Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., December 12, 2006 Kislev 21, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:53 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 05:17 24/11/2006
Noted religious Zionist rabbi calls for anti-Qassam militias
By Nadav Shragai, Haaretz Correspondent

Well-known religious Zionist rabbi Yisrael Rozen is advocating unsupervised Jewish militias as a solution to the Qassam rocket fire in the South.

"Had the reins of the state been in 'Jewish' hands, not necessarily religious, we should have allowed the youth of Sderot, Ashkelon, the western Negev and anyone fit to bear arms ... to fight back in the framework of ungoverned militias," he wrote in remarks that will be published Friday in the weekly Zomet Institute bulletin Shabbat Beshabato.

"The eternal response to terror is counter-terror, an eye for an eye," wrote Rozen, who heads the Zomet Institute in the Gush Etzion settlement of Alon Shvut, which addresses issues related to Judaism and modern life.

Advertisement

"The strategic affairs minister will be able to argue that the State of Israel has become integrated in the Middle Eastern sphere and is incapable of controlling the mili[tant]-Zionist youth," Rozen argues.

Rozen wrote he would not argue with those who claim the suggestion is ineffective, "primarily because of the leftist underground organization in the media."

Rozen defends the proposal, saying he considers it an ethical one.

Earlier in the week, the settlers' rabbinical council expressed support for a return to the "Jewish ethic" of killing someone before he kills you.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Selling Hanoch Levin
Events are being staged to introduce international directors to Israeli theater and dance.
Herzl's pipe dream
A joint Israeli-Jordanian- Palestinian project is seeking to preserve the Dead Sea.
  1.   It is already twenty eyes for one. 05:23  |  Billy Jack 24/11/06
  2.   The time has come for "Religious" action 05:37  |  Steve 24/11/06
  3.   Jewish militia 06:01  |  Simon G 24/11/06
  4.   As we correctly advise brainwashing Muslim clerics... 06:04  |  Steve 24/11/06
  5.   Back to Reverso-World 06:06  |  Natallie Durson 24/11/06
  6.   Spot On 06:15  |  Art 24/11/06
  7.   Probably the only way... 06:23  |  Ravikumar 24/11/06
  8.   reponse to #1 Billy Jack are u nuts? 06:36  |  Stan 24/11/06
  9.   WOW! 06:57  |  Danite 24/11/06
  10.   He`s right 06:58  |  Gili 24/11/06
  11.   There will be nobody left who can see! 07:12  |  Zvi-Hersch 24/11/06
  12.   Israel needs another Haganah 07:18  |  RA 24/11/06
  13.   AMEN! Only JEWS can`t defend JEWS, not the UN not the French 07:45  |  amir 24/11/06
  14.   Bring back the davidka 08:06  |  Richard S. 24/11/06
  15.   He`s Living In A Western Movie 08:13  |  Rowan Berkeley 24/11/06
  16.   Correction to # 11 08:19  |  Zvi-Hersch 24/11/06
  17.   Extremists On Both Sides Can Agree 08:21  |  David 24/11/06
  18.   Need leadership that Israelis trust. 08:25  |  PETER SM 24/11/06
  19.   Middah K`negged Middah 08:36  |  Ilana 24/11/06
  20.   Billy Jack #1 08:42  |  Brad 24/11/06
  21.   militias 09:07  |  Butch 24/11/06
  22.   rabbi rosen 09:18  |  colin elkon 24/11/06
  23.   Marching bravely into Gaza to take on Hamas fighters? 09:41  |  Clickfool 24/11/06
  24.   Militia Groups 09:42  |  joshiewitz 24/11/06
  25.   He`s right,pals+UN shamelessly explore Israeli restraint 09:51  |  Absolute Sweden 24/11/06
  26.   I`d prefer to see Gaza bulldozed flat 10:14  |  Allon 24/11/06
  27.   The message vs The messenger 10:20  |  Elimelech 24/11/06
  28.   ROSEN AND ANARCHY 10:25  |  simon 24/11/06
  29.   yeah great idea, more bloodshead and primitive behaviour 10:30  |  Tom Smitsloo 24/11/06
  30.   Eye 4 Eye Means More Dead Israelis 10:39  |  Danya 24/11/06
  31.   Now there is a great idea 10:51  |  Colin Wright 24/11/06
  32.   Huzza, The final solution 10:58  |  Joe 24/11/06
  33.   I don`t think it would work 11:02  |  Michael A. Shoemaker 24/11/06
  34.   Why not? 11:04  |  Marcelo 24/11/06
  35.   Jewish government 11:10  |  shulamit 24/11/06
  36.   Clickfool No. 23 is FAKE 11:13  |  Clickfool 24/11/06
  37.   are we as primitive as our opponents? my dogtrainer tought me.... 11:38  |  tom smitsloo 24/11/06
  38.   #19, Ilana. Were your rule realized, there`d be no Ilana 11:52  |  zmogus 24/11/06
  39.   Good Idea: Send independent `Kach` assasination squads to Aza 12:11  |  Yehuda Maccabbee 24/11/06
  40.   And this is what theYouth of Sderot wants? 12:12  |  Jack 24/11/06
  41.   Rabbi Is Wrong 12:26  |  Terry 24/11/06
  42.   I doubt the truth of this report 12:37  |  Shalom Freedman 24/11/06
  43.   What do we learn from this ? 13:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/11/06
  44.   Be Palestinian militants` guests, dear armchair militia-to-be 13:21  |  zmogus 24/11/06
  45.   God forbid. We are not Palestinians. 13:24  |  Shlomo from Tel Aviv 24/11/06
  46.   "Jewish" cowboy 13:30  |  Honi 24/11/06
  47.   Shalom Freedman, I agree 13:46  |  Paul Henzen 24/11/06
  48.   Bravo!!! Shlomo. You are 100% right! 13:46  |  the pope 24/11/06
  49.   to `ALLON`s post 13:55  |  Shira Alfandari 24/11/06
  50.   # 34- Marcelo- Excellent Suggestion. 14:02  |  Klaudia 24/11/06
  51.   I thought Israel already had that. i.e. IDF/ Jewishness 14:11  |  Lubnani Yehudi 24/11/06
  52.   WILD EYED IN-BREEDS ON THE RAMPAGE!! 14:58  |  Dave 24/11/06
  53.   Fight terror with terror 15:06  |  Dr David I. Gross 24/11/06
  54.   this is long overdue!! 15:09  |  Anubhav 24/11/06
  55.   #45, Shlomo from Tel Aviv . Let`s see you reprimand from closer 15:09  |  zmogus 24/11/06
  56.   like Mohammad he shld declare himself a prophet 15:10  |  Wondering 24/11/06
  57.   Counter-terror for terror 15:18  |  Stephen Connor 24/11/06
  58.   Lubnany -Yehudi La takuna- Israel will never hurt the innocent 15:20  |  My Ego speaking 24/11/06
  59.   Not an eye for an eye but a Qassam for a Qassam 15:31  |  Zev 24/11/06
  60.   3Ms: Militias, Messianic, Missionary 15:42  |  Yussef Cohen 24/11/06
  61.   Is a Natural Consequence 16:09  |  Avi 24/11/06
  62.   Jewish militias 16:11  |  robert 24/11/06
  63.   Democracy?? 16:20  |  Mike 24/11/06
  64.   Shooting first is cold blooded murder 16:37  |  Marilyn 24/11/06
  65.   Billy Jack 17:21  |  Samir Khoury 24/11/06
  66.   Appalling atrocities would be the result 17:34  |  Michael 24/11/06
  67.   Jewish terrorists 17:35  |  Tosefta 24/11/06
  68.   Finding a Solution to Stop the Qassam Rockets 17:52  |  Johnny Weintraub 24/11/06
  69.   364 an austarlian story from marylin IT MAKES US WEEP 17:58  |  paul harris 24/11/06
  70.   Shlomo from Tel Aviv # 45 I Agree 18:06  |  Jeff Northridge 24/11/06
  71.   dave the champion of the underdog ??? 18:09  |  paul harris 24/11/06
  72.   #63 Israeli Minutemen 18:20  |  Bob 24/11/06
  73.   Would they get on the EU and U.S. terror-list ?? 18:30  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/11/06
  74.   #39, Yehuda Maccabbee. Show compassion to Kach 18:30  |  zmogus 24/11/06
  75.   Samir 18:31  |  ODP 24/11/06
  76.   To Samir 18:42  |  Josh 24/11/06
  77.   EMANUEL - G_D IS WITH US - to Yussef Cohen 19:08  |  Stephen Connor 24/11/06
  78.   foolish robert -#62 19:17  |  Stephen Connor 24/11/06
  79.   # 42 Freedman, One only has to look... 19:21  |  John 24/11/06
  80.   Shooting First - 67 madness? 19:34  |  Dr David I. Gross 24/11/06
  81.   Ethics? My foot. 19:55  |  S 24/11/06
  82.   Ethics? My foot. 19:56  |  Shelley 24/11/06
  83.   Israel`s bullying is self destructive 19:58  |  Dutch 24/11/06
  84.   Jewish terrorists 20:18  |  Tosefta 24/11/06
  85.   Good joke, Stephen Connor # 67 20:20  |  Clickfool 24/11/06
  86.   Challenge for David L.Gross # 53 20:28  |  Clickfool 24/11/06
  87.   Marilyn Your Outrage Please 20:28  |  Gabe1 24/11/06
  88.   #81, Dutch 20:43  |  michael matters 24/11/06
  89.   Jewish terrorists 20:45  |  Tosefta 24/11/06
  90.   "jewish ethic" 20:57  |  tadchase 24/11/06
  91.   Ilana you are completly wrong 21:02  |  Aby 24/11/06
  92.   Bialystok Precedent for Militia 21:03  |  Stephen T. Meadow 24/11/06
  93.   "jewish ethic" 21:07  |  tadchase 24/11/06
  94.   The next generation will be Yisraaiili 22:13  |  Dawiidh ibn Dawiidh 24/11/06
  95.   You have state terrorism. 22:18  |  Billy Jack 24/11/06
  96.   #88 Michael, About self -Defense 22:36  |  Dutch 24/11/06
  97.   Noted religious Zionist rabbi calls for anti-Qassam militias 22:47  |  liorn 24/11/06
  98.   SAmir...# 65....YOu got what you 01:42  |  Ali 25/11/06
  99.   RE-Brad self defence? 02:06  |  Billy Jack 25/11/06
  100.   Mr. Cluckfool 02:08  |  Harold Wasserbomb 25/11/06
  101.   re-Samir kouhry 02:51  |  Billy Jack 25/11/06
  102.   # 53- Clickfool.. Milk and Cookies 03:05  |  Klaudia 25/11/06
  103.   I`m not a jew, but I thought rabbi`s were supposed to have wisdom 04:41  |  Voice of Reason 25/11/06
  104.   I don`t think it`s right 06:12  |  Willy 25/11/06
  105.   only fair 11:01  |  Rose 25/11/06
  106.   JOE VA Where does he say final solution.? 12:08  |  PETER SM 25/11/06
  107.   UPSET? how about protests at Qassems aimed at civillians? 12:15  |  PETER SM 25/11/06
  108.   BILLY JACK You have slogans. 13:21  |  PETER SM 25/11/06
  109.   Gabe1 15:27  |  Danite 25/11/06
  110.   Just goes to show 15:30  |  Danite 25/11/06
  111.   To Dave 16:27  |  G. Ron 25/11/06
  112.   Rabbi Rosen 16:47  |  Joe 25/11/06
  113.   is this guy a bush in rabbis clothing? 17:01  |  ravi 25/11/06
  114.   #103 No time to play follow the leader 18:57  |  Dutch 25/11/06
  115.   #95 Billy Jack, Amazing 19:01  |  John 25/11/06
  116.   You`re on your own 19:45  |  Jim 25/11/06
  117.   #23 19:51  |  Jim 25/11/06
  118.   Oh, no! Not again! 20:07  |  Jim 25/11/06
  119.   # 51 For Lubnani Yehudi 20:15  |  Jim 25/11/06
  120.   # 10 Gili in Canada says... 20:25  |  Jim 25/11/06
  121.   to clickfool 20:39  |  c 25/11/06
  122.   to tom smitsloo 20:46  |  citizen zero 25/11/06
  123.   to #52, dave from london 20:58  |  citizen zero 25/11/06
  124.   # 2 Good advice... 21:12  |  Jim 25/11/06
  125.   # 60 Yussef Cohen 21:42  |  Jim 25/11/06
  126.   controlled and measured manner 21:49  |  Kym 25/11/06
  127.   Make it the science class 22:39  |  George 25/11/06
  128.   #126 KYM IT HAS BEEN LONG ESTABLISHED IF THE STATE CANT DEAL WIT 23:21  |  paul harris 25/11/06
  129.   Zionist rabbi calls for anti-Qassam militias 00:20  |  Ralph 26/11/06
  130.   anti-Qassam militias , self defense 00:37  |  Ralph 26/11/06
  131.   Naqba part II 00:45  |  Pssd Off American 26/11/06
  132.   peter sm 00:54  |  billy jack 26/11/06
  133.   A society of law?? 01:23  |  Reason 26/11/06
  134.   #Lubnani Yehudi and the "rabbi" 01:55  |  Chaya K. 26/11/06
  135.   DEATH WISH 13-JEWISH STYLE. COMING TO THEATERS THROUGHOUT GAZA 03:20  |  Timothy 26/11/06
  136.   Israel is governed by UN EU and US 07:09  |  Rope-a-dope 26/11/06
  137.   Chosen of god!!! 07:11  |  ballistic 26/11/06
  138.   Solution to katushas 07:18  |  ballistic 26/11/06
  139.   jewish defense!!!! 07:26  |  Ben 26/11/06
  140.   Kym-measured response 07:49  |  Rope-a-dope 26/11/06
  141.   No to Mob Rule 07:54  |  SJ 26/11/06
  142.   The Right to Self Defense 08:08  |  Efox 26/11/06
  143.   248 eyes for 1 eye 08:11  |  Efox 26/11/06
  144.   we do NOT need a JEWISH MILITIA .. WE HAVE A STATE !! 09:12  |  DAVID KOHEN 26/11/06
  145.   Good Idea 10:14  |  Marc Hamil 26/11/06
  146.   #42: Another provocation by the Left? 11:08  |  Yaakov K. 26/11/06
  147.   #144: A state, yes, but not a JEWISH state 11:12  |  Yaakov K. 26/11/06
  148.   A strong response maybe needed 15:28  |  Ishmael ali Hussani 07/12/06
  149.   RIGHT ON ART! 17:18  |  JOSHUA 12/12/06
 Today Online
Nadav Shragai: Jews who understand only the Palestinian dream
Responses: 65
Yitzhak Laor: Israel's battle cries and false beliefs
Responses: 22
PM faces storm over nuclear weapons remark
Responses: 185
El Al foreswears Sabbath flights amid boycott threat
Responses: 87
Israeli 'not sorry' Tutu probe into Beit Hanun canceled
Responses: 79
Rosner's Domain
* On Conservative homosexuals and liberal values
* Rosner's Guest: The halakhic status of homosexuals
* What I said (and what I meant) about Carter's book
* Is Baker an enemy of Israel?


More Headlines
17:30 PM: Israel won't be first to introduce nukes to region
17:24 Three Qassams hit western Negev despite Gaza cease-fire
17:34 Four Fatah demonstraters hurt by Hamas gunfire in Gaza Strip
17:43 Likud MK Eitan: High Court will destroy Israeli democracy
16:56 Iran conference lauds Ahmadinejad for doubting Holocaust occurred
17:06 Court eases compensation ban for civilians harmed by IDF
07:40 Olmert sends emissaries on secret Ramallah visit to Abbas
10:15 Int'l council approves 'face-lift' plan for Auschwitz-Birkenau
14:53 Court sentences officer who refused evacuation orders
16:53 Israeli Arab taken captive in Gaza released after 46 days
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Yad Ezra VeShulamit
This Chanukah gift the gift of a hot meal to a Jewish child
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved