Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., December 15, 2006 Kislev 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:11 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:11 17/11/2006
Palestinians: Our human shield against Iran nukes?
By Bradley Burston

"It's 1938, and Iran is Germany," Benjamin Netanyahu said this week, in a speech to the North American Jewish community.

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Netanyahu continued, "is preparing another Holocaust for the Jewish state."

If Netanyahu is right, and there is little solid evidence to the contrary, the scenario is all too familiar. Iranian defense officials have laid it out again and again - an attack, either American or Israeli, against Iran's nuclear facilities. Either way, Tehran responds with a devastating onslaught against Israel.

Advertisement

How devastating?

"If the Zionist regime commits such stupidity, the response by the Iranian military will be swift, strong and crushing," Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Mohammed Ali Hosseini said this week, referring to a possible Israeli strike. "Iran will take no longer than a second to respond."

This, from the one country in all the world whose president has explicitly called for another nation to be "erased."

But Tehran cannot consider a nuclear holocaust against Israel without taking into account those whom Iran holds to be rightful Muslim heirs to Muslim land. The Islamic republic cannot erase the State of Israel without killing large numbers of the very people whose lives it has sworn to protect: the Palestinians.

There was a time, not so long ago, when many Israelis believed that no Arab power would attack Jerusalem, for fear of damaging the holy sites sacred to Islam. Moreover, there was a feeling that Arab powers would refrain from attacking both the holy city and the territories, in order to avoid Palestinian casualties.

But long-held taboos governing the actions of Muslim fighters have been bent, broken and discarded with impunity in recent years. In Iraq, the February bombing of the Al-Askari mosque, one of the holiest of all shrines to Shi'ites ? apparently at the hands of an Al-Qaida cell - was followed within a day by reprisal attacks on no fewer than 161 Sunni mosques.

Where Islamists once refrained from killing non-combatants, especially Muslims, the number of Muslim non-combatants killed in Iraq has grown so astronomically as to resist accurate count.

During the recent war in the north, nearly half of the Israeli civilians killed by Katyusha rockets fired by Iran's client militia Hezbollah, were Arabs.

Under certain circumstances, might Iran sacrifice the Arabs of the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem, to say nothing of a million Muslim Israeli citizens, in a cataclysmic assault on the Zionist entity?

More directly, would Iran be willing to kill off millions of Arabs if that were the price of exterminating the state of Israel?

The truth, one wishes, were "No." But the real truth, one suspects, is "Not yet."

In recent decades, radical changes in warfare and radical re-interpretations of Koranic law suggest a growing willingness among Islamic extremists, clerics at their head, to justify the killing of Muslim bystanders in a suicide bombing.

In the phrase of New York University Prof. Noah Feldman, writing in the New York Times Magazine last month, the prevailing ideology of suicide bombing holds that the "involuntary martyrdom" of Muslim bystanders killed in a suicide bombing is viewed as "no less glorious for being unintentional."

In the future, Feldman notes, "the logic of sacrificing other Muslims against their own wills could be extended to the national level."

Were an Islamic state to use nuclear weapons against Israel or other Western targets, "the guaranteed retaliation would cost the lives of thousands and maybe millions of Muslims. But following the logic of suicide bombing, the original bomber might reason that those Muslims would die in God's grace and that others would live on to fight the jihad."

Feldman stresses that no state in the Muslim world has adopted this view. "But after 9/11," he adds, "we can no longer treat the possibility as fanciful."

A number of analysts have suggested that at present, the most effective deterrent to a large-scale Iranian attack on Israel, is Iran's fundamental wish to continue to survive.

Although Shi'ite positions and those of Ahmadinejad are seen as more potentially apocalyptic that those of Osama Bin Laden and of the Sunnis, the cagey Iranian regime has played the rest of the world with the skill and the outlook of a poker master who wants to stay in the game for good.

Should future events take a turn for the very worst, however, and an all-out Iranian attack on the Holy Land appear imminent, perhaps Tehran will issue the kind of recommendation to Palestinians that Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah delivered to Haifa's Arab population during the war - warning them to leave town so that Hezbollah gunners could step up rocket attacks without shedding the blood of fellow Muslims.

"I have a special message to the Arabs of Haifa, to your martyrs and to your wounded. I call on you to leave this city. I hope you do this," Nasrallah said.

"Please leave so we don't shed your blood, which is our blood."

__________________


Talkback Guidelines

The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and an openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, ethnic cleansing, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.
5.Use of the phrase: "There are no Palestinians" or derivatives thereof.

_________________


Previous blogs:

I voted for a war criminal
When rabbis' gay-hate turns murderous
The New Dark Ages
Targeting Muslims - the new Inquisition

Bookmark to del.icio.us
In-between spaces
Shimon Shapiro says that architecture is an emotional and spiritual experience.
Jews on film
The eighth annual Jewish Film Festival opens in Jerusalem this weekend.
  1.   Remember the Iranian child mine-sweepers? 10:17  |  Lindsey 17/11/06
  2.   The Palestinians as guarantee for Israels survival ? 10:20  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/11/06
  3.   Nuclear Iran 10:29  |  Amir 17/11/06
  4.   Poor old Bradley Burston whistling in the dark 10:30  |  Clickfool 17/11/06
  5.   THE AL-ASKARI`S MOMENT OF TRUTH 10:35  |  indrajaya 17/11/06
  6.   If the Iranians can get rid of Israel... 10:51  |  Zev 17/11/06
  7.   Talkback Guidelines 10:53  |  Ben 17/11/06
  8.   1948 REVISTED, "FLEE MY BROTHERS` 10:55  |  fox 17/11/06
  9.   Israel will leave no Palestines 10:56  |  ali 17/11/06
  10.   THE WESTERN WAS SO SURPRISED 10:59  |  indrajaya 17/11/06
  11.   "FLEE MY BROTHERS" 1948 revisited? 11:00  |  FOX 17/11/06
  12.   Mosque in iraq-mossad did really good job 11:01  |  Johannes 17/11/06
  13.   Clickfool 11:01  |  JewishHeart 17/11/06
  14.   to dino#2 11:11  |  Nina 17/11/06
  15.   BRADLEY IRAN WILL WIPE OUT JORDAN SYRIA AND EGYPT 11:13  |  paul harris 17/11/06
  16.   MIND GAMES 1 11:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/11/06
  17.   Lindsey`s great steaming pile of buffalo droppings # 1 11:14  |  Clickfool 17/11/06
  18.   Mr. Burston, I do think Ahmadinijad cares about the Palestinian 11:17  |  Nadav 17/11/06
  19.   Ahmadinejad has already defeated Israel with words not weapons 11:18  |  Yossi Cronenberg 17/11/06
  20.   Don`t count on it 11:23  |  Natallie Durson 17/11/06
  21.   Ahmadinejad vs. Hitler 11:26  |  Shirah 17/11/06
  22.   MIND GAMES 2 11:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/11/06
  23.   Food for thought 11:41  |  American 17/11/06
  24.   Bradley is partially right by starnger things happen 11:44  |  Haham me Bat Yam 17/11/06
  25.   Iran Will Spare No One for Allah 11:46  |  Marc Hamil 17/11/06
  26.   IRANIAN NEWSPAPERS CALLS MUSLIMS TO PREPARE FOR GREAT WAR?? 11:59  |  Bill. 17/11/06
  27.   The Goal of Islam 12:03  |  JewishHeart 17/11/06
  28.   `No solid evidence to the contrary` Bradley? 12:03  |  Michael 17/11/06
  29.   holocaust 12:05  |  jj burke 17/11/06
  30.   "Martyrs to the Cause" 12:06  |  Gina 17/11/06
  31.   # 4, CLICKFOOL 12:07  |  indrajaya 17/11/06
  32.   MADINDEHED HAS PROCLAIMED HE DOES NOT MIND SACRIFICING 1/3 IRAN?? 12:12  |  Bill. 17/11/06
  33.   Bradley Bradley Bradley 12:13  |  Chris Linthwaite 17/11/06
  34.   WHAT DID JOSEPH GOEBBELS SAY ABOUT A LIE ?? 12:19  |  Bill. 17/11/06
  35.   Let`s be serious ! 12:33  |  Yankelowitz 17/11/06
  36.   bradley you are wonderful 12:33  |  admirer 17/11/06
  37.   Hitler, too, sacrificed his own people 12:41  |  Paul Henzen 17/11/06
  38.   Many Muslim dont care if they kill Palestinian Muslims! 12:51  |  Haldrik 17/11/06
  39.   Palestinians: Our human shield against Iran nukes !!! 12:52  |  Andre 17/11/06
  40.   hmm 12:58  |  matt 17/11/06
  41.   Nazi Germany Did The Same 13:02  |  Ben Israel 17/11/06
  42.   No. 18-Chris Linthwaite Obviously Doesn`t Know Any Israelis 13:07  |  Ben Israel 17/11/06
  43.   surely 13:17  |  jj burke 17/11/06
  44.   Read the responses of the Muslims on this Talkback... 13:22  |  Reality Check 17/11/06
  45.   AKA.9-11.Arabs Leave,Israel /Pays Price,IF Attacks Iran,BetMe! 13:29  |  Moses 17/11/06
  46.   The Need to Lie? 13:29  |  FOX 17/11/06
  47.   # 25- Bill... I like your Madindehed.... what do you think of... 13:36  |  Klaudia 17/11/06
  48.   Fatal flaw in Burston`s logic 13:41  |  Shane 17/11/06
  49.   # 46- FOX ... Why the Left Lies.. 13:46  |  Klaudia 17/11/06
  50.   LOL, Iran doesn`t care if it Kills a Bunch of Arabs 13:55  |  David 17/11/06
  51.   Ahmadninjad knows he doesn`t need a nuke for Israel 14:01  |  Nechama 17/11/06
  52.   Ahmandinejad is playing a game and so is Netanyahu 14:03  |  Ronnie Wolman 17/11/06
  53.   # 1 - 45 (with a few exceptions) Seems almost to me....... 14:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/11/06
  54.   WISE MEN TALKS, NOT FIGHT 14:06  |  Marco 17/11/06
  55.   Heretical Sunnis and Zionist in Iran`s crosshair 14:26  |  Mosh 17/11/06
  56.   Iran would sacrifice Iran to destroy Israel 14:34  |  Saul 17/11/06
  57.   Ben Israel 14:35  |  Chris Linthwaite 17/11/06
  58.   Making peace with Lebanon, Syria and Palestinians 15:04  |  Roi is back 17/11/06
  59.   The FOX Network 15:04  |  Ronnie Wolman 17/11/06
  60.   Chris Linthwaite - out of perspective 15:09  |  Reality Check 17/11/06
  61.   Why and for what purpose this silly piece? 15:19  |  Chazkele 17/11/06
  62.   What do Palestinians get in return for (maybe) saving Israelis ?? 15:21  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/11/06
  63.   On nuclear holocaust by the Israelis # 31 15:23  |  Clickfool 17/11/06
  64.   IRAN WANTS TO BE ONE BIG SUICIDE BOMBER 15:31  |  Dan 17/11/06
  65.   Ahmadinejad - 1934 - only a little loudmouth so far 15:39  |  Bart 17/11/06
  66.   Iran, Economically 3rd World, But Talks Big! 15:57  |  Ambrose 17/11/06
  67.   Swiss 16:02  |  Polybios 17/11/06
  68.   To Chris Linthwaite-Jews Are Coming To Israel 16:03  |  Ben Israel 17/11/06
  69.   To David and al... 16:03  |  Noura 17/11/06
  70.   The individual doesn?t exist 16:10  |  KUTW 17/11/06
  71.   Swiss(Dino) 16:22  |  ODP 17/11/06
  72.   Two Birds With One Nuclear Stone. 16:25  |  Tony Anthony 17/11/06
  73.   rationality please 16:29  |  Moderate 17/11/06
  74.   israel was the 16:29  |  sam i am 17/11/06
  75.   Are PALS "SHIELDS"? - Absolutely absurd idea! 16:31  |  Vittorio 17/11/06
  76.   #59 Swiss 16:32  |  Polybios 17/11/06
  77.   # 64 Polybios 16:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/11/06
  78.   I thought they all wanted to be martyrs anyway 16:34  |  British academic 17/11/06
  79.   So Scary 16:39  |  Chris 17/11/06
  80.   Judging by recent experience. I would say no 16:41  |  Jacob Blues 17/11/06
  81.   ali # 9 Palestinian Birth and Death Rates 16:41  |  Jeff Northridge 17/11/06
  82.   clickfool 16:43  |  harzion 17/11/06
  83.   #59. Swiss (part II) 16:44  |  Polybios 17/11/06
  84.   Irresponsible paranoid talk in Israel about Iran 16:46  |  Tosefta