Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 19, 2006 Cheshvan 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:14 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
You promised a dove, we got Qassams
By Israel Harel

The unilateral disengagement, said the politicians who initiated it and carried it out and the journalists who jumped on the bandwagon, will bring calm to the Gaza border. The unilateral withdrawal from Lebanon, went one of the most influential arguments, proved that steps of this nature, despite the delusional warnings of opponents of peace, succeed. Shelly Yachimovich, who, from her influential positions in the media, was one of the instigators of the flight from Lebanon, even scoffed: "The entire region will burn? Not only is the region not burning, but there is absolute calm" (Haggai Segal and Uri Orbach, "They Promised a Dove").

Not even an enclave like Shaba Farms, on the Lebanese border, was left in the Gaza Strip. Instead, 25 flourishing settlements were uprooted and Israel withdrew to the last millimeter. In addition, a high fence, almost impassable, was erected between the Gaza Strip and the western Negev. And good fences, according to the slogan that those who supported the flight from Lebanon, the uprooting in Gaza and the uprooting in Judea and Samaria like to recite, make good neighbors.

But despite the fence and the traumatic disengagement that tore Israeli society apart, 100 doves of peace are not springing up in the Gaza Strip as promised. Instead, Palestinians are shooting hundreds of Qassam rockets, including the lethal ones fired yesterday. Miraculously, most have not been fatal. But yesterday, there were no miracles.

Advertisement

Last week, an annual conference on social issues took place in Sderot. At one session, following the calamity in Beit Hanun, a melancholy rhetorical question was asked: What is the point of our responding forcefully, even though we certainly did not intend to kill civilians? There have been years of military operations, but the Qassams continue to fall. And shells from Israeli cannons kill civilians, including children. How is it possible to educate our children in such a situation? What kind of hope are we giving them, so that they will not abandon the country and emigrate?

These remarks were made out of genuine concern. But past experience shows that as long as we were educated, and educated others, to a reality of "there is no choice," there were few cracks in our emotional fortitude and our sense of justice. The loss of hope occurred after we tried the "alternatives" and, as at Oslo, "achieved breakthroughs."

The sowers of illusion convinced us that there is a Palestinian partner, and pushed the decision makers into unrealistic and even delusional harbors. For the sake of "giving the children hope," whether their own children or all children, the parents who were in the driver's seat lent a hand to moves that have proven lethal: Oslo, the flight from Lebanon and the disengagement. And because they were lethal for the Jews, they were also - since it is not possible to refrain from responding to suicide bombings, or even to Qassams - lethal for the Arabs.

It is not vacuous, and therefore unavailing, moves, like the uprooting from Gaza and the flight from Lebanon, that our children need to prevent them from abandoning the country, and us. Imparting illusions, instead of educating our children to believe in the principles of Zionism, national and social solidarity and the need to continue fighting as long as fighting is necessary, increases emigration rather than decreasing it.

It is no wonder that many of those who believe in these illusions have evaded service in the Israel Defense Forces or now live abroad. In the bubble of illusion, disappointment and despair reign: "You promised a dove," they say, but you did not keep your promise.

We must tell the next generation the truth. We must prepare it, and ourselves, to cope without illusions - among other things, with the fact that fences and unilateral withdrawals increase the enemy's motivation.

In the Bnei Akiva youth group and the national religious community's educational institutes, they do not teach that our life in this country is conditional on the Palestinians' consent. There, teaching about the nation of Israel's right to its land - which used to be what everyone was taught - is still the key component of an education, and not the supposed injustices the nation of Israel is causing the neighboring nation. Nor is reality whitewashed there.

And the results prove that a difficult truth is preferable to a fraudulent illusion.

It is important to educate for peace. But it is also necessary to inculcate the fundamental educational baggage that will give the students the tools to cope with a situation in which the longed-for peace fails to arrive, despite sincere and costly efforts to attain it. Above all, it is necessary to instill in the students something that many households and educational institutes no longer do: a belief in the justice of Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
The unconventionally-named Rahamims of Nahal Oz: Danny, Siobhan, Irem, Karin and Lian.
Zvika from the hood
Four weeks ago I learned that my brother, a seasoned Canadian, is a millionaire.
  1.   How many times and the results are the same 10:31  |  Khalil Ishabib 16/11/06
  2.   The withdrawal - lie or Israels favourite, but wrong excuse 10:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  3.   WHEN ARE YOU LEFTIES GOING TO REALISE 11:07  |  Nicole 16/11/06
  4.   justice of jewish sovereignty?? Advocating for apartheid 11:18  |  Sami 16/11/06
  5.   Israel Harel`s deviant Zionism 11:20  |  zeev 16/11/06
  6.   STUPIDITY IS CATCHING AND DISENGAGEMENT WAS SUPPORTED BY HAARETZ 11:25  |  paul harris 16/11/06
  7.   #2 DINO AND THE MARTIANS GATHER IN GENEVE 11:32  |  paul harris 16/11/06
  8.   ISRAEL WAS TOO PROUD TO LISTEN 11:42  |  indrajaya 16/11/06
  9.   good article 12:03  |  mb 16/11/06
  10.   half-baked solutions 12:25  |  Jean-Luc Ngarambe 16/11/06
  11.   Sorry Ze`ev 12:48  |  Star of David 16/11/06
  12.   A critical point is upon us 12:57  |  Natallie Durson 16/11/06
  13.   I Couldn`t Agree More 13:11  |  Terry 16/11/06
  14.   # 6- paul harris- Yes !! REPATRIATE ! 13:44  |  Klaudia 16/11/06
  15.   Nathalie durson and peace agreements 14:22  |  Kjeli 16/11/06
  16.   to Nicole #3 - on lefties 14:52  |  zeev 16/11/06
  17.   Jean-Luc`s "Logic" 14:58  |  Proud Zionist 16/11/06
  18.   Sami does the same justice apply to the islamic middle east 15:08  |  British academic 16/11/06
  19.   # 1 Khalil Ishabib 15:13  |  Josef 16/11/06
  20.   Now you talking , Keep on singing the same music under different 15:26  |  Joseph E . 16/11/06
  21.   I want somebody to explain something 15:42  |  Gee 16/11/06
  22.   TO PAUL HARRIS, DON`T BE SO SURE .... 15:55  |  MICHELE 16/11/06
  23.   The responsibility of a nation 15:58  |  Walter 16/11/06
  24.   British acadmic is a blow horn for Israeli propaganda 16:02  |  Sami 16/11/06
  25.   Political Cartoon 101 for Khalil Ishabib 16:16  |  Jacob Blues 16/11/06
  26.   could a smart rightist(is there one?) please tell me 16:18  |  harel won`t 16/11/06
  27.   Be careful what you wish for Dino 16:18  |  Jacob Blues 16/11/06
  28.   # 7 paul harris Could you do us a favor ???? 16:20  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  29.   No failure to listen indrajaya 16:21  |  Jacob Blues 16/11/06
  30.   #22 IN 100 YEAR WE WONT BE HERE MICHELE 16:23  |  paul harris 16/11/06
  31.   No Walter, the responsibility of a nation 16:25  |  Jacob Blues 16/11/06
  32.   # 21 If You Wish Upon A Star... 16:30  |  Tony Anthony 16/11/06
  33.   Response to Post No. 26 16:38  |  Johnny Weintraub 16/11/06
  34.   Walter #23 16:43  |  Gee 16/11/06
  35.   #26 VERY SIMPLE THE SAN REMO CONFERENCE OF 1920 SET THE BORDERS 16:44  |  paul harris 16/11/06
  36.   NOTHING WILL CHANGE UNTIL WE GET A NEW GOVERNMENT THAT... 16:46  |  bat yam 16/11/06
  37.   Principles 16:53  |  Harry D 16/11/06
  38.   to Kejli 17:20  |  USA 16/11/06
  39.   Yes Jacob Blues #31, the responsibility of a nation ... 17:47  |  zeev 16/11/06
  40.   LOL..A DOVE IN A CAGE... 18:01  |  MIKE KATZ 16/11/06
  41.   # 27 Jacob Blues Did you get something wrong ?? 18:08  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  42.   Israel Harel 18:10  |  Mordechai 16/11/06
  43.   1# Ask your question,yourself it might help you. 18:25  |  Akram Zekaria 16/11/06
  44.   #2 Swiss. To bad threads don`t carry over... 18:46  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  45.   #24. Sami - that is no answer 18:49  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  46.   To Nicole # 3 18:54  |  Basim 16/11/06
  47.   Thx Israel Harel: at least some good sense in Haaretz 19:08  |  Moshe 16/11/06
  48.   Harel wont 19:11  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  49.   Nothing wrong Dino 19:22  |  Jacob Blues 16/11/06
  50.   # 44 Polybios Reality check needed ?? 19:26  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  51.   Gee #21 19:28  |  Walter 16/11/06
  52.   Palestinian muslims already have equal voting rights in Israel 19:37  |  British academic 16/11/06
  53.   Harel - An Oasis of Intelligence in a Wastleland of Lefty Idiocy 19:41  |  Tod Zuckerman 16/11/06
  54.   to Star of David #11, Sorry ... 19:42  |  zeev 16/11/06
  55.   #50. Swiss. Reality is here already.. 20:12  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  56.   8:The reality 20:41  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/11/06
  57.   Let`s reduce the level of hypocrisy! 20:42  |  Voice of Reason 16/11/06
  58.   24 - Response 20:43  |  Bruriah Sarah 16/11/06
  59.   # 55 Polybios I am amazed..... 21:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/11/06
  60.   Shaba Farms is not an "enclave" 21:32  |  DJStahl 16/11/06
  61.   to bat yam #36 - competent you said? 21:34  |  zeev 16/11/06
  62.   Shaba Farms is not an "enclave" 21:46  |  DJStahl 16/11/06
  63.   natallie 22:24  |  bev 16/11/06
  64.   Dishonest article 22:36  |  Roi is back 16/11/06
  65.   Gaza occupation was too expensive 22:48  |  Amused 16/11/06
  66.   voice of reason 23:34  |  bev 16/11/06
  67.   Extremists Viewpoints Don`t Conceal A Lousy LEADERSHIP 23:37  |  Lee 16/11/06
  68.   Swiss #59. Very serious 23:55  |  Polybios 16/11/06
  69.   Really Zeev. I thought that the brouh-haha 01:11  |  Jacob Blues 17/11/06
  70.   No more Qassams 02:19  |  David King 17/11/06
  71.   #16, zeev 03:52  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/11/06
  72.   To Sami #4 on Palestinian sovereignty 04:24  |  William 17/11/06
  73.   Swiss #59 04:32  |  William 17/11/06
  74.   The difficulty is not our right to the land, but 05:10  |  Shalom Freedman 17/11/06
  75.   Swiss #59. 4th attempt (??!) 05:12  |  Polybios 17/11/06
  76.   #4, Sami 05:32  |  Cipora Juianna Kohn 17/11/06
  77.   #59. Swiss (part II) 05:34  |  Polybios 17/11/06
  78.   Swiss - part III (since part I isn`t here) 06:11  |  Polybios 17/11/06
  79.   WHERE IS ZION? 08:00  |  Maureen Ann 17/11/06
  80.   Same old same old 08:55  |  ussishkin 17/11/06
  81.   the words of mortally wounded Yosef Trumpeldor at Tel-Hai 09:01  |  zayyin ba ayin 17/11/06
  82.   Israel Harel, about the Jewish peoples legal connections to Israe 09:16  |  Dutch 17/11/06
  83.   #79, Maureen 09:18  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/11/06
  84.   to C.J. Kohn #71 09:30  |  zeev 17/11/06
  85.   # 6 Ignorance flourishes 10:18  |  Eric 17/11/06
  86.   #84, zeev 10:36  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/11/06
  87.   to Maureen Ann #79 11:10  |  zeev