Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 20, 2006 Cheshvan 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:36 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Two miserable towns
By Haaretz Editorial

Residents of Beit Hanun are not born holding Qassam rockets in their hands. Until a few years ago, they used to work in Sapir College, near Sderot - the neighboring town at which they now launch Qassams every day. One of these rockets killed Faina (Fatima) Slutzker, 57, who moved to Israel with her husband and two children three years ago. At that time, residents of Beit Hanun were already completely cut off from their jobs in Israel, leaving them unemployed, as she was. Slutzker was killed on her way to one of the training centers set up under the Wisconsin Plan, whose goal is to encourage people to join the work force. Beit Hanun does not even have a recourse like that for the economic distress.

Sderot residents cannot tolerate daily Qassam fire on their city, even when no one is physically hurt. It is not possible to expect people to live under permanent threat, and the solution cannot be fortifying and refortifying rooms and roofs and emergency shelters.

People also want to be able to live their lives outside such protected spaces - in the street, in coffee shops, in their gardens, or going to and from their houses. Had Sderot been a city with wealthier residents, people who have the money to move elsewhere, it is doubtful that most Sderot residents would still live there.

Advertisement

Residents of Beit Hanun also have nowhere to go. When the Israel Defense Forces inform them that they must vacate their houses in advance of an attack, they flee to the hospital to find shelter. Some 450 houses were destroyed in the most recent IDF operation, yet after it ended, the Qassam fire continued, and even intensified. When a missile was fired at the house of 4-year-old Bara Fiad of Beit Hanun, it plowed a deep pit in the courtyard, and he disappeared into it.

This reality of mutual misery and mutual intimidation is turning into a dead-end situation. Israel and the Palestinians have been caught up in a dangerous diplomatic vacuum. From a military standpoint, it seems that the IDF has not managed to find a solution to the Qassam fire, and it is doubtful one even exists. In July, when the chief of staff was asked to explain why Katyusha fire on the Galilee was continuing despite the IDF operation in Lebanon, he gave the example of the Qassam rockets fired at Sderot, to which no military solution has been found, either.

When people talk about a large-scale operation in Gaza, it is necessary to remember the facts. The IDF has already conducted large-scale operations, in which it killed hundreds of Palestinians, but the Qassams continue to fall - even when the IDF is in the Gaza Strip.

It is impossible to continue seeking reasons not to talk with the Palestinians. It is impossible to continue setting conditions even for beginning a dialogue, and for any kind of interim, partial or temporary arrangement, or any initiative for the mutual release of prisoners, that could bring relief, even partial or temporary, to both sides, which are both paying the price, day after day. We must seize any thread, however thin - this time, perhaps, in the form of the new government that will be established in the Palestinian Authority - in order to try to break the pattern of vengeance and retaliation that leads only to more suffering.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Gaydamak's harvest
The state has turned this man into one of the most influential individuals in the country.
Stealing clients
Thousands of non-Jewish lawyers took the clients of their Jewish colleagues in 1944.
  1.   Residents of Beth Hanoun have plenty of place where to go 10:26  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 16/11/06
  2.   Break the cycle of retaliation 10:33  |  tbora 16/11/06
  3.   This is new news for all Israeli people 10:39  |  Khalil Ishabib 16/11/06
  4.   18 - 1 or it would be wise to restrain this time 10:44  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  5.   Retaliation to retaliation? 10:54  |  Tony Price 16/11/06
  6.   #1 Sholomo from Tel Aviv- Ben Hanoun residents shud move back 11:08  |  tbora 16/11/06
  7.   Don`t move the people; move the qassams 11:30  |  Jasmine Murphy 16/11/06
  8.   Mutual misery? 11:32  |  Paul Henzen 16/11/06
  9.   Nice to know that there are sensible commentators working here 11:42  |  Johnboy 16/11/06
  10.   SWISS After their "revenge" they keep firing. 11:49  |  PETER SM 16/11/06
  11.   Depopulate? Let`s hope this is not the new buzzword 12:26  |  Shlomissimo 16/11/06
  12.   Beit Ha Nes 12:31  |  Star of David 16/11/06
  13.   For Khalil 12:34  |  Tesahbeab 16/11/06
  14.   Temporary Arrangemetns 12:41  |  WGDC 16/11/06
  15.   Paul Henzen, are you blind? 13:23  |  Marilyn 16/11/06
  16.   4: It is war 14:25  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/11/06
  17.   To #11 14:30  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 16/11/06
  18.   Marilyn, you are blind! 14:36  |  Paul Henzen 16/11/06
  19.   tbora do you have a mind? 14:38  |  Steven 16/11/06
  20.   # 1 to Shlomo 14:52  |  Farooq 16/11/06
  21.   Break the cycle 14:59  |  annie 16/11/06
  22.   # 7 to Jasmine....Agree to move Qassam out But..... 15:06  |  Farooq 16/11/06
  23.   Another miserable editorial 15:11  |  Shlomo 16/11/06
  24.   Breaking "cycle of violence" 15:14  |  Gene 16/11/06
  25.   Farooq you do not know what terrror is, or you support it. 15:21  |  Steven 16/11/06
  26.   Two miserable towns 15:21  |  Michael Katz 16/11/06
  27.   Swiss (Dino) Post No. 4 15:23  |  Johnny Weintraub 16/11/06
  28.   Swiss (Dino) The IDF can stop the bombs 15:24  |  Steven 16/11/06
  29.   Anne we know you hate jews, but you have no logic. 15:26  |  Steven 16/11/06
  30.   Hudna - NOW 15:27  |  Tzfonit 16/11/06
  31.   Michael Katz are you on drugs? 15:36  |  Steven 16/11/06
  32.   # 19 To steven..you have single track mind 15:41  |  Farooq 16/11/06
  33.   Editorial Folly 15:45  |  Herbert Weissblum 16/11/06
  34.   What a stupid editorial 15:45  |  Gee 16/11/06
  35.   # 25 To steve 15:49  |  Farooq 16/11/06
  36.   # 10 PETER SM 15:53  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  37.   # 27 Johnny Weintraub 16:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  38.   # 28 Steven Well, actually my colors are.... 16:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  39.   # 16 Bruriah Sarah 16:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  40.   Farooq you just hate jews be honest 16:10  |  Steven 16/11/06
  41.   Another pederast Editorial Arabic propaganda 16:16  |  Sal 16/11/06
  42.   Cure the misery 16:19  |  Jo Jo 16/11/06
  43.   # 40.Here you go..... Steven 16:34  |  Farooq 16/11/06
  44.   Farooq I have nothing against Arabs 16:47  |  Steven 16/11/06
  45.   Swiss (Dino) Post No. 37 16:47  |  Johnny Weintraub 16/11/06
  46.   The solution is easy 16:48  |  KUTW 16/11/06
  47.   Another 4-year-old victim 16:58  |  KUTW 16/11/06
  48.   1. Shlomo from Tel-Aviv: Residents of Beth Hanoun have plenty of 17:13  |  KUTW 16/11/06
  49.   2. tbora: Break the cycle of aggression 17:16  |  KUTW 16/11/06
  50.   3. Khalil Ishabib: The new news 17:20  |  KUTW 16/11/06
  51.   4. Tony Price: Retaliation to retaliation? 17:25  |  KUTW 16/11/06
  52.   # 44 17:30  |  Farooq 16/11/06
  53.   Paul Hanzen from Netherlands is right. Marilyn from Australia is. 17:36  |  Vittorio 16/11/06
  54.   #1 Shlomo and his solution 19:03  |  Wes 16/11/06
  55.   False symmetry The Palestinians are 100% to blame 19:11  |  Shalom Freedman 16/11/06
  56.   no mutual situation - one sided 19:25  |  yoni 16/11/06
  57.   Actually, Swiss #39, Here`s the problem... 19:28  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  58.   So Dresden & Coventry were also twin towns of misery? 19:38  |  Yehuda Maccabbee 16/11/06
  59.   Occupied Land? 20:05  |  Barry 16/11/06
  60.   Schlomo from Tel-Aviv 20:07  |  Walid 16/11/06
  61.   Tzfonit 20:23  |  Walid 16/11/06
  62.   27: What Eye for an eye means 20:26  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/11/06
  63.   30 - what Hudna means 20:29  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/11/06
  64.   39: Hamas wants to destroy Israel 20:31  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/11/06
  65.   sociopathic criminality 20:33  |  Wade 16/11/06
  66.   # 57 Polybios Israels and its image.... 20:44  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  67.   KUTW 20:46  |  Walid 16/11/06
  68.   Steven, same old, same old 20:55  |  Janice 16/11/06
  69.   Wade 20:57  |  Walid 16/11/06
  70.   Janice 21:05  |  Walid 16/11/06
  71.   amen 21:21  |  Aaron 16/11/06
  72.   Walid 21:26  |  Wade 16/11/06
  73.   more equivalence garbage 21:30  |  peter 16/11/06
  74.   Actions Speak Louder Than Words 21:54  |  Tom B 16/11/06
  75.   #66. Swiss 22:24  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  76.   Two Towns 22:33  |  P. J. Casey 16/11/06
  77.   #59 Barry - 2 corrections 23:02  |  Johnboy 16/11/06
  78.   Janice same ol` self hating revisionist. 23:13  |  Steven 16/11/06
  79.   Janice more to you 23:15  |  Steven 16/11/06
  80.   Polybios you have no clue 23:27  |  Steven 16/11/06
  81.   Walid of course you agree, she states your lies 23:29  |  Steven 16/11/06
  82.   Wade 00:03  |  Walid 17/11/06
  83.   SWISS.There are plenty of Pal newspapers.Try it. 00:16  |  PETER. S.M 17/11/06
  84.   Even Haaretz embarrassed by disproportion? 00:19  |  Just Curious 17/11/06
  85.   Sparks Fly Upward 00:43  |  Peter Wallace 17/11/06
  86.   73peter is right: False symmetry, like London & Berlin in WWII 00:43  |  Logician 17/11/06
  87.   To #27 Johnny Weintraub 00:49  |  Just Curious 17/11/06
  88.   Haaretz - Always Preaching Appeasement, Always Proven Wrong 00:49  |  Tod Zuckerman 17/11/06
  89.   67. Walid