Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., November 23, 2006 Kislev 2, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:30 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Israel's UN ambassador Dan Gillerman. (Archive)
Last update - 09:05 19/11/2006
Gillerman: France demonstrates excessive eagerness to 'understand' terror
By Shlomo Shamir, Haaretz Correspondent, and Haaretz Service

Israeli envoy to the United Nations Dan Gillerman on Saturday was furious at a UN resolution to establish an investigative team to probe a recent incident in which some 20 Palestinians were killed in the north Gaza Strip town of Beit Hanun.

The UN General Assembly on Friday night overwhelmingly passed a resolution condemning the errant shelling of a Beit Hanun house. Representatives of 156 countries voted in favor of the resolution, seven objected and six abstained.

In an interview with Haaretz, Gillerman was highly critical of France, which was particularly active in raising the majority at the UN vote, pressuring European nations that considered abstention to support the resolution.

Advertisement

"The French demonstrated excessive eagerness to understand terror while exhibiting utter insensitivity to the pain of (Israeli) terror victims," Gillerman said.

Voting "no" were the United States, Israel, Australia, the Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru and Palau. Abstaining were Canada, Ivory Coast, Papua New Guinea, Tonga, Tuvalu and Vanuatu.

Europe's envoys cast their votes unanimously in favor of the resolution.

"The French were more active in promoting the resolution than the Qataris who submitted it. As a result of France's persuasion efforts, [other] delegates submitted amendments to the original draft resolution, written by the Arabs, which made significant changes that allowed them to support the resolution," he said.

Gillerman is of the opinion that "what spurred the French were tensions in Lebanon. The French expressed at the UN their chagrin at Israel for the overflights of Israel Air Force jets near French army positions in southern Lebanon, which they believe jeopardized their troops."

On Sunday morning Gillerman told Israel Radio: "If the French feel under attack then I think it would be a classic case depicted by the childhood phrase 'the thief's hat is on fire' (meaning the culprit's guilt is clear to all)."

"As I said over the pulpit, what a country like France would do if it were under rocket attacks? Would they be sending out flowers to those who launched the missiles? This (UN) resolution is like sending out flowers to terror, flowers that, God forbid, might be laid at the grave of another victim from Sderot."

"Anyone who saw the French ambassador leaning over the shoulder of the Palestinian envoy during my speech realizes this is more than a reasonable effort to try pass this resolution and to force other European countries to join in on the effort," Gillerman said.

Dan Gillerman walked out of the voting session in protest Friday, saying his words were falling on deaf ears and that he was better off holding a nearby press conference.

Prior to the debate, Gillerman said the session is a "humiliation and cynical exploitation of the UN, and whoever lends a hand to this decision is lending a hand to terror."

The United States ambassador to the UN, John Bolton, warned member states against approving the proposal, saying it would undermine the organization's relevance.

"Such a decision will only strengthen the widespread doubts regarding the UN, and lead many to conclude that the global organization cannot fulfill a role in the region," said Bolton.

Bolton called the resolution "one-sided" and said its adoption would only "increase tension and serve the interests of those hostile to Israel and that do not accept Israel's right to exist."

Bolton also slammed the UN Human Rights Council, based in Geneva, which called Wednesday for an inquiry into the Beit Hanun shelling.

"Since its inception, the new Human Rights Council has focused solely on Israel while completely ignoring human rights abuses in Darfur, Burma, and North Korea," said Bolton.

The Palestinian Authority's representative to the UN, Riad Mansour, called for "Israeli war criminals" to be put on trial for the shelling.

European states lead efforts to soften the proposed condemnation. The original draft, presented by Arab states, called for an "international mechanism" to protect Gaza Strip residents.

The draft also includes a clause urging UN Secretary General Kofi Annan to dispatch a "working investigative team" to Beit Hanun to conduct an inquiry into the shelling. American media reported former United States president Jimmy Carter is set to lead the team.

The clauses were included in a Qatari-proposed Security Council resolution that was vetoed last week by the U.S.

European states succeeded in changing the proposal's language, replacing the condemnation of the shelling with an expression of sorrow over the incident. A call on Palestinians to halt Qassam rocket fire at Israeli communities along the Gaza Strip had also been added..

Bookmark to del.icio.us
One land, two peoples
If the data published by Peace Now is true, the settlement movement is suffering a blow.
No monopoly on fear
Residents of Kibbutzim near Sderot say Qassam fire is causing them anxiety, too.
  1.   Israel should stop these ridiculous warnings of pals before IAF b 20:12  |  Absolute Sweden 17/11/06
  2.   give the UN something to talk about on purpose 20:52  |  vik 17/11/06
  3.   No News 20:56  |  Realistic Arab 17/11/06
  4.   America out of the UN! 20:59  |  Jon 17/11/06
  5.   # 1 21:02  |  Khosrow 17/11/06
  6.   UN investigation 21:09  |  J 17/11/06
  7.   This hearing was forced by the Arab League 21:12  |  Jake 17/11/06
  8.   Screw the UN, Screw the Arabs, Screw the EU 21:21  |  Proud Jew 17/11/06
  9.   #4 Jon 21:29  |  Chris Linthwaite 17/11/06
  10.   what kind of crap is this? 21:32  |  drew 17/11/06
  11.   #2 Vik 21:33  |  Metatron 17/11/06
  12.   John Bolton 21:55  |  GZLives 17/11/06
  13.   strangle and provoke 22:04  |  j 17/11/06
  14.   The Israeli Ambassador to the UN 22:22  |  Clickfool 17/11/06
  15.   #11 you are soooo correct 22:24  |  vs 17/11/06
  16.   No point in walking out might aswell observe the hipocrisy 22:27  |  Manny 17/11/06
  17.   Proud JEW 22:35  |  TOMY 17/11/06
  18.   UN IS NOT FAIR 22:50  |  GILBERT 17/11/06
  19.   When has the UN condemned pal attacks? 22:53  |  KUTW 17/11/06
  20.   The Usual Howling and Wailing 23:01  |  chet 17/11/06
  21.   A crime was commited 23:12  |  Baz Mann 17/11/06
  22.   Beit Hanun emergency session in UN 23:35  |  n_erber 17/11/06
  23.   Hypocritical UN, hypocrital Arabs 23:41  |  Dave 17/11/06
  24.   # 1,2,4,5,6,7,8,10,11 What a bunch of sore loosers you are !! 23:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/11/06
  25.   Beit Hanun shelling in UU 23:54  |  n_erber 17/11/06
  26.   EZLives, NYC 00:01  |  DOVERFOX 18/11/06
  27.   STATE TERRORISM 00:17  |  Frank Gregory,MD 18/11/06
  28.   I watched the whole session on TV it was better than usual 00:33  |  fatima 18/11/06
  29.   #14 Do you live in the W.B. or Gaza? 00:38  |  j. 18/11/06
  30.   15"Swiss" Dino: You are invited to visit Shderot. 00:42  |  Logician 18/11/06
  31.   Hypocracy of the Arab world from a disgusted Lebanese Canadian 00:46  |  Marwan 18/11/06
  32.   Israel and the US 01:09  |  Elie 18/11/06
  33.   Guilty 01:21  |  Paulo 18/11/06
  34.   #31 Marwan I agree with you - Iran and Syria are the real threat 01:36  |  Israeli-Arab 18/11/06
  35.   israeli walkout 01:46  |  tom 18/11/06
  36.   WHO ARE THE TERRORISTS? 02:05  |  Max 18/11/06
  37.   poor Israelis they commit massacres and then they cry !!! 02:11  |  david 18/11/06
  38.   Israel is acting like a small child 02:13  |  Maria 18/11/06
  39.   Lies of the UN - condemn Hamas for chosing war over peace 02:26  |  Raul 18/11/06
  40.   FRESH AIR 02:32  |  Brant 18/11/06
  41.   Israel and the US should boycott the UN 02:36  |  Chris 18/11/06
  42.   stop whinging 02:40  |  Georges 18/11/06
  43.   anti-semites 02:42  |  Georges 18/11/06
  44.   What a mockery. No Arab oil, never an issue. 02:44  |  David 18/11/06
  45.   #35 Tom I would go further if this is published 02:46  |  Chris Linthwaite 18/11/06
  46.   UN Shma UN pandemic virus called Vice , Vice club 02:53  |  Joseph E . 18/11/06
  47.   accountability 02:56  |  fadi 18/11/06
  48.   un condemnation 02:58  |  nukeman 18/11/06
  49.   The image of israel in the world 02:58  |  Aman 18/11/06
  50.   Tom, this has not been in the Security Council 03:00  |  Jake 18/11/06
  51.   Israeli arab # 34 03:03  |  Philippe 18/11/06
  52.   working investigative team 03:05  |  vik 18/11/06
  53.   Paulo, you don`t know how the UN works 03:06  |  Jake 18/11/06
  54.   Paulo # 33 03:07  |  Philippe 18/11/06
  55.   Paulo, Jenin massacre? 03:07  |  Jake 18/11/06
  56.   as a proressive jew I say Israel is A rogue sate 03:08  |  Progressive jew 18/11/06
  57.   Right on Jon....spread the word, you are smack on the money! 03:14  |  Reouven 18/11/06
  58.   Surprised? 03:15  |  JJ 18/11/06
  59.   Still You cannot see How you are alone! 03:15  |  Tayfun_Turkey 18/11/06
  60.   Reality Check for N_erber and Baz Man 03:16  |  GZLives 18/11/06
  61.   Reality Check for Tom 03:20  |  GZLives 18/11/06
  62.   Reality Check for Chet 03:27  |  GZLives 18/11/06
  63.   Parasitic UN 03:29  |  * BEN JABO 18/11/06
  64.   Parasitic UN 03:29  |  * BEN JABO 18/11/06
  65.   US, Australia & Canada that`s all? 03:30  |  angiolillo 18/11/06
  66.   Hey George 03:32  |  GZLives 18/11/06
  67.   56 I agree too I am a Jew and I say Israel is a rogue state too 03:33  |  damien 18/11/06
  68.   Mincing Dan 03:36  |  Hannah 18/11/06
  69.   LITTLE BY LITTLE OR ALL AT ONCE 03:39  |  MAJOR DANI 18/11/06
  70.   I`ll be so damn glad to leave this place! 03:40  |  David James Vickery 18/11/06
  71.   Dark clouds behind funny faces 03:43  |  TonyL 18/11/06
  72.   #56 03:45  |  JJ 18/11/06
  73.   UN resolution on qassams 03:45  |  peter 18/11/06
  74.   The The UN can pass as many resolutions as it wants 03:47  |  Dave 18/11/06
  75.   democracy? 03:51  |  jorge 18/11/06
  76.   HARD TO GET TICKETS FOR UN COMEDY 03:52  |  TOBIA 18/11/06
  77.   WHY BOTHER? 03:53  |  MAJOR DANI 18/11/06
  78.   Ashamed of Australia 03:55  |  Marilyn 18/11/06
  79.   Well Done UN - Next Up, Sanctions and Travel Restrictions 03:57  |  Fred Farkelsteinman 18/11/06
  80.   The US don`t pay their fees to UN 04:00  |  Marilyn 18/11/06
  81.   YOU CANT BLAME ONE PERSON 04:03  |  TOBIA 18/11/06
  82.   JJ. and that`s absolutely correct 04:08  |  Jake 18/11/06
  83.   Tayfun (59): How about a two-state solution for Turkey? 04:10  |  sk 18/11/06
  84.   "Progressive Jew", you mean Trotskyite/anarchist 04:11  |  Jake 18/11/06
  85.   The General Assembly is not "the UN" 04:12  |  sk 18/11/06