Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., December 07, 2006 Kislev 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:38 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 14:44 12/11/2006
I voted for a war criminal
By Bradley Burston



They say that confession is good for the stricken soul. So here's mine:

I voted for a war criminal.

I didn't know it at the time. My intentions were sound. I wanted a better life for the Israelis who had it the worst. I wanted a better life for the Palestinians, who had it worse than anyone.

I weighed the options, examined the alternatives. I had met Amir Peretz when he was still mayor of this town that no one had heard of, Sderot. He was socially conscious, savvy, energetic, courageous, responsive to his constituents, true to his ideals.

He got the right things done. He wanted peace with his neighbors across the Gaza border, in Beit Hanun. He had good ideas about how to get there. People in town thought he could do the impossible, become Israel's first Moroccan-born prime minister.

On March 28 of this year, I walked into the voting booth, having assessed the choices Peretz had made so far. I saw the new people he had attracted to the Labor Party, Ami Ayalon, Avishai Braverman, a host of other capable, creative people, keen to help heal this country, anxious to make a broken nation better.

I considered with care. Like the crew of the IDF self-propelled howitzer ordered to fire at the site of a Qassam launch, an otherwise deserted orange grove in northern Gaza. A safe distance from the houses in adjacent Beit Hanun. Or so they believed.

The crewmen checked before they acted. Their intentions were sound. They had no reason to doubt that the information they had received was reliable. They had no reason to fear that they were about to kill 19 people in a matter of seconds, some of them children still asleep in their beds.

I made it possible. I and all the others who took the ballot with the word Emet (Truth) written on it, and dropped it in the slot. I and all the others who believed Amir Peretz. We gave the go to the 155 mm shells. We killed those kids.

Over the next half year, I would watch my single act of voting turn from hopeful to misguided to stupid to immoral.

The defense minister was the man who could have ruled out the artillery fire before it took its horrible toll. The defense minister was the man who could have said no to the generals who approved it, Gaza front chief Yoav Galant and his divisional commander, Chico Tamir. And we put the defense minister where he is.

We could console ourselves with the truth that functions as a lie, that we didn't intend for him to be defense minister, that we elected him to be a finance minister or a welfare minister.

The artillery crew did not intend for those shells to kill civilians, either.

We can, if we prefer, lay it all off on Peretz, the man who, at a time of critical human need, passed up the chance to be a great and valued cabinet engine for social affairs, in order to be an ineffectual and even dangerous minister of defense.

He could have addressed the needs of thousands of the hungry, the jobless, the handicapped, the elderly, the undereducated. He could have saved thousands of Israelis from job poverty, from despair.

Instead, at this point, the only person Amir Peretz is succeeding in saving, is Ismail Haniyeh.

You may ask, are Qassams fired at innocent civilians a war crime? Of course they are. Does that absolve us from guilt? Not in the slightest.

A few months before that March election, at a huge memorial in Tel Aviv marking 10 years since the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, I listened to the newly elected leader of the Labor Party, Amir Peretz, speak with passion and evident conviction of his goals:

"I have a dream, Yitzhak, that one day an industrial zone will be set up in the no-man's land between Sderot and Beit Hanun. Entertainment venues and playgrounds for our children and Palestinian children will be set up, and they will play together, and build a common future together."

There will be those on the right, and they will be many, who are gloating just now.

Gloat away. Gloat all you want.

This is not a partisan issue. It is much wider than that. It involves personalities in the military and the defense establishment who failed us, who failed their own. And it involves their boss, who can neither gain control over them nor replace them.

Over Gaza as over Lebanon, Israel is being forced to make concessions not because of terrorist fire, but because of our own.

In Gaza as in Lebanon, the generals pushed, and Peretz caved.

For years, the army did its job of the saving the Israeli people. Now it's up to the people to save the army, and to save Israel from its misdeeds.

Better much too late than never. Ask the Republican Party. It has taken action - to save itself, America, perhaps the world, from Donald Rumsfeld.

It's time now for the Labor Party, and the left as a whole, to save itself, from Amir Peretz.


__________________


Talkback Guidelines

The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and an openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, ethnic cleansing, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.
5.Use of the phrase: "There are no Palestinians" or derivatives thereof.

_________________


Previous blogs:

When rabbis' gay-hate turns murderous
The New Dark Ages
Targeting Muslims - the new Inquisition
Israel's spokesman, Israel's enemy

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Devil wears Prada
Patricia Field dresses models with the fashion philosophy reflected in 'Sex and the City.'
Wizards and music
The children's musical 'The Wiz' is back again this Hanukkah for the third time.
  1.   Haaretz and Burston 13:24  |  Kate 12/11/06
  2.   So you did, Mr. Burston 13:32  |  Maral 12/11/06
  3.   Good Attempt Mr "Writer"to acquit IDF and makeup for an accident! 15:24  |  Tayfun_Turkey 12/11/06
  4.   DO NOT FIRE,LIBERATE GAZA,ESTABLISH ORDER,LET GAZANS GO.FOREVER)) 15:42  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 12/11/06
  5.   interesting censorship criteria 15:49  |  raymond deane 12/11/06
  6.   Because violence begats more violence 15:54  |  And it must STOP 12/11/06
  7.   burston 16:07  |  chaim 12/11/06
  8.   to haaretz 16:25  |  chaim 12/11/06
  9.   The view from the diaspora 16:36  |  Neil 12/11/06
  10.   Well said Neil 16:50  |  Dante 12/11/06
  11.   Waiting for the Day 16:52  |  Choni 12/11/06
  12.   I voted for a war criminal 17:03  |  Richard Lefkowitz 12/11/06
  13.   Jews and the state of Israel... 17:20  |  Isak 12/11/06
  14.   Diaspora 18:21  |  Marcelo 12/11/06
  15.   its something else 18:32  |  ravi 12/11/06
  16.   Tayfun from Istanbul 19:13  |  David Israel 12/11/06
  17.   to Kate #1 19:27  |  Sanda 12/11/06
  18.   17Aachen: Your advice is as good as Chamberlain`s to the Czech 19:53  |  Logician 12/11/06
  19.   Hamas&Disengagement mudered in Bet Hanon 20:42  |  Sam 12/11/06
  20.   deaths in beit hanoun 20:48  |  richard fox 12/11/06
  21.   to a fellow Pennsylvanian 21:18  |  LB 12/11/06
  22.   16Tayfun from Istanbul: Not thousands but 1000000 Armenian killed 21:30  |  Logician 12/11/06
  23.   I voted for a war criminal 21:42  |  Michael Katz 12/11/06
  24.   To Kate # 1 - Fully irrelevant 21:47  |  Yankelowitz 12/11/06
  25.   Death of innocents is fact of war: continues til Muslims stop war 21:48  |  Hal 12/11/06
  26.   Israel can count on bloody America 22:04  |  Yankelowitz 12/11/06
  27.   Dream of peace between Jews and Muslims = Lieberman`s plan 22:13  |  Hal 12/11/06
  28.   apropos michael katz 22:37  |  richard fox 12/11/06
  29.   #1 Kate, don`t shoot the messenger 22:45  |  Boycott 12/11/06
  30.   stop crying Burston 22:59  |  Nicolas 12/11/06
  31.   Nonsense 23:01  |  Shalom Freedman 12/11/06
  32.   View from the outside 23:02  |  Spoff 12/11/06
  33.   To Kate 23:59  |  Barry 12/11/06
  34.   Another possibility 01:58  |  John 13/11/06
  35.   Burston is ... 02:13  |  Yakov 13/11/06
  36.   Spoff in Aukland 02:55  |  KT 13/11/06
  37.   Bradley Burston : there is hope 02:58  |  Sam (UK) 13/11/06
  38.   too far, not too late 03:03  |  not in my name 13/11/06
  39.   KT 03:41  |  Spoff 13/11/06
  40.   Kate#1 04:48  |  Sam (UK) 13/11/06
  41.   John of NYC - what tripe 05:21  |  Marilyn 13/11/06
  42.   we too can do maths 05:54  |  H 13/11/06
  43.   Mr. Tayfun 06:33  |  Habib 13/11/06
  44.   War criminal? 08:12  |  Bretware 13/11/06
  45.   Nu Be Emet Bradley, You voted for an idiot 08:30  |  Judith 13/11/06
  46.   "ethnic cleansing" in relation to Israel/Palestine 09:04  |  george 13/11/06
  47.   Bradley Give It Up And I Reject Your Comments About Rumsfeld! 09:13  |  Yosemite Sam 13/11/06
  48.   bradley 09:19  |  jj burke 13/11/06
  49.   Bradley`s agenda 09:22  |  FOX 13/11/06
  50.   Kate & Burston`s article 09:23  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/11/06
  51.   #11 Choni 09:26  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/11/06
  52.   To Barry #33 09:32  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/11/06
  53.   NOBODY CAN SAVE ISRAEL NOW 09:37  |  indrajaya 13/11/06
  54.   Incomprehensible 09:54  |  Choni 13/11/06
  55.   I ALSO voted for a war criminal 09:58  |  Binyamin 13/11/06
  56.   Boycott Israel 10:02  |  Ama 13/11/06
  57.   To Ari # 51 10:05  |  Choni 13/11/06
  58.   The fate of a war-criminal is very different in this world..... 10:05  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/11/06
  59.   Guidelines on talkback should apply always 10:06  |  Gordy 13/11/06
  60.   To "H" who can also do math 10:07  |  Big 13/11/06
  61.   diaspora fallout 10:12  |  alex 13/11/06
  62.   INCOMPETENT, YES, WAR CRIMINAL, NO 10:12  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/11/06
  63.   Banning Burston from the confessional 10:21  |  S. Cimitar 13/11/06
  64.   Remember how the religious right started inadvertently 10:27  |  Joseph E . 13/11/06
  65.   For Big #60 10:34  |  Little 13/11/06
  66.   # 62 Cipora Julianna Kohn 10:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/11/06
  67.   Taking responsiblity 10:36  |  Palestinian 13/11/06
  68.   Indrajaya Actually! 10:38  |  Yosemite Sam 13/11/06
  69.   To Benyamin # 51 10:47  |  Choni 13/11/06
  70.   58Swiss; Are you (&Bradley) prosecutor ,judge & jury? 10:52  |  Logician 13/11/06
  71.   What`s so incomprehensible Choni # 54 10:54  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/11/06
  72.   To Ari # 50 10:57  |  Choni 13/11/06
  73.   Ridiculous 10:59  |  Jewish Mayhem 13/11/06
  74.   We are a nation of war criminals that accepts IDF crimes against 11:05  |  Yossi Reichman 13/11/06
  75.   To #57 still in Exile!!!! 11:09  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/11/06
  76.   Choni, do a painiting of the scene of Arab leaving Palestine 11:19  |  Skandar 13/11/06
  77.   #60. If Pals stop fight, end to "massacres", if Israeli stop.. 11:21  |  Logician 13/11/06
  78.   YOU Voted for a politician out of his depth in this portfolio. 11:22  |  PETER SM 13/11/06
  79.   Burston goes for the blast 11:25  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/11/06
  80.   David Israel, the new Plato 11:25  |  Skandar 13/11/06
  81.   To Ari # 71 11:27  |  Choni 13/11/06
  82.   "YOSSI REICHMAN" funny you sound just like an Arab progandist. 11:28  |  PETER SM 13/11/06
  83.   #66, Swiss 11:29  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/11/06
  84.   Sam(UK) 11:30  |  Jasmine 13/11/06
  85.   #20, Richard is no Fox 11:32  |  Skandar