Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 03, 2006 Kislev 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:00 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Cease the fire in the West Bank, too
By Haaretz Editorial

The developments of the last few days are liable to arouse hope. The agreement on a cease-fire in the Gaza Strip, together with the prime minister's impressive speech in Sde Boker, could generate a new atmosphere in Israel's relations with the Palestinians - an atmosphere that would enable the start of serious negotiations between the parties. Israel must not waste this rare window of opportunity.

Against this backdrop, it is difficult to understand the opposition of certain Israel Defense Forces officers, and the reservations expressed yesterday by the defense minister, with regard to an expansion of the cease-fire to the West Bank as well - especially given the Palestinians' declarations that they would be interested in expanding the cease-fire.

The cease-fire will be able to take hold only if it applies to both the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. It is impossible to separate what happens in these two places: Every military operation in the West Bank is liable to draw a response from Gaza, and vice versa. Therefore, the IDF's predawn operation in Qabatiyah on Monday, a day after the cease-fire in Gaza took effect - an operation that resulted in the deaths of a Popular Resistance Committees operative and a 55-year-old woman - was harmful and unnecessary. Anyone who wants to give the cease-fire a chance must impose maximum restraint on himself.

Advertisement

Israel should therefore declare it seeks a total cease-fire, in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, and the IDF should be ordered to hold its fire in both areas, if the Palestinians commit to a similar move. The fact, reported yesterday, that the IDF has already hastened to revise its new rules of engagement in the Gaza Strip in order to once again permit soldiers to open fire on Qassam rocket launchers will also not serve the efforts to consolidate the cease-fire. The Palestinians must be given a real opportunity to work to stop the Qassam fire. Given their complex situation, this cannot be done overnight.

"The State of Israel is so strong that it can allow itself to hold back in order to give the cease-fire a real chance," the prime minister correctly stated on Monday. The IDF must act in this spirit and exercise restraint. Israel can only gain thereby.

But a cease-fire is not enough. If Israel wants to begin a new chapter, it must immediately take a series of practical steps aimed at giving real force to the straightforward words of Ehud Olmert's Sde Boker speech.

A demonstration of intentions that included a symbolic prisoner release, even before a deal over the release of Gilad Shalit is finalized, as well as the removal of some of the dozens of checkpoints in the West Bank, an end to the policy of "isolation" that divides the West Bank into cantons, and a relaxation of the draconic movement restrictions at the roadblocks, would help change the rules of the game.

The fact that, for instance, Nablus residents between the ages of 18 and 25 are not allowed to leave their city at all, while Jenin residents aged 16 to 35 are not allowed to pass through Tapuah Junction, makes daily life unbearable for tens of thousands of Palestinians. This must stop.

This is the time to demonstrate openness and generosity. Israel must give the cease-fire a chance, and not bring about its collapse through unnecessary military operations, as has happened more than once with past cease-fires. The order of the day must now be: Cease the fire, both in the Gaza Strip and in the West Bank.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Portion of the Week
This week's reading shows us the maze of relations that forms the basis of the Jewish People.
Second helpings
In used book shops, your money goes further and the choice is often greater.
  1.   Good Idea 09:52  |  Natallie Durson 29/11/06
  2.   Winds of change in Jerusalem ?? 09:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  3.   Unless the present Gaza cease-fire (sic) holds, 10:20  |  Yaakov K. 29/11/06
  4.   what cease fire? 10:29  |  JG 29/11/06
  5.   AT YOUR PERIL AT YOUR PERIL 10:34  |  paul harris 29/11/06
  6.   Paul Harris, are you a squatter? 11:01  |  Marilyn 29/11/06
  7.   i disagree with durson, the reason for the so called "draconic... 11:08  |  Pablo 29/11/06
  8.   "The IDF must act in this spirit and exercise restraint... 11:28  |  Maureen Ann 29/11/06
  9.   Hope for the Haaretz editorial comparable to 12:00  |  Sal 29/11/06
  10.   Dear Sal 12:22  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 29/11/06
  11.   Haaretz where is your honour? 12:52  |  Jonathan S 29/11/06
  12.   What cease-fire? 13:05  |  Matthias Roth 29/11/06
  13.   The Arabs should begin the ceasefire first! 13:30  |  Michael 29/11/06
  14.   Yaakov 14:33  |  Jack 29/11/06
  15.   What ceasefire? Haaretz editors should be made to live in Sderot 14:40  |  Ronny 29/11/06
  16.   #2 swiss 14:45  |  alan 29/11/06
  17.   Not Yet!! 15:09  |  infidel 29/11/06
  18.   Palestinian definition of `ceasefire` 15:18  |  Ian 29/11/06
  19.   "Cease the fire in the West Bank, too" 15:21  |  Yonatan 29/11/06
  20.   Lesson for Haaretz editors 15:28  |  Sidney 29/11/06
  21.   THE CEASEFIRE WILL NOT HOLD IF NOT EXPANDED TO WB 16:02  |  Messaoud 29/11/06
  22.   Diplomacy 16:07  |  Edward Rothberg 29/11/06
  23.   To Ronny who makes a good point 16:09  |  Jonathan S 29/11/06
  24.   Zulpa Al Husseini , reporter for Wallah web said 16:16  |  Joseph E . 29/11/06
  25.   Gaza Cease-Fire as Smoke Screen 16:28  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/11/06
  26.   To Sullivan who seems to be smoking 16:47  |  Jonathan S 29/11/06
  27.   #14: Israel has barely tickled the "pal"s in the last few months! 16:54  |  Yaakov K. 29/11/06
  28.   Jonathan, jonathan, such arguments simply dont hold anymore #26 17:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/11/06
  29.   # 16 alan 17:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  30.   "Atmosphere would enable start of serious negotiation" *YAWN* 17:49  |  Palestinian suicide 29/11/06
  31.   Haaretz will be rewarded when we destroy Israel 18:04  |  Haniyeh and Meshal 29/11/06
  32.   Getting West Bank cease-fire for peace sake 18:20  |  J.M.Jordan 29/11/06
  33.   Yes to cease fire agreement in West Bank too 18:33  |  Hadassah H. 29/11/06
  34.   We need a fresh start 18:39  |  Melanie Oliver 29/11/06
  35.   #6 4TH ATTENMPT TO ANSWER MARYLIN 18:54  |  paul harris 29/11/06
  36.   I fully agree with your editorial 18:58  |  Ben Alofs 29/11/06
  37.   #6 Poor ignorant Marilyn 19:04  |  Sidney 29/11/06
  38.   To Sullivan who prefers Israel-bashing against facts 19:07  |  Jonathan S 29/11/06
  39.   Two steps forward, one step back 19:16  |  Jim 29/11/06
  40.   Is There Political Control of the IDF? 19:36  |  chet 29/11/06
  41.   Why limit it to West Bank? 19:40  |  Gene 29/11/06
  42.   # 2 No change in Jerusalem 19:53  |  Jim 29/11/06
  43.   Jonathan and his lies #38 19:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/11/06
  44.   # 33 Hadassah H. 20:14  |  Jim 29/11/06
  45.   You can`t dance at two weddings... 20:22  |  Tzfonit 29/11/06
  46.   #29 Swiss 20:23  |  alan 29/11/06
  47.   #42 Jim 20:29  |  alan 29/11/06
  48.   # 26 One advantage, perhaps. 20:44  |  Jim 29/11/06
  49.   Paul Harris#35... HOW ABOUT THE PALESTINIANS? 21:07  |  Jeremy 29/11/06
  50.   31 - Response 21:15  |  Bruriah Sarah 29/11/06
  51.   Messaoud 21:20  |  Jasmine Murphy 29/11/06
  52.   #43 - Ignoring your blather, it`s YOU who`s the liar, bucko! 21:25  |  Yaakov K. 29/11/06
  53.   the enemy strategizes 21:32  |  sho 29/11/06
  54.   47 - Indigenous People? 21:35  |  Bruriah Sarah 29/11/06
  55.   Bad Idea Haaretz 21:45  |  Samantha Carter 29/11/06
  56.   # 36 Ben 21:57  |  Jim 29/11/06
  57.   To Yaakov Sullivan 22:00  |  Mark B. 29/11/06
  58.   # 8 Maureen Ann 22:12  |  Jim 29/11/06
  59.   # 4 JG 22:19  |  Jim 29/11/06
  60.   # 50 22:37  |  Jim 29/11/06
  61.   Jack from Tampa - Israel can wipe them out within a day 22:52  |  Jabadini 29/11/06
  62.   Yaakov Sullivan - Your not an idiot dont be so nieve 22:57  |  Jabadini 29/11/06
  63.   #49 Jeremy, You are wrong. 23:00  |  Sidney 29/11/06
  64.   Yaakov Sullivan - Hudna means break to regroup 23:00  |  Jabadini 29/11/06
  65.   To Jim from Murfreesboro 23:02  |  Jonathan S 29/11/06
  66.   has anyone ever considered.... 23:04  |  maria 29/11/06
  67.   Melanie Oliver cant have it both ways 23:04  |  Jabadini 29/11/06
  68.   Yaakov - #43 which nation do you speak of 23:09  |  Jabadini 29/11/06
  69.   has anyone ever considered that the palestinians... 23:15  |  maria 29/11/06
  70.   Jim #58 Israel should trust the UN??? 23:17  |  Jabadini 29/11/06
  71.   Desperately seeking Fritz 23:23  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/11/06
  72.   Sullivan it`s fire that makes smoke 23:26  |  Jasmine Murphy 29/11/06
  73.   # 17 Not Yet? Right! 23:37  |  Jim 29/11/06
  74.   # 14 Yaakov 23:49  |  Jim 29/11/06
  75.   #5 Paul Harris Are you able to hear sonic bombs when.... 01:02  |  Maureen Ann 30/11/06
  76.   #75, what is a sonic bomb? 02:34  |  Danny - Israeli one 30/11/06
  77.   MAUREEN ANN Are you able to hear sonic booms from Qassems? 02:37  |  PETER SM 30/11/06
  78.   Go for it! See if the Pals can break it faster than in Gaza 02:41  |  PETER SM 30/11/06
  79.   Ben Olofs, What thugs in the IDF ! 02:50  |  Dutch 30/11/06
  80.   Natallie,thank you for all you have to say!! 02:52  |  John 30/11/06
  81.   Terror Bases in the "West Bank" 03:19  |  Liz Biggin 30/11/06
  82.   sonic bombs 03:28  |  Pssd Off American 30/11/06
  83.   #70 Jabadini asks lots of questions 03:47  |  Johnboy 30/11/06
  84.   Is it any wonder why there is no peace? 04:15  |  Guy From NYC 30/11/06
  85.   #Peter SM Do you have proof....... 05:15  |  Maureen Ann 30/11/06
  86.   69# maria. You are right. History the rightful Juadge. 06:15  |  Akram Zekaria 30/11/06
  87.   to akram in london 06:50  |  maria 30/11/06
  88.   86# maria The only problem with Israel is the politicians. 07:25  |  Akram Zekaria 30/11/06