Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., December 16, 2006 Kislev 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:13 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 12:34 12/11/2006
When rabbis' gay-hate turns murderous
By Bradley Burston


This was going to be about tolerance.
It could turn out to be about murder.

This was going to be about courageous steps taken by police officials and leaders of both the ultra-Orthodox and gay communities, to reduce the friction, the fury, the hurt feelings, and the possibility of violence in the dispute over the planned Gay Pride Parade in Jerusalem.

This was going to be about the many gay activists who were concerned about the sensitivities of Orthodox residents of Jerusalem and worked to see that the parade would not be held in their neighborhoods.

This was going to be about a well-intentioned if ultimately futile attempt late Monday by members of the ultra-Orthodox Eida Haredit organization to calm tensions and curb rioting.

Members of the group used megaphones to try to stop Haredi youths who were pelting police officers with large stones, blocks, bottles, angle irons, and wood planks, telling them that the Torah forbade taking actions that endangered lives and declaring a curfew.

Then this.

"The Rabbinical Court has held a special session and discussed placing a pulsa danura on those who have a hand in organizing the march," Rabbi Shmuel Papenheim, editor of the Eida Haredit's weekly magazine "Ha'eidah" told Army Radio on Tuesday.

The curse could also be cast "against the policemen who beat ultra-Orthodox Jews," Papenheim added.

If words can kill, 'pulsa danura' is a weapon of mass destruction.

It may be said with certainty that Badatz, the Eida Haredit's rabbinical High Court, intends no physical harm to those connected with the parade or those charged with guarding them.

But there is an entirely inexcusable element of irresponsibility in citing the pulsa danura in connection with a powderkeg issue that mines and exacerbates political, religious and cultural tensions all at once.

The mere mention of the concept bears explosive force in the supercharged climate of woe and worry and fear of the Other - fear of the Other even if the other is, in fact, one of yours.

It's the hallmark of the tribalism of a Holy Land in which we're all related, though history, through blood, through Genesis, through the hourly news.

There is another point that we all know but take pains never to discuss, all of us who live in the Holy land and its holiest city: the high incidence of mental illness among our political fanatics.

Although frequently over-simplified and misunderstood as a Talmudically rooted kabbalistic curse of death, the contemporary meaning of pulsa danura - as a voodoo tool of the psychotic right - has taken on a deadly power of its own.

As a fringe group with worldwide adherents, Voodoo Jewry happens to hold many views that align with the far-right and very religious. But Voodoo Jewry, whether Kahanist or quasi-kabbalist or revisionist Hasidic in nature, goes well beyond.

Consider Avigdor Eskin, who told reporters that on the night of October 6, 1995, he pronounced the following curse on "Yitzhak, the son of Rosa Rabin," for signing the Oslo peace agreements and speaking ill of the settlers:

"Put to death the cursed Yitzhak. May he be damned, damned, damned!"

"Angels of destruction will hit him. He is damned wherever he goes. His soul will instantly leave his body," Eskin intoned, "and he will not survive a month."

Eskin's publicity-grabbing curses accompanied more descreet rulings by extremist rabbis, who cited the concepts of "din rodef" in implying that Rabin deserved to be put to death.

On November 4, 1995, Rabin was gunned down by law student Yigal Amir, who has since become perhaps the central role model, idol, and, for many, sex symbol, of Voodoo Jewry.

The lunatic fringe of Voodoo Jewry received further reinforcement when Ariel Sharon was stricken with a massive cerebral hemorrhage in January, six months after radical opponents of the then-prime minister's disengagement from Gaza gathered in a graveyard in Rosh Pina to ask the Angel of Death to kill him.

None of this deterred the Badatz from placing the pulsa danura on the docket.

Rabbi Papenheim was similarly unfazed. He told Army Radio on Tuesday that the ultra-Orthodox rioting in the streets of Jerusalem was not the exercise of violence but "conducting a campaign."

As for the parade and the pulsa danura, "We've done what we could to uproot this evil from Jerusalem. The moment we see that we've done all that we could from here, we will engage higher forces, with their Torah powers, so that they will take care of this matter, which we see as the most grave."

Moving the parade to another area of the city would make no difference, he continued. "First of all, we would not allow such a thing in Jerusalem, nor anywhere else in the world. This is against the halakha, against the Torah, and against all morality.

"In this case, when we're speaking of a public obscenity, and greatly harms our children and their upbringing, we've taken it upon ourselves to fight this with all our power."

According to the rabbi, the Badatz of the Eidah Haredit had not instituted the pulsa danura for 50 years, since Jerusalem opened its first pool for mixed swimming of men and women.

"We know that all those who had a hand in the Pool of Abomination did not end up well," Rabbi Papenheim said, noting that then-Jerusalem mayor Gershon Agron's life "did not last out the year."


__________________


Talkback Guidelines

The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and an openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, ethnic cleansing, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.
5.Use of the phrase: "There are no Palestinians" or derivatives thereof.

_________________


Previous blogs:

The New Dark Ages
Targeting Muslims - the new Inquisition
Israel's spokesman, Israel's enemy
Peace Never

Bookmark to del.icio.us
He cast a giant shadow
Modern Hebrew writing is deeply rooted in earlier literature, especially Agnon's.
Work space to my place
If one spends hours a day at work, one way to feel at home is to jazz up the work cubicle.
  1.   So, if pulsa danura works... 14:38  |  Maral 07/11/06
  2.   Do You Think It Works ? 14:55  |  jack 07/11/06
  3.   THE PULSA ON RABIN ORCHESTRATED BY SECRET POLICE & IT "WORKED"))) 15:25  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 07/11/06
  4.   Gay-hate turns muderous on Jerusalem 15:35  |  Sam 07/11/06
  5.   Guidelines 15:47  |  Jo Jo 07/11/06
  6.   well done 15:48  |  iftikhar mirza 07/11/06
  7.   It doesn`t work 15:49  |  Freylakhs 07/11/06
  8.   It wasn`t us, it was higher forces 15:49  |  sh 07/11/06
  9.   This is the 21st centuary 15:57  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 07/11/06
  10.   Burston had better get to like it 16:03  |  Mark Lincoln 07/11/06
  11.   Invitation to Primasexual Pride Parade, Jerusalem, 2007 16:06  |  Clickfool 07/11/06
  12.   #1 Maral 16:19  |  ODP 07/11/06
  13.   Clarification of Earlier Comment 16:26  |  ODP 07/11/06
  14.   Good observation 16:35  |  danite 07/11/06
  15.   Bradley, Please.....the gays are being provocative 16:41  |  Sam 07/11/06
  16.   Murder 16:46  |  Choni 07/11/06
  17.   We 16:48  |  Harold A. Maio 07/11/06
  18.   Mark Lincoln 16:54  |  Danite 07/11/06
  19.   Danite #14 16:59  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  20.   Make them go to public schools 17:07  |  M 07/11/06
  21.   Danite and BB 17:09  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  22.   Gabe1 17:12  |  Danite 07/11/06
  23.   Make them all go to Yeshivot 17:37  |  ODP 07/11/06
  24.   W.M.D. 17:53  |  Choni 07/11/06
  25.   Response to M 18:07  |  Lana 07/11/06
  26.   Choni and Gabe1 18:09  |  Maral 07/11/06
  27.   What century do these guys live in 18:10  |  Marilyn 07/11/06
  28.   Herzl 18:13  |  Bana 07/11/06
  29.   The Pulsa DNura is NOT Kabala 18:15  |  -- 07/11/06
  30.   Murder? 18:15  |  J. Danzger 07/11/06
  31.   murderous hatred against rabbis 18:21  |  Joe Jew 07/11/06
  32.   Response to ODP 18:24  |  Lama 07/11/06
  33.   Response to ODP 18:26  |  Bill 07/11/06
  34.   Imams and Rabbis 18:28  |  GZLives 07/11/06
  35.   The Pulsa DNura is NOT Kabala 18:28  |  -- 07/11/06
  36.   Response to Maral 18:36  |  Lana 07/11/06
  37.   Maral 18:40  |  Gana 07/11/06
  38.   maral#26 18:43  |  Danite 07/11/06
  39.   WHO IS WORSE 18:44  |  TOBIA 07/11/06
  40.   Rabbis have you forgotten, THOU SHALT NOT KILL? 18:45  |  Timothy 07/11/06
  41.   #27 18:53  |  J. Danzger 07/11/06
  42.   #34 19:00  |  J. Danzger 07/11/06
  43.   Lama and the haredi lifestyle 19:01  |  sh 07/11/06
  44.   #40 19:05  |  J. Danzger 07/11/06
  45.   Gana 19:06  |  Maral 07/11/06
  46.   Herzl - Bana 19:08  |  Gana 07/11/06
  47.   With all due respect, Lana 19:09  |  Maral 07/11/06
  48.   The "Israel in danger" excuse doesn`t work here 19:10  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  49.   Maral #26 Danite #38 19:12  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  50.   Danite #38 19:24  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  51.   Those Who Yell The Loudest 19:32  |  Ben Dover 07/11/06
  52.   why we should be able to march 19:50  |  Lindsey 07/11/06
  53.   Lama and Bill, please re-read. 20:15  |  ODP 07/11/06
  54.   Lashon Ha`ra 20:19  |  Leib 07/11/06
  55.   Jerusalem is a holy city 20:43  |  Bruriah Sarah 07/11/06
  56.   when rabbis` hate turns murderous 20:48  |  Mendel the Mean 07/11/06
  57.   You are out of touch with reality 20:57  |  cod 07/11/06
  58.   LO Bakoach Lo Bachayill Ki IM Baruchi 21:17  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  59.   HOMOSEXUALS ARE AN ABOMINATION BECAUSE.. 21:21  |  JEFF 07/11/06
  60.   National Service for Haridim 21:51  |  Oatez 07/11/06
  61.   Drilling a Hole in the Universe 21:54  |  Rabbi Mitterhoff 07/11/06
  62.   Pushing for Jerusalem rally is provocation 22:11  |  Gili 07/11/06
  63.   Nice article Bradley 22:34  |  Rab 07/11/06
  64.   When rabbis` gay-hate turns murderous 22:37  |  Rafael 07/11/06
  65.   Vatican City and Mecca 22:55  |  sh 07/11/06
  66.   Haredi Jews, Israel needs you to apply halakha to a 21st century 22:58  |  AV 07/11/06
  67.   golden calf 23:06  |  === 07/11/06
  68.   gabe1 23:11  |  Danite 07/11/06
  69.   #57 23:14  |  Charles 07/11/06
  70.   JEFF 23:14  |  Danite 07/11/06
  71.   #11 Clickfool 23:17  |  Charles 07/11/06
  72.   When in Rome... 23:46  |  Nathan Es 07/11/06
  73.   sh 23:48  |  Danite 07/11/06
  74.   Why in Jerusalem? 23:57  |  Ludmila 07/11/06
  75.   When rabbis` gay-hate turns murderous 00:08  |  Robbie 08/11/06
  76.   desecrating Jerusalem 00:27  |  Josh Goldman 08/11/06
  77.   Danite to Jeff, got the nail on its head 01:32  |  Ziad 08/11/06
  78.   DANITE #67 02:51  |  Gabe1 08/11/06
  79.   Ziad marchaba! 03:09  |  Danite 08/11/06
  80.   Pulsa Danura 03:23  |  Klaudia 08/11/06
  81.   its just the start of something beautiful - the death of medina 03:24  |  & death of erev rav 08/11/06
  82.   pulsa 03:36  |  mike 08/11/06
  83.   The Role of a Priest Of The Most High 04:17  |  Father have mercy 08/11/06
  84.   Right? By whom? 05:03  |  Ri 08/11/06
  85.   Will We be Deemed Worthy of Jerusalem if We Parade "Abomination" 05:48  |  Me 08/11/06
  86.   Haredi curses 06:42  |  Charles 08/11/06
  87.   Rabbi Shmuel Papenheim incitment to murder 07:04  |  Pink Boy 08/11/06
  88.   of murder and rape 07:54  |  Josephine 08/11/06
  89.   Ultra Orthodox, others and Reality 08:19  |  HonestAbe 08/11/06
  90.   Afraid of a few Prayers? 08:24  |  Efox 08/11/06
  91.   What are they telling their Arab brothers? 10:57  |  Sad 08/11/06
  92.   Both sides NEED to REPENT. Prepare ye, the Way of the Lord. 12:38  |  Who will be first? 08/11/06
  93.   # 37 Gana 13:16  |  Shelly 08/11/06
  94.   # 88 Josephine 13:24  |  Shelly 08/11/06
  95.   Ignorant superstition 14:22  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 08/11/06
  96.   Have respect for each other 14:31  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 08/11/06
  97.   Shelly #93 14:45  |  Gana 08/11/06
  98.   # 97 Gana 15:07  |  Shelly 08/11/06
  99.   Holiness of Jerusalem 15:16  |  Norman 08/11/06
  100.   Ignorance 15:32  |  Jack the ripper 08/11/06
  101.   kill leftists any way possible 15:40  |  homos = hamas 08/11/06
  102.   Jeff 16:42  |  Asher Levelheaded 08/11/06
  103.   Asher #101 17:38  |  Nama 08/11/06
  104.   To Norman 18:05  |  Patricia 08/11/06
  105.   Gays dont have to respect hate. 18:07  |  Hal 08/11/06
  106.   Pulsa Denura for Ahmadinejad 18:37  |  o amigo 08/11/06
  107.   #102 18:46  |  J. Danzger 08/11/06
  108.   #11 Jews advocating extermination 19:00  |  Zeje 08/11/06
  109.   Guidelines 19:02  |  Andreas 08/11/06
  110.   [IN TODAYS] TORAH READING SODOM WAS DESTROYED! 19:05  |  JEFF 08/11/06
  111.   #103 response zeje 19:43  |  Robbie 08/11/06
  112.   Yes Jews from its begining always fought 19:54  |  with prayers and all 08/11/06
  113.   The Tora doesnt forbid homosexuality 22:16  |  AV 08/11/06
  114.   Gay `Rights` reply to AV 22:55  |  Joe 08/11/06
  115.   #113 23:13  |  J. Danzger 08/11/06
  116.   Conservative Sydney? 23:13  |  Hillel 08/11/06
  117.   Dont misquote the Tora 23:49  |  AV 08/11/06
  118.   Burning in hell baby 01:26  |  Sean 09/11/06
  119.   GAY "HATE" BY RABBIS 02:14  |  Solomon Rosengarten 09/11/06
  120.   GAY "HATE" 02:21  |  Solomon Rosengarten 09/11/06
  121.   Religion isn`t a satisfactory excuse for hate. 03:34  |  Hal 09/11/06
  122.   The Meaning of Democracy 04:50  |  JoanneGMurphy 09/11/06
  123.   The Rabbi`s are correct 05:09  |  BEPP 09/11/06
  124.   To Av...you don`t know what The Torah says! 05:24  |  BEPP 09/11/06
  125.   Vayikra 08:50  |  AV 09/11/06
  126.   Reply to Av 08:54  |  Joe 09/11/06
  127.   response to lana 09:40  |  aeli 09/11/06
  128.   Seems Judaism has its share of whackos and terrorists too 09:48  |  KDP 09/11/06
  129.   #59 - this is not a choice 10:00  |  Mira 09/11/06
  130.   a few other `abominations` 10:20  |  Mira 09/11/06
  131.   The real matter is- Do you fear G-d? 12:30  |  Ilana 09/11/06
  132.   IT IS AN AFFLICTION OF UNNATURAL DESIRES 12:49  |  Prayer Warrior 09/11/06
  133.   20 14:28  |  W 09/11/06
  134.   pulsa de nura 14:39  |  mario felappi 09/11/06
  135.   # 132 mario felappi 15:35  |  Shelly 09/11/06
  136.   violence 15:57  |  Seth Johnston, M.D. 09/11/06
  137.   Reply to Joe 18:54  |  AV 09/11/06
  138.   Voodoo 19:56  |  Hollywood Jim 09/11/06
  139.   Mishlei 26:2, M. Berachot, Pulsa denura 20:00  |  DJStahl 09/11/06
  140.   A Common Place in Heaven 20:16  |  michel 09/11/06
  141.   #113 almost correct 20:16  |  DJStahl 09/11/06
  142.   #129 hard-wired 20:34  |  DJStahl 09/11/06
  143.   #130 Bible quotes 20:46  |  DJStahl 09/11/06
  144.   gay-hate 21:01  |  Zalman Lachman 09/11/06
  145.   Stop cursing our own! 21:22  |  TL 09/11/06
  146.   Almost correct ... 22:59  |  AV 09/11/06
  147.   Laura Goldman is an idiot 23:03  |  Lurker 09/11/06
  148.   Curses versus transformation 23:05  |  George Bowker 09/11/06
  149.   erev r AV #1 23:47  |  revolution 09/11/06
  150.   erev r AV #2 23:48  |  violent overthrow 09/11/06
  151.   erev rav #3 23:50  |  high (on crack)court 09/11/06
  152.   AMEN George Bowker, you are a blessing, Thank you. 02:42  |  Virginia 10/11/06
  153.   Bradley and the Rabbis are nuts 13:09  |  FOX 10/11/06
  154.   thank you, erev rAV (#149,150,151) 20:14  |  rz 10/11/06
  155.   homophobia 22:25  |  marvin lustgarten 10/11/06
  156.   Gays are a litmus test 23:54  |  AV 10/11/06
  157.   spell 00:03  |  Sylvoe 11/11/06
  158.   To: BEPP #124 00:09  |  Jonathan 11/11/06
  159.   RABBONIM WHO HATE ABOMINATIONS 01:49  |  MARVIN LUSTGARTEN 11/11/06
  160.   #149 Rav you`re very learned but I dont understand all references 01:55  |  wher can learn more? 11/11/06
  161.   Jerusalem Where Prophets Marched 04:25  |  Hussein 11/11/06
  162.   #157...No, you can`t read 05:15  |  BEPP 11/11/06
  163.   Hussein #161 - It`s NOT about what they deserve 15:09  |  Not a Jew 11/11/06
  164.   gay israelis are sooo rude and arrogant 18:51  |  oscar 11/11/06
  165.   bana your post 20:05  |  bev 11/11/06
  166.   bepp 22:59  |  morty 11/11/06
  167.   CURSE????????????????? 00:03  |  SAM EL LLANITO 12/11/06
  168.   #161-Hussein 00:35  |  Uzziel 12/11/06
  169.   #165...you are mistaken 07:41  |  BEPP 12/11/06
  170.   Glad parade was cancelled 11:07  |  Joe 12/11/06
  171.   THANKS BRADLEY 23:10  |  DAVID 16/12/06
 Today Online
Abbas calls for fresh elections in PA as soon as possible
Responses: 69
Bradley Burston: Jews who make Satan look good
Responses: 263
Ze'ev Sternhell: The Green Line is the border
Responses: 177
Iran: Olmert's nuclear comments are sign of Israel's weakness
Responses: 202
Ultra-Orthodox Shabbat boycott hits El Al in the pocket
Responses: 113
Rosner's Domain
* Comparing President Bush to President Truman
* Christmas trees, Menorahs and the shortcut to hell
* Poll: Did Olmert kill Israel's nuclear ambiguity?
* Q&A with Rabbi Epstein on the issue of Conservatives and gays


More Headlines
21:33 18 people hurt in Hamas-Fatah clashes in Gaza
20:42 Abbas calls for fresh PA elections as soon as possible
22:13 ANALYSIS: Abbas prepares for battle - one of these days
18:17 Iran offers to help neighbors develop nuclear technology
16:20 Syrian FM: Returning Golan not a precondition for peace talks
16:10 British PM: Coming days critical for Middle East peace process
18:18 20-year-old Palestinian militant killed by IDF fire in Nablus
15:54 UN to register Palestinians' complaints over West Bank fence
23:04 Rice to seek additional funds to boost Abbas' security forces
22:52 17-year-old runs over, kills mother in Jezreel Valley tractor accident
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Yad Ezra VeShulamit
This Chanukah gift the gift of a hot meal to a Jewish child
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Menorahs by Judaica Mall
Great selection of Hanukkah gifts
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved