Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 12, 2006 Cheshvan 21, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:04 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Palestinians attending the funerals Thursday of 19 Gazans killed in IDF shelling the day before. (AP)
Last update - 02:13 10/11/2006
Peretz to reevaluate IDF policy of shelling northern Gaza Strip
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent, Haaretz Staff and Agencies

Defense Minister Amir Peretz decided Thursday to reevaluate the policy of directing IDF artillery fire at the Gaza Strip, following the killing of 19 Palestinian civilians by errant Israel Defence Forces shelling in Beit Hanun on Wednesday.

Peretz also decided that from now on all artillery fire must be approved by GOC Southern Command Yoav Galant, or his superior officers.

The IDF has halted the artillery fire until the completion of an inquiry into Wednesday's incident.

Advertisement

Major General Meir Kalifi, who is heading the IDF inquiry, met Thursday evening with Peretz and presented him with the inquiry's findings.

The inquiry found that a malfunctioning electronic card in the artillery battery's guidance system, which was replaced five days ago, was the cause of the errant fire.

The card fed the battery's guidance system with wrong coordinates, as a result of which the battery errantly fired seven shells into Palestinian homes, instead of open areas from which Qassam rockets were being fired at Israeli communities.

The Israeli-developed "Shilem" guidance system has been in use by the IDF for roughly 30 years. It is considered reliable, and IDF inquiries into the matter found that this is the first time this particular malfunction has occured in the system or similar systems used abroad.

According to military sources, it would be worthwhile to look into whether the artillery battery team could have nonetheless avoided the incident through more proper performance, and careful monitoring of the equipment.

The Kalifi inquiry has yet to complete its work, but as yet has found that the replacement card was examined in a professional manner by the proper technicians.

The inquiry is considering recommending two changes to IDF regulations: requiring a live-fire test of artillery batteries following parts replacement, and requiring human tracking of where shells are falling in addition to the radar.

The inquiry will also examine the standard operating regulations in IDF artillery batteries and in the Gaza division, as well as how well they are upheld in practice.

Peretz also ordered an examination of IDF regulations regarding the minimum required distance between where artillery fire can be directed and the nearest populated area.

In the past year the IDF reduced this minimum required distance from 300 meters to 100 meters, before raising it back to 200 meters. Some IDF generals believe this minimum distance is too small.

Nonetheless, IDF Chief of Staff Dan Halutz and Galant are convinced the IDF should not rule out entirely the use of artillery shelling to combat rocket fire.

Following the presentation of the inquiry's findings, Halutz said the incident in Beit Hanun was "difficult and saddening" due to the deaths of "uninvolved civilians."

Halutz added that the inquiry was thoroughly conducted and announced that he is adopting its findings, conclusions, and recommendations.

"The IDF takes care to avoid harming the civilian population and acts solely against the terror infrastructure," Halutz said.

Olmert calls for immediate meeting with Abbas
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert on Thursday said the IDF shelling was caused by a "technical failure" and called for an immediate meeting with Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas.

"He will be surprised, when he will sit with me, by how far we are prepared to go. I can offer him a lot," Olmert said, without elaborating.

In his comments, Olmert said he is ready to meet with Abbas "any time, any place, without preconditions." He said Abbas has prevented a meeting from taking place.

Olmert, speaking in English at a business conference, expressed regret for Wednesday's bloodshed. "I'm very uncomfortable with this event. I'm very distressed," he said, adding he had personally looked into the cause of the pre-dawn artillery strike.

"This particular case ... was a mistake," he said. "It was not a planned attack."

"It was a technical failure of the Israeli artillery. I checked it, and I verified it."

He added, however, that Israel will continue its military operations in Gaza as long as Palestinian rocket attacks persist. He said Israel will do everything it can to avoid similar mistakes, but warned that further tragedies are possible. "It may happen," he said.

Olmert said Wednesday's artillery strike was aimed at an orange grove used by rocket squads in northern Gaza to attack Israel.

At Beit Hanun funerals, Fatah official vows revenge
Tens of thousands of Palestinians joined mass funeral processions in Gaza on Thursday as the bodies of 19 people killed by the botched IDF shelling the day before were buried to the accompaniment of gunfire and vows of revenge.

Groups of militants, some masked and firing their weapons in the air, flanked the processions as they snaked through the streets of Beit Hanun, where Wednesday's attack took place, before the dead were laid to rest in a new cemetery.

The bodies, including six children and seven women, were each wrapped in a yellow flag, the symbol of the Fatah movement of Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, and borne aloft on stretchers among a vast chanting crowd of mourners.

Cries of "Allahu Akbar" (God is Greatest) filled the air as the bodies were placed in their graves, and more gunfire sounded before a Fatah official, addressing the crowds through a loudspeaker, pledged vengeance against Israel.

"The killers in Israel, you will never be able to defeat one Palestinian child," said Abdul Hakim Awad.

"The Zionist enemy understands only the language of force and therefore I say, an eye for an eye and a soul for a soul. There will be no security in Ashkelon, no security in Tel Aviv or Haifa, until our people in Beit Hanun are secured."

All activity in Beit Hanun was focused on the funerals. Ordinarily, on a Thursday morning, the town's streets are teeming with people. In the hours before the funeral, the streets were all but deserted.

A three-day mourning period declared by Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas kept shops shuttered. Schools, as is the custom in Gaza and the West Bank, were closed Thursday.

Khadra Abu Shabat, 55, said sadness mingled with worry on an emotionally charged day.

"All of us are feeling sad, and worried, too," said Abu Shabat, tears streaming down her face. "We are going to bury this family and ask ourselves, 'Who's next? Me? My grandchildren? My neighbor?"'

Hamas' military wing also called for attacks against American targets on the grounds of U.S support for Isrsael. President George W. Bush called for restraint on all sides Wednesday.

Israel was placed on high security alert following the shelling in Beit Hanun. Hamas swore to avenge the deaths, and called on all Palestinian groups to renew attacks inside Israel.

The errant artillery barrage provoked Palestinian threats of a new wave of violence. Khaled Mashaal, the supreme leader of the Palestinians' ruling Hamas movement, canceled a cease-fire with Israel that has largely held since February 2005, raising the specter of renewed suicide bombings.

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni expressed regret for the deaths, saying that Israel did not set out to harm innocent civilians.

At this stage it is unclear whether the incident was caused by a technical or human error. Israel Defense Forces Chief of Staff Dan Halutz has appointed Major General Meir Kalifi to head an investigation into the shelling.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Paint over the mosaic
Elana Gomel has no idea what life is like for the Israelis who support Lieberman.
On U.S. and them
The vitriolic hatred that the U.S. inspires in so many is striking chords everywhere.
  1.   Danite, Having read your transliterated note, I responded to it, 08:26  |  Nadav 09/11/06
  2.   MORAL SLIP 09:44  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 09/11/06
  3.   Where Is US Condi Favorising Abbas Technocratie 10:13  |  Joseph E . 09/11/06
  4.   # 2 NEUTERED OBSERVER 10:21  |  Joseph E . 09/11/06
  5.   Who`s next? Me? My grandchildren? My neighbor? 12:09  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 09/11/06
  6.   Crocodile tears 12:14  |  S.Cimitar 09/11/06
  7.   Will the palestinians fire rockets from the cemetry 12:23  |  British academic 09/11/06
  8.   #5 Shlomo 12:47  |  Dov 09/11/06
  9.   Don`t hide among civilians,people don`t want to die! 13:15  |  Infidel 09/11/06
  10.   # 7 13:21  |  John 09/11/06
  11.   wheres the voice of the Harideem 13:45  |  PiNK BOY 09/11/06
  12.   Amoral citizens. 13:47  |  Nora 09/11/06
  13.   Condolences to the suffering families.(2nd attemp) 14:26  |  PETER SM 09/11/06
  14.   Israel will hope the world will forget the Beit Hanun atrocity 14:48  |  Clickfool 09/11/06
  15.   re: Shlomo #5 14:49  |  Paulo 09/11/06
  16.   No.8 Just the night before, Rabbis said this would happen... 15:12  |  Dan 09/11/06
  17.   How dare Israel defend itself against rocket attacks??!! 15:18  |  Henry in Canada 09/11/06
  18.   HAMAS COWARDS 15:22  |  MIKE 09/11/06
  19.   the choice is theirs 15:24  |  pete 09/11/06
  20.   No inalienable right to shoot rockets 15:33  |  Paul Freedman 09/11/06
  21.   No. 5 15:34  |  Oschner 09/11/06
  22.   What a pile of crap... 15:40  |  Ben 09/11/06
  23.   palestians need to learn terror doesnt work 15:49  |  zionist forever 09/11/06
  24.   Shlomo from TA 15:53  |  sh 09/11/06
  25.   Guess? 16:03  |  R.A 09/11/06
  26.   In addition to being terrorist, Fatah 16:04  |  KUTW 09/11/06
  27.   Shame on you, Israel. 16:05  |  Chaim 09/11/06
  28.   That is the only language Fatah understands 16:09  |  KUTW 09/11/06
  29.   #4 16:10  |  Elie 09/11/06
  30.   The DIFFERENCE: Israel states remorse but Abbas et al vow revenge 16:10  |  r 09/11/06
  31.   Take Revenge at Arafat Living Peace Legacy and their Oslo Accords 16:13  |  Joseph E . 09/11/06
  32.   9. Nora: Who?s to blame 16:17  |  KUTW 09/11/06
  33.   Botched Shelling - 16:28  |  * BEN JABO 09/11/06
  34.   Botched Shelling - 16:28  |  * BEN JABO 09/11/06
  35.   To Shlomo 16:29  |  Georges 09/11/06
  36.   #9 - Amoral - Not really 16:31  |  * BEN JABO 09/11/06
  37.   Well who would have guessed? 16:37  |  Allon 09/11/06
  38.   i agree with Shlomo 16:42  |  Allon 09/11/06
  39.   Dangerous Chaos (2nd attempt) 16:45  |  ScotGuy 09/11/06
  40.   Islamist-Jihadists hysteria 16:48  |  Brod 09/11/06
  41.   Since 1948 16:49  |  Nathan 09/11/06
  42.   At Beit Hanun funerals, Fatah official vows revenge 16:54  |  Ben Ali 09/11/06
  43.   Britsih Academic#7... SHAMEFUL ON YOU! 16:55  |  Frederic 09/11/06
  44.   to KTW #15 17:00  |  Alberto 09/11/06
  45.   # 16 Elie @ Beirut / Lebanon 17:10  |  Joseph E . 09/11/06
  46.   The Hell is waiting for all of you --give back soldier 17:10  |  Sal 09/11/06
  47.   Nothing New 17:11  |  Mary 09/11/06
  48.   29. Alberto 17:18  |  KUTW 09/11/06
  49.   Actually Frederic they havent 17:19  |  British academic 09/11/06
  50.   Tired 17:22  |  Rui 09/11/06
  51.   British Acad.#7 NOT MISSING AN OPPORTUNITY 2 DEMONIZE THE VICTIM! 17:26  |  James 09/11/06
  52.   again look at the picture 17:26  |  vik 09/11/06
  53.   To Sal 17:34  |  Georges 09/11/06
  54.   19 KUTW, 22 Ben Jabo. 17:35  |  Nora 09/11/06
  55.   to KTW 17:35  |  Alberto 09/11/06
  56.   To British Academic 17:38  |  Georges 09/11/06
  57.   James and Frederic you post the same paragraph 17:41  |  British academic 09/11/06
  58.   # 20 17:50  |  alan 09/11/06
  59.   Georges you just prove the stereotypical.. 17:58  |  British academic 09/11/06
  60.   53. Nora 18:01  |  KUTW 09/11/06
  61.   Boo Hoo Hoo 18:01  |  Black Death 09/11/06
  62.   By the way Georges what are your brothers doing 18:01  |  British academic 09/11/06
  63.   54. Alberto 18:03  |  KUTW 09/11/06
  64.   #54 Nora`s investigation 18:14  |  * BEN JABO 09/11/06
  65.   olmert has nothing to offer 18:20  |  albert 09/11/06
  66.   British Academic = zionist undercover agent in Britain 18:25  |  Frederic 09/11/06
  67.   #53 Giorges --Mecca is waiting for all Euro Muslims 18:26  |  Sal 09/11/06
  68.   #14--invective is not a logical argument 18:32  |  Paul Freedman 09/11/06
  69.   #62. British Academic and "Georges" 18:34  |  Polybios 09/11/06
  70.   OLmerts meeting with Abbas -the last supper 18:34  |  Sal 09/11/06
  71.   #58: calling names not an argument 18:37  |  Paul Freedman 09/11/06
  72.   Damage control Israeli - style ?? 18:39  |  Swiss 09/11/06
  73.   policy needed: anti-Zionist hatred ignorable 18:44  |  Paul Freedman 09/11/06
  74.   To British Academic 18:49  |  Liz 09/11/06
  75.   Frederic/James or should I say Mo 18:49  |  British Academic 09/11/06
  76.   jihad ends, bloodshed ends 18:51  |  Harry 09/11/06
  77.   An eye for an eyelash 18:52  |  Benyamin 09/11/06
  78.   For your crimes after crimes of the Angels (the Children) 18:55  |  Humanbeing 09/11/06
  79.   Do not cave in to the terrorists - they use civilians as shields 18:59  |  Robert 09/11/06
  80.   "I can offer him a lot"... says olmert 19:02  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/11/06
  81.   Arab League debating Bet Hanoun 19:05  |  rich 09/11/06
  82.   NO TALKS WITH WAR CRIMINALS.... 19:05  |  Messaoud 09/11/06
  83.   self-styled "British Academic" 19:16