians? 12:52  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 03/12/06
  7.   LIKE TEXAS COWBOY MOVIE 12:56  |  indrajaya 03/12/06
  8.   #1, clickfool, easy tiger 13:38  |  viper 03/12/06
  9.   For Cippy # 6 13:44  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  10.   The USA is super power of Ignorance and Hooliganism 13:52  |  Sam (UK) 03/12/06
  11.   Bush is in a state of denial 13:57  |  Mark B. 03/12/06
  12.   A state of denial? # 11 14:23  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  13.   # 1- Clickfool 14:33  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  14.   Cickfool ...only in the muslim world 15:04  |  British academic 03/12/06
  15.   CLICKFOOL STANDS ON SOAP BOX AT HYDE PARK 15:26  |  paul harris 03/12/06
  16.   To Paul Harris on WAR 15:39  |  Mark B. 03/12/06
  17.   INCLUSION not EXCLUSION 15:53  |  British academic 03/12/06
  18.   Absent? No! 15:57  |  Mark Lincoln 03/12/06
  19.   Klaudia 15:57  |  Robert 03/12/06
  20.   The thing is not over yet 16:06  |  Jonathan S 03/12/06
  21.   For "British Academic" # 14 16:15  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  22.   Sigh...fake British academic (the second posting) 16:35  |  British academic 03/12/06
  23.   # 19- Robert 16:42  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  24.   British or Academic 16:49  |  Robert 03/12/06
  25.   # 22- British Academic- This has " Clickfool "Written all over i 16:50  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  26.   Klaudia 17:01  |  Robert 03/12/06
  27.   To Clickfool- Buzz off !! We KNOW you are "Robert " 17:14  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  28.   Poor robert...back up your accusation with evidence 17:25  |  British academic 03/12/06
  29.   Absent 17:30  |  tbora 03/12/06
  30.   Clickfool are you 10 years old 17:39  |  British academic 03/12/06
  31.   tbora please next to a muslim leader Bush is a GENIUS 17:48  |  British academic 03/12/06
  32.   # 28- British Academic 18:26  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  33.   Nautilus 18:45  |  Aaron 03/12/06
  34.   #31 British academic `Genius` 18:50  |  tbora 03/12/06
  35.   For Klaudia # 25 18:51  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  36.   For Klaudia, again # 27 18:54  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  37.   Imagine if... 19:08  |  chet 03/12/06
  38.   More Mishegoss from Bar`el in the Bubble 19:11  |  Tod Zuckerman 03/12/06
  39.   To- Clickfool / Robert 19:20  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  40.   Iranian genius 19:31  |  British academic 03/12/06
  41.   OLMERT IS A DEFEATIST WHO WILL ALWAYS CAVE IN TO ARAB TERROR 19:34  |  DANIEL ROSEHTHAL 03/12/06
  42.   To Klaudia and British academic re:clickfool 19:36  |  citizen zero 03/12/06
  43.   The only way out Part I 19:38  |  Baz Mann 03/12/06
  44.   The only way out Part II 19:43  |  Baz Mann 03/12/06
  45.   British Academic 19:46  |  Peaches 03/12/06
  46.   Isn`t It Funny 19:56  |  Abe 03/12/06
  47.   Klaudia #13 20:00  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  48.   British academic 20:11  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  49.   Risks of occupation 20:12  |  Baz Mann 03/12/06
  50.   Dead Wrong British Academic 20:16  |  Mark Lincoln 03/12/06
  51.   Dead Wrong British Academic 20:16  |  Mark Lincoln 03/12/06
  52.   # 47- Guess Who 20:35  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  53.   Peaches academia is about freedom of opinion 20:44  |  British academic 03/12/06
  54.   Prophetic words #47 20:46  |  Baz mann 03/12/06
  55.   Hey Klaudia, how can u know Clickfool is Robert 20:50  |  Lebanese in Canada 03/12/06
  56.   Mark Lincoln...no by stubburnly pursuing 20:50  |  British academic 03/12/06
  57.   What with the leftists Klaudia 20:54  |  Lebanese in Canada 03/12/06
  58.   Baz Mann I imagine 21:08  |  British academic 03/12/06
  59.   Lebanese in Canada..didnt your fellow canadian muslims 21:13  |  British academic 03/12/06
  60.   For Lebanese in Canada # 55 21:16  |  Clickfool 03/12/06
  61.   # 55- Lebanese in Canada 21:27  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  62.   British academic #56 21:30  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  63.   Bush`s little helpers 21:32  |  Spectator 03/12/06
  64.   # 57- Lebanese in Canada 21:32  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  65.   #53 -British Academic 21:34  |  peaches 03/12/06
  66.   British academic #56 (2) 21:38  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  67.   Clickfool AKA Robert re #59 21:42  |  peaches 03/12/06
  68.   British academic #58 21:46  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  69.   Clickfool, pls boycot Israeli newspapers 21:52  |  Chris 03/12/06
  70.   British academic 21:53  |  Robert 03/12/06
  71.   To Clickfool, It Doesn`t Matter 21:56  |  Abe 03/12/06
  72.   Clickfool 21:57  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  73.   # 60- For Clickfool 21:58  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  74.   Robert - the only thing you prove with your reasoning 22:58  |  British academic 03/12/06
  75.   amerca does not learn 23:05  |  david 03/12/06
  76.   Guess who the solution could be 23:05  |  British academic 03/12/06
  77.   Guess who I`m sure this would happen 23:13  |  British academic 03/12/06
  78.   # 70- Robert/Clickie 23:20  |  Klaudia 03/12/06
  79.   Thinking in the long term 23:34  |  Aaron Levitt 03/12/06
  80.   British academic #77 23:54  |  Guess who 03/12/06
  81.   British academic #76 00:04  |  Guess who 04/12/06
  82.   Poor guess who...if you havent noticed 00:21  |  British academic 04/12/06
  83.   The Missing Superpower 00:24  |  Karl Schulze 04/12/06
  84.   From Cold War to Hot Peace ! 00:26  |  Akram Zekaria 04/12/06
  85.   Clickfool 00:49  |  Robert 04/12/06
  86.   To # 1 Clickfool : Bush is a puppet controlled from Tel Aviv 01:18  |  Yankelowitz 04/12/06
  87.   Re #58 Sampson option 01:43  |  Baz Mann 04/12/06
  88.   Mark Lincoln :Don`t insulate facts. 01:59  |  Akram Zekaria