An irrelevant test of intentions - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Wed., November 14, 2007 Kislev 4, 5768

Israel Time: 04:15 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 08:48 13/11/2006

An irrelevant test of intentions

By Akiva Eldar

Every time an errant bomb that's launched to execute a Palestinian "wanted man" kills people who are obviously "innocent bystanders," mainly women and children, there is first an expression of heartfelt regret and then comes the time for self-righteousness. "As opposed to the Arabs," declares the defense minister - this time, Amir Peretz - "we do not deliberately target innocent civilians." As opposed to our neighbors, in our case the defense minister, known as "the man of peace," immediately appoints a special investigator to examine the "mishap" and to ascertain that a "tragedy" of this kind will not recur. Until the next time. In other words, don't judge us according to the harsh consequences of our actions. What counts is our good intentions.

Would an expression of regret help the heads of a Palestinian organization who sent a terrorist to blow himself up at a hitchhiking post for soldiers, if the schlemiel were to set off the bomb near a bus load of children? Would the test of intentions save him and the passersby from the revenge of the Israel Defense Forces? What Israeli judge would accept the defense of an activist of the military arm of Fatah, who claimed that his violent acts were meant to release his people from the Israeli occupation?

The cemeteries and prisons are full of thousands of Palestinian who are loyal to the two-state solution. For the goyim the only thing that counts is the test of results. The test of intentions is relevant only when it comes to Israelis.

	Advertisement

However, when it suits our politicians, the test of intentions - which finds expression in deliberate policy - has nothing to do with the conflict. No one knows better than they do that if Israeli governments were to be examined according to their ongoing behavior in the territories over the past 40 years, they would be extremely lucky to get a grade of unsatisfactory.

The dozens of settlements that were established contrary to international law, some of them on private Palestinian land, cannot be considered an "errant bomb." This is a policy that is designed to annex parts of the West Bank to Israel. Outposts that were established on Palestinian land, with the assistance of government funding, are not "an unfortunate mistake." This is a method of turning a blind eye to the forcible establishment of facts on the ground.

If Israel is to be judged by its intentions, we cannot make do with the generous promises of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. His nice words are worthless when at the same time the Defense Ministry is expropriating more Palestinian land for the purpose of building another highway meant for Israelis only. The peace declarations of Foreign Ministry Tzipi Livni are of as much interest as the snows of yesteryear to the residents of Nablus, who are not allowed to visit their relatives in the Jordan Valley. Even our High Court of Justice, not to mention the International Court of Justice in The Hague, has ruled that the route of the fence deliberately serves to expand the settlements, under a camouflage of security considerations.

If the response to the acts of others should be based on their long-term intentions, rather than according to the consequences of an isolated mistake, it is not certain that Israel comes out ahead. An order that separates a Palestinian mother from her children living in Israel is not something unavoidable that stems from the need to fight terror. It is a "demographic policy." A law that denies compensation to Palestinians who are "innocent bystanders" and have become disabled because IDF soldiers do not respect the instructions for opening fire, is not a necessary consequence of "the situation." It is a cruel amendment to a law that was passed by a majority in Israel's Knesset.

There have been many other bad consequences with bad intentions behind them. The severance of the Gaza Strip from the West Bank, and of hundreds of thousands of families from the sources of their livelihood, including withheld tax money, is not a divinely ordained law. It is the method chosen by the Israeli government to punish Palestinian children for the fact that a substantial percentage of their parents voted for Hamas.

It's a shame that people of conscience in Israel and the world over have fallen asleep on their watch and have grown accustomed to living with innumerable deliberate injustices that have become routine. It's a shame that they wake up only when one bomb misses its mark.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Speaking for Israel
	U.S. Secretary Rice says Israelis are prepared to give up the West Bank for peace.


	Doable deal
	Solana says an Israeli-PA peace agreement can be achieved within 9 months.




1.	AND WHY DOES THE BOMB FLY ELDAR??	09:15	\|	paul harris	13/11/06

2.	Pearls before Swine	09:30	\|	Natallie Durson	13/11/06

3.	Paul Harris	11:42	\|	Michael	13/11/06

4.	intention is crucial in criminal law	14:54	\|	so what	13/11/06

5.	hate to say this	15:18	\|	near misses	13/11/06

6.	Consequences	18:54	\|	ussishkin	13/11/06

7.	GOOD INTENTIONS WON`T HOLD UP IN A COURT OF LAW	22:48	\|	Dutch	13/11/06

8.	#1 Akiva, pay no attention	23:12	\|	Dutch	13/11/06

9.	tel aviv is illegal	01:07	\|	David Zion	14/11/07

Today Online


	Burston: Palestine, and the crime of being a Jewish state
	Responses: 320


	Abbas says an end to the occupation will bring peace
	Responses: 139


	Harel & Issacharoff: Hamas losing grip on Gaza, Fatah gaining
	Responses: 62


	PA official: Barak, Livni holding Olmert back on peace process
	Responses: 157


	Peres makes history with first address to Turkish parliament
	Responses: 139


	Haaretz.com TV: 'Gazans detained by IDF return naked'
	Responses: 76

More Headlines
03:54 Israel to announce freeze on settlement building


23:19 Rice: Israelis are prepared to give up West Bank for peace


23:02 IDF Chief: Lebanon war could have made gains with less loss of life


04:00 Dichter: Syria is only neighbor that prevents smuggling


01:13 Iran summons 5 Argentines over 1994 Jewish center bombing


02:01 State refuses to release list of Waqf-owned properties in T.A., Jaffa


04:07 Lador will not recuse himself in Bank Leumi affair


18:42 In Turkey, Peres gives first presidential address to Muslim legislature


21:22 Senior gov't officials meet in attempt to end teachers' strike


19:46 Interior Minister: Israeli Arabs must perform national service