Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., November 28, 2006 Kislev 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:23 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Israeli ambassador Itzhak Levanon during a UN Human Right Council meeting in Geneva on November 15. (AP)
Last update - 20:29 27/11/2006
UN Human Rights Council urges Israel to dismantle settlements
By The Associated Press

The United Nations Human Rights Council, which has censured only Israel during its six-month existence, overwhelmingly urged Israel on Monday to halt expansion of settlements on occupied land as a first step towards their removal.

A total of 45 countries, including European Union members, Latin American states and Japan, voted in favor of the resolution proposed by Arab and other Islamic countries, with only Canada voting against and Cameroun abstaining.

The resolution, similar to others approved in the past by the old Human Rights Commission which the Council replaced earlier this year, called on Israel to take "serious measures" to prevent settlers attacking Palestinians.

Advertisement

It urged parties in the area to renew efforts to achieve peace and a comprehensive political settlement in order to create a situation "which will allow two states, Israel and Palestine, to live in peace and security".

In a speech urging the 47-member Council to reject the resolution, Israeli Ambassador to the UN's international offices in Geneva, Itzhak Levanon, said he had asked the Palestinian delegation to support its withdrawal in the light of the weekend ceasefire agreement between the two sides.

This would have given "an indication of their positive and constructive intention", he declared.

The resolution, Levanon said, failed to take account of Israel's dismantling of settlements in Gaza and the north of the occupied territories last year - "unilateral moves which only served to create an ever-worsening security situation for Israeli civilians".

Rights council votes against Israeli annexation of Golan
The council earlier Monday passed a resolution criticizing Israel's occupation of the Golan Heights.

The council voted 32-1 with 14 abstentions to declare illegal Israel's 1981 annexation of the Golan Heights and demand that Israel rescind its decision to impose its laws and jurisdiction on the area, which it captured in the 1967 Middle East war.

Canada, which said the resolution was unbalanced, was the only no vote, and European Union members abstained.

The United States and Israel are not members, but Levanon said Syria had proposed the resolution "purely to draw attention away from its ... own deplorable human rights record."

"Under Syrian possession, the Golan Heights were used to launch constant
attacks against Israeli civilians," Levanon said. "Today, the Golan Heights is more peaceful than ever, stable and thriving. The economy is booming, fields are blossoming, and everyone is enjoying the benefits of democracy."

The resolution said Israel should "desist from changing the physical
character, demographic composition, institutional structure and legal status of the occupied Syrian Golan" and allow the displaced population to return to their homes.

The vote came as the council considered resolutions proposed at its September three-week session.

Earlier China, Cuba, Arab and African countries had already demonstrated their dominance of the new council by forcing through a resolution recommending a "code of conduct" for UN human rights experts.

The council approved the resolution proposed by Algeria on a 30-15 vote with two abstentions, overriding objections from the European Union, Canada and Latin American countries.

The vote gave an indication of the strength of countries which some human
rights organizations say are determined to rein in the experts who submit
critical reports on countries to the 47-nation council.

The measure doesn't spell out what should be in the code of conduct, but
requests that an intergovernmental group reviewing the work of the "special rapporteurs" assigned to different countries and issues should draft such guidelines taking into account suggestions made by council members.

The independent experts, who have been assigned to some of the world's worst rights abusers, often anger the governments they report on.

There already have been moves in the UN General Assembly to discourage UN
human rights bodies from adopting resolutions condemning the human rights
situation in any country.

Israel is the only country criticized by the council since it replaced the widely discredited Human Rights Commission last June. The new body has passed resolutions in regular session and in three emergency sessions, blasting the Israelis for the invasion of Lebanon and treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The voice of Agnon
Salman Schocken's scion's estate yields a rare recording of author S.Y. Agnon.
Soon-to-be lost garden
Advocates of the Mt. Scopus botanical gardens claim neglect on the part of the Hebrew U.
  1.   Get used to losing votes 15:34  |  Natallie Durson 27/11/06
  2.   Plus ca change... 15:44  |  BenAbuzaglo 27/11/06
  3.   Uncivilized, violent world gains more power. Pre-World War III? 15:46  |  Robert Finkelstein 27/11/06
  4.   Utter stupidity 15:58  |  Wise Syrian 27/11/06
  5.   The UN vote will always be against Israel 16:07  |  The Warrior 27/11/06
  6.   ISRAEL SAY ONE MAGIC WORD:THIS LAND G-D-GIVEN TO US &NO ONE ELSE 16:08  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 27/11/06
  7.   What it means?Who pays these freaks ?Hopefully not Europeans 16:09  |  Sal 27/11/06
  8.   NATALLIE, YOU R RIGHT:ISRAEL LOST SINCE THEY GAVE UP "OCCUPATION" 16:12  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH 27/11/06
  9.   Natalie Durson 16:26  |  Yariv 27/11/06
  10.   we did wrong. we should have and now must claim all historical je 16:30  |  ralph 27/11/06
  11.   WORKING VERY HARD 16:34  |  TOBIA 27/11/06
  12.   we need 10 organizations like this one 16:47  |  sam 27/11/06
  13.   Ever heard of the Security Council of the UN? 17:00  |  John 27/11/06
  14.   Ever heard of the Security Council of the UN? 2 17:00  |  John 27/11/06
  15.   Wise Syrian 17:03  |  Yaron 27/11/06
  16.   To Robert Finkelstein 17:03  |  John 27/11/06
  17.   UN resolution 17:21  |  TOMY 27/11/06
  18.   Everyone is enjoying the fruits of democracy??? 17:25  |  Joe 27/11/06
  19.   DOES THE CHARTER SAY( JOHN) 17:36  |  TOBIA 27/11/06
  20.   DONT START WARS AND LOSE ( JOE) 18:15  |  TOBIA 27/11/06
  21.   Natallie # 1 18:26  |  Twogunz 27/11/06
  22.   Re #20 18:36  |  Joe 27/11/06
  23.   Sam- The only judge is Hashem 18:56  |  The 3rd Floor 27/11/06
  24.   This UN body is a joke 19:18  |  Gina 27/11/06
  25.   Thank you Canada 19:24  |  Phillipe T. Lucre 27/11/06
  26.   # 19 19:27  |  worried 27/11/06
  27.   Absurd behavior when it comes to the Jewish State 19:37  |  Ben 27/11/06
  28.   Un Human Rights Council needs a new title 20:05  |  Cynic 27/11/06
  29.   UN HR Council 20:13  |  forrest Turner 27/11/06
  30.   CANADA FOR ABUSE OF HUMAN RIGHTS? 20:16  |  Messaoud 27/11/06
  31.   to quote gwb, WHO CARES WHAT YOU THINK? 20:16  |  Michelle 27/11/06
  32.   #1 You`re way off Natalie Durson 20:18  |  Dave 27/11/06
  33.   They voted the world flat also.............. 20:41  |  r 27/11/06
  34.   This UN HR council has no credibility 20:45  |  Dave 27/11/06
  35.   #24, Gina 20:45  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/11/06
  36.   to Messaoud 20:50  |  Ilya 27/11/06
  37.   #1 Natallie. Well said 20:54  |  Ben 27/11/06
  38.   Ashamed of Canada`s Vote 21:03  |  chet 27/11/06
  39.   Let`s all email Kofi Annan 21:04  |  Dave 27/11/06
  40.   yariv re natalie durson 21:06  |  dubious 27/11/06
  41.   Arab and Islamic countries... 21:09  |  Paul Henzen 27/11/06
  42.   Arabs poison is splashed over UN 21:13  |  Joseph E . 27/11/06
  43.   Ben #37 21:16  |  Yariv 27/11/06
  44.   Double standard 21:18  |  W 27/11/06
  45.   Dismantle the UN first 21:20  |  Michael 27/11/06
  46.   Save precious money: Dump the UN 21:25  |  Boris 27/11/06
  47.   John: Security Council 21:27  |  Paul Henzen 27/11/06
  48.   Yaron # 15 - Interesting 21:35  |  christa 27/11/06
  49.   Twogunz is wrong 21:41  |  christa 27/11/06
  50.   #2: No Natalie: try door #1 on those votes 21:43  |  Paul Freedman 27/11/06
  51.   # 37 Ben on # 1 Natallie 21:45  |  christa 27/11/06
  52.   You have been told Israel. 21:58  |  Maureen Ann 27/11/06
  53.   Israel has the best human rights standards, Arab world the worst 22:01  |  Robert Finkelstein 27/11/06
  54.   So which one was it? 22:03  |  Colin Wright 27/11/06
  55.   IAF attacks don`t help 22:13  |  Pssd Off American 27/11/06
  56.   So what??!!! 22:23  |  ScotGuy 27/11/06
  57.   Dismantling settlements would not lead to peace 22:26  |  Dave 27/11/06
  58.   United Nations Human Rights Council kisses..... 22:34  |  Mr. Ami Goldman 27/11/06
  59.   golan heights 22:42  |  jon 27/11/06
  60.   #39 lost control 22:43  |  alan 27/11/06
  61.   #23 22:45  |  alan 27/11/06
  62.   Christa: pre-67 "Normalcy"??? 22:50  |  Yitzhak 27/11/06
  63.   The UN: just ignore it 22:50  |  Real Swiss 27/11/06
  64.   Give back the Golan???Please 22:50  |  G.Perez 27/11/06
  65.   occupation ? 23:02  |  Jules 27/11/06
  66.   No respect for a UN that focuses on Israel instead of Darfur 23:04  |  Lebanese Christian 27/11/06
  67.   Golan Heights, and settelments.. 23:07  |  Galvin Templar 27/11/06
  68.   To G.Perez 23:08  |  Real Swiss 27/11/06
  69.   Short memory 23:12  |  G.Perez 27/11/06
  70.   Maureen Ann#52 23:29  |  Yariv 27/11/06
  71.   Umm Shumm for a reason 23:45  |  Jacob Blues 27/11/06
  72.   Umm Shumm for a reason 23:45  |  Jacob Blues 27/11/06
  73.   I`ve Got A Better Idea! 23:47  |  Yosemite Sam 27/11/06
  74.   WORLD HAS ENOUGH(MAUREEN ANN) 00:35  |  TOBIA 28/11/06
  75.   Of human rights and inhumane rights 02:37  |  Jeffrey 28/11/06
  76.   UN says stop building on land that`s not yours. Who can disagree? 05:09  |  Timothy 28/11/06
  77.   If you`re going to hire a liar, hire a good one. 06:02  |  Timothy 28/11/06
  78.   Protect Palestinians against the so called "settlers." 06:25  |  Timothy 28/11/06
  79.   this whole un human rights council is nothing but a joke 08:58  |  saul a. readner 28/11/06
  80.   #6-Israel say.... 19:07  |  Martha 28/11/06
 Today Online
Halutz: IDF not consulted enough on truce decision
Responses: 95
Bradley Burston: Occupation poisoning - Envy the extremist
Responses: 127
Ze'ev Schiff: Truce proves that Hamas' strategy worked
Responses: 44
Menachem Rosensaft: Lego can teach about the Holocaust
Responses: 26
Nadav Shragai: Palestinians have taken over much Jewish-owned land
Responses: 25
Qassams prompt change in IDF rules of engagement
Responses: 95
Rosner's Domain
* So, how many unaffiliated Jews voted for the Democrats?
* Rosner's Guest: Can Jews and Latinos be friends?