Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., February 24, 2007 Adar 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The checkpoint generation
By Amira Hass

For nearly a month now, a young Palestinian has been hospitalized at Beilinson Hospital; soldiers shot him at a checkpoint in northern Nablus on Saturday, November 4. Haitem Yassin, 25, is conscious now, but he is still hooked up to a respirator. In recent days, he has been suffering from a high fever, apparently caused by an infection in his abdomen, which was wounded in the shooting. His family is still waiting for a report from the hospital about the number or type of bullets that caused the serious injury.

At the Samaria Brigade, they are still investigating what happened that day at the fortified and isolated Asira al-Shmaliya checkpoint, through which only the inhabitants of several villages are permitted passage. However, according to testimonies taken by a researcher for B'Tselem - The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, it emerges that Yassin had irritated the soldiers. He dared to suggest to them that their demand of women to feel their own bodies to carry out a "security check" was inappropriate. So annoying was he that a soldier shoved him.

Yassin, who had returned from overseas a few months earlier, had apparently not yet internalized the fact that it is dangerous to remind a soldier that a Palestinian is a human being. When the soldier shoved, Yassin shoved back. The soldier, according to the testimonies, started to scream and curse and hit. He quickly received reinforcement from two other soldiers, who fired into the air and at the ground. Even though Yassin fell to the ground after the shooting, the soldiers, relate the witnesses, threw him onto a concrete block, handcuffed him and kicked him. They also kicked him in the head, according to the testimonies, and beat him with their rifles.

Advertisement

In a village in the Nablus area, S., another young Palestinian, is recovering from the trauma he suffered from a harsh beating at the hands of a soldier at the Jit checkpoint, midway between Nablus and Qalqilya. The office of the Israel Defense Forces Spokesman has stated that it was the young man who had shoved and hit a soldier who told him to return to his vehicle, whereas the soldier only fended him off, but the testimony of S. is completely different. He, like many others on that day, November 9, had got out of his vehicle while on the way to the Jewish settlement where he works, in order to find out why, just when everyone was hurrying to work, the line of cars at the checkpoint wasn't moving.

According to one taxi driver, the soldiers announced that the cars would not be able to go through until noon. S., according to his own testimony, intended to return to his vehicle when the soldier approached him and looked as though he was going to hit him with his rifle. S. grabbed the rifle and pushed it aside. This apparently really bothered the soldier, who grabbed him, pulled him away from the rest of the people, flung him to the ground, and proceeded to him in all parts of his body. Including his head.

Other soldiers, at the Beit Iba checkpoint west of Nablus, also got annoyed: At a student who felt he was suffocating among the mass of people who flocked to the checkpoint on October 9, and who felt the only way he could get some air was to climb a pole. When he refused to obey the soldiers' orders to come down, because there was no room and no air, they fell upon him and beat him with a rifle. According to the testimony of a friend, who spoke to an activist from Machsom Watch, the soldiers also broke his glasses and punished him: They detained him in "solitary confinement," in a kind of punishment cell into which the soldiers and the commanders throw Palestinians who "misbehave." The cell is intended for security suspects, but all too often people who dare to argue with the soldiers are thrown in there, or held in another sort of punishment cell at other checkpoints.

In tens of thousands of homes in the West Bank live others, who may have not ended up in the hospital, but who every day accumulate harsh impressions of the nature and behavior of almost the only Israelis whom they encounter - the soldiers at the checkpoints. The non-Palestinians who pass through the checkpoints can also reach a similar conclusion - that most of the soldiers stationed at them are crude, arrogant, boastful and definitely hardhearted. All too often it appears that the soldiers intentionally cause the line of cars and people to dawdle at a checkpoint for a very long time. All too often they are seen laughing and grinning at the sight of the hundreds of people jostling and crowding in the slow line behind the narrow inspection turnstile.

The Palestinians are not interested in, and do not need to be interested in, the explanations that Israel will give: It's a difficult mission; the soldiers are afraid; maybe someone will come bearing an explosive belt; they're young, still children; they're defending the homeland; if they weren't posted at checkpoints in the middle of the West Bank, suicide terrorists would be free to enter Israel.

The truth is that even the soldiers' parents should not be interested in these explanations. They should, however, be very worried about their country sending their sons and daughters on an apartheid mission: to restrict Palestinian mobility within the occupied territory, to narrow the Palestinian expanse in order to enable Jews to move freely within that same occupied territory and in order to increase their expanse within it. In order to carry out this mission in full, facing the natives, the soldiers must feel and act like "superiors."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Whose land is it?
A new book discusses the question of equality in the 'only democracy in the Mideast.'
Bittersweet good-bye
We bid a fond farewell to our house in the desert, consoling ourselves with a feast.
  1.   Interesting article 09:26  |  Matt 29/11/06
  2.   MORE TOTAL HOGWASH FROM HA---ASS 09:38  |  paul harris 29/11/06
  3.   machsom etiquette 09:40  |  whodey 29/11/06
  4.   what an abuse of language 09:49  |  david 29/11/06
  5.   there is always another day 09:51  |  shaun 29/11/06
  6.   Amira Hass is a traitor (together with Gideon Levy) 10:00  |  Vittorio 29/11/06
  7.   Not "apartheid", but preventing terrorism 10:01  |  Paul Henzen 29/11/06
  8.   Israel beautifully summed up by Amira Hess, a mensch 10:01  |  Clickfool 29/11/06
  9.   A brave reporter 10:01  |  Andrew Watson 29/11/06
  10.   The fifth mother, and the lesson of S. Lebanon 10:16  |  DJStahl 29/11/06
  11.   OK, Amira, just step to the side while the zionists grab the mike 10:18  |  Johnboy 29/11/06
  12.   A question of legality 10:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  13.   and what would amira say about `occupation` -free aza 10:24  |  shraga 29/11/06
  14.   Apartheid 10:25  |  David Menahem 29/11/06
  15.   They have their own government...sure 10:30  |  RW 29/11/06
  16.   The Movie "Checkpoint" 10:33  |  Baracka 29/11/06
  17.   Amira Hass 10:37  |  JewishHeart 29/11/06
  18.   How Zionists howl when the truth is told 10:38  |  Clickfool 29/11/06
  19.   One day, you will say "thank you" to Amira 10:45  |  Yankelowitz 29/11/06
  20.   So protecting women means being shot? 10:48  |  Marilyn 29/11/06
  21.   There is no fence around the US 10:54  |  Marilyn 29/11/06
  22.   Of Course Clickfool and Dino 11:03  |  JewishHeart 29/11/06
  23.   No Marilyn, that is not Apartheid 11:13  |  David 29/11/06
  24.   #16 Baraka has seen it all in a movie 11:20  |  Johnboy 29/11/06
  25.   Jewish Heart is right 11:36  |  Kim 29/11/06
  26.   To Paul Harris 11:36  |  David James Vickery 29/11/06
  27.   Enough WHINING already about our "poor" ENEMY! 11:37  |  Yaakov K. 29/11/06
  28.   Amira: Ask Yourself This Question! 11:37  |  Yosemite Sam 29/11/06
  29.   another self-hating Jew 11:38  |  rz 29/11/06
  30.   #16 "Checkpoint" movie 11:39  |  Tony Price 29/11/06
  31.   Keep telling it as it is Amira.... 11:41  |  Maureen Ann 29/11/06
  32.   S. 11:44  |  Fed Up 29/11/06
  33.   Amira Hass 12:19  |  Claire G 29/11/06
  34.   To Yaakov K. in Al-Quds re: Amira 12:19  |  David James Vickery 29/11/06
  35.   Oh Amira! 12:20  |  Nechama 29/11/06
  36.   To Amira Hass, Yankelowitz. Peace or not ? 12:20  |  Altalena 29/11/06
  37.   Hass as usual violating basic journalistic principles 12:31  |  Jonathan S 29/11/06
  38.   was there ever an isreali soldier judged ? 12:32  |  lola 29/11/06
  39.   # 22 JewishHeart Wrong accusations !! 12:33  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  40.   Listen to Ex US President Jimmy Carter 12:37  |  Political 29/11/06
  41.   Well said and done Amira 12:39  |  Ben 29/11/06
  42.   Amira Hass dream of a Great Palestine 12:51  |  Dr D 29/11/06
  43.   Some idiots here write some uncivilised posts about Amira 12:57  |  Tamir Gaza 29/11/06
  44.   Not easy for the IDF soldiers 12:59  |  Haavard 29/11/06
  45.   Amira Hass is a very honest and courageous Mensch 13:06  |  Mark B. 29/11/06
  46.   paul harris re alternatives 13:17  |  dubious 29/11/06
  47.   Amira - running out of topics to skew? 13:18  |  William 29/11/06
  48.   to David (#23) 13:28  |  cf 29/11/06
  49.   To Altalena with her ridiculous comments 13:36  |  Mark B. 29/11/06
  50.   # 40 Political Jimmy Carter 13:42  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  51.   Amira: NOBODY wants this! 13:50  |  Jack 29/11/06
  52.   FOR ALL OF YOU WHO HAVE NEVER BEEN ASOLDIER!!! 13:59  |  paul harris 29/11/06
  53.   Those innocent palestinians... 14:08  |  Cowboy Bob 29/11/06
  54.   # 40 Political 14:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  55.   Amira Hass 14:13  |  Ronnie 29/11/06
  56.   Dino 14:16  |  JewishHeart 29/11/06
  57.   If they send women suicide bombers,women will be searched 14:16  |  PETER SM 29/11/06
  58.   Bad Day for Amira Hass 14:18  |  JewishHeart 29/11/06
  59.   Well CF, you`re wrong again 14:28  |  David 29/11/06
  60.   Arabs are illegal immigrants 14:29  |  justice 29/11/06
  61.   Surprise I agree with Dino 14:32  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/11/06
  62.   #44 Haavard 14:34  |  whodey 29/11/06
  63.   Amira, I fully support your point of view 14:37  |  Neville Chamberlain 29/11/06
  64.   Jimmy Carter: Replacement theologist, anti-Jewish, anti-Israel 14:38  |  Yacov 29/11/06
  65.   Great article 14:42  |  Maya Roth 29/11/06
  66.   amira,again,transcend please. 14:45  |  you`re telling us?! 29/11/06
  67.   Claire G, Yaakov K 14:48  |  whodey 29/11/06
  68.   More fake Clickfools! 14:49  |  Clickfool 29/11/06
  69.   aparhied 14:55  |  michael 29/11/06
  70.   David, the occupation is clearly aparthied. 15:03  |  Ibrahim 29/11/06
  71.   To 45, 49. Mark B. We remember 15:03  |  Altalena 29/11/06
  72.   Texas Has CheckPoints Also 15:04  |  Johnny Weintraub 29/11/06
  73.   Vittorio 15:09  |  Vittorio II 29/11/06
  74.   Haavard (Post No. 44) 15:14  |  Johnny Weintraub 29/11/06
  75.   For Clickfool # 18 15:18  |  Victor Smolinsky 29/11/06
  76.   Will Hass soon praise 57 old grandmother suicide bomber? 15:25  |  Andre 29/11/06
  77.   David Menahem # 14 New Word Needed 15:27  |  Jeff Northridge 29/11/06
  78.   # 53 Jewish Heart 15:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  79.   Apartheid IS as Apartheid DOES! 15:31  |  Benjamin 29/11/06
  80.   Amira "one note" Hass 15:36  |  David 29/11/06
  81.   William and his IDF pride #47 15:37  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/11/06
  82.   Jimmy Carter - - Peanut Brain 15:46  |  George Kaplan 29/11/06
  83.   hass,harris,hassles 15:49  |  victoria amos 29/11/06
  84.   # 56 Margie in Tel Aviv 15:50  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/11/06
  85.   thanks amira hass