Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., December 01, 2006 Kislev 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:29 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sadat, not Israel, made history
By David Govrin

The story of the Israeli-Arab conflict is full of formative events of historical, cultural and religious significance. The many wars have captured most of the focus in the analysis of the conflict's turning points and its division into various periods. However, the significance of peace events, such as former Egyptian president Anwar Sadat's historical visit to Jerusalem, have not always been appreciated for themselves.

Sadat's visit to Jerusalem in November 1977 was an event of tremendous importance, the results of which are still evident. His exceptional political wisdom taught us that a considerable part of the conflict is actually a psychological barrier - alienation, suspicion and mistrust - and that we can progress to a better future if we only find a way to overcome it.

When Sadat announced his willingness to come to Jerusalem, people argued that there was an ulterior motive to his visit, and that, in actuality, his views had not changed significantly. The shock that spread among parts of the public and the Israeli leadership proved how difficult it was to believe in a real move for peace and reconciliation in the existing whirlpool of hostility and hatred. It seems the psychological barrier in the conflict is still in force today, as is the necessary conclusion: Breaking this barrier is essential for developing a constructive dialogue.

Advertisement

The results of the visit were far-reaching: For the first time in the history of the conflict, an Arab leader expressed his willingness to recognize Israel unequivocally, to live with it in peace and security and to accept it into the family of nations in the region. Thus Israel was given the opportunity to become a part of the Middle East. Moreover, by publicly addressing Israel, Sadat demonstrated his acceptance of the principle of direct negotiations.

But apparently the results of Sadat's visit were not sufficiently internalized by the generation born after the event. This generation tends to treat the strong peaceful relations between Egypt and Israel as self-evident, and occasionally even tries to minimize the importance of the fact that the Israeli flag flies in the heart of Cairo. One might say it's a good thing that this generation is not familiar with any other reality.

The historical perspective of almost three decades reinforces the impression of the farsightedness of the Egyptian leader, and particularly of his words on the Knesset dais, that "peace is not a mere endorsement of written lines. Rather it is a rewriting of history." To a certain degree, it is ironic that while Israel repeatedly claimed that its hand was stretched out for peace, it was Sadat who so well expressed the desire for a new life and taught the younger generation in the region a new chapter in history: a chapter of reconciliation, recognition and mutual respect.

The writer serves as an adviser in the Political Planning Bureau of the Foreign Ministry.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
World Aids Day
HMO offers free AIDS tests to residents of Tel Aviv to mark world AIDS day.
Merging the parts
After 10 gigs at the Met, Israeli conductor Asher Fisch can call 2006 a record year.
  1.   He wanted the Suez and Western money 09:37  |  David Teich 23/11/06
  2.   David Teich - a perfect example of the problem 09:58  |  Michael 23/11/06
  3.   Lessons unlearned 10:20  |  Natallie Durson 23/11/06
  4.   to Michael from UK. But David Teich is right 10:21  |  Anubhav 23/11/06
  5.   Michael`s Double Standard, so obvious 10:31  |  Pablo 23/11/06
  6.   Israeli flag 10:41  |  emanuel 23/11/06
  7.   Typical......But It`s wearing Thin!!!!! 10:42  |  Tim 23/11/06
  8.   Poor Saadat 10:44  |  Mica 23/11/06
  9.   sadat 10:58  |  eva 23/11/06
  10.   David Teich, you are part of the problem 11:01  |  Esra 23/11/06
  11.   Pablo`s obliterations 12:01  |  sh 23/11/06
  12.   EGYPT KEEPING THE PEACE *COLD* NOT ISRAEL 12:22  |  URALL MADD 23/11/06
  13.   ISRAEL WAS FULL PARTNER TO PEACE WITH EGYPT. IF ONLY PALESTINIANS 12:36  |  URALL MADD 23/11/06
  14.   David Teich is making something positive sound negative 12:48  |  Wael Hendawi 23/11/06
  15.   Israel doesn`t want peace 13:17  |  David King 23/11/06
  16.   Sadat 13:22  |  Brod 23/11/06
  17.   David Teich 13:32  |  MR 23/11/06
  18.   SADAT AND RABIN... 13:41  |  Rami 23/11/06
  19.   better read this, jews about jews ......... 13:42  |  george 23/11/06
  20.   George de Nivelles 14:34  |  Dw 23/11/06
  21.   HAARETZ - WHY WONT YOU PUBLISH THE TRUTH 14:50  |  Dr David I. Gross 23/11/06
  22.   hello DW, how are you ? 14:57  |  george 23/11/06
  23.   David King - 15:12  |  Dr David I. Gross 23/11/06
  24.   #14 15:22  |  MR 23/11/06
  25.   on MR #17 15:22  |  zeev 23/11/06
  26.   George de Nivelles 15:27  |  MR 23/11/06
  27.   zeev from Beer-Sheva 15:36  |  MR 23/11/06
  28.   hey MR and DW, what game is it ? 15:40  |  george 23/11/06
  29.   to eva #9 - 2nd try 15:46  |  zeev 23/11/06
  30.   Re: Brod/HI-Tech weapons 15:54  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  31.   Great EGYPT 15:54  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  32.   George de Nivelles 15:57  |  MR 23/11/06
  33.   RE: DR.DAVID GROSS 16:04  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  34.   on Dr David I. Gross #21 - too ignorant to know the truth 16:06  |  zeev 23/11/06
  35.   so the problem is psychological 16:15  |  george 23/11/06
  36.   Half the Story 16:18  |  Danite 23/11/06
  37.   #6 Emanuel 16:30  |  Ernst 23/11/06
  38.   Zeev - Creative history 16:38  |  Dr David I. Gross 23/11/06
  39.   Pharaoh 16:43  |  Dr David I. Gross 23/11/06
  40.   to MR #27 16:46  |  zeev 23/11/06
  41.   Begin used Sadat to get Israel into trouble with Syria 16:48  |  Tosefta 23/11/06
  42.   WHAT A BLOODY AWFUL DEAL!! 16:52  |  paul harris 23/11/06
  43.   George de Nivelles 16:55  |  MR 23/11/06
  44.   Tosefta 17:06  |  danite 23/11/06
  45.   33 pharoah BUILDS TOMB FOR TRUTH !!! 17:28  |  paul harris 23/11/06
  46.   MR and real 17:30  |  george 23/11/06
  47.   RE:Paul Harris 17:31  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  48.   Re: Paul Harris #2 17:47  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  49.   Re: Paul Harris #2 17:47  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  50.   #47 pharoah and a WEAK MEMORY!!! 17:50  |  paul harris 23/11/06
  51.   #41 BUT THE GOLAN IS ISRAEL NOT SYRIAN 17:53  |  paul harris 23/11/06
  52.   Egypt rearms and prepares for war 18:01  |  Melvin Schnell 23/11/06
  53.   51 Golan?s real history (David Stoler 41; yesterday) 18:22  |  Tosefta 23/11/06
  54.   #49 GOOD IDEA PHAROAH ALL THE ARABS IN GAZA TO SINAI 18:22  |  paul harris 23/11/06
  55.   paul harris #50 18:34  |  Gee 23/11/06
  56.   Danite the Emotional 44 18:35  |  Tosefta 23/11/06
  57.   Pharaoh #49 18:36  |  Gee 23/11/06
  58.   George in Belguim (Post No. 22) 18:44  |  Johnny Weintraub 23/11/06
  59.   When I read your comments... 19:10  |  Pharaoh 23/11/06
  60.   To #22 george the Belgian 19:21  |  Israel supporter 23/11/06
  61.   59Pharaoh You sure got it upside down: 19:57  |  Michigan 23/11/06
  62.   And Israel believed that Arafat would be another Sadat... 20:02  |  Michigan 23/11/06
  63.   Sadat was worried about A-bomb on Nile dam flooding Delta 20:09  |  Michigan 23/11/06
  64.   nd what should Israel have offered to Arafat that it did not? 20:16  |  Michigan 23/11/06
  65.   to 60 & 58 - do you feel so much better than me ?? 20:36  |  george 23/11/06
  66.   supporting schnell,disproving harries 20:55  |  malkitsedek,cohen el 23/11/06
  67.   Tosefta the Apologist 21:15  |  danite 23/11/06
  68.   to Michigan #64 21:33  |  zeev 23/11/06
  69.   Begin made sure to destroy any hopes for further peace 22:20  |  Ibrahim 23/11/06
  70.   #57 GEE READ 49 AND SEE CORRECTION 23:01  |  paul harris 23/11/06
  71.   ZEEV 23:07  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/11/06
  72.   Who cares? Sadat is ancient history 00:06  |  Me 24/11/06
  73.   # 50 PH 00:17  |  Outsider 24/11/06
  74.   why sadat came to israel 00:31  |  harold 24/11/06
  75.   to Michigan #64 - 2nd try 02:18  |  zeev 24/11/06
  76.   Thank you Ha`aretz for pushing hard towards peace 03:00  |  Yankelowitz 24/11/06
  77.   To MR with love from France. A kiss on both of your cheeks 03:10  |  Yankelowitz 24/11/06
  78.   Georges #65 - weird definitions of zionism 03:18  |  lulu 24/11/06
  79.   Only War can buy you Peace. 04:50  |  Akram Zekaria 24/11/06
  80.   Michael ...David teich 05:11  |  John 24/11/06
  81.   it takes two. you have it wrong. israel always wanted peace. this 05:44  |  ralph 24/11/06
  82.   To Pharaoh 06:13  |  Klaudia 24/11/06
  83.   74Zeev Is Jewish Quarter of Old city of Jerusalem "occupied"? 06:17  |  Michigan 24/11/06
  84.   #78, Akram Zekaria 06:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 24/11/06
  85.   Sadat, not Israel, made history 06:46  |  jed nightingale 24/11/06
  86.   SADAT TOOK SINAI, GAVE A PIECE OF PAPER,BUT WAS MURDERED FOR THAT 06:58  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 24/11/06
  87.   Egyptian Response 07:14  |  Ahmed 24/11/06
  88.   Reply to Jed 07:59  |  Les 24/11/06
  89.   Ahmed`s Honest Response 09:00  |  Tim 24/11/06
  90.   #87 Egyptian "response" 09:13  |  Hastaroth 24/11/06
  91.   Sadat & Gaza 09:20  |  david 24/11/06
  92.   on MR #43 09:28  |  zeev 24/11/06
  93.   to C.J. Kohn #71 09:42  |  zeev 24/11/06
  94.   Anwar Sadat`s memory. 09:56  |  sandra chitayat. 24/11/06
  95.   History in eye of beholder 09:58  |  Elimelech 24/11/06
  96.   to Akram Zekaria #79 - Only ending the occupation can buy Peace. 10:21  |  zeev 24/11/06
  97.   # 1 A suggestion for David Teich 10:33  |  Eric 24/11/06
  98.   # 2 Michael - I recall that day... 10:44  |  Eric 24/11/06
  99.   A long healing process 10:46  |  Colin Wright 24/11/06
  100.   Dr David I. Gross 10:54  |  Walid 24/11/06
  101.   To Klaudia 10:59  |  Eric 24/11/06
  102.   Egyptian Response-Continued 11:11  |  Ahmed 24/11/06
  103.   Sadat best arab leader 11:16  |  Sir Hani 24/11/06
  104.   # 87 to Ahmed in Cairo 11:29  |  Eric 24/11/06
  105.   to Akram Zekaria #79 - Only ending the occupation can buy Peace. 13:24  |  zeev 24/11/06
  106.   to Michigan #83 13:46  |  zeev 24/11/06
  107.   95#Zeev`Ending the occupation`.Is Peace ?Be Serious. 14:45  |  Akram Zekaria 24/11/06
  108.   Sadat, not Israel, made history 15:26  |  Moshe Levy 24/11/06
  109.   to Ahmed #87 16:00  |  zeev 24/11/06
  110.   Patheitc article 17:59  |  FOX 24/11/06
  111.   Another Egyptian Response 19:46  |  Ahmose The Egyptian 24/11/06
  112.   Nathalie Why do you fight with us 21:18  |  Aby 24/11/06
  113.   106Zeev Stumling block is "Right of Return" not "Occupation" 22:37  |  Michigan 24/11/06
  114.   to Michigan #113 - part 1 03:05  |  zeev 25/11/06
  115.   to Michigan #113 - part 2 03:07  |  zeev 25/11/06
  116.   114-115Zeev Arafat did never compromise on "Right of Return" 04:42  |  Michigan 25/11/06
  117.   #1 history ! 11:35  |  observer 25/11/06
  118.   to Michigan #116 - 2nd try 19:36  |  zeev 25/11/06
  119.   Sadat made history only because Begin invited him! 19:51  |  Andre 25/11/06
  120.   So, Begin made history together with Sadat!!! 19:52  |  Andre 25/11/06
  121.   Didn`t anyone notice? 00:17  |  Yisrael Medad 26/11/06
  122.   Begin invited him because he has made history 00:26  |  Eric 26/11/06
  123.   to Akram Zekaria #107 04:16  |  zeev 26/11/06
  124.   # 120 Andre--Paris. ALL THESE PRAISES TO SADAT,WHAT A SHAM....... 21:12  |  Kathy 26/11/06
  125.   # Sadat PART TWO.GREAT? I DON`T THINK SO.ONTINUED................ 21:20  |  Kathy 26/11/06
  126.   124/125 Kathy. Wake up ! 04:13  |  Akram Zekaria 27/11/06
  127.   Zeev:331# &123# Sorry late reply. 11:57  |  Akram Zekaria 27/11/06
  128.   # 127 Akram Zekaria. THANK YOU FOR THE RESPONSE,AND HERE IS MINE. 18:00  |  Kathy 27/11/06
  129.   to Akram Zekaria #127 - part 1 03:49  |  zeev 28/11/06
  130.   Zeev.129# (1) 06:02  |  Akram Zekaria 28/11/06
  131.   Sadat`s visit 06:22  |  jon 28/11/06
  132.   to Akram Zekaria #127 - part 2 11:58  |  zeev 28/11/06
  133.   129#Zeev.Left & Right for others.We keep Kosher 15:07  |  Akram Zekaria 28/11/06
  134.   (1)132#Zeev. Are we lost ? 05:57  |  Akram Zekaria 29/11/06
  135.   (2) 132# Zeev. Are we lost ? 06:28  |  Akram Zekaria 29/11/06
  136.   (3)132# Zeev. Are we lost ? 07:06  |  Akram Zekaria 29/11/06
  137.   to Akram Zekaria 05:16  |  zeev 01/12/06
 Today Online
Rice praises Olmert's diplomatic plan during Jerusalem meeting
Responses: 252
ADL slams UN body for making Tutu head of Beit Hanun mission
Responses: 199
Ya'alon quits NZ after arrest warrant issued for war crimes
Responses: 184
Meron Benvenisti: Is Olmert's new plan just spin?
Responses: 59
Nazir Majali: The cease-fire seems to be serious this time
Responses: 54


More Headlines
01:50 High Court nixes Lebanon war probe petition
22:15 Rice meets PM, praises Olmert's diplomatic plan
02:21 Beinisch announces plan to cut Supreme Court caseload
01:33 IDF general implicated in war probe to face military hearing
05:01 IDF soldier gets two weeks in military prison for shooting Palestinian
23:15 IDF troops kill 16-year-old Palestinian near Nablus
02:41 Lawyers halt auction house sale of Nazi-looted paintings
01:48 New research reveals Vatican criticism of Holocaust-era pope
23:34 Iraqi PM: Troops to be ready to take over from U.S. by June
01:56 Songwriter and journalist Eli Mohar dies at the age of 58
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved