Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., November 29, 2006 Kislev 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:20 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Meshal, en route to victory
By Danny Rubinstein

There is not much of a chance that the cease-fire between Israel and the Palestinians will be upheld. The reason is that the deterioration in the security situation between the sides is only one aspect of the Israeli-Palestinian political imbroglio that has been developing recently.

Ten months have elapsed since the dramatic victory of Hamas in the elections of the Palestinian parliament, in the wake of which Ismail Haniyeh's government was set up. The entire world, with the exception of Iran and Syria, rejected it. The United States and Europe, together with almost all the Arab countries, and of course Israel, boycotted it. They refused to transfer money to it or to meet its representatives. The distress in the territories and in particular in the Gaza Strip grew worse and, as the security situation declined, more dead and wounded were counted daily in Gaza and the West Bank.

What has been the result? Instead of the Hamas government collapsing, the movement's strongman and the head of its political bureau, Khaled Meshal, appeared at the end of the week at a news conference in Cairo and issued an ultimatum to the international community: You have six months to organize an Israeli withdrawal from the territories and to end the conflict, otherwise a third intifada will break out and the Palestinian Authority (PA) will collapse.

Advertisement

Of course, Meshal did not address Israel. He has no interest in previous agreements made with the country, nor in international demands that they be recognized. He looks down on the chairman of Fatah and the PA, Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen), and appears to mock him and his predecessor Yasser Arafat for wasting almost 10 years in negotiations over self-rule with only miserable results. What those leaders did not manage to achieve over long years of recognition of Israel, he hopes to achieve in a few short months. It is hard to believe Meshal will succeed, but it is clear that he, and Abu Mazen, with help from Israel and other nations, have succeeded in creating a crisis of such complexity in Palestinian politics that no one can see a way out.

To solve the crisis, it is necessary to overcome four interrelated problems simultaneously. First, a Palestinian national unity government has to be established, whose composition and political platform will be acceptable to the international community and will lead to a lifting of the boycott. Second, a genuine and stable cease-fire must be attained - not a partial, fragile one as was declared yesterday. Third, Gilad Shalit must be freed as part of a deal in which Palestinian prisoners are also released. And fourth, a framework has to be established for renewing peace negotiations.

It is difficult to follow the complexities of the discourse surrounding these four problems. Every day new proposals are made: Names of future ministers are bandied about, arguments ensue over certain clauses in the diplomatic plan, drafts are prepared for an agreement to free prisoners. Abu Mazen takes the various proposals, goes to Jordan, Egypt and Saudi Arabia, and returns with remarks and reservations. Haniyeh looks over the ideas, passes them on to Meshal and the leadership in Damascus, and returns with further comments. There is simply no end to this.

To square the circle even further, the international community, including the Arab regimes, is demanding that Meshal must not come out of all this victorious. If Meshal brings about the release of 1,400 prisoners in return for Shalit, and the establishment of a government that does not explicitly recognize Israel, this will be a clear message that Abu Mazen and the veteran Fatah and PLO activists have been selling Palestinian interests far too cheaply: They have recognized Israel without any serious quid pro quo, and because of their groveling policies, tens of thousands of Palestinians are today languishing in Israeli jails without any chance of being released.

It is doubtful whether under present circumstances the Israeli government can do much to change the situation. Meshal and Hamas are on the way to victory and if they are stopped en route, the price will be further deterioration and destruction.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Byzantine relic
Entire arch dating to Byzantine period discovered during J'lem synagogue renovations.
Ski scandal
Group accuses owner of Mt. Hermon ski resort of charging illegal fees.
  1.   What `victory` are you talking about? This does not make sense 09:07  |  Shalom Freedman 27/11/06
  2.   If peace concessions don`t hurt, you`re not doing it right 09:14  |  Natallie Durson 27/11/06
  3.   FORGET OSLO I, OSLO II, WYE, ROADMAP! LIBERATE GAZA, W.BANK)))))) 09:23  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 27/11/06
  4.   Hamas has to cancel its charta 09:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  5.   What Victory? 09:56  |  Gina 27/11/06
  6.   #4 Swiss (Dino) 10:01  |  chris 27/11/06
  7.   crazy danny r. 10:03  |  vladimir 27/11/06
  8.   Israel`s policy of killing Palestinians 10:08  |  Andrew Watson 27/11/06
  9.   Swiss 10:16  |  Gina 27/11/06
  10.   # 6 Chris 10:18  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  11.   For Swiss (Dino) # 4 10:20  |  Clickfool 27/11/06
  12.   Meshal not winning. Olmert/Peretz are losing it for us. 10:32  |  Bennie 27/11/06
  13.   Let this @$$hole bring on another "intifada"! 10:41  |  Zuriel 27/11/06
  14.   # 12- Bennie .. You said it Brother ! 10:41  |  Klaudia 27/11/06
  15.   what "international community"? 10:46  |  raymond deane 27/11/06
  16.   # 9 Gina 10:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  17.   # 11 Clickfool 10:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  18.   #10 Swiss (Dino) - which "Israel" to recognise? 11:06  |  chris 27/11/06
  19.   # 15 Raymond Deane 12:11  |  Nick Ferriman 27/11/06
  20.   the problem remains THE SOLUTION REMAINS 12:13  |  paul harris 27/11/06
  21.   Never peace with Hamas 12:23  |  Jonathan S 27/11/06
  22.   Defeat Terrorists Will Bring Peace 12:29  |  Terry 27/11/06
  23.   So how do YOU suggest our ineffective gov`t be dumped? 12:31  |  Yaakov K. 27/11/06
  24.   #11 Clickfool points out the "facts on the ground" 12:55  |  Johnboy 27/11/06
  25.   IT IS NOT ABOUT VICTORY... IT IS ABOUT HOPE FOR BETTER FUTURE 12:59  |  Messaoud 27/11/06
  26.   what victory? Time will decide. 13:22  |  the third man 27/11/06
  27.   JUSTICE WILL FIND A WAY 13:25  |  indrajaya 27/11/06
  28.   Israel doing that? very funny Mr. Aldar 13:29  |  Abbey 27/11/06
  29.   (As good as) nothing to lose 14:14  |  Fred 27/11/06
  30.   Borders #8 14:17  |  Jo Jo 27/11/06
  31.   # 24 Johnboy 14:35  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  32.   Killing Sleeping Palestinians and a Truce for the Killers 14:48  |  Yossi Cronenberg 27/11/06
  33.   Johnboy and Chris et el 15:25  |  Avi Yerushalmi 27/11/06
  34.   Of course, Meshal & Hamas on way to victory-IDF lost as usual 15:27  |  Nir Caspi 27/11/06
  35.   Question 16:05  |  ODP 27/11/06
  36.   Johnboy 16:10  |  ODP 27/11/06
  37.   Avi Yerushalmi 16:13  |  ODP 27/11/06
  38.   Simple Exchanges or Comprehensive Discussions 16:14  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/11/06
  39.   To Johnboy #24 16:32  |  Geoff 27/11/06
  40.   #38 Ronnie Wolman 16:57  |  tbora 27/11/06
  41.   Messaoud this is the first time 16:57  |  bev 27/11/06
  42.   # 35 ODP Play on words 17:00  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  43.   Tbora 17:18  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/11/06
  44.   Swiss(Dino) 17:23  |  ODP 27/11/06
  45.   tbora 17:27  |  ODP 27/11/06
  46.   Swiss 17:29  |  Gina 27/11/06
  47.   # 44 ODP 17:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  48.   ODP #37 17:54  |  Avi Yerushalmi 27/11/06
  49.   of course. they are leaders 17:54  |  naftaly k 27/11/06
  50.   JUSTICE never found its way 18:00  |  Honi 27/11/06
  51.   Jump to attention, ordered temporary ceasefire. 18:13  |  H.H.M 27/11/06
  52.   # 46 Gina 18:21  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  53.   Swiss - words are important 18:35  |  Gina 27/11/06
  54.   Olmert, You Moron, Even Rubinstein Thinks Your Dumb! 18:42  |  Tod Zuckerman 27/11/06
  55.   Avi 18:54  |  ODP 27/11/06
  56.   Swiss(Dino) 18:57  |  ODP 27/11/06
  57.   # 52 Gina 19:12  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  58.   Swiss -- I am not Israeli 19:29  |  Gina 27/11/06
  59.   15 - Response 19:38  |  Bruriah Sarah 27/11/06
  60.   32 - And what about Jews who are being killed? 19:40  |  Bruriah Sarah 27/11/06
  61.   THEY HAVE BEEN VICTORIOUS... 20:13  |  MIKE KATZ 27/11/06
  62.   When the peace ball gets rolling it`s out of Meshal`s hands 20:17  |  Hadassah H. 27/11/06
  63.   Why should Israel negotiate??? 20:23  |  ScotGuy 27/11/06
  64.   # 58 Gina 20:23  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/11/06
  65.   Swiss 20:53  |  Gina 27/11/06
  66.   to Swiss, Gina and ClickFOOL 21:20  |  Dave from Chicago 27/11/06
  67.   Evantually there will a one state solution.. looks like 21:24  |  omolll 27/11/06
  68.   natalie #2 21:33  |  dana 27/11/06
  69.   With this newspaper, Hamas does need any of its own 21:34  |  Dr. Allan 27/11/06
  70.   Gina and Swiss 21:50  |  albert amato 27/11/06
  71.   Israel must negotiate with a Palestinian unity government 22:04  |  Ben Alofs 27/11/06
  72.   Gina #46 23:07  |  dana 27/11/06
  73.   Andrew Watson 00:00  |  Martin 28/11/06
  74.   Chicago Dave....Sharon`s 1982Innvasion 00:16  |  John 28/11/06
  75.   #33 Avi, sorry, you are spin, spin, spinning 01:20  |  Johnboy 28/11/06
  76.   #36 and #39 land swap for settlements 01:32  |  Johnboy 28/11/06
  77.   #63 ScotGuy asks why Israel needs to negotiate 01:43  |  Johnboy 28/11/06
  78.   albert amato 02:24  |  Gina 28/11/06
  79.   dana - context 02:30  |  Gina 28/11/06
  80.   Ben Alofs - Should Gilad be given a visit from the Red Cross? 02:32  |  Gina 28/11/06
  81.   Dave from Chicago 02:35  |  Gina 28/11/06
  82.   Ronnie Wolman #43 03:07  |  GHMY 28/11/06
  83.   #80 Should Gilad have Red Cross visits? 04:55  |  Johnboy 28/11/06
  84.   no one can defeat terrorism! 06:15  |  maria 28/11/06
  85.   #64, Dino 07:36  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 28/11/06
  86.   Gina again 07:49  |  dana 28/11/06
  87.   dana - the status quo serves which group? 09:03  |  Gina 28/11/06
  88.   Johnboy 09:10  |  Gina