Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., January 26, 2007 Shvat 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 04:41 30/11/2006
Occupation poisoning - Envy the extremist
By Bradley Burston



Occupation is a dirty word. That is why it makes extremists happy.

Like all obscenities, it distorts more than it describes. It inflames more than it informs. It obscures much more than it illuminates. And like all true obscenities, it poisons those who employ it, as much as those who are its intended targets.

The poison that is occupation is in all of us. It is everywhere around us, even for those of us who cannot see it. If you live here, even for those of us who don't feel it - or don't realize that they do - it's inside of you.

Can you learn to live with it? Not really. Because it poisons all of our lives. There is no antidote that has tested safe. No cure. Only the extremist can live with it. In fact, the extremists on both sides positively thrive on the concept and its fallout, its mind-set, its bloodshed. Occupation gives extremists on both sides their reason for being, their sense of empowerment, of superiority of intellect, of divine right, of knowing what the rabble do not, of feeling what the masses cannot.

It is the poison of occupation that pumps extremists full of themselves. It is the poison that puts that gleaming, terrifying smile on the face. It is the poison of occupation that fuels their passion for the messianic, their belief in messianism as realism, their sense of being able to make perfect, symmetric, rational sense of a horrific world.

It is the poison of occupation that kills any proposed solution to the conflict that threatens us all. Only the extremist is not threatened. The extremist will tell you that he loves this place like no other. Believe him. For the extremist, a Holy Land in perpetual strife in heaven on earth.

By his actions, by his beliefs, the extremist will make certain that there is no antidote for the poison of occupation, no cure for what ails us. On either side. Why should he? He's got what he wants right now.

Hamas is on its throne, and is not about to budge. No compromise, no recognition of Israel as a reality, not even if that meant alleviating suffering for the needy, not even if that meant an eventual solution we could all live with. No flexibility over the right of return, even if that meant never having a Palestinian state at all. Not even if that meant that Palestinians could have a modicum of well-being, their children a future.

The radical settlers are on their land, and they're not about to budge. No compromise, no recognition of the Palestinians as a reality. Not even if that meant that the settlement blocs endorsed by our American ally could be part of a solution, internationally recognized as sovereign parts of the permanent borders of an internationally recognized state of Israel. Not even if that meant that we could have a modicum of well-being, our children a future.

Why? Both sides will tell you: We can't let them have any more. They already have taken much too much by force. We've given up much too much. They're already occupying vast swaths of land which is rightfully ours. If we don't resist them, they'll only want more. If we don't resist them by force, they'll only take more by force.

They want it all. If we let them, they'll take it all.

At this point, in our poisoned state, the moderates on both sides can barely bring themselves to function.

Envy the extremist.

Envy him his freedom from ambiguity, his immunity from ambivalence. Only the extremist knows exactly why there is no moral equivalency between the sides, and that only his side is in the right.

Only he knows what the world does not, what the world refuses to see. Only the extremist knows what many on his own side refuse to see, either because they lack his vision, or they lack his loyalty. Only he knows who's at fault for all our ills. The other side. Only the extremist knows who started all this suffering, who's entirely to blame, who are the transgressors, why they're the real villains.

What is this drug that allows us to thrive while the rest of us stew in the misery their actions and beliefs cause us?

It is the drug that is compounded of old dreams. Dreams, rivers and mountains and bottomless reservoirs of dreams, are the cultural birthright of our peoples, the Jews and the Palestinians both.

In the past, our dreams were all that we could truly rely on as possessions. Little wonder that we cannot bring ourselves to part from them.

It will take radical action to do so. It will take radical action on the part of people unaccustomed to viewing themselves as radicals. It will take a willingness to take the most radical step that anyone who loves and lives in this Holy Land of ours can take:

To see the person on the other side, not as the Other Side, but as a person.

_________________


Previous blogs:
We can't be war criminals, we're Palestinian
Ten ways to make sure that peace stays dead
Palestinians: Our human shield against Iran nukes?
I voted for a war criminal


_________________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and an openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, ethnic cleansing, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.
5.Use of the phrase: "There are no Palestinians" or derivatives thereof.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dishonorable President
In his speech on Wednesday, Katsav proved that he is not worthy of the presidency.
Demanding reform
A group of Jewish study centers will no longer refer candidates to Israeli courts.
  1.   Israel created Hamas. Live with it. 09:58  |  Natallie Durson 28/11/06
  2.   Bradley, do you have a BS in political science? 10:02  |  Shlomo 28/11/06
  3.   Occupation. The Israeli disease 10:13  |  Ben 28/11/06
  4.   Disengenuous 10:24  |  Gina 28/11/06
  5.   Occupation is a tool used by extremists 10:31  |  John 28/11/06
  6.   It is Uncivilized when a Person Burn Churches 10:49  |  Joseph E . 28/11/06
  7.   occupation, the great beast 10:55  |  Ernst 28/11/06
  8.   To islamists, the whole of Israel is "occupied" 10:56  |  Paul Henzen 28/11/06
  9.   It is uncivilized from peace now to state a land grabb 11:03  |  Joseph E . 28/11/06
  10.   I AM AN EXTREMIST 11:04  |  indrajaya 28/11/06
  11.   Ben, What Decisions? 11:10  |  JewishHeart 28/11/06
  12.   natalie 11:11  |  abe 28/11/06
  13.   Natalie 11:13  |  A.M. 28/11/06
  14.   occupation, blah-blah 11:15  |  joe 28/11/06
  15.   1to 6 PLEASE ADD THE FOLLOWING BRADLEY 11:16  |  paul harris 28/11/06
  16.   What is the point of talkback in Haaretz? 11:18  |  Name 28/11/06
  17.   To Natallie: No. 1 11:27  |  Natan 28/11/06
  18.   #3 however ben it survived as a country HOW AWFUL FOR YOU 11:35  |  paul harris 28/11/06
  19.   #1.Hamas is part of the Moslem brotherhood,100 years old,created? 11:38  |  PETER SM 28/11/06
  20.   BEN. Wrong!.1967.The Arabs were offered it ALL back for peace 11:45  |  Peter S.M. 28/11/06
  21.   Morally equivocating on questionable grounds? 11:55  |  Chuck 28/11/06
  22.   At the end, Hamas may have saved the Jewish state of Israel 11:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 28/11/06
  23.   I AM AN EXTREMIST, TOO 12:03  |  Paul Henzen 28/11/06
  24.   Your guiding principles would bar Golda Meir from posting here! 12:06  |  Yael 28/11/06
  25.   Indrajaya:yes,you`re blind extremist 12:06  |  Chris 28/11/06
  26.   # 1 Natallie Durson @ Los Angeles / USA 12:17  |  Joseph E . 28/11/06
  27.   Natallie hits the nail 12:23  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 28/11/06
  28.   Angles and Indrajaya 12:36  |  sh 28/11/06
  29.   Extremists from both sides are objective allies 12:37  |  Marwan 28/11/06
  30.   ISLAM IS POISONING ISRAEL`S G-D GIVEN LAND INHERITANCE ?? 13:09  |  Bill. 28/11/06
  31.   Re #10 - Indraya: I AM AN EXTREMIST 13:16  |  Daniel 28/11/06
  32.   According to Dante...You have a Reservation in Hell 13:17  |  Klaudia 28/11/06
  33.   to indrajaya 13:22  |  alef 28/11/06
  34.   Re # 24 Yael and Haaretz guidelines 13:22  |  Daniel 28/11/06
  35.   peter s.m 13:23  |  sacher-masoch 28/11/06
  36.   Re # 16 Talkback on Haaretz 13:28  |  Daniel 28/11/06
  37.   Re #23 Paul Henzen 13:33  |  Daniel 28/11/06
  38.   #30 Bill 13:45  |  Baal 28/11/06
  39.   #24 Yael 13:47  |  Metatron 28/11/06
  40.   Joseph E 13:53  |  Walid 28/11/06
  41.   There is no symmetry between two sides, Mr Burston 13:57  |  www.kibush.co.il 28/11/06
  42.   Abe 14:15  |  Walid 28/11/06
  43.   SACHER Torte? Yawhol mein Kommandant krieg ist hel nichtwahr? 14:19  |  PETER SM 28/11/06
  44.   SACHER Torte? Yawhol mein Kommandant krieg ist hel nichtwahr? 14:20  |  PETER SM 28/11/06
  45.   are there Palestinians? 14:20  |  Watcher 28/11/06
  46.   Interesting responses 14:21  |  Chris Linthwaite 28/11/06
  47.   the extremist joker 14:22  |  Watcher 28/11/06
  48.   Paul Henzen 14:25  |  Walid 28/11/06
  49.   Only one solution-exercise your right of return 14:39  |  Amin Nusseibeh 28/11/06
  50.   # 45 Are there israelis? 14:40  |  Jens 28/11/06
  51.   Nat Durson..Now the Pals can deal with Hamas 14:40  |  albert amato 28/11/06
  52.   The difference between an extremist and a non-extremist 14:52  |  Zev 28/11/06
  53.   #11 Decisions 14:56  |  Ben 28/11/06
  54.   so true and so scary 14:58  |  michael 28/11/06
  55.   Taking a thoughful step back 15:27  |  Richie 28/11/06
  56.   Chris Linthwaite 15:15  |  goo 28/11/06
  57.   to Jens, Americans, Russians 15:18  |  Watcher 28/11/06
  58.   #1 natallie UTTERLY REFUSES TO LEARN HISTORY 15:27  |  paul harris 28/11/06
  59.   # 23 Paul Henzen. I AM AN EXTREMIST AS WELL, ACCORDING TO BRAD` 15:38  |  Kathy 28/11/06
  60.   Bradley,Gaza is not occupied 15:44  |  Ronnie Wolman 28/11/06
  61.   What defines the word extremism ? 15:46  |  Swiss (Dino) 28/11/06
  62.   #56 Goo 15:49  |  Chris Linthwaite 28/11/06
  63.   # 40 Walid @ Beirut 15:57  |  Joseph E . 28/11/06
  64.   Messiah 15:58  |  Yoel 28/11/06
  65.   Ernst 16:02  |  ODP 28/11/06
  66.   Schlomo...what is the problem 16:02  |  Jack 28/11/06
  67.   To Bradley Burston............... 16:04  |  Kathy 28/11/06
  68.   Hamas more moderate than settlers 16:06  |  Tosefta 28/11/06
  69.   What is `occupation` 16:25  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 28/11/06
  70.   Burston and his ill-fated comparisons 16:27  |  Jonathan S 28/11/06
  71.   Bradley - Well Put 16:28  |  Blinky the Fish 28/11/06
  72.   Amin Nusseibeh #49 16:28  |  GHMY 28/11/06
  73.   Hamas more moderate than settlers 16:36  |  Tosefta 28/11/06
  74.   # 65 ODP Silent accomplice 16:38  |  Swiss (Dino) 28/11/06
  75.   Burston Makes False Equivalency 16:41  |  Bruriah Sarah 28/11/06
  76.   Margie in the UK 16:43  |  GHMY 28/11/06
  77.   30 - Response 16:48  |  Bruriah Sarah 28/11/06
  78.   # 68 Margie in Tel Avivv 16:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 28/11/06
  79.   40 - The land was legally obtained 16:54  |  Bruriah Sarah 28/11/06
  80.   The tragedy is this fight over land has turned good people bad. 16:59  |  Timothy 28/11/06
  81.   Swiss(Dino) 16:59  |  ODP 28/11/06
  82.   41 - Response I 17:01  |  Bruriah Sarah 28/11/06
  83.   41 - Response 2 17:09  |  Bruriah Sarah 28/11/06
  84.   who is the extremist? 17:12  |  mrs. defarge 28/11/06
  85.   46:Hamas & Fatah want to destroy Israel 17:14  |  Bruriah Sarah