Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 12, 2006 Cheshvan 21, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:58 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:10 09/11/2006
A cease-fire in Gaza (2)
By Haaretz Editorial

Yesterday, we wrote here that "Israel should declare a complete cease-fire in the Gaza Strip for a predetermined period, during which it will not engage in any violent actions, neither assassinations nor incursions. Simultaneously, it should call on the Palestinians to hold their fire as well."

What we feared has come to pass - and for the Palestinians, even worse: At least 19 Palestinians were killed yesterday during a sustained Israel Defense Forces artillery attack on the town of Beit Hanun. Of these, 11 were members of a single family, including women and children.

No excuse can justify this atrocity. When artillery batteries aim their shells near a residential neighborhood, such a disaster is inevitable, even if it is unintentional.

Advertisement

Anyone who fired shells in the direction of civilian houses knows very well that he is liable to kill indiscriminately with them.

None of Israel's responses to this catastrophe - expressions of regret by the prime minister and defense minister, offers of humanitarian assistance to the wounded, the establishment of an inquiry committee headed by Major General Meir Kalifi, cessation of the shelling and the opening of the Rafah border crossing for a day - can paper over Israel's sole responsibility for this fearsome and senseless killing. Therefore, it is no longer enough to express regret; it is also necessary to draw conclusions.

It has now become conclusively clear that the campaign against the Qassam rocket launchers in Gaza can no longer be entrusted solely to the IDF. The chief of staff, the chief of command, the divisional commander, and the other officers who bear moral and operational responsibility for yesterday's disaster had failed even before this, during Operation Autumn Clouds, which ostensibly ended on Tuesday. That operation sowed only death and destruction, without bringing an end to the Qassam fire. On the contrary, it only increased it.

Yesterday's shelling therefore seems, above all, like an act of revenge by the IDF for the continued Qassam fire.

The prime minister, as the person who bears overall responsibility, must order the IDF to halt the fire on Gaza - immediately, in all cases and with every type of weapon.

If Israel does not want to find itself embroiled soon in a new bloodbath, including suicide bombings in its cities, it must launch a dramatic, unequivocal move, as only such a move might prevent the outbreak of a new intifada. Such a move must begin with a total cease-fire, even a unilateral one, in the context of which Israel will commit itself to total restraint for a predetermined period, even if Qassams continue to fall here and there.

Instead of more and more pointless military operations, which will not lead to anything except to kindling more hatred, we must try a completely different path. Instead of military operations with attractive names, we must immediately embark on a diplomatic operation.

The cannons must be replaced with calls for dialogue, the economic boycott must be replaced with an opening of the taps, and the cruel siege of Gaza must be replaced with a supervised opening of the border crossings.

Only in this way can we perhaps change the dangerous atmosphere that now prevails, and even more so following the bloodbath in Beit Hanun. The responsibility for this rests entirely on the prime minister's shoulders.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Paint over the mosaic
Elana Gomel has no idea what life is like for the Israelis who support Lieberman.
On U.S. and them
The vitriolic hatred that the U.S. inspires in so many is striking chords everywhere.
  1.   Reason must supercede emotion. 10:19  |  Robert B. 09/11/06
  2.   There is no excuse, stop firing Kassams 10:21  |  Ariel 09/11/06
  3.   It`s time for a (fair) ultimatum on Israel 10:26  |  Swiss 09/11/06
  4.   Suicidal maniacks of "Haaretz" want an unconditional surrender 10:28  |  Absolute Sweden 09/11/06
  5.   A great editorial BUT 10:28  |  Clickfool 09/11/06
  6.   QASSAMS ON ASHKELON, SAME AS ON TEL AVIV, NY,PARIS,LONDON.... 10:32  |  Ben 09/11/06
  7.   HAARETZ=Plain Talking 10:33  |  David Torres 09/11/06
  8.   Wake Up Israel 10:37  |  David King 09/11/06
  9.   Common Ground 10:38  |  Maral 09/11/06
  10.   The big question is what to do if they continue firing 10:38  |  ash 09/11/06
  11.   excellent editorial 10:44  |  freddy 09/11/06
  12.   I Don`t Know What To Tell You Guys! 10:45  |  Yosemite Sam 09/11/06
  13.   white wash inquiry 10:46  |  Avram 09/11/06
  14.   Cease fire and end of occupation 10:47  |  Petter B 09/11/06
  15.   Take what you want from our blood and leave !!! 10:51  |  Haytham 09/11/06
  16.   Thirsty for blood 10:54  |  Peace? 09/11/06
  17.   Haaretz, incorrect article 10:54  |  Liz Biggin 09/11/06
  18.   Posters on this site 10:59  |  Microraptor 09/11/06
  19.   There`s no excuse! 11:03  |  Ariel 09/11/06
  20.   Jews, you poor lot 11:05  |  sefian 09/11/06
  21.   to #3 - How wrong u are! 11:07  |  El 09/11/06
  22.   Is anyone innocent? 11:08  |  Brendan 09/11/06
  23.   reason must be objective 11:11  |  A.M. 09/11/06
  24.   Part..1-Haaretz Editors:SET UP a "Court for War Crimes".. 11:12  |  Haham me Bat Yam 09/11/06
  25.   Legalizing pogroms in Israel 11:18  |  Yakov 09/11/06
  26.   not true, the gaza surrrender is responsible and Oslo etc 11:20  |  Pablo 09/11/06
  27.   Part 2-Haaretz Editors: SET UP a "Court for War Crimes" for Jews. 11:24  |  Haham me Bat Yam 09/11/06
  28.   Common Ground (2nd try) 11:28  |  Maral 09/11/06
  29.   Why should we be overly sensative? 11:28  |  Avi Yerushalmi 09/11/06
  30.   Editorial piffle 11:29  |  S.Cimitar 09/11/06
  31.   Operation Autumn Clouds 11:33  |  Maureen Ann 09/11/06
  32.   Philistines Play With Matches: Get Burned 11:33  |  Yishai Kohen 09/11/06
  33.   maral and "common ground" 11:39  |  thucydides 09/11/06
  34.   Part 3-Haaretz Editors:Set Up a "Court for War Crimes" for Jews 11:40  |  Haham me Bat Yam 09/11/06
  35.   #4, Clickfool - Churchill on Israel 11:42  |  Robert 09/11/06
  36.   WAR is barbaric always.Hamas excludes peace& keeps repeating it 11:43  |  PETER SM 09/11/06
  37.   Kahane again 11:49  |  Choni 09/11/06
  38.   get their leaders, no other choice for us 11:49  |  felipe 09/11/06
  39.   wow more mistakes...what next, another massacre 11:52  |  Rimon 09/11/06
  40.   Who needs excuses? 12:01  |  Beni 09/11/06
  41.   To ClickFOOL, count Dracula of Lewes 12:04  |  Jonathan S 09/11/06
  42.   Part 5-Haaretz :Your editorial: RUN of the "JEW" (Ref. Borlat) 12:07  |  Haham me Bat Yam 09/11/06
  43.   Draw Your Conclusions Go live in Gaza 12:12  |  Joseph E . 09/11/06
  44.   What rockets you are talking about ???? 12:12  |  Joseph 09/11/06
  45.   All the palestinians have to do is start state building 12:16  |  British academic 09/11/06
  46.   Qassams - a brave editorial 12:17  |  Tony Price 09/11/06
  47.   Maral, I actually feel very good with your post. Indeed, we are 12:17  |  Nadav 09/11/06
  48.   Microraptor 12:19  |  Dave Kennaird 09/11/06
  49.   IT IS NAKED TRUTH 12:19  |  Marco 09/11/06
  50.   only a shallow satisfaction 12:21  |  Cornelia 09/11/06
  51.   Haaretz is very clever at giving easy advice 12:30  |  Judith 09/11/06
  52.   The Occupation itself is an act of violence 12:31  |  Michael 09/11/06
  53.   Pablo`s "history." 12:35  |  Wiktor 09/11/06
  54.   Gaza 12:38  |  Victor 09/11/06
  55.   For Jonathan S, from Count Dracula again# 34 12:43  |  Clickfool 09/11/06
  56.   # 31-Maureen Ann- Hey we Agree ! 12:46  |  Klaudia 09/11/06
  57.   israeli mythology 12:49  |  freddy 09/11/06
  58.   Here`s the bottom line people 12:49  |  Ken Jurist 09/11/06
  59.   Haaretz gets it wrong 12:51  |  Ann Coulter 09/11/06
  60.   Yes Yes Yes Yes 12:53  |  Johnboy 09/11/06
  61.   Maureen Ann 12:56  |  Dave Kennaird 09/11/06
  62.   #2 NO Ariel. YOU ARE WRONG 12:57  |  Johnboy 09/11/06
  63.   Mr. Kohen and the Philitines! #32 13:02  |  Wiktor 09/11/06
  64.   If the Palestinians don`t want attacks to continue 13:09  |  Nechama 09/11/06
  65.   British "academic." # 37 13:10  |  Wiktor 09/11/06
  66.   Dear Maral 13:11  |  Nechama 09/11/06
  67.   NO EXCUSE FOR HAMAS ARMING VIA EYGPT FOR FUTURE ATTROCITIES ? 13:15  |  Bill. 09/11/06
  68.   #37 And how *do* they "start state building"? 13:16  |  Johnboy 09/11/06
  69.   gaza 13:20  |  HC 09/11/06
  70.   A very lucid and telling article 13:30  |  Chris Linthwaite 09/11/06
  71.   Israel is a terrorist state 13:34  |  Stephen Murray 09/11/06
  72.   You Need to To Have Your heads Examined 13:35  |  Dr David I Gross 09/11/06
  73.   RE 32: Ethnic Cleansing 13:38  |  Tupac 09/11/06
  74.   Response to Bet Hanun 13:39  |  Hersh 09/11/06
  75.   respect 13:41  |  nana 09/11/06
  76.   #37 spare us armchair arrogance 13:48  |  will 09/11/06
  77.   to swiss 14:09  |  shalomaleikum 09/11/06
  78.   to Swedish no.4 14:11  |  Shalomaleikum 09/11/06
  79.   This is a war - casualties are expected to happen 14:16  |  Brurirah Sarah 09/11/06
  80.   Wow! 14:21  |  Gee 09/11/06
  81.   Liz Biggin 14:23  |  Dani Reiss 09/11/06
  82.   Stemming from A Knowledge That They Are Loosing 14:25  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/11/06
  83.   40: Settlements are Legal 14:27  |  Bruriah Sarah 09/11/06
  84.   38: And what about arabs killing Jews? 14:31  |  Bruriah Sarah 09/11/06
  85.   No, Robert B of LA, there is no rejoicing 14:34  |  Yaakov Sullivan 09/11/06
  86.   Tupac: Jews Living In YOUR Neighborhood May Be "Illegal" 14:38  |  Yishai Kohen 09/11/06
  87.   Gaza 14:39  |  Chaim Gorenstein 09/11/06