Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 20, 2006 Cheshvan 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:22 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Historians won't believe it
By Ari Shavit

You can't just kill 20 innocent civilians in Beit Hanun and say: "Oops, we made a mistake. We're sorry." You can't. You simply can't. At the very least, the prime minister should appeal personally to the victims and the Palestinian people and express regret, offer compensation and request absolution. At the very least, the defense minister should declare that the catastrophe was the result of a rash policy for which he takes full responsibility. At the very least, there should be an announcement that the evil artillery shelling will cease.

Anything less is unacceptable. Anything less is inhuman and un-Jewish and inconceivable. Inconceivable? In the land of hollow leadership, anything is possible, anything goes.

It is inconceivable to fail in war and to remain in one's post, and sweep things under the carpet. It is inconceivable, simply inconceivable. At the very least, there should be a whole new approach - if not an immediate replacement of the leadership in its entirety, then at least a different program. At the very least, there should be the establishment of a national emergency government comprising worthy and capable individuals of stature. At the very least, there should be an amendment in the decision-making mechanism when it comes to national security, and the army should be embodied with a new spirit. At the very least, the nation should be offered a new ethos and all its resources should be amassed ahead of the challenges of the near future.

Advertisement

Anything less is unacceptable. Anything less is un-Zionist, un-Israeli and inconceivable. Inconceivable? In the land of hollow leadership, anything is possible, anything goes.

It is inconceivable to see a war approaching - and fail to take action. It is inconceivable to understand that the failure of the 2006 war brings the 2007 war closer - and fail to do anything about it. It is inconceivable, simply inconceivable. At the very least, there should be a repeat of what Israel did immediately after the beating it took in the Yom Kippur War: a rebuilding of the army in record time, and the initiation of a political process without delay. At the very least, the Syrians and Palestinians should be brought face-to-face with a terrifying deterrent force, and offered the alternative of a meaningful process of dialogue. At the very least, there should be no provoking or striking out, and the neighbors should be confronted with a big stick and soft words.

Anything less is unacceptable. Anything less is immoral, irresponsible and inconceivable. Inconceivable? In the land of hollow leadership, anything is possible, anything goes.

It is inconceivable to allow the State of Israel to become a state of rot - and to remain silent. It is inconceivable, simply inconceivable. At the very least, a man who is essentially a mega wheeler-dealer should not be allowed to be prime minister. At the very least, there should be public backing for the decent members of the civil service who are trying to stop the mega wheeler-dealer in his tracks. At the very least, the colleagues of the mega wheeler-dealer among the Israeli leadership should refrain from giving him their support and should lower their eyes and keep quiet. At the very least, the Israeli public should bear aloft the handful of decent individuals at the treasury, the State Comptroller's Office, the police, the State Prosecutor's Office and the office of the attorney general, who are now facing the supreme test of the fight against corruption.

Anything less is unacceptable. Anything less is inconceivable. Inconceivable? In the land of hollow elite, anything is possible, anything goes.

The historians won't believe it. They will watch the farcical programs that our television channels aired at these times and they won't believe it. They will read the spin that filled some of our newspapers these days and they won't believe it. They won't be able to comprehend how, with the writing so clearly on the wall, Israel's best agreed to collaborate with the corrupt, the corrupter and the wanton. Where were the media, they will ask. Where was the spirit? Where was the wealth? Where were we all when anything and everything was possible?

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Gaydamak's harvest
The state has turned this man into one of the most influential individuals in the country.
Stealing clients
Thousands of non-Jewish lawyers took the clients of their Jewish colleagues in 1944.
  1.   Historians won`t believe it 09:09  |  Joseph Gold 13/11/06
  2.   ZIONISM IS AN EVIL IDEOLOGY 09:13  |  indrajaya 13/11/06
  3.   Another fine article, but will anybody in Israel listen ?? 09:15  |  Swiss 13/11/06
  4.   Fabulous piece of writing by Ari Shavit, God bless him 09:17  |  Clickfool 13/11/06
  5.   Stop Crying For Our Enemies 09:38  |  Terry 13/11/06
  6.   Shavit Shah Vay??? 09:39  |  S.Cimitar 13/11/06
  7.   I agree 09:43  |  Natallie Durson 13/11/06
  8.   #4 State of rot 09:56  |  Miki 13/11/06
  9.   How does Clickfool know??.... 10:07  |  Dave Kennaird 13/11/06
  10.   Historians Won`t Believe It 10:08  |  Naomi Spiegelman 13/11/06
  11.   Where were we ? You were busy ... 10:18  |  Abbas 13/11/06
  12.   Israel`s rot 10:23  |  Andrew Watson 13/11/06
  13.   Ari Shavit is a typical liberal 10:28  |  Paul Henzen 13/11/06
  14.   # 5 stop crying? 10:34  |  Eric 13/11/06
  15.   anti-Semitic Indrajaya 10:46  |  Curious 13/11/06
  16.   Clickfart 10:49  |  Proud Zionist 13/11/06
  17.   #2 when is the evil indrajaya going to be barred? 10:50  |  paul harris 13/11/06
  18.   Half- truth and whole- truth 10:56  |  Shalom Freedman 13/11/06
  19.   Inconceivable 11:12  |  Choni 13/11/06
  20.   # 17, PAUL HARRIS 11:21  |  indrajaya 13/11/06
  21.   BELIEVE ME. HISTORIANS WILL BELIEVE IT 11:22  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/11/06
  22.   inhuman and un-Jewish and inconceivable. 11:26  |  jj burke 13/11/06
  23.   CURIOUS `s JUSTIFICATION 11:28  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 13/11/06
  24.   A test for Dave Kennaird # 9 11:29  |  Clickfool 13/11/06
  25.   For so-called Proud Zionist # 16 11:31  |  Clickfool 13/11/06
  26.   Badly phrased 11:32  |  Peter Dale 13/11/06
  27.   Tend your own dungheap Clickfool 11:44  |  flighty 13/11/06
  28.   Eric. 11:46  |  Justicia 13/11/06
  29.   Cipora 11:49  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/11/06
  30.   Seeds of own destruction 11:59  |  Marco 13/11/06
  31.   #28 and #4 12:02  |  Mira 13/11/06
  32.   A waste of a good web page 12:07  |  Johnboy 13/11/06
  33.   LET HISTORY RECORD THE WAR CRIMES OF ZIONISM IN THE HOLY LAND 12:09  |  Jeremy 13/11/06
  34.   Proud Zionist #16 12:19  |  TonyL 13/11/06
  35.   Ari Shavit has his facts wrong 12:22  |  Ken Jurist 13/11/06
  36.   #20 indra the joker replies with ONE TENTH OF NO FACT. 12:33  |  Paul harris 13/11/06
  37.   Brave words well put 12:33  |  Martin K 13/11/06
  38.   #23 try writing in context observer and take off the blindfold 12:35  |  paul harris 13/11/06
  39.   Israel is destined for destruction and it will disappear soon 12:43  |  Jonathan S 13/11/06
  40.   Clicky`s `tests` 12:56  |  Yitzhak Katalan 13/11/06
  41.   Clickfool #25 13:01  |  TonyL 13/11/06
  42.   To Terry 13:05  |  Harald 13/11/06
  43.   I don`t believe it either 13:08  |  Ernst 13/11/06
  44.   Inconceivable ??? No, PREDICTABLE !! 13:29  |  Klaudia 13/11/06
  45.   wrong again vague again 13:35  |  please explain 13/11/06
  46.   Historians do believe, but, sometimes, they don`t report 13:48  |  Boris 13/11/06
  47.   Historians do believe, but, sometimes, they don`t report 13:49  |  Boris 13/11/06
  48.   A nation has the leaders it merits 14:04  |  Pablo 13/11/06
  49.   RE :NEUTERED OBSERVER 14:19  |  Pablo 13/11/06
  50.   anti-Semitic Indrajaya 14:30  |  David King 13/11/06
  51.   To terry #5 14:35  |  Bill 13/11/06
  52.   To fake swiss 14:49  |  Gene 13/11/06
  53.   Indrajaya`s misunderstanding 14:54  |  Ziv 13/11/06
  54.   It Is Inconceivable 15:10  |  CHGODMK 13/11/06
  55.   Indrajaya: Whining in Jakarta 15:17  |  CHGODMK 13/11/06
  56.   maral no requiem for the 200 killed in iraq yesterday? 15:17  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  57.   Eric in NM #14 15:20  |  CHGODMK 13/11/06
  58.   Eric in NM #14 15:20  |  CHGODMK 13/11/06
  59.   maral your hizb leader who you look to with awe 15:21  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  60.   Pablo in Spain 15:30  |  CHGODMK 13/11/06
  61.   my name is bradley burston 15:30  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  62.   failure in war 15:37  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  63.   johnboy@handmaderockets 15:42  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  64.   I am afraid Ari Shavit is correct 15:47  |  Allen 13/11/06
  65.   Remember King Husein 15:53  |  L A 13/11/06
  66.   For Jonathan S, who fears for Israel # 39 16:02  |  Clickfool 13/11/06
  67.   Technological Israel 16:48  |  Dan 13/11/06
  68.   Ari Shavit:"You can`t just kill"(?).What about luanching QASSAMS 16:53  |  Vittorio 13/11/06
  69.   re: Technological Israel 17:37  |  Pablo 13/11/06
  70.   Shavit`s right except the first section :One can`t win wars apolo 17:38  |  Absolute Sweden 13/11/06
  71.   #18 Half- truth and whole- truth 17:41  |  aryeh 13/11/06
  72.   # 39 Jonathan S tries to incite propaganda ..... 17:46  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/11/06
  73.   doron almog 17:58  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  74.   to gal hirsch`s wife and children 18:05  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  75.   Neutered Observer 18:21  |  Curious 13/11/06
  76.   Cris de coeur 18:44  |  Michael N 13/11/06
  77.   G-D GAVE ISRAEL TO THE JEWISH NATION 18:55  |  YOSSIE 13/11/06
  78.   inhuman and un-Jewish and inconceivable 19:09  |  Izzi 13/11/06
  79.   To really prepare for the next war... 19:17  |  Polybios 13/11/06
  80.   What precedent for compensating enemies during war? 19:28  |  McQueen 13/11/06
  81.   to gal hirsch`s wife and children.. 19:32  |  northern neighbor 13/11/06
  82.   #5 Terry 19:49  |  Boycott 13/11/06
  83.   Terry #5 Is why Israel has no peace.... 19:53  |  T A Sheppard 13/11/06
  84.   northern neighbour 20:08  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  85.   northern neighbour some more lebanese killings 20:11  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  86.   Jewish suffering 20:16  |  David 13/11/06
  87.   northern neighbour what the lebanese told israelis 20:16  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  88.   northern neighbour david levy the israeli 20:20  |  thucydides 13/11/06
  89.   And so? 20:21  |  ussishkin 13/11/06
  90.   #79 Polybios 20:41  |  Boycott 13/11/06
  91.   Decent ideas, horrible writing 20:44  |  Mark 13/11/06
  92.   This article is one-sided 20:48  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/11/06
  93.   YOSSI#77... G-D DOES NOT SIGN BLANK CHEQUES!! 20:50  |  Jeremy 13/11/06
  94.   33:Not a war crime 20:51  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/11/06
  95.   72: Jonathan is correct - Iran & its proxies want to destroy Isra 20:55  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/11/06
  96.   Why there is no peace 20:58  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/11/06
  97.   Ari Shavit : and there is hope again 21:01  |  Sam (UK) 13/11/06
  98.   RETURN FROM HISTORY TO PRESENCE. 21:05  |  H.H.M 13/11/06
  99.   And so #88 you must be kidding 21:18  |  Michael N 13/11/06
  100.   War, Jewish morality and the absence of any morality by Muslims 21:18  |  Bimmer 13/11/06
  101.   I agree with #2 21:21  |  Zeje 13/11/06
  102.   #88.Ussishkin 21:25  |  Polybios 13/11/06
  103.   #22 is right 21:25  |  Zeje 13/11/06
  104.   #5 ISrael sure has a lot of enemies 21:26  |  Zeje 13/11/06
  105.   #88 what needs to be done part 2 21:28  |  Michael N 13/11/06
  106.   To ProudZionists 21:29  |  Zeje 13/11/06
  107.   Yes, Bruriah 21:34  |  Zeje 13/11/06
  108.   #90. Boycott. What exactly do you want? 22:01  |  Polybios 13/11/06
  109.   Jeremy # 93 22:17  |  Avi Yerushalmi 13/11/06
  110.   Ari Is Right! 22:25  |  Phinias Woppy 13/11/06
  111.   thucydides 22:25  |  northern neighbor 13/11/06
  112.   when they read you they will 23:15  |  over my head 13/11/06
  113.   Well.. 23:43  |  Danite 13/11/06
  114.   Inconceivable? Yes, but old policy 23:49  |  Fed Up 13/11/06
  115.   107:What G-d said 23:56  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/11/06
  116.   104: Israel also has some good friends 23:57  |  Bruriah Sarah 13/11/06
  117.   Israel shouldn`t be there 23:57  |  pro-Arab 13/11/06
  118.   #63 thucydides thinks this is a forum about Iraq 00:20  |  Johnboy 14/11/06
  119.   Zeje 00:21  |  Danite 14/11/06
  120.   BOYYCOTT where are you people compensating etc.dead civillians? 00:26  |  PETER SM 14/11/06
  121.   Unjewish? un-Zionist, un-Israeli? How so? 00:50  |  Joseph Conrad 14/11/06
  122.   # 28 --- Justicia 01:24  |  Eric 14/11/06
  123.   # 57 CHGODMK 01:31  |  Eric 14/11/06
  124.   # 55 --- CHGODMK 02:15  |  Eric 14/11/06
  125.   historians won`t believe... 02:41  |  Shmuelshachor 14/11/06
  126.   Suggestion for Avi Shavit 04:41  |  Murray of Montreal 14/11/06
  127.   Indra of Indonesia 05:24  |  Willy 14/11/06
  128.   THE WAY ISREAL CAN PREPARE FOR NEXT WAR IS BY REBUILDING GK. 05:39  |  GUSH KATIF REFUGES 14/11/06
  129.   Israel : Why Peace? 05:39  |  Roger 14/11/06
  130.   To Indrajaya #2 05:42  |  Otto Rand 14/11/06
  131.   historians won`t believe it 05:44  |  amir 14/11/06
  132.   Poor Terry 05:52  |  Otto Rand 14/11/06
  133.   # 50, DAVID KING 06:39  |  indrajaya 14/11/06
  134.   cip - still the warmonger 06:43  |  Simin 14/11/06
  135.   # 116, WILLY 06:52  |  indrajaya 14/11/06
  136.   Eric #113: It Won`t Work 07:16  |  CHGODMK 14/11/06
  137.   That`s right Indra that`s all you know!! 07:42  |  Willy 14/11/06
  138.   @67, dan 08:36  |  vladimir 14/11/06
  139.   Inconcievable 09:03  |  Burned Liberal 14/11/06
  140.   Historians won`t believe it 09:13  |  Henry Weil 14/11/06
  141.   Eric #113: It Won`t Work 09:49  |  Eric 14/11/06
  142.   what an amazing article very impressive 11:22  |  fatima 14/11/06
  143.   mazel tov 19:47  |  Ursula Mayr 15/11/06
  144.   What about the US? 21:17  |  unbiased 20/11/06
 Today Online
Yossi Sarid: Free Barghouti, future president of Palestine
Responses: 100
Editorial: Israel is deflecting diplomatic initiatives
Responses: 60
Bush: I'd understand if Israel chose to attack Iran
Responses: 272
IDF used cluster bombs in Lebanon against Halutz orders
Responses: 100
Yoni Goldblat-Lavev: Only Hamas can drive the Jews out
Responses: 62


More Headlines
21:21 Officer: General Staff okayed cluster bombs north of Litani
20:24 Six held in Germany over plot to blow up El Al plane
20:07 Eight families of October 2000 riot victims reject payout deal
20:41 Four Palestinians wounded in clashes with IDF in Bethlehem
19:45 EU, U.S. oppose Iran request for nuclear aid at tense IAEA meet
21:06 Gaydamak calls Olmert 'egoist' who 'misunderstands his job'
19:54 New IDF rule bars Palestinians without permits from Israeli cars
21:04 U.S. skeptical of Iranian offer of Iran-Iraq-Syria anti-violence summit
19:34 Envoy: Israeli and French officials meet on Lebanon overflights
18:12 Bedouin petition High Court requesting access to water supply
19:21 State agrees to build reinforced student dormitories in Sderot
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved