Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 20, 2006 Cheshvan 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:12 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 09:35 19/11/2006
Calibrating the centrifuge
By Zvi Bar'el

Iran has already achieved its goal. It no longer needs thousands of centrifuges or to obtain nuclear weapons to be considered a nuclear power. Iran is already there. It wields deterrence because it has the technology and potential to manufacture nuclear weapons. It is already there because everyone believes it will indeed produce nuclear weapons. And Iran also has one more small and threatening "advantage": a president who looks like a poet and sounds like a lunatic, whose words swell like a radioactive cloud. His threatening rhetoric even makes one forget that he is not the one responsible for the nuclear development. Rather, it was his predecessors, Hashemi Rafsanjani and Mohammed Khatami, presidents who were considered moderate in the West.

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's innovation is his candor. Already a year ago, he made it clear to anyone willing to listen that he plans to transform Iran into a superpower like any other superpower. If the criterion for being a superpower is nuclear capability, then Iran will also have this. From his perspective, this is a rectification of Iran's history. No longer a rag of colonialism, and not even a nice guy who must find favor in the eyes of the West, like his predecessor, Khatami. Ahmadinejad, the president who corresponded directly with George W. Bush, believes the West should respect Iran because of what it is: big, strong and threatening.

And this is starting to work. Whoever listens carefully to Bush and his representatives, instead of Olmert's growls, realizes that Iran will play an important role in the U.S. retreat from Iraq. This is because no Arab state can match Iran's power or its political influence on the Shi'ite leadership in Iraq. No Arab coalition can even compel a peripheral state such as Syria to assist the U.S. like Iran can. And no Western state currently has a magic potion capable of delaying the development of the Iranian weapon.

Advertisement

It is difficult to accept this situation, which evolved under the noses of everyone, especially because Iran is still considered a type of inferior, wild creature - whether its leaders wear a robe, or, as during the period of the shah, silk suits. Now, while the process of reeducating the West on Iran is in full swing, it is even more tormenting.

The loud declarations - one day speaking about a possible attack against Iran, and the next day falling in line with the increasingly conciliatory American policy - are evidence of this confusion. Because it is not only a matter of the tactical difficulty of locating all of Iran's nuclear labs and key scientists. Rather, the main issue is a lack of international consensus regarding the proper course of action. And it seems that Israel's shrillness actually reinforces the international community's feeling that it would be best to act with restraint. After all, in the eyes of many in this community, Israel is also tainted with a considerable amount of craziness and they see the Iranian issue as playing to Israel's political needs no less than affecting its existential concern.

In the absence of an internal consensus on a military solution, it would be best to try to calibrate the centrifuge of Tehran, to assume that Iran will have nuclear capability and to do what is required in light of this: to draw Iran back into the heart of the international community alongside states like India and Pakistan, and to conduct a dialogue with Iran not only on the quantity of centrifuges and the number of video cameras for monitoring the process, but also to involve Iran in international peace efforts. If Iran is worthy of being an interlocutor on the Iraq issue, perhaps it would also be good to talk with Iran about Syria, and perhaps a few other conflicts as well. Instead of allowing Iran to export rugs or pistachios to the U.S., perhaps it would be better to authorize American companies to develop oil fields in Iran. And, in particular, it would be best to discuss terms for deleting the concept of "axis of evil," which has so far generated policy that has caused great damage to the security of the world. Because it seems that Iran is about to receive a new job: monitoring the security of the Persian Gulf.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Gaydamak's harvest
The state has turned this man into one of the most influential individuals in the country.
Stealing clients
Thousands of non-Jewish lawyers took the clients of their Jewish colleagues in 1944.
  1.   Is Zvi Bar`el really a compatriot of Nethanyau and Lieberman ?? 10:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 19/11/06
  2.   Ridiculous cheek, yet again 10:57  |  Hannah 19/11/06
  3.   Cooling instead of stoking 11:16  |  sh 19/11/06
  4.   Dino I rather be dead than have you welcome me. 12:12  |  Steven 19/11/06
  5.   No Option Except Military Strike 12:21  |  Terry 19/11/06
  6.   #4, any more mad men like you here ? 12:59  |  viper 19/11/06
  7.   Israel has nuclear weapons, now so does Iran 12:59  |  David King 19/11/06
  8.   Israel think & act positive... 14:53  |  Guess who 19/11/06
  9.   What about the tyranny and the fatwas? 15:17  |  David Hoffman 19/11/06
  10.   Good more and more good sense in Haaretz! 15:27  |  Moshe 19/11/06
  11.   david king dino; iran shooting off at the mouth 15:40  |  Topanga 19/11/06
  12.   Following The Paradigm 15:59  |  Victor Smolinsky 19/11/06
  13.   # 11 Topanga 16:34  |  tbora 19/11/06
  14.   Excellent and thought-provoking analysis 17:23  |  Bracha 19/11/06
  15.   It is Iran`s desire 19:13  |  Michael 19/11/06
  16.   us and them 19:14  |  jan simon 19/11/06
  17.   Mr. Hoffman 19:14  |  p 19/11/06
  18.   Steven quotes Kahane and despises racists LOL 19:16  |  p 19/11/06
  19.   Bar`el in the Bubble 20:05  |  Tod Zuckerman 19/11/06
  20.   Seymour Hirsch - CIA says no Iran nukes 22:33  |  Boycott 19/11/06
  21.   #17 p and boring fabrications 22:50  |  Reality Check 19/11/06
  22.   Steve 00:59  |  David King 20/11/06
  23.   Terry 01:01  |  David King 20/11/06
  24.   Topanga 01:07  |  David King 20/11/06
  25.   tbora 01:11  |  David King 20/11/06
  26.   Do you want to listen to the truth or propaganda!? 01:12  |  Reza 20/11/06
  27.   Military might is only quarter of the solution 01:42  |  George Goldman 20/11/06
  28.   Assumptions Behind This Article 02:22  |  Harry D 20/11/06
  29.   Reza, Truth vs. propanda 02:39  |  Bruce 20/11/06
  30.   David King Jew hater numero uno, you think I care what you think? 03:05  |  Steven 20/11/06
  31.   too late 03:38  |  Joey 20/11/06
  32.   Reza has a point. 05:36  |  Voice of Reason 20/11/06
  33.   War is futile 05:57  |  Dee Dubb 20/11/06
  34.   And if Israel were silent there would be "international consensus 06:22  |  McQueen 20/11/06
  35.   #20, Boycott 07:46  |  Hannah 20/11/06
  36.   #24, David King 07:50  |  Hannah 20/11/06
  37.   Response To `P` 07:58  |  Harry D 20/11/06
  38.   #28 Harry D makes some good points 08:04  |  Johnboy 20/11/06
  39.   there is not nuclear threat 19:08  |  seth 20/11/06
 Today Online
Yossi Sarid: Free Barghouti, future president of Palestine
Responses: 80
Editorial: Israel is deflecting diplomatic initiatives
Responses: 48
Bush: I'd understand if Israel chose to attack Iran
Responses: 239
IDF used cluster bombs in Lebanon against Halutz orders
Responses: 97
Yoni Goldblat-Lavev: Only Hamas can drive the Jews out
Responses: 53
Rosner's Domain
* Week-off notes: What to read this week
* From the end of history to the end of ideology
* Rob Satloff: Talking to Arabs about the Holocaust
* Bush gives go-ahead for 'Bush Center' in Israel


More Headlines
19:08 Six held in Germany over plot to blow up El Al plane
18:45 Eight families of October 2000 riot victims reject payout deal
16:11 Olmert repeatedly banned Peretz from meeting Abbas
19:04 New rule limits Palestinians from traveling in Israeli cars
18:30 Government agrees to build 700 reinforced dormitories in Sderot
18:31 7 Qassams hit west Negev; IDF: Force can't solve everything
17:08 PA unity gov't talks suspended as Abbas walks out on Haniyeh
14:36 Israel, Palestinians meet to discuss reopening Rafah crossing
18:12 Bedouin petition High Court requesting access to water supply
16:34 Ahmadinejad: Israel, U.S. threats to attack part of 'psychological war'
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved