Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., November 28, 2006 Kislev 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:55 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A cease-fire is not enough
By Akiva Eldar

Who said that Ehud Olmert is not walking along Ariel Sharon's path? The new agreement for a cease-fire in the territories proves that the prime minister is indeed committed to the strategy of "there is no partner for peace." Sharon's unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip taught the Palestinian people that the terrorism of Hamas has worked where the diplomacy of the proponents of Oslo failed. The cease-fire - as "advance payment" for lifting the siege on the Palestinian Authority, releasing funds and freeing prisoners - fits like a boxing glove on the pounding fist of Hamas. Khaled Meshal and his colleagues also prefer unilateral steps to negotiations.

Long-term intermediate arrangements and short sightedness are better suited to the Hamas agenda than recognition of Israel and a peace agreement with the Zionists. With its "no-partner" policy, Israel teaches its neighbors that anyone still left in the peace camp becomes irrelevant. Imposing a cease-fire, lifting the siege on the PA and releasing prisoners are welcome steps whose importance cannot be underestimated. Nonetheless, in the absence of a broader political context, they turn into moves that are a recipe for disaster. They offer the rejectionists breathing room and a time-out to broaden their hold in the territories, without forcing them to alter any fundamental principles.

If it is possible to be rid of the Israelis for free, why pay in hard currency - such as relinquishing violence or all of Palestine? Who needs peace initiatives that require painful surgery now when Meretz leader Yossi Beilin, of Oslo, and key European Union countries are willing to prescribe another dose of pain-killers in the form of interim agreements? A little more patience and the government of Israel will sign off on a hudna (long-term cease-fire), placing all the plans for a final settlement in mothballs for the coming 10, maybe 20 years. Meanwhile, yet another generation will grow up in the territories, not knowing about Oslo and believing that Iran's bomb and Hassan Nasrallah's missiles will put the Jews in their place.

Advertisement

An Al-Qaida state has already been established in Iraq and the Americans are going to flee Baghdad any time now. The day in which Sharon's dream of "Jordan is Palestine" becomes the bitter reality of "Hamastan" on both sides of the river is not far away.

When the sole alternative to temporary arrangements and unilateral steps is the perpetuation of violence, temporary arrangements and unilateral steps become indispensable. However, when an alternative offering all-encompassing peace in the Middle East is within arm's reach - and includes normalization between Israel and the members of the Arab League - a hudna is criminal, if not downright stupid. This alternative is written, in black on white, in Arabic, in an unprecedented resolution passed at the League summit on March 28, 2002 in Beirut. In return for "normal relations" - which is much more than mere recognition of Israel's existence - it says that Israel will pull back to the borders of June 4, 1967, and reach a just, negotiated settlement of the refugee problem on the basis of United Nations Resolution 194.

The significance of the Arab League resolution lies well beyond what it has on offer - a historic shift in the attitude of Arab states vis-a-vis the Jewish state. It is an invaluable achievement also because of what it excludes: It does not mention the evacuation of settlements, and allows for the possibility that settlement blocks can be exchanged for territory elsewhere. It also skips over the phrase "right of return" for every refugee (which is not mentioned in UN resolution 194), and instead grants Israel the right to determine how many refugees will be allowed to return and on what terms. The fact that the holy sites in Jerusalem were not mentioned in the final draft was meant to allow the negotiators room to maneuver over this sensitive issue.

A cease-fire and unilateral initiatives that undermine the Beirut resolution are a heaven-sent gift to Arabs and Jews who believe that having Hebron without peace is preferable to peace without Hebron. Sharon's response to the Arab League initiative, a development of a Saudi Arabian plan, was to carry out Operation Defensive Shield. The destruction of the PA during the operation pushed him into the unilateral disengagement from the Gaza Strip. Olmert's statements suggest that he actually does understand that Sharon's path may be forcing the sensible elements backward.

Saudi Arabia is waiting for a phone call.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The voice of Agnon
Salman Schocken's scion's estate yields a rare recording of author S.Y. Agnon.
Soon-to-be lost garden
Advocates of the Mt. Scopus botanical gardens claim neglect on the part of the Hebrew U.
  1.   The "spoilers" never seem to die out 09:18  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  2.   How can there be peace? 09:28  |  Natallie Durson 27/11/06
  3.   Peace and Israel don`t go together 10:25  |  Andrew Watson 27/11/06
  4.   I propose my own political plan 11:11  |  Shlomo from Tel Aviv 27/11/06
  5.   #1 - I am very sure there will be peace 11:47  |  spyguy 27/11/06
  6.   to # 4 12:10  |  incredible!!! 27/11/06
  7.   #4 Shlomo, your plan boils down to this.... 12:15  |  Johnboy 27/11/06
  8.   Shlomo is definately correct! No Delay 12:51  |  Pablo 27/11/06
  9.   Peace with the Palestinians is not enough 13:06  |  Jonathan S 27/11/06
  10.   IRAN CAN`T BE BULLIED EASILY, SO... 13:32  |  indrajaya 27/11/06
  11.   LET THE EXPERIENCE OF IRELAND GUIDE YOU 13:58  |  paul harris 27/11/06
  12.   SIMPLE MY DEAR WATSON ,GIVE ISRAEL 100% OF ITS OWN LAND 14:00  |  paul harris 27/11/06
  13.   # 4 Shlomo, the " fair and balanced" Israeli 17:57  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  14.   The India/Pakistan two state solution 14:32  |  Nathan 27/11/06
  15.   2# Natallies solution; Judenrein palestine. 14:34  |  Nathan 27/11/06
  16.   Natallie Durson..and cheap peace 14:44  |  kameel 27/11/06
  17.   A chance for a cease-fire 15:04  |  Ron Culver 27/11/06
  18.   To Swiss 15:25  |  Shlomo from Tel Aviv 27/11/06
  19.   Cease fire is enough to keep Palestinians from defeating IDF 15:29  |  Mustapha K 27/11/06
  20.   Gazan exiles from Jaffa will never agree to Arab League proposal 15:39  |  Israeli realist 27/11/06
  21.   Israeli Realist #20 16:18  |  Avi Yerushalmi 27/11/06
  22.   # 18 Shlomo from Tel Aviv 16:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  23.   Johnboy 17:19  |  ODP 27/11/06
  24.   TO SHLOMO / Nr. 04 : HE IS RIGHT !!! 18:12  |  DAVID KOHEN 27/11/06
  25.   `67 borders 18:41  |  Noah 27/11/06
  26.   Why can`t Jews live in "Palestine"? 19:27  |  Allon 27/11/06
  27.   19 - Response 19:44  |  Bruriah Sarah 27/11/06
  28.   25 - Response 19:46  |  Bruriah Sarah 27/11/06
  29.   #1 when will you wake up 21:31  |  Michael 27/11/06
  30.   Akiva, You are right again ! 22:45  |  Dutch 27/11/06
  31.   #11 Harris, your beloved Israelis ... 22:57  |  Dutch 27/11/06
  32.   29 23:02  |  ussishkin 27/11/06
  33.   #18 Shlomo lives in a dreamworld 02:14  |  Johnboy 28/11/06
  34.   #23 ODP, Shlomo`s plan would require that... 02:22  |  Johnboy 28/11/06
  35.   When will you learn 03:29  |  Harry 28/11/06
  36.   to 16 Kameel 03:47  |  Nicolas 28/11/06
  37.   #31 doris the prophetess of doom JORDAN IS THE ARB STATE 03:48  |  paul harris 28/11/06
  38.   to 1- Swiss 03:58  |  Nicolas 28/11/06
  39.   Give it a break Olmert & disconect the phones. 05:34  |  Akram Zekaria 28/11/06
  40.   Enough Right Wing Meshugas 06:33  |  Tony 28/11/06
  41.   let the arabs decide Israels future 06:59  |  zionist forever 28/11/06
  42.   # 4 shlomo 07:04  |  zionist forever 28/11/06
  43.   Akiva believes in Land for Terror Camps. 09:02  |  Ken Jurist 28/11/06
  44.   # 43 Ken Jurist.re: AKIVA ELDAR. THE APPEASER... 23:09  |  Kathy 28/11/06
 Today Online
Halutz: IDF not consulted enough on truce decision
Responses: 128
Bradley Burston: Occupation poisoning - Envy the extremist
Responses: 182
Ze'ev Schiff: Truce proves that Hamas' strategy worked
Responses: 55
Menachem Rosensaft: Lego can teach about the Holocaust
Responses: 30
Nadav Shragai: Palestinians have taken over much Jewish-owned land
Responses: 43
Qassams prompt change in IDF rules of engagement
Responses: 128


More Headlines
21:36 U.S.: No point for Israel to talk to a Syria that supports terror
23:23 PM: Continuation of Qassam fire despite truce is 'disappointing'
23:17 Treasury meets Histadrut chair in last-ditch effort to avert strike
23:49 Palestinian FM enters Gaza Strip carrying case with $20M in cash
22:50 Ramat Gan search for Sela ends in case of mistaken identity
20:13 Mofaz: Arafat agreed to house secret Iranian bases inside PA
17:47 Abbas: Olmert initiative is 'positive' step toward peace-making
21:51 As result of Lebanon war, IDF plans to boost training by 30 percent
23:16 Health Ministry slammed for granting medical degree to sex offender
20:05 Netanyahu probed on alleged personal use of state funds
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved